Steps to get good friday alcohol ban overturned.

ygolometsipe · 17-03-2017 7:23pm #1

I am not Catholic, I don't believe I will go to hell for drinking alcohol on
Good Friday. I know I am a minority in Ireland in this regard but why are my rights ignored on Good Friday and what if any steps could I take to get this overturned?

Note: its not about the alcohol, its about imposing religious dogma on non
religious citizens.

17-03-2017 7:27pm

Pubs are closed Christmas day as well.
Should they open?
Why the hate for good Friday closing?
I'm sure if i had a pub or worked in one, i wouldn't mind a couple of days a year with the pub closed!

jackwigan · 17-03-2017 7:28pm

Good Friday is April 14th. Today is March 17th. You have nearly a month to prepare.

My advice on Thursday the 16th of March go into an off-licence. Buy enough alcohol to last you during Friday. Problem solved, you're welcome.

*Note: This also works for Christmas

Armchair Andy · 17-03-2017 7:29pm

I spent more time reading OP's user handle than the the OP itself.
I need a drink.

Yourself isit · 17-03-2017 7:30pm

I'd bring back the alcohol ban on Paddy's day.

Samuel T. Cogley · 17-03-2017 7:30pm

Just rebrand it for what it is. 'National how can I get round the drinking ban day'.

People love this day, if they didn't they'd just STFU and go shopping in the preceding days.

mikeym · 17-03-2017 7:30pm

Sports clubs serve alcohol on Good Friday.

And staying in is the new going out so stock up on drink the night before.

SteM · 17-03-2017 7:31pm

Alchos getting jittery already, it's over a month away ffs.

Allinall · 17-03-2017 7:34pm

ygolometsipe wrote: »

I am not Catholic, I don't believe I will go to hell for drinking alcohol on
Good Friday. I know I am a minority in Ireland in this regard but why are my rights ignored on Good Friday and what if any steps could I take to get this overturned?

Note: its not about the alcohol, its about imposing religious dogma on non
religious citizens.

What rights are being ignored?

SeaFields · 17-03-2017 7:36pm

ygolometsipe wrote: »

Note: its not about the alcohol

It is though.

ygolometsipe · 17-03-2017 7:36pm

Its not about "stocking up". It would be nice to go for a meal on Friday and
have some wine with food.

The ban is about imposing religious dogma, it does't matter if its one day
or 100 days, if you are religious then don't drink but you have no right to stop others.

Forcing you religious view on people is not ok!

Christmas day should apply too.

Vex Willems · 17-03-2017 7:37pm

bubblypop wrote: »

Pubs are closed Christmas day as well.
Should they open?
Why the hate for good Friday closing?
I'm sure if i had a pub or worked in one, i wouldn't mind a couple of days a year with the pub closed!

If you own it, you can close it whatever days you want.

17-03-2017 7:37pm

I don't really drink much. It doesnt bother me at all that you cant purchase alcohol on that day. I like it, i think its a good 'Irish' thing. Like the angelus (even though i believe thats gone now, and im not at all religious either). I don't see why the rush to turn us into "Generic Euro Country #12".

I like the little 'irish' things that appear.

That said, even as a non-drinker, i think the restricted sale times for alcohol are a bit stupid and only hit the innocent people and not the people with alcohol issues (ie; the joe soap that fancies a drink but works shift work so cant juts pop in and buy it on the way home, etc).

average_runner · 17-03-2017 7:37pm

ygolometsipe wrote: »

Its not about "stocking up". It would be nice to go for a meal on Friday and
have some wine with food.

The ban is about imposing religious dogma, it does't matter if its one day
or 100 days, if you are religious then don't drink but you have no right to stop others.

Forcing you religious view on people is not ok!

Christmas day should apply too.

It's nothing to do with religion. So get over it.

XsApollo · 17-03-2017 7:38pm

All things religion should be a choosing of the people that wish to follow it.
Not forced on people that don't care.
Which is happening slowly in this country , but getting there.
Mainly helped by all the **** that has went on :-).

enricoh · 17-03-2017 7:39pm

The ones I know that go on about good Friday drinking wouldn't be in a pub from one month to the next. Gives em something else to moan about I suppose!

hungry hypno toad · 17-03-2017 7:39pm

It is one day a year. If someone can't manage without alcohol for one day a year then they have an alcohol dependency and should seek help.

Noddyholder · 17-03-2017 7:40pm

ygolometsipe wrote: »

I am not Catholic, I don't believe I will go to hell for drinking alcohol on
Good Friday. I know I am a minority in Ireland in this regard but why are my rights ignored on Good Friday and what if any steps could I take to get this overturned?

Note: its not about the alcohol, its about imposing religious dogma on non
religious citizens.

Nowadays the closure has nothing got to do with the catholic church ,So whether you go to hell or Connaught is your own business.

The minister if so desired could change the law very easily, as its a bit out of date, Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1927 , Tis the government you need to be throwing your wobbler at.

average_runner · 17-03-2017 7:41pm

XsApollo wrote: »

All things religion should be a choosing of the people that wish to follow it.
Not forced on people that don't care.
Which is happening slowly in this country , but getting there.
Mainly helped by all the **** that has went on :-).

Catholic Church are not blocking it.

Maybe look at the headlines tomorrow to see why it won't be overturned

judeboy101 · 17-03-2017 7:41pm

Why stop with good friday? Have alcohol on sale 24hrs a day, 365 days a year. I love the fact that there are 2 days a year that there is a chance some mother or father might not head down to the pub and maybe stay sober enough to be with their family. There are lots of alcoholics who never drink in front of family and only do it in the pub.

Noddyholder · 17-03-2017 7:42pm

hungry hypno toad wrote: »

It is one day a year. If someone can't manage without alcohol for one day a year then they have an alcohol dependency and should seek help.

Personally its not great for tourism either, and does seem very strange to visitors who come here. Also if you really wanted to have a drink ya can always give 3 taps on the side window & your in.:D

hungry hypno toad · 17-03-2017 7:44pm

Noddyholder wrote: »

Personally its not great for tourism either, and does seem very strange to visitors who come here. Also if you really wanted to have a drink ya can always give 3 taps on the side window & your in.:D

Hasn't been an issue for tourism in the past.

So no real problem if it is that easy to bypass then.

ygolometsipe · 17-03-2017 7:46pm

hungry hypno toad wrote: »

It is one day a year. If someone can't manage without alcohol for one day a year then they have an alcohol dependency and should seek help.

Who said anything about not managing? Your not only jumping to conclusions
you leaping to them.

If its only one day then why go to the bother of banning sale at all, it would surely save a lot of hassle.

See its not about the day, its about the symbolism. Catholic Ireland still rules.

hungry hypno toad · 17-03-2017 7:49pm

ygolometsipe wrote: »

Who said anything about not managing? Your not only jumping to conclusions
you leaping to them.

If its only one day then why go to the bother of banning sale at all, it would surely save a lot of hassle.

See its not about the day, its about the symbolism. Catholic Ireland still rules.

Still rules?

lertsnim · 17-03-2017 7:53pm

bubblypop wrote: »

I'm sure if i had a pub or worked in one, i wouldn't mind a couple of days a year with the pub closed!

Anyone who is working 363 days of the year needs to have a word with their boss. Also as previously mentioned there is nothing stopping a pub landlord from closing any day they like.

Nomis21 · 17-03-2017 7:57pm

If you are over 66 years old you can go on the train to Cork for free with your Free pass and get a beer in the bar on there.

Barry Badrinath · 17-03-2017 8:01pm

Step 1: Feel offended.
Step 2: Open up Boards.
Step 3: Create a thread.
Step 4: Convince yourself you have an argument.
Step 5: Hopelessly defend yourself.
Step 6: Lose your argument on Page 1.
Step 7: Cop the fcuk on.

......... · 17-03-2017 8:02pm

average_runner wrote: »

Catholic Church are not blocking it.

Maybe look at the headlines tomorrow to see why it won't be overturned

Indeed, the emergency services favourite day of the year. Street cleaners love the lack of blood, piss and puke as well. So do those living with domestic abuse due to alcohol abuse. One day in the year where it's reduced a little doesn't do anyone any harm.

17-03-2017 8:02pm

I'm not religious at all, and i like to drink too.
I kind of like the good Friday and Christmas day alcohol bans.
I think we should keep them.
It doesn't hurt and it's kinda a nice thing.

Tigger · 17-03-2017 8:06pm

st patricks day used to be a dry day as well
they changed it and now its national drinking day
so if we changed good friday we could have 2 national drinking days

yay economics

http://www.irishcentral.com/roots/history/all-the-pubs-in-ireland-used-to-be-closed-on-st-patricks-day

Christy42 · 17-03-2017 8:07pm

76544567 wrote: »

I'm not religious at all, and i like to drink too.
I kind of like the good Friday and Christmas day alcohol bans.
I think we should keep them.
It doesn't hurt and it's kinda a nice thing.

Why is it a nice thing? Why not ban it on the 10th of every month as well. Just to have it as a nice thing like.

If a pub wants to close on good Friday it should be allowed to but I don't see why the law should be involved on that particular day. I mean I doubt I would go out good Friday but it is still a pointless law.

17-03-2017 8:09pm

Christy42 wrote: »

Why is it a nice thing? Why not ban it on the 10th of every month as well. Just to have it as a nice thing like.

If a pub wants to close on good Friday it should be allowed to but I don't see why the law should be involved on that particular day. I mean I doubt I would go out good Friday but it is still a pointless law.

Well we can do the 10th of every month if you want. But we already have two days and it's perfectly fine to me. But whatever you want to do about the 10ths, work away.

hungry hypno toad · 17-03-2017 8:12pm

Tigger wrote: »

st patricks day used to be a dry day as well
they changed it and now its national drinking day
so if we changed good friday we could have 2 national drinking days

yay economics

http://www.irishcentral.com/roots/history/all-the-pubs-in-ireland-used-to-be-closed-on-st-patricks-day

Why exactly would we want that?

......... · 17-03-2017 8:14pm

hungry hypno toad wrote: »

Why exactly would we want that?

because Diageo needs a replacement for the puke fest that was "Aurhur's Day" and Good Friday would be perfect.

hungry hypno toad · 17-03-2017 8:15pm

......... wrote: »

because Diageo needs a replacement for the puke fest that was "Aurhur's Day" and good Friday would be perfect.

ytpe2r5bxkn0c1 · 17-03-2017 8:16pm

Christy42 wrote: »

Why is it a nice thing? Why not ban it on the 10th of every month as well. Just to have it as a nice thing like.

If a pub wants to close on good Friday it should be allowed to but I don't see why the law should be involved on that particular day. I mean I doubt I would go out good Friday but it is still a pointless law.

I totally agree. I'm a practicing Catholic and will not be drinking that week, but if the pubs were open it wouldn't be compulsory to drink. Let people drink on Good Friday if they wish.

ygolometsipe · 17-03-2017 8:31pm

Senor Fancy Pants wrote: »

Step 1: Feel offended.
Step 2: Open up Boards.
Step 3: Create a thread.
Step 4: Convince yourself you have an argument.
Step 5: Hopelessly defend yourself.
Step 6: Lose your argument on Page 1.
Step 7: Cop the fcuk on.

That's a smug response.

I lost the argument, really? Oh shucks!

PARlance · 17-03-2017 8:31pm

ygolometsipe wrote: »

Its not about "stocking up". It would be nice to go for a meal on Friday and
have some wine with food.

Well, you seem to making the most of this Friday night champ.

beertons · 17-03-2017 8:38pm

At least in the last few years, there are pubs opening and serving food. I know of one place that will be serving Irish coffee's. And having a mini market out the back. If this thread stays open for 4 weeks, I'll drip feed clues to its location.

XsApollo · 17-03-2017 8:49pm

average_runner wrote: »

Catholic Church are not blocking it.

Maybe look at the headlines tomorrow to see why it won't be overturned

I'm not saying the Catholic Church are blocking it.
But it is a religious based reasoning on why the law is there or am I wrong?

beertons · 17-03-2017 8:53pm

I thought bit might have passed this year, but when presented to Francis Fitzgerald, she stone walled the idea. Her replacement might be more of the opinion. Who ever that may be.

Mrs OBumble · 17-03-2017 8:55pm

OP there is no restriction on drinking on Good Friday. The only restriction is on buying alcohol.

If you are challenged by having to buy your alcohol up to 24 hours in advance, then I think you have bigger problems to be worrying about than Good Friday.

Patser · 17-03-2017 8:59pm

Could we organise a massive protest piss up outside the Dáil on Good Friday, where we all show up with random bottles of stuff like Raki, Ouzo, Limencello that were bought on holidays because it seemed the norm, or 6 year old bottles of Bailey's, Sheridans, sherry that we were given as Christmas presents yonks ago..

You know, all that crap that you only drink on Good Friday anyway after you forget to stock up but get invited to a house party.

Just imagine the technicolour vomit Ministers will have to step over even weeks later.....

osarusan · 17-03-2017 9:02pm

On principle, I agree.

But I still don't care that much.

Skid X · 17-03-2017 9:10pm

If Steps manage to get that ban overturned I'll raise a glass to them.

Hopefully some other 90s Pop bands will join the campaign.

Guy:Incognito · 17-03-2017 9:12pm

bubblypop wrote: »

Pubs are closed Christmas day as well.
Should they open?

If they want, yes.

thee glitz · 17-03-2017 9:13pm

average_runner wrote: »

It's nothing to do with religion. So get over it.

It kinda is though, in that it moves with a church day of obligation.

hungry hypno toad wrote: »

Hasn't been an issue for tourism in the past.

If you consider the pub trade to be a part of the tourism industry, it probably has been and continues to be an issue. It would be next to impossible to quantify how many tourists we lose out on due to the ban. It could be considerable, could be none.

For the sake of tourists, I'd like to see pubs open on GF. It doesn't bother me and I can get a pint if I want anyway (probably in Connolly). A friend of mine hosts an annual 'crucifixion party' but I usually spend it with family if not working.

Temptamperu · 17-03-2017 9:20pm

You can buy weed on good friday.

hungry hypno toad · 17-03-2017 9:21pm

thee glitz wrote: »

It kinda is though, in that it moves with a church day of obligation.

If you consider the pub trade to be a part of the tourism industry, it probably has been and continues to be an issue. It would be next to impossible to quantify how many tourists we lose out on due to the ban. It could be considerable, could be none.

For the sake of tourists, I'd like to see pubs open on GF. It doesn't bother me and I can get a pint if I want anyway (probably in Connolly). A friend of mine hosts an annual 'crucifixion party' but I usually spend it with family if not working.

Who really cares? 1 day, so I'm guessing the effect in tourism is less than 1/3 of 1%. Hardly worth it.

17-03-2017 9:23pm

On Good Friday and Christmas Day, I am always envious of those in the Rovers Return having a drink.

thee glitz · 17-03-2017 9:24pm

sugarman wrote: »

These lads? Fair play to them

Didn't you hear?

Steps to get good friday alcohol ban overturned.

Comments