Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

The Angelus on RTE

12346»

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,909 ✭✭✭hynesie08


    You know, i always think I'm gonna get sick of these threads where noxy proves himself to be an embarrassing throwback to 50s Ireland who thinks him and his 5 mates down the pub are right and everyone else is wrong but they keep on delivering.

    Well done AH.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,553 ✭✭✭Tarzana2


    hynesie08 wrote: »
    You know, i always think I'm gonna get sick of these threads where noxy proves himself to be an embarrassing throwback to 50s Ireland who thinks him and his 5 mates down the pub are right and everyone else is wrong but they keep on delivering.

    Well done AH.

    I know, he's like the negative control in an experiment on modern Ireland.


  • Posts: 24,714 [Deleted User]


    Tarzana2 wrote: »
    I presume you have data to back that up? Data, not anecdotes.

    Maybe the hangover horrors are what are making your life seem unfulfilling. ;)

    i'd only around 9 pints and a small drop of whiskey tonight, there will be no horrors from that.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 35,953 ✭✭✭✭Hotblack Desiato


    Comparing this year with say 5 years ago attendance is considerably increasing so I'm afraid you are going to be disappointed.

    People have realised that a life without religion in is not a happy or fulfilling way of life and they are returning to the church.

    I can't think of anything more unhappy or unfulfilling than a life dependent on the whims of some supernatural power who is supposedly open to pleading but has never been observed to pay the slightest bit of notice.

    In Cavan there was a great fire / Judge McCarthy was sent to inquire / It would be a shame / If the nuns were to blame / So it had to be caused by a wire.



  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,553 ✭✭✭Tarzana2


    i'd only around 9 pints and a small drop of whiskey tonight, there will be no horrors from that.

    Sure hun. xoxoxoxox

    Anyway, I have to state plainly that I find the views you've expressed in this thread thoroughly unpleasant and pigheaded. Especially in this post:

    http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=94579894&postcount=238

    Awful stuff. Are you completely devoid of self-awareness and do you really not realise how badly you come across? Well, I suppose the above post was made with a rake of drink on you, so it's certainly telling anyway!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,909 ✭✭✭hynesie08


    i'd only around 9 pints and a small drop of whiskey tonight, there will be no horrors from that.

    Must be a ****e night out if you can count how much you drank.


  • Registered Users Posts: 251 ✭✭shane7218


    hynesie08 wrote: »
    Must be a ****e night out if you can count how much you drank.

    Sounds about as fun as a mass


  • Registered Users Posts: 1,426 ✭✭✭Jamsiek


    Northern Protestants want to cause trouble of course they have no interest whatsoever in a United ireland.

    A small minority want to cause trouble, let's not generalize.
    I really wouldn't blame them for not wanting to be part of a country that imposed a different religion on them


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,766 ✭✭✭Bongalongherb


    Are you paying your TV licence ? To RTE ? if you are , then you can send RTE this new enhanced audio of the Angelus to play as a new re-write of the old dreary depressing one.



  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,438 ✭✭✭TwoShedsJackson


    Comparing this year with say 5 years ago attendance is considerably increasing so I'm afraid you are going to be disappointed.

    People have realised that a life without religion in is not a happy or fulfilling way of life and they are returning to the church.

    Oh look it's an anecdote from nox about what he supposedly sees in several rural churches- well that settles things.


  • Advertisement
  • Posts: 24,714 [Deleted User]


    Jamsiek wrote: »
    A small minority want to cause trouble, let's not generalize.
    I really wouldn't blame them for not wanting to be part of a country that imposed a different religion on them

    Yes I should have said some not all.

    Im done with this thread anyway.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,630 ✭✭✭Zen65


    catallus wrote: »
    On an ecumenical level is there any reason at all to listen to those who are deaf to the voice of God in their hearts?

    I, for one, tend to distrust those who think they hear voices. Especially if the voices tell them to take away the rights of others.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,085 ✭✭✭Rubberchikken


    this isn't a secular state. it's a catholic country, and those that attempt to erode this have too much time on their hands.

    as an agnostic, a tv licence payer and a non-rte-watching citizen i have no issue with the Angelus being shown on tv each day or on national radio.

    there are a lot of things this country needs to change but losing it's catholic identity is not one of them.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,630 ✭✭✭Zen65


    shane7218 wrote: »
    Its an absolute disgrace and all forms of religion (including the angelus rubbish) should be removed from the public sphere.

    If people want to practice Christianity, through any of its branches, or Buddhism, or Islam, or Judaism, or whatever religion they like, they should be free to do so, and to do so publicly if they wish. That is what freedom of religion means, provided that those who choose not to practice a religion are also free to not practice it.

    Religious freedom requires that no state body should include a reference to any religious doctrine. Neither should a state body promote a religion. I would have no issues if the Catholic Church took the sixty seconds from 6.00 to 6.01 to play the Angelus as a paid advertisement. I do not find it objectionable compared to (say) the No Nonsense insurance advert. What I object to is that the licence fee I am obliged to pay to RTE funds that one minute advert.

    Personally I'd hate to live in a world where the Hare Krishna were not free to walk up and down Grafton Street with their funky music.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,772 ✭✭✭mg1982


    Zen65 wrote: »
    If people want to practice Christianity, through any of its branches, or Buddhism, or Islam, or Judaism, or whatever religion they like, they should be free to do so, and to do so publicly if they wish. That is what freedom of religion means, provided that those who choose not to practice a religion are also free to not practice it.

    Religious freedom requires that no state body should include a reference to any religious doctrine. Neither should a state body promote a religion. I would have no issues if the Catholic Church took the sixty seconds from 6.00 to 6.01 to play the Angelus as a paid advertisement. I do not find it objectionable compared to (say) the No Nonsense insurance advert. What I object to is that the licence fee I am obliged to pay to RTE funds that one minute advert.

    Personally I'd hate to live in a world where the Hare Krishna were not free to walk up and down Grafton Street with their funky music.

    What you have described is what freedom of religion is actually about. Anybody is free to practice any religion they so wish but its not the states remit to promote any religion above another. I been hearing this is a catholic country BS since i was a child and even as a child i knew it was an opressive influence on this country.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,630 ✭✭✭Zen65


    there are a lot of things this country needs to change but losing it's catholic identity is not one of them.

    That really depends on what you think the Catholic identity is?

    For those abused at the hands of the church, the Catholic identity is very different than it is to the pensioner who has gone to mass every day for 60 years and finds great comfort in the ritual.

    For those who experienced the Catholic church's support of Hitler, it meant something different again. Others may see its tradition through the eyes of the missions that sought to convert people in Africa by bestowing help on the condition of accepting a faith that was not naturally theirs. The family of Savita Halappanavar see the Catholic identity in a very different way.

    For many Irish women, the Catholic identity was seen in the enforced imprisonment of those women who spoke against their husbands, or who demanded rights. Perhaps they see the Catholic tradition as being the unequal treatment of women in the church? Perhaps some remember the insistence on a priest performing a ceremony to absolve women of the sin of childbirth? Others recall how our Catholic identity meant that we could not have contraception, while our neighbours in Belfast could?

    People within a religion (not just Catholicism) often do not see the flaws and absence of human rights which are enshrined within that religion's teachings. They see it in other religions of course. So those who see the violent teachings in the Islamic faith are quick to condemn it, but are most typically blind to the violence in the teachings of their own church. The Bible, like the Koran, contains many passages advocating murder, genocide, rape and slavery.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,197 ✭✭✭Eutow


    I never said im in favour of freedom of religion, I'm in favour of Catholicism.


    Other religions are wrong so they should not be promoted and they are not equal.


    All religions are wrong, including yours, so the only way to be fair is to NOT promote any. Your attitude is extremely dangerous, forcing people to believe in your way of thinking. We can see how this pans out in the world today.

    Are you suggesting a Muslim, a Hindu, a Buddist or a Jew that practices his or her religion peacefully, is not equal to a Catholic? What makes the Catholic above anybody else. It is just by pure chance you were born in Ireland, it doesn't make you superior to anybody.


    Comparing this year with say 5 years ago attendance is considerably increasing so I'm afraid you are going to be disappointed.

    The fact that there are less masses being said because of dropping attendences is proof that this isn't the case.

    People have realised that a life without religion in is not a happy or fulfilling way of life and they are returning to the church.

    People can live a wonderfully fulfilling life without religion, just as people can live one that they find fulfilling with religion. Also, people can suffer a depression unhappy filled life with religion.


  • Registered Users Posts: 12,011 ✭✭✭✭PopePalpatine


    Yes I should have said some not all.

    Im done with this thread anyway.

    Yeah, I'd surrender too if my anecdotes weren't working.

    Didn't you claim to be a physicist? As one, you should know that anecdotes are one of the worst forms of "evidence" for your claim.


  • Posts: 24,714 [Deleted User]


    Eutow wrote: »
    All religions are wrong, including yours, so the only way to be fair is to NOT promote any. Your attitude is extremely dangerous, forcing people to believe in your way of thinking. We can see how this pans out in the world today.

    Are you suggesting a Muslim, a Hindu, a Buddist or a Jew that practices his or her religion peacefully, is not equal to a Catholic?

    People should be free to practice their religion of course, however Catholicism is the majority religion so it's natural that it will be far more prominent, promoted and part of people's life's.
    Yeah, I'd surrender too if my anecdotes weren't working.

    Didn't you claim to be a physicist? As one, you should know that anecdotes are one of the worst forms of "evidence" for your claim.

    My anecdotes don't need to "work". I know what I see week in week out whether you believe it or not is irrelevant. As I've said before I'm basing it on a far bigger sample than my local church.

    I've better things for doing (sleeping being one at the moment) that arguing on this thread hence why I said I will be stopping posting.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,630 ✭✭✭Zen65


    Are you suggesting a Muslim, a Hindu, a Buddist or a Jew that practices his or her religion peacefully, is not equal to a Catholic?
    People should be free to practice their religion of course, however Catholicism is the majority religion so it's natural that it will be far more prominent, promoted and part of people's life's.

    Question not answered!


  • Registered Users Posts: 12,011 ✭✭✭✭PopePalpatine


    My anecdotes don't need to "work". I know what I see week in week out whether you believe it or not is irrelevant. As I've said before I'm basing it on a far bigger sample than my local church.

    If you want to convince people that the RCC is really rebounding after getting a well-deserved drubbing after this country woke up to its abuses, how about some data?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,106 ✭✭✭catallus


    It is tiresome when people who want to get rid of something for the sake of freedom or equality can't recognise their own transparent fascist tendencies. Screeching moralists may be unbecoming, but when the screechers believe in nothing it is all the more disheartening.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,909 ✭✭✭hynesie08


    My anecdotes don't need to "work". I know what I see week in week out whether you believe it or not is irrelevant.

    When people say what you believe is irrelevant you consider it a personal attack, bit hypocritical no? Doesn't your religion teach you to turn the other cheek? Or is that another element of it you choose to ignore cause it doesn't suit you?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,197 ✭✭✭Eutow


    People should be free to practice their religion of course, however Catholicism is the majority religion so it's natural that it will be far more prominent, promoted and part of people's life's.


    You stated that non Catholic children should find alternative schools to get an education, bit hard when over 90% of schools are owned by the Catholic churches, who then get taxpayer money from everybody. Not very equal is it? People should not be discriminated over religion, it is illegal.
    My anecdotes don't need to "work". I know what I see week in week out whether you believe it or not is irrelevant. As I've said before I'm basing it on a far bigger sample than my local church.

    When living in Ireland, my local church had Saturday night mass, and then five masses every Sunday morning (8, 9, 10, 11, 12) and then an evening mass. This doesn't happen anymore, I think there are only two masses on the Sunday nowadays. So, this could only mean there are less people going to mass.

    To make it a bit clearer, when there were all those masses previously on the Sunday, say 480 people in total went to those six masses, or on average 80 for each mass. Now that is reduced to two masses on Sunday due to declining numbers, now only 220 people go to mass, or on average 110 people per mass. Looking at the latter figures it would appear more people are going to mass, but that is only because the numbers are not spread out like in the former. The only way to be sure is to look at the TOTAL number that went to mass that day/week.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 774 ✭✭✭daveyeh


    It should be replaced.

    Slowly fading in & out pictures of Bono with a gospel choir singing 'Gloria' in the background.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,438 ✭✭✭TwoShedsJackson


    My anecdotes don't need to "work". I know what I see week in week out whether you believe it or not is irrelevant. As I've said before I'm basing it on a far bigger sample than my local church.

    Facts! Proof! Who needs them? nox is the physicist who can't be bothered with the scientific method or any of that other anti-Catholic mumbo-jumbo.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,106 ✭✭✭catallus


    daveyeh wrote: »
    Slowly fading in & out pictures of Bono with a gospel choir singing 'Gloria' in the background.

    How about some Rachmaninov!? :)



    Always puts a smile on the day!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,113 ✭✭✭shruikan2553


    Eutow wrote: »
    You stated that non Catholic children should find alternative schools to get an education, bit hard when over 90% of schools are owned by the Catholic churches, who then get taxpayer money from everybody. Not very equal is it? People should not be discriminated over religion, it is illegal.

    Im pretty sure he claimed that all schools should be Catholic as it is the one true religion which all children should be brought into so at least allowing alternative schools is an improvement from Jihadi Nox.
    catallus wrote: »
    It is tiresome when people who want to get rid of something for the sake of freedom or equality can't recognise their own transparent fascist tendencies. Screeching moralists may be unbecoming, but when the screechers believe in nothing it is all the more disheartening.

    Indeed, as often seen in the US people cry freedom of religion but what they actually mean is freedom for their religion while everyone else can **** off. The idea of being treated as equals to everyone else is persecution to them.


  • Registered Users Posts: 850 ✭✭✭Hans Bricks


    I honestly think people are getting way too emotionally charged over this. The Angelus isn't preventing your kid from moving up the list in an RC primary school or to promote the ugly sided legacy of Catholicism. It's something I'm sure most of us posting here grew up listening to during the evenings, I genuinely see it as more cultural and nostalgic more than anything. We can have our secular state and retain a few things I imagine. Doesn't have to be so black & white.

    That said, it's disgraceful about some poster's kids being hindered during the selection process in schools.


  • Posts: 24,714 [Deleted User]


    Im pretty sure he claimed that all schools should be Catholic

    I never claimed anything of the sort. I probably said something along the lines that catholic schools should be for Catholics first, just as it is in the UK for instance (although over there if you aren't catholic and can't prove you go to mass etc you aren't even considered for entry). I have no problem with other religions setting up schools or educate together schools being setup but converting over Catholic schools to something else would not be an option imo.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,197 ✭✭✭Eutow


    I honestly think people are getting way too emotionally charged over this. The Angelus isn't preventing your kid from moving up the list in an RC primary school or to promote the ugly sided legacy of Catholicism. It's something I'm sure most of us posting here grew up listening to during the evenings, I genuinely see it as more cultural and nostalgic more than anything. We can have our secular state and retain a few things I imagine. Doesn't have to be so black & white.

    That said, it's disgraceful about some poster's kids being hindered during the selection process in schools.


    It's the mentality of certain people that is the problem. The Catholic influence on everything such as schools, law and order, healthcare, the Dail, the court system. Certain people claiming that the angelus on RTE is not significant, but if removed those same people would be screaming, so not unsignificant then.


  • Registered Users Posts: 850 ✭✭✭Hans Bricks


    Eutow wrote: »
    It's the mentality of certain people that is the problem. The Catholic influence on everything such as schools, law and order, healthcare, the Dail, the court system. Certain people claiming that the angelus on RTE is not significant, but if removed those same people would be screaming, so not unsignificant then.

    All of which I agree needs to be addressed and rectified, but the Angelus is the least of those problems on scale.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 774 ✭✭✭daveyeh


    Replace it with this...



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,630 ✭✭✭Zen65


    I have no problem with other religions setting up schools or educate together schools being setup but converting over Catholic schools to something else would not be an option imo.

    That is nonsensical. The number of school places is determined by the number of students. If a new school is set up it needs to be funded by the state in exactly the same way as any other school, and since the % shift of school attendees will tend to be from the majority (Catholic) schools to these new non-denominational or non-Catholic schools then the Catholic schools would have to lose funding proportionately and hence close down.

    TL;DR? - Once you set up alternate schools then Catholic schools (or at least, classes) have to be eliminated.

    Multiculturalism. It's a heck-of-a-wonderful thing to embrace, and signals a brave new tomorrow for Ireland.


  • Registered Users Posts: 850 ✭✭✭Hans Bricks


    Zen65 wrote: »
    That is nonsensical. The number of school places is determined by the number of students. If a new school is set up it needs to be funded by the state in exactly the same way as any other school, and since the % shift of school attendees will tend to be from the majority (Catholic) schools to these new non-denominational or non-Catholic schools then the Catholic schools would have to lose funding proportionately and hence close down.

    TL;DR? - Once you set up alternate schools then Catholic schools (or at least, classes) have to be eliminated.

    Multiculturalism. It's a heck-of-a-wonderful thing to embrace, and signals a brave new tomorrow for Ireland.

    Someone's gonna have to educate me here. Is every primary/secondary school with a "St. Mary's .... " name privately owned by the Catholic church, but funded exclusively by the state ? And if so, can't the Department of Education not threaten cuts in funding to these schools should they not adhere to non-denominational standards and regulations ?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,630 ✭✭✭Zen65


    Is every primary/secondary school with a "St. Mary's .... " name privately owned by the Catholic church, but funded exclusively by the state ?

    It's not quite that simple.

    A lot of primary (and secondary) schools are owned by a religious order, but the operational costs are provided for by the state (mainly teacher salaries, etc.) This applies even if it is a public (non-fee-paying) school. The teaching curriculum is mainly secular, but the local parish ensures that religious teaching is provided only in the denomination of the owner. Religious preparation for events such as communion and confirmation is conducted in the school for those who wish to avail of it.

    Even for private (fee-paying) schools the owners may choose to teach, or not, their own religious doctrine on top on the school curriculum.

    Neither case permits (AFAIK) for non-teaching of curriculum based on religious beliefs.

    There are also rules around representation on the Board of Management, ensuring some representation by parents etc., but that does not usually dilute the doctrinal teachings by much.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,553 ✭✭✭Tarzana2


    As I've said before I'm basing it on a far bigger sample than my local church.

    What, like, five churches?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,088 ✭✭✭SpaceTime


    Zen65 wrote: »
    It's not quite that simple.

    A lot of primary (and secondary) schools are owned by a religious order, but the operational costs are provided for by the state (mainly teacher salaries, etc.).

    Mainly everything actually, the state funds between 93 and 95% of all running costs of most schools, with some other extras being funded by parents/community fund raising.

    The state also paid for and continues to pay for most new school building.

    For example it's currently spending €2.2 billion in a five-year capital investment programme launched in March 2012.

    The schools are basically nominally owned by religious communities for historical reasons or for some bizarre reason that the state will not allow itself to own schools.

    I honestly think it's a very strange situation where the state basically pays for everything, but the school is allowed to make this very small nominal contribution to ensure that it retains 'ownership' of everything.


  • Registered Users Posts: 12,011 ✭✭✭✭PopePalpatine


    I never claimed anything of the sort. I probably said something along the lines that catholic schools should be for Catholics first, just as it is in the UK for instance (although over there if you aren't catholic and can't prove you go to mass etc you aren't even considered for entry). I have no problem with other religions setting up schools or educate together schools being setup but converting over Catholic schools to something else would not be an option imo.

    It becomes a massive problem in rural Ireland, where the nearest ET school could be tens of kilometres away. It's nonsensical to have a dozen or so tiny rural schools (and the overhead that requires) because of religious segregation rather than one or two medium ET schools to serve the local (albeit in rural Ireland's case this could mean a 10-20km radius) community.


  • Registered Users Posts: 16,500 ✭✭✭✭DEFTLEFTHAND


    It must annoy the anti-Catholic brigade, that they are infact Catholics themselves. I don't particularly give a toss about religion, and am non-practicing, but I was still christened, so am still a Catholic at the end of the day whether I like it or not. Just like 95% of this country. It's only a minute at 6 anyway, so who cares? Get out more if that's all you have to worry about. As long as this country is predominantly Catholic, there will always be some Catholic tradition in it whether people like it or not

    Once you're Confirmed you become a full made member and you can never leave. At this point you become a Soldier of Christ.


  • Advertisement
  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 3,188 ✭✭✭DoYouEvenLift


    It's like a minute long, why bother interfering with it, just change the channel if it bothers you. There are still lots of elderly people who enjoy that stuff, do you not have any old relatives who are happy out in their traditional ways?


  • Registered Users Posts: 476 ✭✭Cen taurus


    It's like a minute long, why bother interfering with it, just change the channel if it bothers you. There are still lots of elderly people who enjoy that stuff, do you not have any old relatives who are happy out in their traditional ways?

    They have, that's the problem holding them back, and apparently they aren't dying off fast enough for some people, hence the demands for euthanasia to be brought in, before the pillows have to come out. No country for old men it seems.


Advertisement