Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Werewolf - Mario vs Sonic - SONIC WORLD
Options
Comments
-
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
Ok, Clodagh next. Clodagh enters with a fairly big post....Clodagh WW wrote: »Right, caught up, it's been a long day!
It's been an interesting read, and at least not usual D0 fluff (it not being D0 and all certainly helps). I am a bit lost in the whole Angus/Vernon/Phil battle that's going on. And that's before we add in Mary and Desmond. I'd say that there's a good chance of there being a wolf in that lot (which isn't exactly rocket science, I grant you, since 30% are wolves here anyway and I've just named 50% of us).
I think I need to read back with a clearer head to make sense of who's defending who and who's accusing who here. In the mean time I think it'll be nearly lottery as to who I pick from that lot for lynch. Though with over two hours still to go there could be more info to be garnered. I've put a placeholder in anyway in case I fall asleep before time.
Confidence of a wolf in that lot gives me pause. You've just named half the players :pac: (Which granted, you point out, but why make a redundant statement like that. The Angus Vernon Phil thing I'd advise people to look at if Clodagh is a wolf at a later date. I have a thing about rule of 3 and grouping people together like that. I know I'm a villager, but I'm happy to be looked into regardless. Phil has claimed Sonic which leaves... Angus. But enough on that for now.
I also don't like the use of the word lottery, random voting for a lynch isn't a villager move, but anyways, we'll move on.Clodagh WW wrote: »Can somebody who knows more about Sonic explain the Emeralds things to me and why it looks like Vernon is collecting them?
Ok another question about the Emeralds. They're topical and easy to talk about so could be done as either alignment.Clodagh WW wrote: »Okay, thanks. So, Vernon did a task for sure, so it's for us to decide whether he's Sonic or Wario? While 50/50 of catching a wolf sounds good, I'm not sure I'm happy on going 50/50 on losing our Hero? I don't think it's a good idea to vote for him. Maybe depending on how others flip later in the game, will tell us more on which way his task leans him?
Clodagh actually responds. I don't like (naturally) the auto jump to me doing a task rather than thinking it through. Could be just jumping to conclusions but it could also be a way to pile on a bandwagon. Sonic hasn't claimed yet either. The 50/50 thing has been debunked already by better mathematicians than me so I'm not touching that.Clodagh WW wrote: »Alright, just did a bit of Googling (Wikipediaing to be precise) and all of our goodies are from Sonic and our baddies from Mario, though this is the Sonic thread. That's probably obvious to anyone who knows the games, but wasn't to me. Does that mean anything for our game though?
Fluff, gamespeak but not really relevant gamespeak. I can see a wolf posting this to try and seem involved in the thread.Clodagh WW wrote: »Okay, based on Vernon's weak-ass defence, I'm happy to take Phil at his word and vote to lynch Vernon.
Fair enough, interesting that you never explain what is weak about my defence though. Would you prefer me to have counter-claimed and lied?Clodagh WW wrote: »Why would a Villager do a task?
The task thing, fair question.Clodagh WW wrote: »What task? So you just happened to write sentences that started with the initial letters of each number?
I never noticed any task until you pointed them out.
That's the whole point of my self-appointed task, it was hardly random. Fair enough though.Clodagh WW wrote: »Why? Do you think Phil is lying so?Clodagh WW wrote: »Surely, if that was your plan then Phil's reveal would be inconvenient, no?
These two posts go together so I'll respond to both at the same time. There's a lot of questions from Clodagh which is natural, but I'm seeing a pattern here of reactive posting rather than proactive, there isn't any gamesolving apart from her jumble sale of players in her opening post.Clodagh WW wrote: »I don't understand why Des, Angus and Vernon would vote to off a roled player claim???
Again, fair question, but you also seem to ignore the off wagon voters who didn't commit either way.Clodagh WW wrote: »Even if you’re right about wolf Phil being saved by the Shaman, you didn’t know that before the lynch and you risked lynching our potential Hero.
Again, it's a fair point but I've responded to this. Only person as a villager I'm sure of at this time is me, so why would I not vote to save myself.
And that's it from last night. So this morning...Clodagh WW wrote: »a) if Phil is telling the truth (which I personally believe he is, though don't know it for sure)
b) if Wario has the same tasks as Sonic
c) if Wario somehow failed on all three sections of task. Maybe he only failed on one (ie, got the post count, got the FFA but nobody voted to lynch him, who would that include?). Or maybe Wario completed it, but Sonic got there first
There's a lot of parameters, and I'm not just saying that because I'm in that list. Look into me all you want. I've nothing to hide. But don't tunnel to just those three, as Wario could be anywhere and there's also two other wolves somewhere too.
Responded directly to my thoughts on Wario possibly being one of her, Liam or Katie. And her points are valid. That's more like her first post. Proactive and looking for other avenues.Clodagh WW wrote: »Just checked, so in answer to my own question, Vernon's trio of those who didn't FFA or reach post limit (I'm taking his word on this btw, though I know I didn't do an FFA) were Clodagh, Liam and Katie who also didn't have anyone voting for them. But also not to receive a vote against them, but did reach limit and did FFA were Desmond and Gabriel.
Again, a better look. Proactive.Clodagh WW wrote: »A 1up as in your vote counted twice, or you starting with -1 as a tally? In that case, why wasn't Vernon lynched, instead of no-one?Clodagh WW wrote: »Yep. Best case scenario we lynched a wolf, but not losing a villager is a pretty good second prize.Clodagh WW wrote: »Ah, okay. Lack of theme knowledge is my downfall again. Thanks. Makes sense.Clodagh WW wrote: »Yay, good news!!!
Last four are NAI, they're likely to be made as either alignment.
Summary: Clodagh has some good points but equally some bad. She comes across as an emotive poster, with the use of exclamation points and multiple question marks which is no bad thing. It shows she has an interest in the game at the very least, so definitely not disinterested.
However she has a tendency to be very reactive, and the probing questions she asks aren't really gathering information in my opinion, as she doesn't follow up on a lot of them.
I also really dislike her player salad in her first post, naming half the roster and saying there's likely to be a wolf in there really doesn't help anyone.
Overall though there are positive points and she's improved on the reactive/proactive divide a good bit this morning.
I'd have her as more likely to be a villager than a wolf at this point in time.0 -
-
Sonic Challenge - Sonic World
- A mod will play the first level of Sonic the Hedgehog (Megadrive version) on a fast run.
- Each player will PM a Mod (Kolido) the time they think it will take to complete the level. HINT: It is under 1 minute
- The player closest to the time (over or under) will be declared the winner. In the event there is a tie, the player who PM's the earliest will be declared the winner.
- Winner will receive prize to use in the game.
What you need to do: PM me a time, under 1 min, you have until 11:300 -
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
Ok so the plan was to attempt to draw the first munch. I know I'm a villager so my obvious 'task' might draw the kill onto me instead of a more important player.
If in fact Phil is Sonic then that's a little faux pas on my part but I stand by the points I made yesterday that he was acting extremely wolfy, and my job as a villager is to find wolves.
Personally I'd probably never do that as I would assume it'd draw the village onto me as apposed to the wolves especially with us starting with a lynch but once again what your posting today makes far more sense to me than yesterday and I had assumed it was something along those lines so will probably leave the "task" talk... for a while at least 0 -
-
Personally I'd probably never do that as I would assume it'd draw the village onto me as apposed to the wolves especially with us starting with a lynch but once again what your posting today makes far more sense to me than yesterday and I had assumed it was something along those lines so will probably leave the "task" talk... for a while at least
I walk on the wild side
Makes things more interesting. 0 -
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
Advertisement