Kilkenny GAA Discussion Thread Mod Warning Post # 5885 #4894 & #5202

Powerhouse1 · 01-06-2015 10:50pm

Why can't a Kilkenny Referee make it on to the elite Inter County Panel? Is it down to not having quality Refs in Kilkenny? Seems that Westmeath have one of the better records of producing top Referees.

pmy.murphy · 01-06-2015 10:55pm

Powerhouse1 wrote: »

Why can't a Kilkenny Referee make it on to the elite Inter County Panel? Is it down to not having quality Refs in Kilkenny? Seems that Westmeath have one of the better records of producing top Referees.

I cant name any top referees from Westmeath anyway

blackcard · 01-06-2015 11:00pm

pmy.murphy wrote: »

[/B]

I cant name any top referees from Westmeath anyway

Careful, Brian

dobbs2210 · 01-06-2015 11:05pm

Did you happen to take in any Kilkenny club games locally of late. The standard of reffing is absolutely scandalous to say the least. Maybe 2 decent referee's in Kilkenny at a stretch.

pmy.murphy · 01-06-2015 11:09pm

dobbs2210 wrote: »

Did you happen to take in any Kilkenny club games locally of late. The standard of reffing is absolutely scandalous to say the least. Maybe 2 decent referee's in Kilkenny at a stretch.

I thought Maurice Flynn was atrocious in the Rower V Mvat game last weekend. Some awful decisions and stupid frees awarded rather evenly to both sides including the Rowers winning score which came from yet another questionable free. It was a terrible performance from him

unrealtime · 01-06-2015 11:10pm

Think that is a very good under-21 team and I expect them to win tomorrow.

blackcard · 01-06-2015 11:13pm

unrealtime wrote: »

Think that is a very good under-21 team and I expect them to win tomorrow.

I think Dublin beat them at Minor level 3 years ago, home advantage too. Hope for the best

citykat · 02-06-2015 7:30am

Powerhouse1 wrote: »

Why can't a Kilkenny Referee make it on to the elite Inter County Panel? Is it down to not having quality Refs in Kilkenny? Seems that Westmeath have one of the better records of producing top Referees.

AFAIR Pascal Long is the most recent high profile referee we have had and it must be over 25 yrs since he has officiated at a high level. Our record in providing referees is poor given our profile in the game. From what I have seen at local level it's going to be a while before we see a Kilkenny referee in charge of a high profile inter county game.

citykat · 02-06-2015 7:58am

savannahkat wrote: »

Anyone here know much about the under 21 team.

Darren Brennan (St. Lachtains)

2. Conor Delaney (Erin’s Own)

3. Cíaran Wallace (Erin’s Own)

4. Evan Cody (Dicksboro) (Capt.)

5. Jason Cleere (Bennettstbridge)

6. Diarmuid Cody (James Stephens)

7. Paddy Deegan (O’Loughlin/Gaels)

8. James Maher (St. Lachtains)

9. Mark Mansfield (Mullinavat)

10. Cíaran Ryan (Rower/Inistioge)

11. Willie Brennan (Fenians)

12. Liam Blanchfield (Bennettsbridge)

13. Liam Hickey (St.Lachtains)

14. Conor Martin (Emeralds)

15. Chris Bolger (Clara)

16. Alan Murphy (Glenmore)

17. Brian Troy (Emeralds)

18. Enda Morrissey (Bennettsbridge)

19. Huw Lawler (O’Loughlin/Gaels)

20. Luke Scanlon (James Stephens)

21. Tom Phelan (Conahy Shamrocks)

22. David Burke (O’Loughlin/Gaels)

23. Niall Mullins (James Stephens)

24. Séan Morrissey (Bennettsbridge)

I wouldn't have any fear for this team from a hurling ability point of view as they're all playing senior/intermediate with their clubs. The only issue is how well they gel/play together. There's very few of these lads involved with the senior panel (AFAIK) at the moment. This should be a plus as it can be a distraction.

babyjesus14 · 02-06-2015 8:54am

unrealtime wrote: »

Think that is a very good under-21 team and I expect them to win tomorrow.

It's a very "young" under 21 side by my count at least nine of the starting 15 are underage again next year, don't know about Brennan and Hickey. Five of the starters have another two years in this grade. Would be fearful about tomorrow night, 5 of the Dublin team were part of the 24 for the seniors on Sunday. But if we could get through tomorrow night it would open everything up and i would expect us to at least make an All-Ireland final.

junospider · 02-06-2015 9:17am

Who ever organised this fixture is some genius,some of these lads are starting the leaving cert tomorrow.

Deathwish4 · 02-06-2015 9:57am

pmy.murphy wrote: »

I thought Maurice Flynn was atrocious in the Rower V Mvat game last weekend. Some awful decisions and stupid frees awarded rather evenly to both sides including the Rowers winning score which came from yet another questionable free. It was a terrible performance from him

Flynns handling of the Village & Ballyhale drawn County Final a few years back was one of the worst refereeing displays i've ever had the misfortune to witness.

On a broader note, if John Walsh is still refereeing Senior Club games in this county, then I think that says it all really about the standard that's out there.

Deathwish4 · 02-06-2015 9:59am

unrealtime wrote: »

Think that is a very good under-21 team and I expect them to win tomorrow.

I'd be of the opposite opinion actually, I think Dublin will win this.

babyjesus14 · 02-06-2015 10:18am

junospider wrote: »

Who ever organised this fixture is some genius,some of these lads are starting the leaving cert tomorrow.

Surely that is down to the individuals, their parents and the management team. The Leinster council can't provide for every possible eventuality, the Minor is put on hold for 6 weeks because more players are likely to be effected in that grade. Under 21's doing their Leaving would be the exception rather than the rule.

Mountainlad · 02-06-2015 11:09am

I think there was a Cleere lad reffing games there a few years ago, may only have been Minor matches though.

babyjesus14 · 02-06-2015 11:13am

Mountainlad wrote: »

I think there was a Cleere lad reffing games there a few years ago, may only have been Minor matches though.

He was the sideline official who reported Pat Donnellan for striking with the hurl in the Clare-Limerick game.

dzer2 · 02-06-2015 12:38pm

Mountainlad wrote: »

I think there was a Cleere lad reffing games there a few years ago, may only have been Minor matches though.

Yeah he reffed the minor final a few yrs back think it was the won with the dodgy point.

citykat · 02-06-2015 1:06pm

junospider wrote: »

Who ever organised this fixture is some genius,some of these lads are starting the leaving cert tomorrow.

Most of the lads impacted are on the bench as far as I can see?

babyjesus14 · 02-06-2015 1:20pm

citykat wrote: »

Most of the lads impacted are on the bench as far as I can see?

Cleere and Blanchfield are doing it.... hardly makes a difference whether they are playing or not unless they were planning on getting a bit of study done on the bench!

WhatsGoingOn2 · 02-06-2015 1:23pm

babyjesus14 wrote: »

Cleere and Blanchfield are doing it.... hardly makes a difference whether they are playing or not unless they were planning on getting a bit of study done on the bench!

Delaney is doing it too

citykat · 02-06-2015 2:25pm

babyjesus14 wrote: »

Cleere and Blanchfield are doing it.... hardly makes a difference whether they are playing or not unless they were planning on getting a bit of study done on the bench!

I presumed the original concern was regarding potential for injury rather than study. An evening away from the books at this stage aint going to make much of a difference.

Fireball07 · 02-06-2015 2:40pm

Last year Cian Lynch played an U-21 game the night of his first exam, with Dean Coleman coming on as a sub iirc. Most players doing the Leaving opt out of the squad if they have a match around the Leaving. I think it is a decision that it is up to the player himself- personally, I would have loved nothing more than playing a match the evening after my first exam but others are different.

Although maybe it could be delayed, the rest of the provincial games are played within a couple of weeks at the end of July, surely they could fit this in at the end of June or something?

savannahkat · 02-06-2015 2:42pm

According to the Indo, Chris Bolger, Brian Troy, Diarmuid Cody and Conor Martin are part of the senior panel.

citykat · 02-06-2015 2:49pm

savannahkat wrote: »

According to the Indo, Chris Bolger, Brian Troy, Diarmuid Cody and Conor Martin are part of the senior panel.

As far as I know bar Bolger, the rest are part of the extended panel i.e. making up numbers in training. Lot of people though reckon Cody will make matchday panel(s) this year.

babyjesus14 · 02-06-2015 2:56pm

savannahkat wrote: »

According to the Indo, Chris Bolger, Brian Troy, Diarmuid Cody and Conor Martin are part of the senior panel.

And Troy can't make the team? Which surprises me, i was impressed by him the few times i saw him hurling with UL in the spring.

pat 22 · 02-06-2015 8:06pm

Any reports from the u 21 game tonight ?

Brian017 · 02-06-2015 8:11pm

pat 22 wrote: »

Any reports from the u 21 game tonight ?

It's live on the box. Dublin lead 1-8 to 1-6 at HT. We should be further behind tbh

STB. · 02-06-2015 8:11pm

pat 22 wrote: »

Any reports from the u 21 game tonight ?

Dublin 1-8 Kilkenny 1-6. Half time. Dubs should be miles ahead. TG4

pat 22 · 02-06-2015 8:13pm

I'm out of the country, unfortunately won't see it !

STB. · 02-06-2015 8:15pm

pat 22 wrote: »

I'm out of the country, unfortunately won't see it !

They dont geoblock it http://www.tg4.tv/beo.html

Kilkenny GAA Discussion Thread Mod Warning Post # 5885 #4894 & #5202

Comments