Good Friday and no meat.

RichieC · 22-04-2011 02:02PM

Corvus Maximus wrote: »

Anyway OP - I'll eat meat today, who declared it wrong anyway?

Not the bible anyway.

krudler · 22-04-2011 02:03PM

Corvus Maximus wrote: »

Assuming there was a JC, once emperor Constantine legitimised Christianity in the Roman Empire, we have seen the gradual usurping of JC's message of tolerance, compassion and forgiveness ect, ect. The church has evolved into a militaristic structure of religious rank - Priest, Canon, Bishops ect. Somehow I don't think they got the memo from JC really.

We now have a system of man made dictates issued from the emperor in Roman, bear in mind this guy has nothing in common with JC's message. Centralised control and domination is we what we have today. How can these guys stand up and use JC as a role model. When their church is worth billions, yet millions die of disease and starvation every year. If there was ever a case for evil, then this hypocrisy is surely it?

Anyway OP - I'll eat meat today, who declared it wrong anyway?

If more Christians were more Christ-like and less Christian the world would be better off.

Son Of A Vidic · 22-04-2011 02:04PM

krudler wrote: »

If more Christians were more Christ-like and less Christian the world would be better off.

Well said and there is the irony of it all.

Doublin · 22-04-2011 02:05PM

hondasam wrote: »

I Don't agree with a lot of what the catholic religion is but it will not stop me saying a prayer before I go to sleep. I do it for me and nobody else. I'm not asking you are anyone else to approve or disapprove.

I am very against the Catholic Church(and all organised religions) as an institution, that throughout history caused as much bad as good for people.

Having said that, I am spiritual. I wouldn't say a prayer, but I take a few minutes out of my day to find a quiet spot on a park bench & talk to 'something'. It doesn't have a face that I picture (if I was to give it a name I'd say the Holy Spirit) & I'm not asking for things. It's just something that helps me contemplate my day, work through things & brings a bit of peace to my life. If a prayer before you go asleep gives you something beneficial like that, than stay with it. You don't have to prove anything to anyone else on how religious you are and how many of the man-made religious rules you adhere to. It's a personal relationship.

The Church is a man-made thing & it's rules are man-made, and we all know how perfect man is.. I've had numerous discussions with a friend who is a priest. He agrees with the failings of the Church & agrees that if what I do works for me, then keep it. He actually gave me a bible once & I tried to read it, but again I can only see it a something written by man & was written/interpreted with an agenda, so I didn't go back to it. His spiritual beliefs have led him to help many people in inner city Dublin and he is a very good person.

hondasam · 22-04-2011 02:07PM

RichieC wrote: »

no one said you cant pray at home. you misrepresented our argument.

RichieC wrote: »

:pac:

you're taking the piss, right?

have you told people what you want to happen when You die ?
will you want prayers?

Rhyme · 22-04-2011 02:09PM

Countdown to BBQ, delighted.

RichieC · 22-04-2011 02:11PM

hondasam wrote: »

have you told people what you want to happen when You die ?
will you want prayers?

I want to be put in the trash, like my hero.

krudler · 22-04-2011 02:11PM

Corvus Maximus wrote: »

Well said and there is the irony of it all.

indeed, I dont think Jesus had a city sized palace and marble altars in mind when he was going around preaching about the simple life.

krudler · 22-04-2011 02:12PM

RichieC wrote: »

I want to be put in the trash, like my hero.

I want to be shot.

out of a cannon.

into the sun.

RichieC · 22-04-2011 02:12PM

krudler wrote: »

I want to be shot.

out of a cannon.

into the sun.

this is better!

hondasam · 22-04-2011 02:18PM

RichieC wrote: »

I want to be put in the trash, like my hero.

seriously will there be prayers?

I know people who are not religious etc etc but they would want a funeral and mass, this I cannot understand.

I myself would want a private service and cremation.

minidazzler · 22-04-2011 02:19PM

mconigol wrote: »

Yeah congratulations you went online and found the first definition in a google search. That's not a proper definition in my opinion.

You have a great deal of faith in google. Yet more irony.

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/cult

Now, that's the official definition in Merriam webster...I guess that a well respected definition isn't proper because you don't want it to be either?

mconigol wrote: »

No where did I say that?

It would quite likely be considered a cult. Not definitely though. As far as I am the classifications are not exactly precise.

You just don't want classifications to be precise so you feel secure in your belief that you are a member of the one true religion, when given you believe in exactly one more god than me, and there are hundreds of religions and gods, how can you be sure of yours?

(P.S. Fry up on, but that was planned before I realised it was good friday.)

GLaDOS · 22-04-2011 02:20PM

hondasam wrote: »

I know people who are not religious etc etc but they would want a funeral and mass, this I cannot understand.

More than likely because it's the way things are done, a lot of people don't really question it and just go along with it. I don't mean that in a disrespectful way, it's just not an issue for people.

Personally, religion will not be anywhere near my funeral.

Adyx · 22-04-2011 02:25PM

This thread shows up exactly what's wrong discussing religion in AH. Some of the atheists on Boards border on fanaticism with their preaching.

hondasam · 22-04-2011 02:27PM

ScienceNerd wrote: »

More than likely because it's the way things are done, a lot of people don't really question it and just go along with it. I don't mean that in a disrespectful way, it's just not an issue for people.

Personally, religion will not be anywhere near my funeral.

I agree but it is been hypocritical.

stovelid · 22-04-2011 02:30PM

Not eating meat on Good Friday because the church told you to = church is inside your head

Going out of your way to eat meat because the church told you not to = church is inside your head

kylith · 22-04-2011 02:30PM

Conversation with Himself today:

Me: If you have any ideas for dinner let me know.
Him: Isn't it Good Friday?
M: Yeah
H: So... Steak?

Steak it is!

Pace2008 · 22-04-2011 02:33PM

hondasam wrote: »

I agree but it is been hypocritical.

It's not being hypocritical, it just means they haven't really taken the time to honestly consider their position.

I bit like you saying you disagree with a lot of what the Catholic Church teaches, but still identify with them because you say a prayer before bed. (If I haven't misconstrued your sentiments).

stimpson · 22-04-2011 02:41PM

stovelid wrote: »

Not eating meat on Good Friday because the church told you to = church is inside your head

Going out of your way to eat meat because the church told you not to = church is inside your head

And going out of your way to eat meat because it is delicious = bacon inside your belly.

krudler · 22-04-2011 02:41PM

Adyx wrote: »

This thread shows up exactly what's wrong discussing religion in AH. Some of the atheists on Boards border on fanaticism with their preaching.

what preaching? the majority of athiests on boards know more about the religion that supposed catholics follow. its just people who see through the bullsh1t around religion and can hold an argument better than "ah shure tis what we are" reasoning behind being an Irish Catholic.

Adyx · 22-04-2011 02:50PM

krudler wrote: »

what preaching? the majority of athiests on boards know more about the religion that supposed catholics follow. its just people who see through the bullsh1t around religion and can hold an argument better than "ah shure tis what we are" reasoning behind being an Irish Catholic.

I wasn't specifically referring to this thread (although there is a certain amount in it imo). What does it matter what you or I know about the religion? If a person chooses to believe in God or practice the Catholic faith, I can respect that and not feel the need to call them stupid or sheep or hypocrites. But this almost invariably happens in this forum when someone mentions that they pray or don't eat meet on Good Friday or go to mass. It's as if atheists feel they need to educate the poor misguided unfortunates of the errors of their ways.

There isn't half as much preaching from people who are religious in some way.

stimpson · 22-04-2011 02:57PM

Adyx wrote: »

There isn't half as much preaching from people who are religious in some way.

You should check out the Christianity forum sometime. The mods there are nearly as fundamentalist as the ones in Cycling.

mossyc123 · 22-04-2011 03:01PM

krudler wrote: »

fffuuuuu

Personal Abuse or am I mistaken?

krudler · 22-04-2011 03:02PM

mossyc123 wrote: »

Personal Abuse or am I mistaken?

if you're that rageface meme, sure

mossyc123 · 22-04-2011 03:03PM

stimpson wrote: »

You should check out the Christianity forum sometime. The mods there are nearly as fundamentalist as the ones in Cycling.

This thread isn't in the Christianity or A&A forum though.

RichieC · 22-04-2011 03:04PM

wouldnt piss on the Christianity forum... never seen so much complete bollocks compressed into a single forum in my entire life.

And I freq Free Republic.

krudler · 22-04-2011 03:07PM

RichieC wrote: »

wouldnt piss on the Christianity forum... never seen so much complete bollocks compressed into a single forum in my entire life.

And I freq Free Republic.

I got myself banned from there

(my request) couldnt be bothered with the place anymore, I still go in while logged out for a chuckle sometimes though.

mossyc123 · 22-04-2011 03:07PM

krudler wrote: »

if you're that rageface meme, sure

So your "raging" about someone following tradition?

stimpson · 22-04-2011 03:11PM

mossyc123 wrote: »

This thread isn't in the Christianity or A&A forum though.

Which is why it's still going - nobody to stand up for the crybabies.

mossyc123 · 22-04-2011 03:15PM

stimpson wrote: »

Which is why it's still going - nobody to stand up for the crybabies.

Good Friday and no meat.

Comments