Kilkenny GAA Thread

kksaints

Horrible 2nd half although Carlow deserve huge credit for their performance. Murphy's puckouts were disgraceful in the 2nd half, too slow and hitting them down on top of a sweeper. TJ ha one of his worst matches and the rest of the forwards were awful. Half back line kept shooting wides, Awful, Awful stuff. Ref was appalling and really he shouldn't be near inter county level.

dastardly00

I know many people will give out about the officiating, and there was some shocking decisions, but the ref wasn't the reason we didn't win that match. The players were awful. Some of the shot decisions and subsequent wides. Absolutely brutal. The criticism will be deserved.

EDIT: I should add, well done to Carlow. Great performance from them.

The White Feather

Great game for a neutral and I think a draw was fair but last last free was ridiculous. Its like the ref said ah lets give Carlow a draw!

KK wides were very poor

jamesbond2022

Deserved draw for Carlow but a few questionable calls by the ref near the end on cian Kenny and I’ve never seen a free given for a player throwing the ball away when it was off the field already

Our accuracy and overall urgency didn’t seem to be to there at little bit like Galway last week I think we took Carlow for granted and thought we just had to show up

Were Under a lot of pressure now with that result

The injuries and knocks are piling up

me89

Going long on nearly every puck out in the 2nd half when there was a free man on to go short nearly every time. Then from open play lumping high ball down on top of the extra man. Woeful shooting to top it off

kksaints

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122124888#Comment_122124888

I agree really some of the shot choices, puckouts and tackling were dreadful. No composure from any of the players and management.

blackcard

Apparently the last free was given for throwing the ball into the stand. Never saw one given for that before

The White Feather

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122124914#Comment_122124914

Yes I never saw it too but they said technically a free. I never knew that

kk.man

I just can't believe that result… in all of my time maybe westmeath 2009 but we won that game!

hurlaway

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122124917#Comment_122124917

Let's hope the ref in Cork will be as diligent on all the throwing we are about to see,but I wouldn't hold my breath

gobo99

Why was the free 10 yards in from the sideline though? Bizarre

Well done to Carlow

Charlie69

Ah jaysus lads…. We were absolutely brutal, exactly how not to play with 14 men. Fair play to Carlow but my God the referee …. I thought James Owen’s was bad but that was just incredible. Seriously what was the last free for?… I don’t think the ball was even in play?

kala85

Who was sent off.

Can't find a report of the game anywhere

brookville

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122124907#Comment_122124907

Its no suprise that scruffs puckouts have being dreadful a long time now. We were complacent but playing a chap completely out of his dept is scandalous. Theres lads who have being consistently poor a long and just keep getting picked. Ya wouldnt see it in any other county

Charlie69

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122124972#Comment_122124972

Killian Doyle…. genuinely no idea why.

me89

Killian Doyle was sent off

mullinr2

Would we even get out of Munster?

JJs Left Hand

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122124990#Comment_122124990

End of the hurl into the ribs

usualstripes

Firstly fair play to Carlow. That draw will hopefully spur the county onto greater things. In leinster we need as many competitive teams as possible to be up there challenging and today even though kilkenny had most of the play they never gave up and got some decent scores.

The officiating was cruel and hard to believe at times but the winning of the game should be beyond that particular side of things.

As for ourselves we don't really need to say a whole lot apart from we were as poor as most of us could have imagined.

Our movement and passing coming out of the backs in the 1st half was actually good. Its just that we spurned so many chances. In the 2nd half our movement was all over the place, as was our cavalier attitude with passing and deliveries into the forwards.

Hard to comprehend really. We were far too casual in our approach so the lessons to be learned are simple

Give 110% for every ball, pass and delivery we make and in the forwards we need to be far more clinical, in our movement, passing and striking.

Fairly simple. A trip to parnell Park will end in tears if we don't.

Swamp_Cat

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122124783#Comment_122124783

I don't. Just a perspective from someone outside the KK bubble for the most part. Love the place btw. Watergarden still around? Used to take friends niece and nephew there after bringing them to train w/their club. Nice relaxing place if not a little yuppie-ish + $$. 😉 Anyway, All the best.

Shocking result today. Carlow deserved it though.

Charlie69

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122125009#Comment_122125009

Fair enough…. Couldn’t see it but everyone around me baffled. Really don’t want to come across as a bad sport because I’m actually very pleased for Tom Mullally and the Carlow hurlers but you just couldn’t not mention how poor the ref was.

davidx40

When in the name of god are we going to see sense and get a goalkeeper who can distribute the ball .....people are saying it on here with 5 years

brookville

Murphy is in the goal a long time now. The whole county has being on about the puckouts for years. Kk were cruising till the sending off. We got a massive kick up the hole today.

mullinr2

Lyng should have read the riot act after the match. I know Cody would have. Unacceptable to be drawing with Carlow

JJs Left Hand

The Tommy Walsh for Billy Ryan substitution was criminal. Incredibly negative. Just no need for it.

verizon

It's quite typical of Kilkenny of recent years not managing out games well enough.

I was watching the warmup and it was quite intense for such a hot day, yet they still went out in 2nd gear and never up'd their game at all. Very strange day for kilkenny hurling.

An absolute fantastic day for Carlow hurling on the other hand.

Charlie69

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122125244#Comment_122125244

Good point re not closing out games …. happened in Galway and far too many times in the last couple of years.

BearMarketFresh

Serious questions for Derek Lyng to answer. The poorest performance I've seen from a Kilkenny side ever.

mullinr2

They would be wiped out of it in Munster

Marrooned

our crowd wouldn’t give Tom Mullally any of the underage jobs ? Will Killian Doyle still be eligible Wednesday night seen as it’s a different competition