The Weird, Wacky and Awesome World of the NFL - General Banter thread V3

adrian522

He's letting Twitter know about it anyway.

https://twitter.com/RSherman_25

Foxtrol

adrian522 wrote: »

He's letting Twitter know about it anyway.

https://twitter.com/RSherman_25

Now that he is with the 49ers I love how he keeps himself continuously annoyed. In general I don't like it when players in public force that kind of motivation but the fact that he gets so animated about it, nearly to the point of parody, is hilarious.

Foxtrol

Realt Dearg Sec wrote: »

I was one of the people who was critical of him at the time. I mean it was still a pretty reckless gamble, but repeatedly he's proven himself to be one of the smartest players in the league, so sooner or later you have to admit he had a better understanding and analysis of the situation than his critics.

I think it was completely fair to question the deal, I did myself, but some of the stuff was way over the top, especially from elements of the media.

Plenty of agents sign players up to much worse deals than what Sherman agreed, even when younger and not coming off a serious injury, and practically all the media won't say a negative thing because the agent has leaked some ridiculously over-inflated number to make it sound great and the rest of the media parrot it.

raze_them_all_

Richard sher an going to town on twitter about everyone said he got screwed when he negotiated his own contract... Made about 13 million this year

el Fenomeno

Derrick Henry's senior season in high school:

krustydoyle

Cowboys just hired Mike McCarthy as their new coach

phatkev

krustydoyle wrote: »

Cowboys just hired Mike McCarthy as their new coach

They've somehow manged to get a coach just as bad as Garrett!

brinty

krustydoyle wrote:

Cowboys just hired Mike McCarthy as their new coach

I'm disgusted and in utter awe of how inept Jerry Jones could be

Itssoeasy

krustydoyle wrote: »

Cowboys just hired Mike McCarthy as their new coach

Why ?

DvB

krustydoyle wrote: »

Cowboys just hired Mike McCarthy as their new coach

Ah FFS!!! Finally an opportunity to freshen up the team & we go & hire the one coach that could match Garret in the underwhelming stakes.

MrKingsley

https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2019/12/16/mike-mccarthy-coaching-nfl-fmia-week-15-peter-king/

A bit of reading on how he’s been scouting the league and different trends the past year.

Have to admire the man for adapting.

I don’t think it’s a terrible hire at all. A young or college coach may not have been able to deal with Jones sticking his beak in non stop

Foxtrol

MrKingsley wrote: »

https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2019/12/16/mike-mccarthy-coaching-nfl-fmia-week-15-peter-king/

A bit of reading on how he’s been scouting the league and different trends the past year.

Have to admire the man for adapting.

I don’t think it’s a terrible hire at all. A young or college coach may not have been able to deal with Jones sticking his beak in non stop

Agree that he isn't as terrible a coach as is being made out here. Think he will be an improvement on Garret and I don't think the Cowboys is a franchise where it would suit a college coach trying to find their footing. Old Jerrah is on the clock and I don't think he'd want to be baby sitting. It will be interesting how McCarthy deals with Zeke and his big deal given his clear dislike for running the ball.

I won't be holding my breath on his claims to have spent the year adapting. It might be true but it coming out so publicly at the time it did stinks of a PR move to change the perception of him with owners.

MrKingsley

Foxtrol wrote: »

Agree that he isn't as terrible a coach as is being made out here. Think he will be an improvement on Garret and I don't think the Cowboys is a franchise where it would suit a college coach trying to find their footing. Old Jerrah is on the clock and I don't think he'd want to be baby sitting. It will be interesting how McCarthy deals with Zeke and his big deal given his clear dislike for running the ball.

I won't be holding my breath on his claims to have spent the year adapting. It might be true but it coming out so publicly at the time it did stinks of a PR move to change the perception of him with owners.

Yeah possibly so but that would’ve become pretty obvious during the interview process if that was the case surely

Foxtrol

MrKingsley wrote: »

Yeah possibly so but that would’ve become pretty obvious during the interview process if that was the case surely

Maybe with one of the teams with a more forward looking ownership or front office but we're talking about Jerrah here

MrKingsley

Foxtrol wrote: »

Maybe with one of the teams with a more forward looking ownership or front office but we're talking about Jerrah here

Fair point

Blut2

I don't know how any team could justify hiring a manager 10 years past his sell by date, like McCarthy, when there are so many bright young innovative offensively minded coaches like Lincoln Riley around. This seems a very poor choice.

adrian522

https://twitter.com/sonofbum/status/1214264465937403906

Phillips out in LA. Can't imagine he'll be unemployed for long.

Foxtrol

Blut2 wrote: »

I don't know how any team could justify hiring a manager 10 years past his sell by date, like McCarthy, when there are so many bright young innovative offensively minded coaches like Lincoln Riley around. This seems a very poor choice.

Shiny college coaches rarely work out in the NFL. I think they're a much better option when a team is rebuilding, like Arizona, than throwing them into the expectations of a talented team like the Cowboys.

Leaving that aside, by all accounts the Cowboys are one of the last organisations that would give a coach, young or old, the freedom to innovate.

A lot of problems people have with McCarthy seem to be recency bias. Some coaches just become stale after being with a team for so long, see Andy Reid as an example

BonnieSituation

adrian522 wrote: »

https://twitter.com/sonofbum/status/1214264465937403906

Phillips out in LA. Can't imagine he'll be unemployed for long.

Can we have him back to Mile High please. :O

eagle eye

The offensive side will certainly improve with McCarthy as head coach. All his woes in Green Bay were related to the team's defense.
People were crying out for somebody who can get the most out of Elliott, Dak, Cooper et Al, well you got that.

And for all the moaners McCarthy is a superbowl winning head coach who had two losing full seasons versus nine winning ones in Green Bay.

Foxtrol

BonnieSituation wrote: »

Can we have him back to Mile High please. :O

A hybrid Wade/Fangio defense would be something.

Terrible move by the Rams to let him go. Defense is the least of their problems. If Salah gets a HC job, I'd love for the 49ers to go after him.

BonnieSituation

Foxtrol wrote: »

A hybrid Wade/Fangio defense would be something.

Terrible move by the Rams to let him go. Defense is the least of their problems. If Salah gets a HC job, I'd love for the 49ers to go after him.

I think that that would be almost be a certainty if Saleh goes somewhere.

raze_them_all_

Was amazed Mccarthy was only 50 wins above 500

Shedite27

Sounds like Giants, Panthers and Browns were all looking to offer McCarthy the gig after an interview, so he's obviously changed something that we don't see. The Peter King interview and others sounds like he's made some very good changes to his style. I'm not as negative as others are about it on here.

Jofspring

Ya it seems to me like the cowboys acted quick because of the strong interest in McCarthy from elsewhere.

The_Honeybadger

McCarthy might be the most boring appointment ever. That said, it is probably the right one if he surrounds himself with the right coaching team. He has been there, done that, and knows the league.

Always a big risk appointing a first time HC

cosatron

I always liked mike McCarthy, he came into a terrible situation at green bay after mike Sherman and steady the ship and got Favre to the Nfc championship who threw a crazy int in overtime against the giants and then moved on to Rodgers and won the superbowl. After the 15-1 season when Rodgers carried the team and got spanked in the divisional game against the giants, he should've got rid of Dom capers but held on to him for another 4 years and this irked allot of packers fans and reflected poorly on Mike and after the 2014 nfc championship game he lost a bit of his mojo in terms of playcalling. It will interesting to see how he gets on with dak, considering he had 2 Hall of famers in green bay and is the west coast style offence still viable in the nfl

Knex*

raze_them_all_ wrote: »

Was amazed Mccarthy was only 50 wins above 500

What do you mean, "only", that's a lot!

raze_them_all_

Knex. wrote: »

What do you mean, "only", that's a lot!

Not really when you consider his qb in a 13 year career, it's about 4 wins more than a loss a year

MrKingsley

raze_them_all_ wrote: »

Not really when you consider his qb in a 13 year career, it's about 4 wins more than a loss a year

So he “only” averages 10-6 in the regular season with a SB ring and 3 NFC championship games. Almost every single coach would be happy to retire with that CV