Mayo GAA Discussion Part 2

Fr Tod Umptious

ColeTrain wrote: »

An U-21 title nearly ten years ago doesn't give them a pass in my book nor does Holmes winning a league title nearly 15 years ago. Surely our standards are better than that? I'd look at recent things like Castlebar in the club final to be honest.

Playing Moran as a sweeper against Donegal was a good move but it wasn't the winning of the game. Man for man we are better than Donegal, like Galway it was a game we should be winning most days. You look back against Dublin and say we were lucky to come back from the dead with seven down, it was just pure heart from the players that got us the draw and nothing was learned in the replay. Vaughan starting was a poor call, high ball into O'Shea was a disaster, substitutions were off too. I got the impression that the players were really going for it this year by themselves.

I'd roll the dice and get someone else in. It will freshen things up at the very least because we're going nowhere with the current set-up if we are being honest. I've nothing against Pat and Noel personally but this group of players deserve the very best and the worst thing that could happen is that they chuck it and go through the motions. They need to be inspired and motivated for another year and that's something Noel and Pat won't do.

So who would be the someone else if the dice was rolled, and why ?

Honest question.

Always_Running

Ascii wrote: »

Agree whole heartedly...should not be putting s**te up until the county board meeting next week. Fuelling speculation and rumours

On a side, don't see any harm in giving the U21 job to Mauaghan. Well worth a shot in my eyes. Cant go any lower

The game has fairly moved on since Maughan last managed a county team however looking at the other nominations he will more than likely get this gig. The harm is the 2013 All Ireland minor winning team might end up not even winning a Connacht U21 title.

padd b1975

Generally speaking, I wouldn't be too worried about what AOS says on social media. He's a fine footballer obviously, but he won't be bothering the guys at Mensa anytime soon....

As for Maughan...... Is he really what young players need at this point in their development??

Ascii

Jimmy Macnulty wrote: »

Pretty sure the tweet is directed at the county board for ratifying the existing minor management team again. O'Sheas father was part of a management team that went for the position and I am very surprised myself they didn't get it. Bit silly putting a tweet like that out there though. Either say it out straight or don't say it at all.

I don't know anything about O Shea's father at all....has he any past managerial credentials or successes at club level(U12, 14, 16, minor) or is he only getting a look-in due to his connections with AOS, SOS and COS ?

naughto

He was the breaffy senior manager a few yrs ago did quite well with them if I remember correctly

threebeards

O'Shea's tweet relates to John Maughan throwing his hat into the U21 ring, albeit at a late stage, which resulted in Jim O'Shea's name not being accepted. Aidan's tweet couldn't have been worse/better timed, depending on which way you look at it - it's becoming clearer by the day that he and Pat Holmes have a tenuous relationship at best, to the point possibly (depending on validity of rumours) that O'Shea, among other senior players wants a change in management. The tweet last night, because of its timing, could have been seen to be an opening shot across the bow of the current management team, and the County Board in general. What the tweet has managed to do today, is open up the 'player revolt' rumours to becoming the only GAA topic in the County.

seligehgit

Hopefully we won't have some sorry bloodbath after the review.It appears to have been reported that Donie Buckley is staying on?

threebeards

seligehgit wrote: »

Hopefully we won't have some sorry bloodbath after the review.It appears to have been reported that Donie Buckley is staying on?

Yeah, so the Mayo News are saying. It's hard to know what's going on at the minute

Fr Tod Umptious

threebeards wrote: »

O'Shea's tweet relates to John Maughan throwing his hat into the U21 ring, albeit at a late stage, which resulted in Jim O'Shea's name not being accepted. Aidan's tweet couldn't have been worse/better timed, depending on which way you look at it - it's becoming clearer by the day that he and Pat Holmes have a tenuous relationship at best, to the point possibly (depending on validity of rumours) that O'Shea, among other senior players wants a change in management. The tweet last night, because of its timing, could have been seen to be an opening shot across the bow of the current management team, and the County Board in general. What the tweet has managed to do today, is open up the 'player revolt' rumours to becoming the only GAA topic in the County.

If there is going to be a player revolt then bring it on, can't beat a bit of chaos this time of the year.
As I said o the old thread about 12 months ago. "September is farce month at Mayo GAA"

But let's hope to God the new manager, if there is one, is credible and can bring Mayo forward.

Not like the last time we had a revolt.

martyos121

I don't believe the rumours of dissatisfaction with the management tbh. I don't think a new manager is necessary this year for two reasons:

1) Pat and Noel have only had the one year with this group, they should learn from their mistakes this year and be ready for next season.
2) There aren't many options out there for a new manager that would satisfy most of us. I'd take McStay but I don't see that happening, and there's no one else that really catches the eye that is available (not an expert on these matters by any means, so if I'm wrong there, by all means let me know.)

As far as the U21s, give it to Maughan. He's a safe option when we need stability in that group of players.

padd b1975

davegrohl48 wrote: »

Interesting regarding U21 teams 2006 and 2012.
We have a very good U21 team next year.
1 - Mark Mulligan
2 - Eddie Doran
3 - Seamus Cunniffe
4 - David Kenny
5 - Michael Hall
6 - Stephen Coen
7 - Barry Duffy
8 - Val Roughneen/Gary Walsh
9 - Mathew Ruane/Padraig Prendergast
10 - Sharoize Akram
11 - Diarmuid OConnor
12 - Conor Loftus
13 - Fionan Duffy
14 - TJ Byrne
15 - Brian Reape
That's a hell of a forward line built around the power of TJ Byrne, Fionan Duffy and Diarmuid OConnor.

Maughan musyt have seen this post and liked the look of the team:cool:

padd b1975

threebeards wrote: »

O'Shea's tweet relates to John Maughan throwing his hat into the U21 ring, albeit at a late stage, which resulted in Jim O'Shea's name not being accepted. Aidan's tweet couldn't have been worse/better timed, depending on which way you look at it - it's becoming clearer by the day that he and Pat Holmes have a tenuous relationship at best, to the point possibly (depending on validity of rumours) that O'Shea, among other senior players wants a change in management. The tweet last night, because of its timing, could have been seen to be an opening shot across the bow of the current management team, and the County Board in general. What the tweet has managed to do today, is open up the 'player revolt' rumours to becoming the only GAA topic in the County.

If this is true, I don't like it at all.

Sounds like the O'Shea family are turning into the Mortimer family #2 as regards a sense of entitlement to be involved with Mayo GAA.

seligehgit

martyos121 wrote: »

I don't believe the rumours of dissatisfaction with the management tbh. I don't think a new manager is necessary this year for two reasons:

1) Pat and Noel have only had the one year with this group, they should learn from their mistakes this year and be ready for next season.
2) There aren't many options out there for a new manager that would satisfy most of us. I'd take McStay but I don't see that happening, and there's no one else that really catches the eye that is available (not an expert on these matters by any means, so if I'm wrong there, by all means let me know.)

As far as the U21s, give it to Maughan. He's a safe option when we need stability in that group of players.

Yeah I don't imagine anything has changed re the financial issues the County Board had with Kevin McStay's candidacy,real shame as I thought he was well worth a shot.

davegrohl48

padd b1975 wrote: »

Maughan musyt have seen this post and liked the look of the team:cool:

There is a very winnable Connaught title to be won with the U21 team. It would be the very minimum with the talent pool available
- Good set of backs from 2013 (contained Tyrone in a beaten midfield)
- Good set of forwards from 2014 (goal scorers)
- One of Mayos best half forwards Diarmuid OConnor
- Stephen Coen and Michael Hall senior experience
- Outright physicality in Diarmuid, Fionan Duffy and TJ Byrne
If the midfield mix can be got right, absolutely that team should be gunning for an All Ireland final appearance. The only issue is with midfield. Neither in 2013 or 2014 were the midfields dominant.

Coillte_Bhoy

threebeards wrote: »

O'Shea's tweet relates to John Maughan throwing his hat into the U21 ring, albeit at a late stage, which resulted in Jim O'Shea's name not being accepted. Aidan's tweet couldn't have been worse/better timed, depending on which way you look at it - it's becoming clearer by the day that he and Pat Holmes have a tenuous relationship at best, to the point possibly (depending on validity of rumours) that O'Shea, among other senior players wants a change in management. The tweet last night, because of its timing, could have been seen to be an opening shot across the bow of the current management team, and the County Board in general. What the tweet has managed to do today, is open up the 'player revolt' rumours to becoming the only GAA topic in the County.

Think you're wrong there, it was actually the Minor management that O'Shea was looking to get involved in. delegates voted against opening it up to club nominations afaik

naughto

padd b1975 wrote: »

If this is true, I don't like it at all.

Sounds like the O'Shea family are turning into the Mortimer family #2 as regards a sense of entitlement to be involved with Mayo GAA.

Your talking throught your arse there in fairness with that comment

irishgeo

martyos121 wrote: »

I don't believe the rumours of dissatisfaction with the management tbh. I don't think a new manager is necessary this year for two reasons:

1) Pat and Noel have only had the one year with this group, they should learn from their mistakes this year and be ready for next season.
2) There aren't many options out there for a new manager that would satisfy most of us. I'd take McStay but I don't see that happening, and there's no one else that really catches the eye that is available (not an expert on these matters by any means, so if I'm wrong there, by all means let me know.)

As far as the U21s, give it to Maughan. He's a safe option when we need stability in that group of players.

If what I am hearing is true, its not going to be pretty. Aprerently names have been put on paper.

padd b1975

naughto wrote: »

Your talking throught your arse there in fairness with that comment

Stand by for a statement from the O'Shea family.

Fr Tod Umptious

irishgeo wrote: »

If what I am hearing is true, its not going to be pretty. Aprerently names have been put on paper.

That's two very short posts you have posted in the last few days implying trouble in the camp.

If you know something why don't you expand on it a bit ?
Others have, and I'm sure we would all appreciate it if you shared what you know with us.

As I said if thete is going to be a revolt let's have it and get it over with.

Stoner

Fr Tod Umptious wrote:

As I said if thete is going to be a revolt let's have it and get it over with.

Good point, can't do any damage now.

irishgeo

It's all rumour. I heard 8 or 9 players are unhappy with Mr Holmes and have signed a letter stating that fact. Holmes has fallen out with a number of players and doesn't talk to one or two.

yop

irishgeo wrote: »

It's all rumour. I heard 8 or 9 players are unhappy with Mr Holmes and have signed a letter stating that fact. Holmes has fallen out with a number of players and doesn't talk to one or two.

Heard that last night as well now from another source.
FK sake we are like an episode of Eastenders at this stage will all the splits and changing of the guard.
Everyone laughed at Cork when the players took a stance, we will be no better at this stage. The 2 lads took us to the same stage as last year and uncovered (Parsons not new I know) in my opinion 2 quality players in DOC and Parsons.

They took a lot of flak for taking off both Parsons and Moran but reading an article this week both had reached their max delivering ability, using them fancy dan GPS packs on their back and weren't going to be able to perform. Morans role in the replay didn't help him.

I know Daddy O'Shea is a strong character and was so in Breaffy, but I really do hope that we don't have a repeat of "Poor Conor" again, it won't make them many friends in Mayo GAA.
As much respect I have for Seamie and what he has put in for Mayo football he shouldn't be taking the high ground on anything after his daftness cost us a pivotal player in the replay.

Anyway, paper and ink and all that shI*TE, could be a load of pony, but the fact its even whispered might mean something is brewing.

PARlance

Ascii wrote: »

I don't know anything about O Shea's father at all....has he any past managerial credentials or successes at club level(U12, 14, 16, minor) or is he only getting a look-in due to his connections with AOS, SOS and COS ?

He brought (managed) Breaffy from Junior to Senior. The players were there to do that but he (and his family) has played a massive role in the club for over a decade.
He's a gent, bleeds football and is a smart enough cookie, if he had one flaw during my time it was that he may have been too nice.
He would be a well deserving of a crack at minor management imo.

PARlance

yop wrote: »

Heard that last night as well now from another source.
FK sake we are like an episode of Eastenders at this stage will all the splits and changing of the guard.
Everyone laughed at Cork when the players took a stance, we will be no better at this stage. The 2 lads took us to the same stage as last year and uncovered (Parsons not new I know) in my opinion 2 quality players in DOC and Parsons.

They took a lot of flak for taking off both Parsons and Moran but reading an article this week both had reached their max delivering ability, using them fancy dan GPS packs on their back and weren't going to be able to perform. Morans role in the replay didn't help him.

I know Daddy O'Shea is a strong character and was so in Breaffy, but I really do hope that we don't have a repeat of "Poor Conor" again, it won't make them many friends in Mayo GAA.
As much respect I have for Seamie and what he has put in for Mayo football he shouldn't be taking the high ground on anything after his daftness cost us a pivotal player in the replay.

Anyway, paper and ink and all that shI*TE, could be a load of pony, but the fact its even whispered might mean something is brewing.

It's a long way off Cork proportions yet, that's just being a little hysterical. We regularly get close, so regularly question marks are to be expected.

It didn't take a lot to "uncover" DOC in fairness. He emerged.

naughto

padd b1975 wrote: »

Stand by for a statement from the O'Shea family.

I'd say you will be waiting

NabyLadistheman

Can people stop comparing this situation to the Mortimer's please. No comparison

yop

PARlance wrote: »

It's a long way off Cork proportions yet, that's just being a little hysterical. We regularly get close, so regularly question marks are to be expected.

It didn't take a lot to "uncover" DOC in fairness. He emerged.

He emerged/uncovered what ever really, but they utilized him and he is one of the top contenders for YPOTY and rightly so.

IF it turns into a player revolt then it will be on Cork proportions.

PARlance

yop wrote: »

He emerged/uncovered what ever really, but they utilized him and he is one of the top contenders for YPOTY and rightly so.

IF it turns into a player revolt then it will be on Cork proportions.

I don't think it's case of "whatever really", crediting management with uncovering DOC is a bit much... I think he would have emerged under any management.

padd b1975

naughto wrote: »

I'd say you will be waiting

I really hope so.

yop

PARlance wrote: »

I don't think it's case of "whatever really", crediting management with uncovering DOC is a bit much... I think he would have emerged under any management.

Not if he didn't get game time. Plenty of players over various codes haven't been utilised, in this case they got the best of DOC.