Mayo GAA Discussion Part 2

padd b1975

seligehgit wrote: »

Yes it would have been a wonderful goal, not unlike Çiaran McDonald's effort that crashed off the crossbar against Galway at that end many moons ago.He most definitely would benefit from a weights programme.

Yes that steward really needs to get a life,chasing our next generation of footballers off the pitch.

He told them they weren't insured....

Why is it okay in Nowlan Park, Wexford Park etc etc for young lads to come onto the pitch at half time for a puckaround without helmets!!!

Stoner

seligehgit wrote:

Jason Gibbons was my MOTM,covered every blade of grass in a commanding performance.He needs to be brought back into the Mayo panel as soon as possible,I'm still mystified as to the explanation for his absence from same.We could really have done with him when we were all at sea against Dublin post Seamie's black card and Barry Moran's substitution.He has some engine.

I think he was a find last year, bad game against Kerry then he disappeared. He looked very good from what I saw of him, certainly very mobile, couldn't understand why he was not on the panel.
I don't see much between himself and B Moran, I'd nearly lean towards him.

Fowler87

Looks like McStay is gonna be appointed Ros manager. Disappointing

km79

Fowler87 wrote: »

Looks like McStay is gonna be appointed Ros manager. Disappointing

we missed the boat on him last year
don't care what anyone says
Roscommon are now a big danger

Westernyelp

Vote of no confidence in Connolly and Holmes passed by the players in a secret meeting according to the Connaught Telegraph. what now?

ColeTrain

Westernyelp wrote: »

Vote of no confidence in Connolly and Holmes passed by the players in a secret meeting according to the Connaught Telegraph. what now?

Do you've a link for that?

Westernyelp

ColeTrain wrote: »

Do you've a link for that?

Not really, the front page of the CT is on Broadsheet.ie though

Stereomaniac

I don't see that anywhere, can we get a link to that story if it's being reported somewhere online?

Westernyelp

Stereomaniac wrote: »

I don't see that anywhere, can we get a link to that story if it's being reported somewhere online?

http://www.broadsheet.ie/

tomorrow's Connaught front page is there

ColeTrain

Westernyelp wrote: »

Not really, the front page of the CT is on Broadsheet.ie though

No worries, we'll have to wait until tomorrow.

EDIT

Stereomaniac

Thanks very much, I'll take a look at that now and pass it onto the person I know who's interested.

Westernyelp

It says that Cillian and Keith Higgins were Delegated to inform the managment and that and emergency county board meeting is to happen

ColeTrain

Westernyelp wrote: »

It says that Cillian and Keith Higgins were Delegated to inform the managment and that and emergency county board meeting is to happen

A few interesting days ahead. If the majority of the players have turned on them, their jobs are untenable.

McStay going to Roscommon is also him giving The County Board the two fingers for overlooking him and Liam last year.

This could turn into a right mess but who would be surprised? Sadly, Mayo GAA loves ****ing things up from the inside.

martyos121

They deserve another year IMO. There's nobody available I'd want to see managing the team, and they showed they are capable of getting their tactics right at times, just not in the replay. We're not getting Jim McGuinness so leave them another year to do the job. They have enough incentive to do things right knowing they'll be legends in the county if they can pull it off next year, and there won't be a better chance for ages.

Westernyelp

The Usual sh!tstorm from Mayo GAA alright. lets see what happens, if that report is true though I cant see how they can remain.

ColeTrain

martyos121 wrote: »

They deserve another year IMO. There's nobody available I'd want to see managing the team, and they showed they are capable of getting their tactics right at times, just not in the replay. We're not getting Jim McGuinness so leave them another year to do the job. They have enough incentive to do things right knowing they'll be legends in the county if they can pull it off next year, and there won't be a better chance for ages.

I disagree with that but it's neither here nor there if the players won't row in behind them.

The players deserve to be backed after what they've put in the last few seasons. If they feel that the management isn't capable of taking them any further, how can you argue with them?

happyoutscan

It's true anyway. Wouldn't have had a problem with another year for the management. Loads of bad decision's have been made in semis and finals the last 25 years and nothing said.

Have no problem respecting the players vote though.

Westernyelp

I see the Mayo news are running with the same story, must be true so? Is McStay definite for Ros?

martyos121

ColeTrain wrote: »

I disagree with that but it's neither here nor there if the players won't row in behind them.

The players deserve to be backed after what they've put in the last few seasons. If they feel that the management isn't capable of taking them any further, how can you argue with them?

I just don't think the players know what the situation will be like if Holmes and Connelly are sent packing. They obviously have a major issue with them, and yeah they will get their way, but who replaces them? Who could actually bring us back to the All Ireland final in a year where the draw could be favourable to us? Horan had his chance, he did a good job, but I saw actuall progression under H&C (they got things wrong in the replay, but Dublin just went into another gear and the player were wrecked, it wasn't just their fault). Tired of seeing us take one step forward and two back. We'll win no All Ireland titles with Horan and his laissez-faire attitude towards defending.

seligehgit

Actually it was very strange at the quarters on Saturday and Sunday,I saw no sign of either Noel Connelly or Pat Holmes,bizarre.

Cosmo Kramer

It's the lead story in the Telegraph and the Mayo News. If the players wont play for them their position is untenable really. Awkward situation with Noel's brother on the board - things could get messy if they don't agree to go. But who comes in instead? Probably fair to say the McStay to Ros story is irrelevant, no way he was going to get it anyway. Horan back? Talk of McGuinness already, but that seems pointless, he has a well paid job in Glasgow.

TCDStudent1

Cosmo Kramer wrote: »

It's the lead story in the Telegraph and the Mayo News. If the players wont play for them their position is untenable really. Awkward situation with Noel's brother on the board - things could get messy if they don't agree to go. But who comes in instead? Probably fair to say the McStay to Ros story is irrelevant, no way he was going to get it anyway. Horan back? Talk of McGuinness already, but that seems pointless, he has a well paid job in Glasgow.

If mcguinness was to win an all Ireland with mayo, he'd probably be lauded as the greatest ever Gaelic football manager - succeed with a team that horan & Connelly / Holmes failed with. If he doesn't win an all Ireland with them, then people will say he had them a year too late. So he wouldn't be risking his reputation with taking this job, it'd be purely risk free from him! Whether he actually wants it or has the time for it though is a bigger question though.

Before the county board looks at replacements, they will have to try to understand why the players have no confidence in management. No point in replacing like for like. If it's purely a personality thing, then it'd be interesting if the county board stick by them. If it's a preparation thing, it's be interesting to see what is different under this regime. Has much of the back room team changed (I mean in terms of physios, stats guys etc.)? If it's a team selection thing, then I'd really question the players motivation as it was hard to disagree much with their team selection.

Managers should be judged by their ability to get the best out of their players. Did Connelly / Holmes do that? It's debatable but I certainly don't think they were far off from doing so.

happyoutscan

It's all or nothing now with this group. Interesting to see what pans out, some great legs getting slower.

Feel sorry for Noel C, knew him a long time ago and an absolute gent. Mayo through and through and this will hurt him. His slap in '96 against Meath was a classic.

However, the players get my vote, just hope it isn't 1 or 2 egos dictating to the rest.

MaroonAndGreen

What's the chance of McStay doing a u turn away from roscommon?

Cosmo Kramer

None at all I would think. He wouldn't drop out at this stage and the Mayo CB wouldn't take him anyway. I don't know who the right man for Mayo is, but I don't think it is him. Could be a good appointment for Roscommon though.

PressRun

Was never a fan of the joint manager situation with the Mayo team. I think it's important to have one singular voice leading the team; there's something too cluttered about having two managers, imo. Furthermore, if the players don't support the current management, then their position is absolutely untenable, and after all, these are the lads who put in the time and make the sacrifices. They put their social lives on hold for a large part of the year, they're on strict diets, they're juggling jobs/university and family commitments with football, and they're doing it all in pursuit of an All-Ireland. They're not getting paid, they're doing it because they have a love for the game. This Mayo team have the players to win an All-Ireland. They need a management team that are up to the job too. While I'm sure the two lads at the helm at the moment are nice fellas with the best of intentions, I'm just not sure they're the right men to get the team over the line, and clearly the players feel that way too. Fair play to Keith Higgins and Cillian O'Connor for going ahead and being up front with them on behalf of the other lads.

I can't say I've any suggestions for new management. I think the boat was missed with Kevin McStay last year. If the Rossies haven't already sealed the deal, there may be time to rectify that mistake. I heard murmurings of McGuinness, but I don't know if that's just my Mayo pals and their wishful thinking (would make things very interesting though)! :P

blinding

Talk about shooting yourself in both Feet.

The Mayo county Board must be some bunch of latchegoes.

To have this bunch of players and not to be able to come up with a team management regime that the team are happy with is bloody awful.

manofwisdom

Unwanted messy situation for Mayo by the looks of it. Will be interesting to know why the Mayo players want a change after just one year? this joint management won U-21 All Ireland for a number of these current Mayo seniors. Donie Buckley is still there from team Horan and together they did what was required this year e.g staying up in div one and reaching another semi final, taking Dublin to replay was no mean feat.

PressRun

manofwisdom wrote: »

together they did what was required this year e.g staying up in div one and reaching another semi final, taking Dublin to replay was no mean feat.

Surely it's gone beyond the point of being satisfied with reaching another semifinal or feeling lucky to have pushed Dublin to a replay though? There are players on this Mayo team who aren't getting any younger and have been knocking on the door for a while now. They're probably sick of waiting for their All-Ireland at this stage.

Fr Tod Umptious

If there is going to be a revolt let it happen, the management is untenable if the reports are true.

Personally I thought the management should get another year to continue what they started and let them judged on that.

But my god these players better put there money where their mouths are in 2016.

As I said before the path to the final is not that tough, they better get there and put in the 110% that we have failed to see them do on the big games thus far.

The ball is in the players court they better step up.