Ireland u20 2016 6Nations/Junior World Cup

RedemptionZ

Extremely harsh yellow. Possibly ruined the game.

Utopia Parkway

That's a joke. Really poor from the officials.

ThisRegard

Slight lean I suppose when looked at in slo mo, but ffs in comparison to the shoulder earlier.

penybont exile

wp_rathead wrote: »

claffery didn't move into the welshmans path - just stood his ground - never a penalty never mind a yellow

Agree ....

cson

That's an absolute joke of a decision. Especially with the clear body check earlier. Standard French maverick reffing.

Tin Foil Hat

krazyklown wrote: »

I think thats a ridiculous call - thought the welsh player feigned a bit too.

He went down like a soccer player. Shocking carry on.

Richard Hillman

Ludicrous. Especially after that tackle on the Irish player not too long before.

CMOTDibbler

wp_rathead wrote: »

claffery didn't move into the welshmans path - just stood his ground - never a penalty never mind a yellow

Moved his right leg out and shifted his hips to ensure contact. Definitely intended to obstruct.

irishbucsfan

"Shame" to see young Giles go off. Looked very talented.

eclipsechaser

That's possibly the worst decision I've seen in rugby when taking into account that the TMO got several views of it.

Correct to say that the referee can't see the replay himself because there's no screen?

Utopia Parkway

CMOTDibbler wrote: »

Moved his right leg out and shifted his hips to ensure contact. Definitely intended to obstruct.

Barely moved. Slight contact with his buttocks.

irishbucsfan

eclipsechaser wrote: »

That's possibly the worst decision I've seen in rugby when taking into account that the TMO got several views of it.

Correct to say that the referee can't see the replay himself because there's no screen?

Yeah you're right, probably unfair to blame the ref.

But I'm going to blame him anyway because he's French and it's a Friday night, the bollocks.

corny

Lovely try. Too many Irish lads bumped off.

cson

irishbucsfan wrote: »

But I'm going to blame him anyway because he's French and it's a Friday night, the bollocks.

Just that.

It's a decision that's killed the game for us too so it's frustrating - 10 points since that decision.

Not sure which was worse, the penalty try from the 22 in the Munster - Connacht match or that yellow...

gazump123

Very soft try. Winger and 10 pushed away far too easily.

wp_rathead

corny wrote: »

Lovely try. Too many Irish lads bumped off.

Started with a good block by Deegan but then McPhillips was swiped aside at ease, our two centres went for the one man on the wing when was no need- the lad did a nice offload and the guy in support was able get away from Gallagher..

eclipsechaser

Did the replay show a stamp/ kick to the head there?

I don't have rewind. Maybe someone could check ad I only saw it once. It was at the front of the maul or ruck as we were on the Welsh line. RTE showed a slow motion clip after the attack had ended. It was just after the YC for Wales.

Utopia Parkway

gazump123 wrote: »

Very soft try. Winger and 10 pushed away far too easily.

McPhillips doesn't look to be much of a fan of tackling.

RedemptionZ

wp_rathead wrote: »

Started with a good block by Deegan but then McPhillips was swiped aside at ease, our two centres went for the one man on the wing when was no need- the lad did a nice offload and the guy in support was able get away from Gallagher..

McPhillips looks very weak defensively. Maybe a bad day in the office but it must improve.

CMOTDibbler

Utopia Parkway wrote: »

Barely moved. Slight contact with his buttocks.

He stepped into him. If he'd kept both feet planted he might have got away with it, but I rewatched it a number of times and it's pretty clear. The thing is that he cost the team, not the ref. You don't do stupid sh1t and you don't get binned. Simples.

RedemptionZ

CMOTDibbler wrote: »

He stepped into him. If he'd kept both feet planted he might have got away with it, but I rewatched it a number of times and it's pretty clear. The thing is that he cost the team, not the ref. You don't do stupid sh1t and you don't get binned. Simples.

Contact was minimal. The Welsh player isn't a 30kg little child, he made the most of the contact and no chance that warranted a yellow.

wp_rathead

CMOTDibbler wrote: »

He stepped into him. If he'd kept both feet planted he might have got away with it, but I rewatched it a number of times and it's pretty clear. The thing is that he cost the team, not the ref. You don't do stupid sh1t and you don't get binned. Simples.

not in a million years
He turned around which he is entitled to do, you have to retreat to get onside - he did not step into the path of the player

irishbucsfan

CMOTDibbler wrote: »

He stepped into him. If he'd kept both feet planted he might have got away with it, but I rewatched it a number of times and it's pretty clear. The thing is that he cost the team, not the ref. You don't do stupid sh1t and you don't get binned. Simples.

You're in a world of your own on that one

corny

CMOTDibbler wrote: »

He stepped into him. If he'd kept both feet planted he might have got away with it, but I rewatched it a number of times and it's pretty clear. The thing is that he cost the team, not the ref. You don't do stupid sh1t and you don't get binned. Simples.

He most certainly did not.

gazump123

Browne, Poland and Ryan the standouts for me on the Irish team. Going by that performance, don't know how Browne didn't start based on that performance.

Utopia Parkway

CMOTDibbler wrote: »

He stepped into him. If he'd kept both feet planted he might have got away with it, but I rewatched it a number of times and it's pretty clear. The thing is that he cost the team, not the ref. You don't do stupid sh1t and you don't get binned. Simples.

I strongly disagree. Barely moved and have watched it a few times. Allowed to stand your ground and certainly didn't move enough to bring the Welsh player down.

irishbucsfan

wp_rathead wrote: »

not in a million years
He turned around which he is entitled to do, you have to retreat to get onside - he did not step into the path of the player

You're also completely entitled to brace from impact, whether that's lifting your shoulder or your hip. It wasn't illegal, let alone a binning.

cson

He stepped while both feet were planted? How does one do that?

Wasn't a penalty, let alone a yellow card. End of.

ItsChecoTime

Disappointing that the yellow cost us 10 points and we lost by 11, the fact that it was such a ludicrous decision makes it more so. The Welsh 10 who made the most of it could have been binned a few minutes before for a no hands tackle. An exciting high tempo game though, not expecting to see that on Sunday

ThisRegard

corny wrote: »

He most certainly did not.

He did a little, but the slow motion as usual made it look worse. In real time it looked innocuous.