The uselessness of the gardai

sunnyjim

Cozmo wrote:

My freind (15) got punched in the face by a 35 year old man, called the garda and they showed up 3 MOTHS AFTER! The bloke had moved out by then.

And when my freind threw a rock at a car the garda show up 5 minute's later. They dont give a **** about anyone under 18, they think wre just prank calling or whatever.

If yer mates are the type pf people who throw rocks at cars, maybe they deserved the punch.

The Gardai are demoralised - as said above, they can arrest all they want, but after the arrests, the corralation of evidence and the court sittings, just IMAGINE how fuchin awful it is to see someone walk out, usually giving the 2 fingers to the Garda.

dermo88

I think we had better change the definitions here.

Working class. The word is being misused. We should use other words skanger class, ignorance class, uneducated, scum, waste.....

Ignorance can come in many forms. You can have an ignorant wealthy man in a Mercedes Benz, with a University Degree. You can have an ignorant rude CEO, who mistreats his customers and staff. The problem is, we judge many people in this country by the amount of Euro in their wallet, not the content of their hearts. In a poorer area, one or two broke scumbags can make life hell for 100 families. In a wealthy area, one or two rich scumbags (drug dealers, corrupt politicians), merely export that hell to poorer areas, cause traffic jams on the M50, screw up rezoning applications.....its all relative.

Because, as far as I am concerned, working class means a group of people who are "working". They are productive.

As for civil liberties, give me a country where people are scared to fart crooked in case they get caught, rather than a country where they are scared to walk the streets because of the scum. On one extreme, there is Singapore, where people are watching themselves, on the other.....Lagos Nigeria, where the scum are in control.

The Gardai cannot be all things to all people. We have an unarmed police force in Ireland. They wanted to be unarmed. Just be objective and be fair, and when life is not fair, its life.

\m/_(>_<)_\m/

same ould few, defending the guards no matter what, the majority of the public say...:rolleyes:

laughable really,
do the same ould few really think that the majority of the population are all wrong... if so, they are as out of touch are the rest of the guards who think they are doing a "fine job":rolleyes:

source

same ould few, defending the guards no matter what, the majority of the public say...

laughable really,
do the same ould few really think that the majority of the population are all wrong... if so, they are as out of touch are the rest of the guards who think they are doing a "fine job"

The majority of the public are wrong in their views about Limerick, due to some biased media coverage, yes there is a problem but it's not as bad as it's made out to be.

The reason i say the above is due to the fact that some damaging information has come out about some gardaí in the last few years, which has given them a bad reputation, and if anyone knows how hard it is to shake a bad reputation it's a Limerick man. Bad news is as far as the media is concerned good news, ie it sells, and where do most of the population get their info on the gardaí????? the 6 and 9 o'clock news. There are more than a few gardaí out there who just do their job, and try to make this country a safer place.If you knew any gardaí you would know that they're not all bad apples, it's as with Limerick a small minority who sully the name of a good and proud national police force.

dermo88

You are quick enough to look at the actions of the corrupt in the likes of the McBrearty case, rather than look at the actions of the heroic such as Jerry McCabe.

Sometimes, I felt upset or bitter that the Gardai behaved like a glorified tax collection service, especially when it came to road traffic.

Or the May Day Parade....vs The "Love Ulster" Parade.

Media coverage will always look at the bad news, it grabs more attention, and headlines. Its always easier to discredit than give merit, and its harder to gain than lose. Even in our own lives we find that.

Sometimes, I did not like their attitude, and in my younger "hothead" days, I had two minor run ins. But then, they are'nt there to be sweetness and light, they are there to enforce the laws of the land, and if I break them, its my tough luck.

JayRoc

limklad wrote:

You have to give the common guards some respect. They have since the creation of the state carry no Heavy weapons (firearms) and have a batton to protect themselves with crimminals who have no scruplous with shooting them. There are risking their lives everyday.

Why in god's name would the common garda on the street need to carry "heavy weapons"?
I can't recall hearing of any criminals, scrupulous or not, shooting a uniformed garda (or any garda for that matter) in over ten years.
TEN YEARS.
Hardly South Compton, now is it? :rolleyes:
Let's keep some perspective, shall we?

muppetkiller

The simple fact is they do a great job for the resources and restricions that they have to put up with. Not to mention rubbish wages (My brother is one)
We need about 5-10 times the number of Gardai we currently have on the streets..They don't have the presence that they need to prevent petty crime.

event

Nuttzy wrote:

Also not in the carnival but near the McDonalds(again can be seen from the garda station so ye see how close it is) a 14yr old lad was kicked unconscious and was finally rescued. There was a gang of 40youths hanging arund and 18 of them or so surrounded the lad and attacked him.

im sorry thats a lie

you can see the mcdonalds from the station yeah, but you couldnt see if there was a row or anything in it. It over the river FFS

bookiebasher wrote:

ah lads the guards are great...I was stopped going to work and ended up in court for not wearing a seatbelt...I owe my life to this great guard.

so you wree breaking the law and got caught?

boo-hoo

Cozmo wrote:

And when my freind threw a rock at a car the garda show up 5 minute's later. They dont give a **** about anyone under 18, they think wre just prank calling or whatever.

OMG!!! SRSLY!!!

OH NOES

your friend threw a rock at a car and the gardai showed up?
how dare they, you should go to the minister with that, thats not on

Rudolph Claus

im sorry thats a lie

you can see the mcdonalds from the station yeah, but you couldnt see if there was a row or anything in it. It over the river FFS

Ehhhh, i didnt say that you could see a row going on from within the garda station, i used that reference to show how close the station is to the McDonalds, hardly a patrol car trip away now is it.

And if the garda had of been patrolling/strolling around the carnival then they would clearly have seen and heard the commotion over at McDonalds and heard people screaming at the skangers to "stop before they kill him".

RoyalMarine

and what are 3 guards going to do against a gang of 18 - 40 people?

as said proviously they only have battons. and not all of them actually have them.

i vote the guards be armed and allowed to use more "force".
im sure that gang of 18 - 40 people woul easily run away if a few cops came over with guns and shot a few up in the air.

probably do all them little bastards a lesson. then again, its not the guards fault they did it. its their parents for not parenting them correctly.
the guards can only do so much.

dont forget, they have families aswel. they cant be running into a gang of drunken runts trying to save some fella from getting his head kicked in. why? because they will get their heads kicked in aswel. whats the point in that.

as for the fella above who got stopped for no seat belt, well fair play to the cop who stopped you.
dont play nieve and say you didnt know the rule. its not hard to remember to put a seat belt on when you get into a car... on that matter, its not hard to keep your speed correct to the oh so many millions of sign posts all around the country.

if you pass a sign that says 50 kmph, believe it or not, thats the limit.... its not hard to forget. if you do, then you shouldnt be driving a car at all.

ethernet

RoyalMarineComm wrote:

and what are 3 guards going to do against a gang of 18 - 40 people?

Well if millions weren't wasted on e-voting machines, we could aim to give water cannons to every station in the country to deal with this and spray them with our contaminated, Galway water.

RoyalMarine

ethernet wrote:

Well if millions weren't wasted on e-voting machines, we could aim to give water cannons to every station in the country to deal with this and spray them with our contaminated, Galway water.

wouldnt mind seeing that. water cannons would be a right laff outside a nite club... first little scumbag to throw a punch gets hosed against a wall at 60 mph.

entertainment while you eat your chips.

Kernel

\m/_(>_<)_\m/ wrote:

laughable really,
do the same ould few really think that the majority of the population are all wrong... if so, they are as out of touch are the rest of the guards who think they are doing a "fine job":rolleyes:

What are you on about? all the surveys conducted in recent years have shown a massive amount of public support for the Gardaí. Last approval ratings heard was 83% pubilc satisfaction. Extremely impressive considering the amount of the public who would have been cautioned by Gardaí.

http://www.justice.ie/80256E01003A02CF/vWeb/pcJUSQ67NKDU-en
http://archives.tcm.ie/irishexaminer/2005/09/10/story474833792.asp
http://www.garda.ie/angarda/press/2005/p14sepb2005.html

:rolleyes:

JayRoc wrote:

Why in god's name would the common garda on the street need to carry "heavy weapons"?
I can't recall hearing of any criminals, scrupulous or not, shooting a uniformed garda (or any garda for that matter) in over ten years.
TEN YEARS.
Hardly South Compton, now is it?
Let's keep some perspective, shall we?

While the principal of your statement is fairly valid and worthy of debate, there have been Gardaí shot over the last 10 years. A sergeant was recently shot in Crumlin while in uniform, in a driveby incident involving a single barrell shotgun. Reportedly for a 'dare'.

http://www.rte.ie/news/2006/0928/crumlin.html

It happens from time to time, there are many who have suffered injuries, but thankfully not as many fatalities. Many have been shot at with all kinds of things, not to mention stabbed, sliced, run over with cars and beaten - simply for wearing the uniform and ensuring public order in this country.

Remember a gun in the hands of a Garda is a tool of defence, it doesn't necessarily only become practical if the aggressor himself has a gun. Someone attacking you with a samurai sword or a hatchet can be just as deadly.

Saintly

JayRoc wrote:

Why in god's name would the common garda on the street need to carry "heavy weapons"?
I can't recall hearing of any criminals, scrupulous or not, shooting a uniformed garda (or any garda for that matter) in over ten years.
TEN YEARS.
Hardly South Compton, now is it? :rolleyes:
Let's keep some perspective, shall we?

It's been over six months since I worked in a Dublin hospital - but the amount of shootings when I left were frightening, particularly around the Crumlin region - people taking potshots on a Sunday afternoon in busy residential areas, I remember one poor chap who was shot following mistaken identity. More and more young criminals are carrying weapons. There is certainly a growing argument for increased protection for gardai - who tend to be first on the scene - if not for increased gun patrols, then adequate bullet proof jackets (long promised, unlikely to arrive until a guard is killed) and decent secure radio communication systems.

As for everything else, I personally think policing and policing systems in Ireland requires a huge overhaul. I've worked with the gardai on various issues in the past. Have worked with some lovely people but communication and communication systems are appalling. Pulse is a joke - some of the info I receive is so outdated - I have to wait to talk to PJ after his week off because the info is in his little black book etc. There are just systemic issues that seem to make the gardai inefficient, in daily duties. I completely agree that the judicial system needs a huge overhaul. Guards could spend eight hours of the day hanging around a courtroom waiting to give twenty minutes worth of evidence. Two or three guards off the same shift could wind up in court on the same day, therefore fewer left at the station etc... overhaul, overhaul, overhaul.

By the way, have been out of the country during the whole reserve recruit drive. Does anyone know any reserves - have they started - whats their feedback etc?

Saintly

\m/_(>_<)_\m/

muppetkiller wrote:

..They don't have the presence that they need to prevent petty crime.

prevent petty crime..... any chance they could look at preventing serious crime so. because they are doing nether.

but i suppose that all media hype as well is it.

the spiraling crime figures are all due to the bad media coverage the poor ould guards get...

source

Saintly wrote:

then adequate bullet proof jackets (long promised, unlikely to arrive until a guard is killed) and decent secure radio communication systems.

These are already being worn by members in Limerick and Dublin and are being rolled out to the rest of the force, will stop knife, 9mm and shotgun.

\m/_(>_<)_\m/ wrote:

prevent petty crime..... any chance they could look at preventing serious crime so. because they are doing nether.

but i suppose that all media hype as well is it.

the spiraling crime figures are all due to the bad media coverage the poor ould guards get...

The do prevent serious crime, but there are only so many of them and they can't be everywhere at once and no the media are not responsible for the crime stats, the criminals are, it doesn't matter if they are caught or not, those stats show the amount of crimes reported to the gardai, so what you need to look at is the detection rates, and look to that to see that work the gardai are doing.

source

Nuttzy wrote:

Ehhhh, i didnt say that you could see a row going on from within the garda station, i used that reference to show how close the station is to the McDonalds, hardly a patrol car trip away now is it.

The gardai do not sit in the station waiting for crimes to happen on their doorstep, they tend to be out patrolling the rest of their district, i've said this already, there will often be only 2 or 3 gardai in a station at any one time, one will be at the front desk and the other will be the custody sergent, then what ever few gardai just happen to be there dropping off prisoners, and someone on the radio if they're not working off a central control, all of these people doing very important jobs. They can't just drop this to go deal with a fight where they will probably be hospitalised, and that is if they see it.

Again i said this earlier in the thread, the gardai in the station do not sit around looking out the window waiting for a crime to happen there, that is why there is a free phone number for emergencies 999, if you call it they will come,and damn fast too i must say.

\m/_(>_<)_\m/

foinse wrote:

it doesn't matter if they are caught or not,

and that is the guards attitude as well....

\m/_(>_<)_\m/

foinse wrote:

that is why there is a free phone number for emergencies 999, if you call it they will come,and damn fast too i must say.

that is incorrect, the area you live in determines how fast they arrive..

house burgled in Howth they might arrive in 15 min...flat in Ballymun... they may not arrive at all. FACT

source

\m/_(>_<)_\m/ wrote:

and that is the guards attitude as well....

no it's not, they have appraisals every month or few months not sure which, where their arrest figures are used to judge their performance, so they care more than anyone whether the crims are caught or not, cause it all goes towards their prospects for promotion and salary increases.



edit: correcting typo

source

\m/_(>_<)_\m/ wrote:

that is incorrect, the area you live in determines how fast they arrive..

house burgled in Howth they might arrive in 15 min...flat in Ballymun... they may not arrive at all. FACT

well i don't live in Howth or Ballymun, i do however live in Limerick, and i know for a fact that the gardai respond to all crimes, on a basis of when they have someone available to deal with the situation.

I was at a house party in O'malley park (similar type area to ballymun)with a mate and his car got broken into, the gardai were there in minutes, why???? because they were just around the corner dealing with another call, area does not dictate speed of response, what does, is how busy the shift is for the gardai, staffing, and whether all units are tied up with a major crime.

event

\m/_(>_<)_\m/ wrote:

that is incorrect, the area you live in determines how fast they arrive..

house burgled in Howth they might arrive in 15 min...flat in Ballymun... they may not arrive at all. FACT

thats true

mainly, because if they go into ballymun, more than likely their cars will be stoned.

bit like the way fire brigades and ambulances are

source

event wrote:

thats true

mainly, because if they go into ballymun, more than likely their cars will be stoned.

bit like the way fire brigades and ambulances are

good point event, something i hadn't thought of, they do their best in a tough and often hostile enviroment.\m/_(>_<)_\m/ if you know anyone in the gardai or even just lie and say you're thinking of applying and ask if you can get a ridealong some night and see the work the gardai do and the crap they have to put up with.

\m/_(>_<)_\m/

foinse wrote:

good point event, something i hadn't thought of, they do their best in a tough and often hostile enviroment.\m/_(>_<)_\m/ if you know anyone in the gardai or even just lie and say you're thinking of applying and ask if you can get a ridealong some night and see the work the gardai do and the crap they have to put up with.

on the hostile environment thing....
that is the result OF bad policing, not and excuse FOR bad policing.

and yes they do have to put up with crap, from drunk young fella acting the maggot after the pub....
while the much more serious murders, rapes, and drug dealing take place else where undetected and unsolved...

so ya big shout out for the brave gardai,

you have nailed it, thank you.

source

The hostile enviroment is not a product of bad policing, rather a product of anti social behaviour and people who just don't five a flying f*ck about anything or anyone, and don't care who they hurt, kill or steal from. They didn't get that way through bad policing, they got that way through bad parenting, and no awareness of the social responsibilities that every other person seem to be able to grasp.

edit: one other point, it also would appear that 9 times out of 10 if you ask a scumbag why they don't like the gardai, the will either tell you to f*ck off or tell you it is because they keep hasseling them, ie not leaving them get on with their illegal business.

Dyr

event wrote:

thats true

mainly, because if they go into ballymun, more than likely their cars will be stoned.

bit like the way fire brigades and ambulances are

really, and is that theory backed up by anything other than assumption? I'm from ballymun and i can't say i ever saw a garda car, fire brigade or ambulance being stoned. Saw a maria nearly hit with a tin of emulsion but that was it. The reason that they dont show up because the higher ranks in the gardai have different standards of what is an acceptable level of anti social behaviour in an area. Ballymun gardai station is only an outpost of santry with a small number of gardai for a large population. Some of 'em are decent types struggling against the odds and some of 'em are complete **** in my experience.

\m/_(>_<)_\m/

foinse wrote:

The hostile enviroment is not a product of bad policing,

WHAT, are you for real... of course it is

foinse wrote:

rather a product of anti social behaviour and people who just don't five a flying f*ck about anything or anyone, and don't care who they hurt, kill or steal from.

hers is a novel idea, why not catch these people...
well after all, if one comments a crime, isn't it the policies job to detect and arrest, ( leave the court's out of this for the moment).

and this is what we are talking about here, they don't detect and arrest, therefor people continue on with this behaviour, guards do nothing, they continue to commit crime, guard do nothing, see the pattern

do ya think Rudy Giuliani took that approach in New York...
ah sure it a no go area so we will leave it.
Ya, that's how he almost halved the street crime in these "hostile environment"

Get real, other cities who have faced up to the problem of bad policing have cleaned up the streets, why cant we...

ill tell ya why......Because first we have to admit we have a problem, not stick our heads in the ground and say everything is fine....like we are doing in this country.

pathetic really

source

Okay \m/_(>_<)_\m/, If you have something bad to say, why not try and do it in a constructive way, what are the solutions to the problems you say there are???

Here's some of my suggestions to the problems you're seeing and reasons they haven't been implemented.

1,More gardai on the street???? not an issue for the gardai, this is actually an issue for the gov't they have to put their hand in their pocket for this one to work, and they're too busy spending it on tribunals.

2,Higher police presence in these trouble areas??? see point 1

3,Tougher policing procedures and policies??? Outcry from the indymedia set and bleeding heart liberals, about breach of civil rights, the gov't want to get back into office next term, and this would mean a loss of votes.

Remember the gardai's policies cannot be changed without law being implemented to back up new powers and procedures. The gardai are not the ones who make these laws but rather enforce them. Also the burdon of proof is on the gardai, so they might know very well who the crim is but cannot do anything about it unless they have proof that this is in fact the person who committed the crime.

Dyr

The gardai have beaucoup powers to enforce the law already. Our governments response to everything on this issue is to erode civil liberties further. You can go to jail on the word of a garda alone. you can foregt about being tried by your peers in many circumstances, Your right to silence is becoming a notion. Your right to free assembly went to the wall a few years back.

I want law and order so us ordinary joes can enjoy our civil liberties rather than curtailing those liberties to give us the illusion of law and order

Dyr

foinse wrote:

Also the burdon of proof is on the gardai, so they might know very well who the crim is but cannot do anything about it unless they have proof that this is in fact the person who committed the crime.

sweet zombie jesus, you're complaining that they have to establish a case against someone to prove their guilty? thats what we pay them to do.