Healthcare assistant jailed for 11 years for rape of woman with Alzheimer's

One eyed Jack wrote: »

Just to be clear -

I started the thread because I thought the Judge deserved credit for the sentence he handed down in this particular case, as all too often complaints are made that sentencing for these types of crimes is considered too lenient.

When I started the thread, there was no mention of the perpetrators name in the article I quoted from the RTÉ website. My intent in starting the thread wasn’t just to fuel more shìte talk about migrants. There’s enough of those types of threads in CA already.

As an example of more Judges deserving credit where it’s due for sentencing for this type of crime, there’s another case today in the news where the perpetrator is appealing the length of his sentence where he was sentenced to 14 years -


Rapist Patrick Nevin appeals severity of 14-year sentence, DPP counter appeals


No bollocks talk about “sending him home”, because you can’t. Send him to hell for all I care. I don’t care whether or not the perpetrator in the case I started this thread with is or isn’t a migrant either. He could just as easily be born and bred Irish for all anyone knows or cares. I certainly didn’t care who or where he was from at the time when I made the thread and there was no mention of his name.

The more pertinent fact was that he committed a despicable act against another human being and was handed what I thought was a fair and appropriate sentence, although I do accept it’s a fair point that he should have gotten a longer sentence in this case. The point was more so that all too often Judges are perceived to hand down lenient sentences, and this one deserved to be highlighted and the Judge given credit for the length of the sentence in this particular case.

Well said OP. Regrettably it’s turned into yet another xenophobia thread as a result, no fault of your own.

this was done so easily i would definitely look at his work history and see could he have done this before.

MFPM wrote: »

Ah, you're revealing more and more here....'importing' is an interesting phrase to use.

Revealing nothing, although you seem to be searching

Bringing in, importing, allowing in....use whatever phrase you want....

A whole lot of people entering this country that are not Irish nationals we know little about.

Is it not a healthier discussion for everyone to figure out better protections for the elderly, they are some of the easiest targets and unfortunately receive less protection than children. Would a situation where two carers must be present in any bedroom/bathroom or other private situation? Would surely severely reduce the risk.


I can see the increased cost, it is at least a stick to force total transparency from the nursing home sector

padd b1975 wrote: »

That dangerous bint "Dr" Ebun Joseph has weighed in.

He "took advantage of her" is the synopsis.

She's rightly getting her hole kicked on twitter.

Hold on a second....Why are you putting 'Dr' in inverted commas are you suggesting she's lying about her PhD?

Secondly, can you leave the misogyny at the door - if you want to critique someone's ideas then do that without the abuse and if you don't possess the intellect to do such a thing perhaps consider staying quiet.

suicide_circus wrote: »

still waiting for an answer.

If the children have citizenship then I assume the mother will care for them.
Or do you think the children should be with their father at home in Nigeria?

jam_mac_jam wrote: »

No she didn't say anything wrong.

What she said was

Care worker who raped resident jailed for 11 yrs. This is heartbreaking. No one should be allowed to take advantage of a vulnerable person.

So people heard

Care worker who raped resident jailed for 11 yrs. This is heartbreaking. No one should be allowed to take advantage of a vulnerable person.

Not

Care worker who raped resident jailed for 11 yrs. This is heartbreaking. No one should be allowed to take advantage of a vulnerable person.

Deleted User wrote: »

If it was my mother the law would be involved, but it would be me in the dock.

So three lives ruined instead of two?

kildare lad wrote: »

There was a picture of him the the Star today. I'm sure there's other media outlets won't picture him because he's black

Do tell how you came up with that notion?

Deleted User wrote: »

Because there is no guarantee of him not returning back here, no guarantee of him seeing jailtime. He did the crime here, I'm glad he's serving time here.

what I thought I didnt understand was early release, should not be early release, I dont understand that in any crime, but especially crimes of certain natures.
That said, I dont see why he cant have his nationality stripped following completion of sentence, what employment prospect could he have? care workers are fairly low down on the payscale, what employer would take the risk in any job? will surely be on the sex offenders register, so basically cant secure a job anywhere near vulnerable people or shouldn't, therefore he would be on state benefits, I see no reason why he couldnt re-obtain his nationality of country of origin and be deported.



I think it should be a requirement that dual nationality should be retained/mandated where a detailed history for an Individual cannot be established or cannot be relied upon. In the event of a such a serious crime, 5yrs imprisonment hard labour and then deported, and yes there are Irish nationals where Ireland is their country of origin who commit crimes as bad as this, Id be happy enough for them to have life imprisonment interned on some prison rock off the mainland.
Plenty of scum who have no place to roam freely.


What you seem to be saying is we/this State cannot control who enters our Borders? It might be possible for someone to sneak back in, but in such a case, I think if they had already been deported, then it should be a simple matter to remove them again. That said, we should have agrrements with the UK to prevent them entering the ROI via the UK by ctching them there and vica versa and within the EU.
I cannot understand how anyone could defend allowing this person or anyone of a similar ilk remaining after they complete their sentence, should not have any opportunity to be allowed to roam free again in this country.

Eric Cartman wrote: »

Its very common for media outlets to do that, bbc referring to every muslim arrested as ‘asian’ RTE often downplay or wont talk about race when its a story about somebody foreign.

That's dishonest bollix.....you seriously suggesting that non Irish native people who commit crimes don't appear in media outlets?

As for the 'Muslim' nonsense...how often do you see people who are arrested/convicted of a crime referred to by their religion...Catholic robs bank, Protestant assaults man?

MFPM wrote: »

As for the 'Muslim' nonsense...how often do you see people who are arrested/convicted of a crime referred to by their religion...Catholic robs bank, Protestant assaults man?

Quite a lot actually in this part of the world over the past fifty years or so.

padd b1975 wrote: »

She's not the type of doctor who'd be useful in the golden hour now is she?
Unless you wanted to hear how privileged and racist you are as you lay dieing on the side of the road.

Have a read of her 'thesis' that's linked to on the statues thread, a couple of respected posters have seriously questions about how she managed to graduate on the back of such drivel.

She's not the type of doctor who'd be useful in the golden hour now is she?

You didn't answer my question you simply produce more nonsense...Now are you suggesting that she lied about her PhD and she is not a doctor?

Tell me are you disputing the Dr status of all people who have PhDs or just Black women you disagree with?

Have a read of her 'thesis' that's linked to on the statues thread, a couple of respected posters have seriously questions about how she managed to graduate on the back of such drivel.

Have they now, how do you know they are 'respected' what makes you think the examiners of Dr Joseph's thesis weren't respected? Seriously you need to grow up.