Being forced to use your "Irish" name at school

MadsL · 10-04-2013 12:59PM

reprazant wrote: »

If you say so. I have found you to be defensive, belittling and condescending from the start of this thread but then it seems to be just you as you are quite similar in most of your threads. Sneering at people who have a different opinion to you does not equate to debating with them.

As you have just demonstrated. A bit hypocritical don't you think?

Also, the thread is 44 pages long. People are not necessarily going to remember everything that has been said in it.

I'm repeating things four and five times now and answering some frankly quite absurd speculations.

MadsL · 10-04-2013 01:01PM

ibarelycare wrote: »

MadsL I'm confused. Do you think that the school calling your daughter by the wrong name will cause problems if she goes to apply for a greencard?

It will certainly be quite some explaining to do - Americans tend not to understand this flexible Irish naming culture.

ibarelycare · 10-04-2013 01:01PM

MadsL wrote: »

It will certainly be quite some explaining to do - Americans tend not to understand this flexible Irish naming culture.

Then why on earth aren't you addressing it now if you foresee it being an issue?

MadsL · 10-04-2013 01:03PM

ballsymchugh wrote: »

why oh why don't you complain to the school on her behalf?
so what if she doesn't want your help, she's a teenager and as you put it before 'teenagers, eh?'

what is it about people who complain to others except to the person who can actually do something about it?

Read my previous posts.

reprazant · 10-04-2013 01:03PM

It what way have a I sneered, belittled or been condescending to you, Mads?

Or is pointing out that I find your style of posting to defensive, belittling and condescending now a form of sneering, belittled or acting in a condescending fashion?

Dan_Solo · 10-04-2013 01:03PM

ibarelycare wrote: »

Then why on earth aren't you addressing it now if you foresee it being an issue?

It sounds like the OP is doing exactly that by asking for opinions here? From what I gather the kid has to worry about this in 4 years. No panic yet, but why not see if anybody else has anything relevant to add?

reprazant · 10-04-2013 01:05PM

Dan_Solo wrote: »

It sounds like the OP is doing exactly that by asking for opinions here? From what I gather the kid has to worry about this in 4 years. No panic yet, but why not see if anybody else has anything relevant to add?

He has said he is not going to do anything about it though.

MadsL · 10-04-2013 01:06PM

ibarelycare wrote: »

Then why on earth aren't you addressing it now if you foresee it being an issue?

I am, I sought the wise and patient understanding of AH

The passport thing has only just come up, but it adds another fecking name to deal with!!

And don't get me started on how you renew a passport of a child who lives in a different country...passport office have me running in 3 directions. I'm filling out two forms just in case.

Oranage2 · 10-04-2013 01:06PM

Dan_Solo wrote: »

It sounds like the OP is doing exactly that by asking for opinions here? From what I gather the kid has to worry about this in 4 years. No panic yet, but why not see if anybody else has anything relevant to add?

The op just wants to hear similar opinions that he has.

MadsL · 10-04-2013 01:07PM

reprazant wrote: »

It what way have a I sneered, belittled or been condescending to you, Mads?

Or is pointing out that I find your style of posting to defensive, belittling and condescending now a form of sneering, belittled or acting in a condescending fashion?

Not biting.

Go derail some other thread.

ibarelycare · 10-04-2013 01:07PM

Dan_Solo wrote: »

It sounds like the OP is doing exactly that by asking for opinions here? From what I gather the kid has to worry about this in 4 years. No panic yet, but why not see if anybody else has anything relevant to add?

He said he isn't going to do anything unless it starts upsetting his daughter. So why complain about something that might very well be a serious issue down the line, when a simple email/phonecall/meeting can sort it out?

MadsL · 10-04-2013 01:07PM

Oranage2 wrote: »

The op just wants to hear similar opinions that he has.

hug?

Defiler Of The Coffin · 10-04-2013 01:09PM

Seachmall wrote: »

It's fine when the person themselves changes their name but not when someone else just arbitrarily starts calling them a different name.

Answer me this,

Seachmall wrote:

I know a girl called Bláthín, should I address her as "Flower" from now on because I only speak English with her?

Probably not, as Flower wouldn't usually be seen as an 'acceptable' translation for Bláthín when using her name in a different language.

However, change that to 'David' for 'Daithí' and my answer is different. I think that's acceptable. It's all about what the generally accepted translation is and whether it sounds 'correct' or not. It's all about the semantics and the conventions involved with the languages. That might seem nonsensical to you but that's just the way it is.

All this however is academic without the OP telling us his daughter's name in English and what the school are calling her in Irish. I understand he doesn't want to tell us but without this context it's hard to keep it all rational. Especially for people who aren't into closely reading threads

MadsL · 10-04-2013 01:09PM

ibarelycare wrote: »

He said he isn't going to do anything unless it starts upsetting his daughter. So why complain about something that might very well be a serious issue down the line, when a simple email/phonecall/meeting can sort it out?

Because I haven't yet established what records she will need and she hasn't yet taken exams.

reprazant · 10-04-2013 01:09PM

MadsL wrote: »

Not biting.

Go derail some other thread.

In other words, I can't back up what I said so I am going to deflect. :rolleyes:

Dan_Solo · 10-04-2013 01:09PM

Oranage2 wrote: »

The op just wants to hear similar opinions that he has.

Let me tell you, coming on to boards.ie questioning anything to do with Irish language policy is not the way to go about that.

MadsL · 10-04-2013 01:10PM

Defiler Of The Coffin wrote: »

All this however is academic without the OP telling us his daughter's name in English and what the school are calling her in Irish. I understand he doesn't want to tell us but without this context it's hard to keep it all rational. Especially for people who aren't into closely reading threads

It would be very silly of me to do that in a country as small as Ireland. I trust you can think of your own examples.

MadsL · 10-04-2013 01:11PM

reprazant wrote: »

In other words, I can't back up what I said so I am going to deflect. :rolleyes:

You are still trying to derail. Anything you care to share on the topic instead?

ibarelycare · 10-04-2013 01:11PM

MadsL wrote: »

Because I haven't yet established what records she will need and she hasn't yet taken exams.

Well wouldn't it make sense to nip it in the bud nice and early, in case difficulties arise down the road?

Oranage2 · 10-04-2013 01:12PM

Dan_Solo wrote: »

Let me tell you, coming on to boards.ie questioning anything to do with Irish language policy is not the way to go about that.

Thank you for telling me

is your daughter an only child op?

MadsL · 10-04-2013 01:14PM

Defiler Of The Coffin wrote: »

Probably not, as Flower wouldn't usually be seen as an 'acceptable' translation for Bláthín when using her name in a different language.

OK Ill pick one of Lily, Daisy, Rose and the like and slap it on the poor girl for the rest of her education. That OK?

MadsL · 10-04-2013 01:16PM

Oranage2 wrote: »

is your daughter an only child op?

What on earth?

You finding it comfy under that bridge?

username123 · 10-04-2013 01:16PM

Is this an accurate summary:

Child named on birthcert FirstnameEnglish MaternalSurnameIrish PaternalSurnameEnglish.
Child drops PaternalSurnameEnglish herself.
Primary school uses FirstnameEnglish MaternalSurnameIrish.
Secondary School uses FirstnameIrish MaternalSurnameIrish.

OP is worried about greencards and passports and that his daughter will want to change her name at 18 to something else? (not too clear on that bit).

The passport greencard problem has nothing to do with what the secondary school uses for the Firstname - the problem already existed when OPs daughter dropped PaternalSurnameEnglish.

Whats the issue with what she is called in Secondary School? There is no legal issue. She just doesnt like it. Why dont you set her a good example and tell her to appreciate her good education and not be bothering about silly things.

On changing her name at 18 - will it be something different to either birthcert or school names?

Why not bring her to a solicitor on her 18th birthday and do a name change by deed poll to whatever she wants and then produce that as the legal document.

Defiler Of The Coffin · 10-04-2013 01:17PM

MadsL wrote: »

OK Ill pick one of Lily, Daisy, Rose and the like and slap it on the poor girl for the rest of her education. That OK?

Dude, I'd really like to discuss this in an adult fashion with you but you're making it very difficult. Chill out.

Oranage2 · 10-04-2013 01:20PM

MadsL wrote: »

What on earth?

You finding it comfy under that bridge?

Yep sure your beside me.

Did I see right that she likes her second name in Irish but not her first?

LordSutch · 10-04-2013 01:25PM

Don't know if this has been taclked already, but can they Gaelicise any name from any country? Obviously Irish/Englash/Scottish names can all be given the Gaelscoil treatment by adding an O plus a couple of fadas, but what about Polish, Thai & African names? can they also be gaelicised?

Iwasfrozen · 10-04-2013 01:27PM

LordSutch wrote: »

Don't know if this has been taclked already, but can they Gaelicise any name from any country? Obviously Irish/Englash/Scottish names can all be given the Gaelscoil treatment by adding an O plus a couple of fadas, but what about Polish, Thai & African names? can they also be gaelicised?

Nope, another example of the latent hypocrisy.

MadsL · 10-04-2013 01:27PM

ibarelycare wrote: »

Well wouldn't it make sense to nip it in the bud nice and early, in case difficulties arise down the road?

Which is what I'm looking into - no point ringing the school about what they verbally call her if I have to do some politicking about her records.

username123 wrote: »

Is this an accurate summary:

Child named on birthcert FirstnameEnglish MaternalSurnameIrish PaternalSurnameEnglish.
Child drops PaternalSurnameEnglish herself.
Primary school uses FirstnameEnglish MaternalSurnameIrish.
Secondary School uses FirstnameIrish MaternalSurnameIrish.

There was a bit of FirstnameEnglish MaternalSurnameEnglish in there too at one point.

OP is worried about greencards and passports and that his daughter will want to change her name at 18 to something else? (not too clear on that bit).

She will probably use FirstnameEnglish MaternalSurnameIrish once she is 18 to normalise what her common usage is. School records are NOT this format however.

The passport greencard problem has nothing to do with what the secondary school uses for the Firstname - the problem already existed when OPs daughter dropped PaternalSurnameEnglish.

Perhaps.

Whats the issue with what she is called in Secondary School? There is no legal issue. She just doesnt like it.

There is if she wants/need to use School records for her 2 years common usage as they don't match.

Why dont you set her a good example and tell her to appreciate her good education and not be bothering about silly things.

Because it is not silly and is not upsetting her.

On changing her name at 18 - will it be something different to either birthcert or school names?

Yes.

Why not bring her to a solicitor on her 18th birthday and do a name change by deed poll to whatever she wants and then produce that as the legal document.

That is an option I had not considered.

johnolocher · 10-04-2013 01:29PM

Your name is your name, I think it's wrong when Irish teachers give people Irish names for Irish class or roll call, fair enough a lot of Irish names have older Gaelic forms and by all means make the kid aware of it but don't call it them when they don't use it outside the class room. The biggest problem for me is when they try to put Irish on names that had no traditional older forms just to look Irish, that is when the practice goes from giving someone a version in their name in another language to trying to Gaelisize them in some sort of idealology.

That said in this case the OPs daughter is in a Gaelscoil and that goes with their ideology, it is to be expected. But it should not be such a harsh rule that if the child doesn't like it they still have to have it. I would talk to the teacher or principle and if they disagree because it's the schools policy you signed up too then they are pretty stubborn bhastards and I wouldn't like my children being taught in a school with such rigid philosophies.

MadsL · 10-04-2013 01:30PM

Oranage2 wrote: »

Yep sure your beside me.

Did I see right that she likes her second name in Irish but not her first?

Why do I have to repeat everything.

Her first name "in Irish" is NOT her name. Had we intended to call her that we would have.

Her Surname in Irish is grand.

Is there a problem with someone not liking an approximate translation of their actual name?

Being forced to use your "Irish" name at school

Comments