"Non book readers" - Season 8 Episode 1 "Winterfell"

madalig12 · 18-04-2019 02:16PM

I read the thread and nobody seems to have said that the Dragon scene whilst being 'out of place', 'too long and boring' etc. Was there for a reason...every scene is! Look at the landscape! The huge ravine that would be handy to dump a few thousand white walkers into to burn maybe!?! Every scene is in there for a reason. Im also convincened Jon will kill Danerys now because what Sam said is correct. He will have to to force her to surrender the crown...to him.

DaeryssaOne · 18-04-2019 02:57PM

Deleted User wrote: »

In the books he never goes, with Jamie, to Dorne. Rather Ilyn Payne does (and I think he is the one to train Jamie, in left handed fighting)

I think the show's reason for this was twofold though as the actor who played Ilyn Payne was diagnosed with cancer (and has since recovered) but he was out of action so they never brought him back after season 1. Secondly I'm guessing they also wanted to get their use out of Bronn as he is a fan favourite and it was far more interesting watching him interact with Jaime than a mute Ilyn Payne would ever have been!

18-04-2019 04:20PM

Not that it hugely matters anymore but I could have sworn this was the non book readers thread :pac:

18-04-2019 05:17PM

EagererBeaver wrote: »

Jaime didn't go to Dorne at all in the books, never mind with Bronn or Ilyn Payne. They didn't invent that entire angle to get Bronn out of KL so Jerome Flynn and Lena Headey weren't around each other.

Some of your second paragraph may well end up being accurate but again, it's nothing to do with their relationship ending badly.

You are right, it was somewhere else (getting myself confused with what I've seen) but as pointed out this is the non-book

Apologies

PressRun · 18-04-2019 07:05PM

golfball37 wrote: »

I 100% think Bronn is going to kill Jaime.

I don't think so. I think it's all just being done as a way to reunite Bronn with the Lannister brothers and get the crossbow into the hands of either Jamie or Tyrion, who will use it to kill someone significant. Either Cersei or Danerys. Just my opinion.

Paddy Cow · 18-04-2019 11:37PM

golfball37 wrote: »

I 100% think Bronn is going to kill Jaime.

I don't think so. He's smart enough to realise that Cersei can't be trusted. When Tyrion first met Bronn in season 1, Tyrion made it clear to Bronn that if the time ever came when someone wanted to cross him, he'd pay double. Tyrion doesn't have the Lannister gold behind him anymore but he is allied with Dany. Bronn has to hedge his bets and decide who will win out - the North or Cersei.

The Iron Giant · 19-04-2019 10:57AM

I think Bronn is smart enough to hedge his bets against Cersei.

He must know that there are three sides;
The dead;
Cersei's army; and
Everyone else.

Carrying out a mission for Cersei for a good reward will be fairly futile if she gets decimated which logically she should - although I'm very aware that logic sometimes doesn't feed into it.

leggo · 19-04-2019 11:21AM

Exclamation Marc wrote: »

I think Bronn is smart enough to hedge his bets against Cersei.

He must know that there are three sides;
The dead;
Cersei's army; and
Everyone else.

Carrying out a mission for Cersei for a good reward will be fairly futile if she gets decimated which logically she should - although I'm very aware that logic sometimes doesn't feed into it.

I’m not sure that Jon and Dany would seem like the favourites now. If it was straight up them versus Cersei, yeah they’d easily be the winning side especially with what Bronn has seen. But the Army of the Dead, with their numbers and without Lannister support, would now likely seem like the favourites to Bronn. Meaning of the people who could help him...Cersei’s chances could seem better.

But I’d tend to agree with those who say Cersei’s doing this as a win-win knowing there’s as much chance of him just joining them and getting rid of a potential adversary from KL.

GottaGetGatt · 19-04-2019 09:49PM

Exclamation Marc wrote: »

I think Bronn is smart enough to hedge his bets against Cersei.

He must know that there are three sides;
The dead;
Cersei's army; and
Everyone else.

Carrying out a mission for Cersei for a good reward will be fairly futile if she gets decimated which logically she should - although I'm very aware that logic sometimes doesn't feed into it.

Tbh I thought this was just how they got Bronn back with the rest of the characters since the actors don’t actually speak to each other in real life.

Mr.Maroon · 20-04-2019 02:43PM

What do people think Yara Greyjoys part will be?
She's gone back to the Iron Islands and talked about Dany may need somewhere to run too if the dead are winning.

Surely it's not the last we see of her?

Paddy Cow · 20-04-2019 02:44PM

Mr.Maroon wrote: »

What do people think Yara Greyjoys part will be?
She's gone back to the Iron Islands and talked about Dany may need somewhere to run too if the dead are winning.

Surely it's not the last we see of her?

Didn't she make some deal with Dany last season that if Dany gets the throne, Yara can be Queen in the Iron Islands?

Loafing Oaf · 20-04-2019 03:18PM

Mr.Maroon wrote: »

What do people think Yara Greyjoys part will be?
She's gone back to the Iron Islands and talked about Dany may need somewhere to run too if the dead are winning.

Surely it's not the last we see of her?

I'd anticipate some sort of climactic showdown with Euron. Not sure how that would come about though...

Mr.Maroon · 20-04-2019 03:22PM

Paddy Cow wrote: »

Didn't she make some deal with Dany last season that if Dany gets the throne, Yara can be Queen in the Iron Islands?

She did - but I'd presume that was on the condition she helps Dany get the Iron throne and not run to the Iron Islands when the battles were about to take place.

The Iron Giant · 20-04-2019 03:34PM

Loafing Oaf wrote: »

I'd anticipate some sort of climactic showdown with Euron. Not sure how that would come about though...

I imagine some element of Euron acting cocky whilst fighting from the sea, maybe standing on the deck gloating and Yara appearing out of nowhere a la Theon and essentially taking him by surprise.

She doesn't have many ships I believe so a sneaky kill would be the only like way she could get him id say.

Paddy Cow · 20-04-2019 04:05PM

Mr.Maroon wrote: »

She did - but I'd presume that was on the condition she helps Dany get the Iron throne and not run to the Iron Islands when the battles were about to take place.

She was helping Dany but Euron got her ships and still has them. There's not much she can do, apart from hold the Iron Islands.

paleoperson · 21-04-2019 08:36PM

Loafing Oaf wrote: »

Btw, was Qyburn hinting that Cersei might offer Bronn rewards in addition to a mound of gold, if you catch my drift, if he executes here plan? What did he say, "the queen is very generous to men who serve her loyally" or something? Even if he was, I think we can safely say that one won't ever come to pass...

Qyburn didn't hint anything. He said Cersei might offer Bronn rewards in addition to a mound of gold, which is plausible. He gave the example on how he became her Hand by being a loyal servant.

Loafing Oaf · 21-04-2019 09:33PM

paleoperson wrote: »

Qyburn didn't hint anything. He said Cersei might offer Bronn rewards in addition to a mound of gold, which is plausible. He gave the example on how he became her Hand by being a loyal servant.

Okay but there is a clear implication that the reward for killing Jaime and/or Tyrion would be greater than being appointed her hand. And this is happening immediately after she accepted Euron into her bed...

paleoperson · 21-04-2019 10:28PM

I don't know what you're talking about, try to be more clear next time.

threeball · 21-04-2019 11:19PM

PhiloCypher wrote: »

Was wondering that myself, will they all just march south in one unstoppable undead herd or will the Nights King split his army up, sending his lieutenants off with thousands of wights to take large population centers for fresh undead recruits. I imagine for simplicity sake they'll keep them all together for one set piece battle outside Winterfell where the Nights King will meet is end, conveniently taking out all the wights in his army(as seen last season). The remainder of the season will be taking out Cersei and an episode of epilogue setting the scene for post war Westeros.

Think this is highly likely as it would mean adding an additional 500,000 to the army of the dead before taking on Winterfell.

I had thought that the Night King would take Winterfell then head south to KL where Cersei would offer him her new child in order to return to the north but after last week it seems this kid isn't on the way anytime soon so that probably puts that theory to bed.

I also think Dany will try to burn Jon with a Dragon after he reveals his lineage but he will walk away unscathed as he is a Targaryen.

seligehgit · 22-04-2019 12:49AM

threeball wrote: »

Think this is highly likely as it would mean adding an additional 500,000 to the army of the dead before taking on Winterfell.

I had thought that the Night King would take Winterfell then head south to KL where Cersei would offer him her new child in order to return to the north but after last week it seems this kid isn't on the way anytime soon so that probably puts that theory to bed.

I also think Dany will try to burn Jon with a Dragon after he reveals his lineage but he will walk away unscathed as he is a Targaryen.

Cool theories.:)

paleoperson · 22-04-2019 01:01AM

His first theory is cool but why would Dany burn her own brother that she loved? That would make no sense and is not going to happen.

Fratricide is an incredibly rare thing, especially by a female. Only after years and years of abuse like what happened with Viserys or by an exceptionally evil person like Cersei would it even be a possibility.

Bonzo Delaney · 22-04-2019 08:36AM

paleoperson wrote: »

His first theory is cool but why would Dany burn her own brother that she loved? That would make no sense and is not going to happen.

Fratricide is an incredibly rare thing, especially by a female. Only after years and years of abuse like what happened with Viserys or by an exceptionally evil person like Cersei would it even be a possibility.

Jon's her nephew

Bowlardo · 22-04-2019 10:25AM

As expected third episodes is going to be the action movie we all anticipated.

22-04-2019 10:26AM

Bowlardo wrote: »

As .....

Wrong thread.

threeball · 22-04-2019 10:14PM

paleoperson wrote: »

His first theory is cool but why would Dany burn her own brother that she loved? That would make no sense and is not going to happen.

Fratricide is an incredibly rare thing, especially by a female. Only after years and years of abuse like what happened with Viserys or by an exceptionally evil person like Cersei would it even be a possibility.

Because nothing means more to her than the throne. Its what shes lived for her whole life and now Jon is pushing her into 2nd spot just by his very being. History is chock full of royals who did their siblings in, in order to claim the top spot.

Paddy Cow · 22-04-2019 10:19PM

threeball wrote: »

Because nothing means more to her than the throne. Its what shes lived for her whole life and now Jon is pushing her into 2nd spot just by his very being. History is chock full of royals who did their siblings in, in order to claim the top spot.

She hasn't though. Her whole life she thought Viserys was going to rule. It wasn't until she got pregnant and an assassin made an attempt on her life that Drogo declared he was going to sail to Westeros and take the thorne. Dany likes to make out it was her life's destiny but even Vary's said they expected her to die with the dothraki. Dany became obsessed with ruling when Drogo died and her dragons hatched, which is only about 2-3 years ago.

threeball · 22-04-2019 10:44PM

Paddy Cow wrote: »

She hasn't though. Her whole life she thought Viserys was going to rule. It wasn't until she got pregnant and an assassin made an attempt on her life that Drogo declared he was going to sail to Westeros and take the thorne. Dany likes to make out it was her life's destiny but even Vary's said they expected her to die with the dothraki. Dany became obsessed with ruling when Drogo died and her dragons hatched, which is only about 2-3 years ago.

Only a few episodes ago (first meeting at dragonstone) she explained to Jon that the only thing that kept her going all the years, through rape, threat of death etc. was claiming the iron throne. Everything else pales in significance. You can already see her losing trust in all those around her, Tyrion, Jon etc.

Paddy Cow · 22-04-2019 11:22PM

threeball wrote: »

Only a few episodes ago (first meeting at dragonstone) she explained to Jon that the only thing that kept her going all the years, through rape, threat of death etc. was claiming the iron throne. Everything else pales in significance. You can already see her losing trust in all those around her, Tyrion, Jon etc.

All that only came about after the attempt on her life. Before that she never thought of herself as a ruler. Gilly's child looks about three, so it's only been three years. Dany's full of sh1te. She's obsessed with the throne and will burn those who stand in her way. She is not fit to be a ruler.

threeball · 22-04-2019 11:32PM

Paddy Cow wrote: »

All that only came about after the attempt on her life. Before that she never thought of herself as a ruler. Gilly's child looks about three, so it's only been three years. Dany's full of sh1te. She's obsessed with the throne and will burn those who stand in her way. She is not fit to be a ruler.

Isn't that my point, she'll burn jon because he stands in her way. Only problem is, Jon doesn't burn.

The fact he told her his lineage before the battle only sets up a confrontation during or after the battle of winterfell.

nix · 22-04-2019 11:44PM

threeball wrote: »

Isn't that my point, she'll burn jon because he stands in her way. Only problem is, Jon doesn't burn.

Its possible not all Targaryen's are heat resistant, its possible Danny might be the only one, a power given to her by the lord of light i suspect. As when her brother gets killed in season one, she says "He was no Dragon, fire can not kill a dragon"

When watching the show a few years back, i always thought Jon would be put on fire or attacked by a dragon and would just walk out of the flames unscathed all badass and all and it would be a great reveal that Jon was like Danny, and thats how most would believe or know..

But then when watching the show all over again recently, theres a scene in season 1 when Jon is saving the Lord commander from an undead and he picks up a lantern and throws it at the undead to kill it, but Jon is clearly screaming in pain of being burnt doing it..

Now maybe thats just me being a nerd and an oversight by the show, but yeah

"Non book readers" - Season 8 Episode 1 "Winterfell"

Comments