Werewolf - Winter Is Here - Game of Thrones II Game Thread

fixXxer

tusk wrote: »

I'm sansa, Fixxxer is arya

o/ hi5 sis

tritium

fixxxer wrote: »

Unless Trit knew he could protect me as a convert and it was done to make him look good.

My prize was very specific for my sis. What you’re suggesting wouldn’t make much sense in the context of Janie’s story arc

Necro

Can someone do a quick score count on how we're fixed now after the Night of the Long Knives/Dragons

Necro

NIght King's team still at 4 but how many villagers are left? I've lost track in all the bloodletting

tusk

fixxxer wrote: »

o/ hi5 sis

goddamit. you know I can't resist!

\ô

Ectoplasm

tusk wrote: »

Ok well then my point stands. His prize doesn't mean he's clear.

He won a prize. Legitimately revealed it as what it was just before a similar prize came out. But he could easily have been converted, so alignment is not confirmed by virtue of revealing the prize.

Unfortunately the same is true of QB to an extent - could be using a prize to gain village cred. Fixxxer is the only one 100% cleared by this morning's actions if we assumed they can't target one of their own.

Ectoplasm

Necro wrote: »

NIght King's team still at 4 but how many villagers are left? I've lost track in all the bloodletting

Should be same as my table from last night. Will dig it up now.

Necro

Ectoplasm wrote: »

Unfortunately the same is true of QB to an extent - could be using a prize to gain village cred. Fixxxer is the only one 100% cleared by this morning's actions if we assumed they can't target one of their own.

Only works for today for both though. No one will be clear tomorrow unless we kill the NK tonight

Ectoplasm

Ectoplasm wrote: »

State of play as far as I can tell. Can someone double check this?

Began w/ 21 2 Evil, 19 Good
20 Conversion + Death = 3 Evil, 17 Good Thoros of Myr Clarabel Dead by prize
19 Lynch Ted = 3 Evil, 16 Good Tyrion Lannister Ted Dead by lynch
18 Conversion + Death = 4 Evil, 14 Good Confirmed Varys Dandy/Eva Dead by munch
15 Lynch + Prize Deaths = 4 Evil, 11 Good Sandor Clegane, The Hound Choc Chip Dead by prize
The Mountain Green & Red Dead by prize
Confirmed Melisandre Drumpot Dead by prize



REMAINING PLAYERS, ROLES & ACTIVE PRIZE CLAIMS
Cersei  Guffy
Jamie Lannister Unclaimed 2
Jon Snow Unclaimed 3
Sansa Stark Tusk
Arya Stark Fixxxer
Daenerys Targaryen Ectoplasm
Jorah Mormont LordTSC
Beric Dondarrion LadySkunk
Claimed Gendry. beakerjoe
Claimed Greyworm. Bounty Hunter
Claimed Bronn Necro
Claimed Brienne + prize quickbeam
Claimed Caitlyn Hello 2D Person Below
Claimed Qyburn sKeith

No claim Mick
Claimed an OP role Stu
Claimed an OP role + prize Tritium

I think this is accurate.

Ectoplasm

REMAINING PLAYERS, ROLES & ACTIVE PRIZE CLAIMS
Cersei Guffy
Jamie Lannister Tritium - unused prize
Jon Snow StuRedman
Sansa Stark Tusk
Arya Stark Fixxxer
Daenerys Targaryen Ectoplasm
Jorah Mormont LordTSC
Beric Dondarrion LadySkunk
Claimed Gendry. beakerjoe
Claimed Greyworm. Bounty Hunter
Claimed Bronn Necro
Claimed Brienne + used prize quickbeam
Claimed Caitlyn Hello 2D Person Below
Claimed Qyburn sKeith

Claimed Bran :pac: Mick

beakerjoe

Necro wrote: »

Only works for today for both though. No one will be clear tomorrow unless we kill the NK tonight

How certain are you that Mick is the NK.

Hes bad no doubt. But how certain that hes NK and not the unconverted original minion

Necro

Thanks Ecto so 11-4. I've updated below too

Ectoplasm wrote: »

State of play as far as I can tell. Can someone double check this?

Began w/ 21 2 Evil, 19 Good
20 Conversion + Death = 3 Evil, 17 Good Thoros of Myr Clarabel Dead by prize
19 Lynch Ted = 3 Evil, 16 Good Tyrion Lannister Ted Dead by lynch
18 Conversion + Death = 4 Evil, 14 Good Confirmed Varys Dandy/Eva Dead by munch
15 Lynch + Prize Deaths = 4 Evil, 11 Good Sandor Clegane, The Hound Choc Chip Dead by prize
The Mountain Green & Red Dead by prize
Confirmed Melisandre Drumpot Dead by prize



REMAINING PLAYERS, ROLES & ACTIVE PRIZE CLAIMS
Cersei  Guffy
Jaime Lannister trit
Jon Snow Stu Redman
Sansa Stark Tusk
Arya Stark Fixxxer
Daenerys Targaryen Ectoplasm
Jorah Mormont LordTSC
Beric Dondarrion LadySkunk
Claimed Gendry. beakerjoe
Claimed Greyworm. Bounty Hunter
Claimed Bronn Necro
Claimed Brienne + prize quickbeam
Claimed Caitlyn Hello 2D Person Below
Claimed Qyburn sKeith
Claimed Bran Stark + day 0 peek on tritium Mick

Necro

beakerjoe wrote: »

How certain are you that Mick is the NK.

Hes bad no doubt. But how certain that hes NK and not the unconverted original minion

It's the votes beaker, look at the timing of the last votes on GnR and the general chaos on the thread.

They really didn't want Mick to die

Ectoplasm

Just one thing - if Mick is actually the NK why would he name Tritium a being his peek if Trit is a convert? Does anyone see where I'm going with this?

Speaking of going I'm out for a bit but will be back for tournament. I don't actually want to win as I've been truly awful at using my prizes so far but I don't want the evils to win either.

fixXxer

quickbeam wrote: »

That was my prize. Protect one from my House (Sansa).

Is this a slip?

(really don't want to sound ungrateful)

beakerjoe

Necro wrote: »

It's the votes beaker, look at the timing of the last votes on GnR and the general chaos on the thread.

They really didn't want Mick to die

So based off the votes whom do you think the others are?

I think Trit is starting to look less likely now.

Tusk would be my guess. Pushing hard for Trit this morning rather than Mick.

Lord TSC

Ectoplasm wrote: »

Just one thing - if Mick is actually the NK why would he name Tritium a being his peek if Trit is a convert? Does anyone see where I'm going with this?

Again, Mick's story was all over the shop. Are you wondering if he'd stupidly ship one of his own team-mates in a bid to legitimize himself? Or it's way more likely this actually makes Trit looks decently cleared?

Necro

beakerjoe wrote: »

So based off the votes whom do you think the others are?

I think Trit is starting to look less likely now.

Tusk would be my guess. Pushing hard for Trit this morning rather than Mick.

tusk is a possibility. He was pushing hard for GnR at the end last night too.

Skunk and Guffy would be my other guesses if trit is on the level.

Green & Red really ****ed us up. A villager with a prize to survive an attack. Wouldn't share with the class, wanted to fly solo with their prize in their back pocket thinking they were immune from death.

Necro

Lord TSC wrote: »

Again, Mick's story was all over the shop. Are you wondering if he'd stupidly ship one of his own team-mates in a bid to legitimize himself? Or it's way more likely this actually makes Trit looks decently cleared?

Mick is many things but stupid is not one of them. He's most likely evil but this is a fair point

tusk

beakerjoe wrote: »

So based off the votes whom do you think the others are?

I think Trit is starting to look less likely now.

Tusk would be my guess. Pushing hard for Trit this morning rather than Mick.

I haven't pushed hard for anyone.

I'm just asking questions and giving my take...

Read back

fixXxer

Deleted User wrote: »

Green & Red really ****ed us up. A villager with a prize to survive an attack. Wouldn't share with the class, wanted to fly solo with their prize in their back pocket thinking they were immune from death.

Can we not attack other players please? Everything is perfect with hindsight.

beakerjoe

Lord TSC wrote: »

Again, Mick's story was all over the shop. Are you wondering if he'd stupidly ship one of his own team-mates in a bid to legitimize himself? Or it's way more likely this actually makes Trit looks decently cleared?

Well, if NK dies they all die, if a convert dies the rest if the evils live on.

So its likely that a NK would bus team mate no?

tusk

Necro wrote: »

tusk is a possibility. He was pushing hard for GnR at the end last night too.

Skunk and Guffy would be my other guesses if trit is on the level.

Check the timings. Mick was never on my radar. GnR was. Then I asked for clarity in what the village had decided. The consensus was to go with an unclaimed so I went GnR.

I tried my hardest to get GnR to share his info to save himself and he was having none of it. Why would I do that if I was trying to save someone else?

Necro

beakerjoe wrote: »

Well, if NK dies they all die, if a convert dies the rest if the evils live on.

So its likely that a NK would bus team mate no?

Depends on whether Mick is NK or original right hand

If he's Night King then yeah he might bus

If he's not then trit is probably clear as he wouldn't out another team mate

quickbeam

fixxxer wrote: »

Is this a slip?

(really don't want to sound ungrateful)

A slip how? Other than not having my spreadsheet in front of me and thinking you were Sansa, not Arya. I knew you and Tusk were those two, and got mixed up.

beakerjoe

tusk wrote: »

I haven't pushed hard for anyone.

I'm just asking questions and giving my take...

Read back

Maybe pushed hard is over stating it, but you see what Im saying.

If you are evil, it could be seen as a way to push Trit over Mick.

Keeping a possible NK alive that bit longer.

That said, the more I think about it, would another convert get involved if Trit and Mick are evil ?

Right now I think either Trit and Tusk cant both be evil, its either one or the other..... or neither...... just not both

Necro

Thing that has me thinking Mick is NK as well is he won't vote with anyone and is staying solid on sKeith for both lynches.

Wights would be starting to use their voting block at this point I'd reckon

Exactly Tusk.

tusk

Do we think a prize would stay as is if the holder is converted?

I can't see that being the case. Which would clear qb for me.

Open to rebuttal though