Confused About my fiancé watching gay porn

brassbutterfly

So I'm not sure if this is in the right section or not but I would love a little guidance. I am currently expecting my finances baby. We are getting married next year. The other morning I went to print something from my other halfs laptop. I called to him in bed that I was just using it to print because my own laptop was too slow and he jumped out of bed and came running out of the bedroom to say he just needed to check something first. I knew he was deleting history but I took no notice and just assumed he didn't want me seeing some porn he had been looking at. I got to thinking later though that his reaction had been a little off as he knows I wouldn't have had a problem with him looking at porn and so I retrieved the deleted data to find a lot of gay porn sites that he had been visiting. Then I remembered years ago when we weren't going out too long I found gay porn on his household laptop-at the time he seemed shocked and although he didn't say it,he basically insinuated it was his stepfathers. I totally believed him at the time as I had no reason to doubt him. My question is, how do I handle this? Is he gay/bisexual/experimenting? I'm confused,pregnant and hormonal. Thanks in advance, only helpful comments please.

seamus

brassbutterfly wrote: »

Is he gay/bisexual/experimenting?

Yeah, possibly. That's no help to you unfortunately. There are apparently plenty of straight people who enjoy gay porn even though they have no desire to actually engage in gay sex. Even the taboo of it alone could be the turn on, rather than enjoying the nude men.

For some reason, it's generally seen as fine for a straight woman to watch lesbian porn, but a man watching MM gay porn is automatically assumed to be gay or bi.

If you're happy that he loves you and finds you attractive, then it's not really all that important what kind of porn he does and doesn't watch. While of course ideally you would both be open about what you do and do not like, it can be a deeply personal thing which most people find difficult to share even with their partners. This would especially be the case if he thinks that you would respect him less for what he does watch.

If it's sufficiently bothering you, then burying it and forgetting about it probably isn't the healthiest. But if you do address it, you want to come from the point of view of, "I don't mind what you watch and I don't think less of you", rather than in a confrontational manner.

Adolescenteen

seamus wrote: »

There are apparently plenty of straight people who enjoy gay porn even though they have no desire to actually engage in gay sex. Even the taboo of it alone could be the turn on, rather than enjoying the nude men.

I'm a straight male and I watch gay porn from time to time. I'm not even sure it's because of the taboo of it in my case, just sometimes I'm in a certain mood and state of arousal so I end up watching it.

I used to question about whether this said anything about my sexuality, but when I tried to think of an occasion where I've been sexually attracted to a man, I could think of nothing. Sometimes I just find the idea of two men being attracted to each other appealing (so maybe it is because of the taboo!).

To the OP. I can imagine your confusion, but I wouldn't draw any rash conclusions just yet. It could just be simple curiosity.

LegacyUser

I would say your partner needs to come clean with you what it is exactly he is doing. It is totally unfair of him to conceal these things from you. Especially if you are engaged, secrets like this only breed mistrust, regardless of whether it is merely a fantasy or not.

jobbridge4life

Anyone can come across legal porn of various types on-line without intending to or enjoying it. Sometimes one can stay for the curiosity/shock factor. If it was a lot and if it is an ongoing thing though there is definitely something about his sexuality he isn't being 100% honest to you about.

Talk to him about it, but as said above, being confrontational about it won't help and he'll just shy away from you about it a bit more, and possibly feel a bit shamed.

Come across as understanding and be a bit playful about bringing it up or such. If he hasn't told you about it then he's obviously feeling a bit embarrassed or awkward about it, and the moment you mention it he's going to go straight into defensive-mode.


I'll put my hands up and say that although I've seen a bit of gay porn in my time, it doesn't really appeal to me at all (well, not of the male/male variety anyway :P ). But everyone's got different tastes and as people have said above, enjoying something on a screen, doesn't necessarily mean he's looking to do it in real life.


That said, of course, it could be just as likely that he is interested in doing it in real life. If he does want to have gay relationships, and you're not happy with that, it's best to address it before you get married.


(That said, I'm no expert. So take my advice with a grain of salt, etc.)

baby and crumble

Is it the watching of porn that's an issue for you, OP, or the type of porn? I wouldn't rush to too many conclusions, tbh I often watch gay m-m porn and I'm a lesbian!

kickthecan

With all due respect your partner as much as he is yours and is about to marry you is entitled to his own space and independence. That can include being off doing his own thing with friends, hobbies that don't include you or in this case privacy watching this kind of porn. If he hasn't told you its because he feels ashamed, embarrassed or any other amount of reasons.

As long as your relationship is healthy, you love him, he loves you, he treats you well and there is trust between you I wouldn't go digging. Just leave it imo. Im sure there are things you wouldn't like him to know that simply doesn't effect your relationship.

jobbridge4life

kickthecan wrote: »

With all due respect your partner as much as he is yours and is about to marry you is entitled to his own space and independence. That can include being off doing his own thing with friends, hobbies that don't include you or in this case privacy watching this kind of porn. If he hasn't told you its because he feels ashamed, embarrassed or any other amount of reasons.

As long as your relationship is healthy, you love him, he loves you, he treats you well and there is trust between you I wouldn't go digging. Just leave it imo. Im sure there are things you wouldn't like him to know that simply doesn't effect your relationship.

OF course a person is entitled to the space and freedom but frankly IMHO not up to concealing parts of your sexuality from the person you are going to marry. Moreover lets be honest this isn't hiding a predilection for girls with ginger hair from your wife it may be hiding that you are sexually attracted to another sex altogether.

The point is the fiancee deserves the truth and to enter into her marriage either being kept in the dark by her future husband or the very least suspicious that she might be is not the best course of action.

Pumpkin PJs Fan No.9

kickthecan wrote: »

With all due respect your partner as much as he is yours and is about to marry you is entitled to his own space and independence. That can include being off doing his own thing with friends, hobbies that don't include you or in this case privacy watching this kind of porn. If he hasn't told you its because he feels ashamed, embarrassed or any other amount of reasons.

As long as your relationship is healthy, you love him, he loves you, he treats you well and there is trust between you I wouldn't go digging. Just leave it imo. Im sure there are things you wouldn't like him to know that simply doesn't effect your relationship.

What?

Seriously... What?

Did you even read the OP?

Obviously the relationship is already less than healthy due to her being aware of all this.


Your logic equals... noTice a lump on your nuts that wasn't there last week - just ignore it... it will be fine...


Again... What?

Are you the Fiancé by any chance?

________________

"How do I get the upside down question mark?"

Annasopra

Pumpkin PJs Fan No.9 wrote: »

Are you the Fiancé by any chance?

No need for a comment like this

frostyjacks

He's being dishonest with himself and his future wife. The fact he was so keen to cover his tracks shows that he knows what he is doing is wrong. If it had been one or two sites you could pass it off as curiosity, but the fact that it was a lot of sites would suggest it's something deeper.

kickthecan

frostyjacks wrote: »

He's being dishonest with himself and his future wife. The fact he was so keen to cover his tracks shows that he knows what he is doing is wrong. If it had been one or two sites you could pass it off as curiosity, but the fact that it was a lot of sites would suggest it's something deeper.

You are just sensationalising it even more. Is there actually anyone in existence completely proud and open about their secrets. If she never came across the web history she recovered they could live and die together and never need to know these things.

wakka12

Well the vast majority of men who watch gay porn are in fact gay or bi..but I know of a small number of lads who are straight who sometimes enjoy it. So I wouldn't go worrying about it just yet. If you see him staring at hot men in public or making flirty eyes with your attractive male friends then maybe start to worry.

frostyjacks

kickthecan wrote: »

You are just sensationalising it even more. Is there actually anyone in existence completely proud and open about their secrets. If she never came across the web history she recovered they could live and die together and never need to know these things.

I'm sensationalising? A man about to get married is viewing lots of gay porn sites, I'm not sure how to downplay that. Is it better to keep such things secret? If it was straight porn, possibly. But this is crossing the line.

Pumpkin PJs Fan No.9

frostyjacks wrote: »

I'm sensationalising? A man about to get married is viewing lots of gay porn sites, I'm not sure how to downplay that. Is it better to keep such things secret? If it was straight porn, possibly. But this is crossing the line.

Well, regardless of the nature of the porn, he could be a "Looner" (look it up) for the sake of this debate, 'cause I think hiding any part of your sexuality from the person you plan to spend the rest of your life with, is a very bad way to start.

And if he as been watching a lot of this material, well, he's obviously a curious kitty; he may act on these desires, he may not - but it doesn't change the fact that his fiancee is suffering from his lack of disclosure. Not a good way to begin a marriage.

jimdublin15

Your fiancée seems to have been watching gay porn.

Maybe it's just fantasy or maybe he's BI . Who knows, and even if he was or is I'm not sure why that's a problem as long as its a fantasy he's not acting on.

I mean I watch a wide range of porn myself but that does not means i actually want what is happening or being done in the porn to happen in real life .
It's just fantasy, my fantasy.

It's only really a problem if you think he is taking his porn to a different level and acting on it behind your back and if you're this worried about a bit of porn or the choice of porn it sounds to me you have bigger issues in the relationship to work on and that would be the trust level and room to still be yourselves within the relationship.

As for retrieving the data from the laptop to find out what he has been looking at ...Would you accept it if your partner went looking in your bag ? Phone or laptop to see what you had been doing? Because I have to say I would not accept that level of snooping from a partner no matter what the circumstances it's just too controlling.

brassbutterfly

Thanks for all the comments. We have since discussed the issue- I brought it up and he was very honest, explaining he watches a variety of porn. I realise now I shouldn't have gone snooping and I won't be doing it again. It served no purpose only to upset me (completely my own fault) which is something he would never set out to do. And some of you are correct, I wouldn't like him looking through my search history. It serves no purpose, only to upset and confuse when there is no need for same. Thanks for the feedback everybody.

kickthecan

Told ya to just leave it. But its good you have peace now and hopefully you haven't listened to all the shock horror replies. We all have our guilty pleasures. Good luck with your marriage!!!

LorMal

frostyjacks wrote: »

I'm sensationalising? A man about to get married is viewing lots of gay porn sites, I'm not sure how to downplay that. Is it better to keep such things secret? If it was straight porn, possibly. But this is crossing the line.

I totally agree. I am a straight man and I would never watch gay porn. Not that I have a problem with it, but it really would do zero for me. (In fact I find porn in general pretty grotty).
This chap is either gay or very uncertain. Either way, the OP needs to confront him.

kickthecan

LorMal wrote: »

I totally agree. I am a straight man and I would never watch gay porn. Not that I have a problem with it, but it really would do zero for me. (In fact I find porn in general pretty grotty).
This chap is either gay or very uncertain. Either way, the OP needs to confront him.

See post 18

Annasopra

LorMal wrote: »

I totally agree. I am a straight man and I would never watch gay porn. Not that I have a problem with it, but it really would do zero for me. (In fact I find porn in general pretty grotty).
This chap is either gay or very uncertain. Either way, the OP needs to confront him.

Why is there an insistence to box people so restrictively? Maybe he's just a straight guy that likes gay porn.

Summertime8989

@Joey. And what interest would a straight man have in watching gay porn? Do you watch lesbian porn and get aroused by it? How do you propose a gay man would watch lesbian porn if he has no attraction/arousal towards females? She found gay porn on his old pc so there is obviously an attraction of some sort there. Yes we don't want to box people but we don't want to be completely daft either when the evidence is staring you right in the face. You don't watch gay porn unless you are aroused/attracted by men. A dose of cop on is needed. OP just ask him straight out is he gay or bi, no point finding out in 20 years because we don't want do box people.

Summertime8989

Joeytheparrot wrote: »

Why is there an insistence to box people so restrictively? Maybe he's just a straight guy that likes gay porn.

This is impossible. A straight guy is sexually attracted to females exclusively, if he likes gay porn then he isn't straight. No straight man is attracted to males engaging in sex. It's absolutely ludicrous what you're spouting. How many gay men secretly watch lesbian porn behind their boyfriends back? Lol they don't fancy women so would take no enjoyment from this. OP the warning signs are off the scale, I'd ask you not heed the advise of people who think straight people can "get off" to gay porn out of their own will. They are obsessed with not labeling people it's obstructing the ability to use common sense. Good luck

Summertime8989

kickthecan wrote: »

See post 18

For techniques on how ostriches bury their head in the sand. Of course her fiancee is going to say what she wants to hear if he's in the closet. And according to you him watching gay porn is a "Guilty pleasure" hmmm to take pleasure from something means you enjoy it and you can't enjoy gay porn unless you're sexually attracted to men and he's guilty about it too apparently, guilty because he's hiding his sexual attraction to men. Nice logic you have there. You live on la la land

Annasopra

Not everyone fits into this neat little binary of straight and gay.

This is not really a new concept. There are lots of straight men (self defining as straight) who sometimes fantasise about other men or have sex with other men. Placing people into some rigid box that they must be gay or straight just because doesn't work for everyone. Of course most people do fit the labels/boxes but not everyone does and I really fail to see why these rigid labels/boxes are forced on people. It's defining yourself as an expert on someone elses life.

The reality is labels and boxes are fine but sticking rigidly to them doesnt work. Even medical professionals realise this. They realised that lots of men who have sex with men did not self define as gay or bi.

Nope not buying this idea at all that all people must be boxed into a rigid inflexible binary or even trinary label of straight, gay or bi.

Annasopra

Summertime8989 wrote: »

This is impossible. A straight guy is sexually attracted to females exclusively, if he likes gay porn then he isn't straight. No straight man is attracted to males engaging in sex. It's absolutely ludicrous what you're spouting. How many gay men secretly watch lesbian porn behind their boyfriends back? Lol they don't fancy women so would take no enjoyment from this. OP the warning signs are off the scale, I'd ask you not heed the advise of people who think straight people can "get off" to gay porn out of their own will. They are obsessed with not labeling people it's obstructing the ability to use common sense. Good luck

No. Its not impossible at all.

Summertime8989

" There are lots of straight men (self defining as straight) who sometimes fantasise about other men or have sex with other men. Placing people into some rigid box that they must be gay or straight just because doesn't work for everyone." See even you put "straight" in brackets and that proves my point exactly. If they are having sex with men or watching lots of gay porn for years then they are at least bi(No straight man would engage in those activities) sorry to disappoint whatever fantasy you may have. I didn't say everyone has to be straight or gay so I don't understand that ramble, he is at least bi if he's watching and climaxing to two men having sex on a frequent bases over the span of years

Summertime8989

Joeytheparrot wrote: »

No. Its not impossible at all.

So tell me this do you get aroused watching lesbian porn or does the idea of it do anything for you? How many gay men go online and watch lesbian porn that you know of instead of watching gay porn? If a gay man is aroused by two females having sex then he isn't completely gay. And you think straight men willing choose to watch gay porn over straight porn then you don't know what straight means.

OP otherhalf obviously isn't completely straight, he at least has gay tendencies,if not bi or even closeted gay.

Porn-sexually explicit videos, photographs, writings, or the like, produced to elicit sexual arousal
Homosexual- sexually attracted to members of one's own sex: relating to sexual desire or behavior directed toward members of one's own

You're barking mad to believe frequently watching gay porn over years and hiding it from your other half means you're entirely straight

The dictionary must be wrong too, you don't buy it but that's the definition.

Summertime8989

In conclusion Joey thinks A) Straight men fantasise about having sex with men. Watch gay porn instead of straight porn. C) Have sex with men. D) They're still straight. K

ixoy

Summertime8989 wrote: »

In conclusion Joey thinks A) Straight men fantasise about having sex with men. Watch gay porn instead of straight porn. C) Have sex with men. D) They're still straight. K

Eh no he doesn't. Joey thinks that some men, who identify as straight, on occasion like to watch gay porn as an alternative to only watching straight porn. That's very different to what you're trying to say.

Hunchback

ixoy wrote: »

Eh no he doesn't. Joey thinks that some men, who identify as straight, on occasion like to watch gay porn as an alternative to only watching straight porn. That's very different to what you're trying to say.

Both different and hard to believe. Straight men who sleep with men 'identify' as 'straight', but it stretches the meaning of the phrase 'straight' to breaking point IMO.

Summertime8989

ixoy wrote: »

Eh no he doesn't. Joey thinks that some men, who identify as straight, on occasion like to watch gay porn as an alternative to only watching straight porn. That's very different to what you're trying to say.

How can straight men "like" to watch another man ride another man. Another ridiculous mod has entered the conversation. Let me reverse what you said, gay men, on occasion like to watch lesbian porn as an alternative to watching gay porn. See how thick that sounds

And yes joey does think that, "There are lots of straight men who sometimes fantasise about other men or have sex with other men." I propose you throughly read what he said before attempting to tell what I was trying to say, should be a given when you're a mod.

So there you go joey thinks lots of straight men fantasise about men sexually, watch gay porn and have sex with men and they're still straight. K

Hunchback

ixoy wrote: »

Eh no he doesn't. Joey thinks that some men, who identify as straight, on occasion like to watch gay porn as an alternative to only watching straight porn. That's very different to what you're trying to say.

To clarify, I feel the same way about 'straight' men who watch gay porn. It stretches the meaning of the phrase 'straight' to breaking point, if the individual watches gay porn over an extended period.

I also think Summertime made a very salient point re lesbian porn. I identify as exclusively homosexual and never EVER once have I watched lesbian porn or porn of any nature for the purposes of observing women in sexual situations. Why? Because I am not sexually attracted to women and therefore am not even curious.

Summertime8989

Thank you CK for clarifying my point. You don't watch lesbian porn because for you as a gay man it's pointless. Just like gay porn is pointless for a straight man. If a man enjoys gay porn he isn't entirely straight, he may well be bi but he isn't completely straight no matter how much he "identifies" he is(in denial).

Annasopra

Summertime8989 wrote: »

In conclusion Joey thinks A) Straight men fantasise about having sex with men. Watch gay porn instead of straight porn. C) Have sex with men. D) They're still straight. K

No.

I am pointing out that

A) Gay, Straight and Bi are a trinary of sexual orientation but not everyone identifies as gay, straight or bi
People can place themselves into one of the trinary but they may possibly display characteristics associated with one of the others
C) Not everyone fits neatly into one of the trinary labels
D) Because I realise that there is a fluidity associated with the labels I never force them onto other people and I actually think it's really rude to do so. E.g. I would never prescibe the OPs other half as "definitely gay" or "definitely bi" - who am I to appoint myself as an expert on someone else. I also believe if he identifies as straight then he is straight. Many lesbians watch straight porn, many gay men watch straight porn etc etc.

Summertime8989

How many gay men watch lesbian porn to get off to it? You keep ignoring that as you can't answer. "I also believe if he identifies as straight then he is straight." Yeah because **** to two men sleeping together is really straight. Coming from someone who said ""There are lots of straight men who sometimes fantasise about other men or have sex with other men."it isn't surprising. You must have a fantasy about getting with a "straight" man and this is where it stems from. Do you fantasise about women and sleep with them?

LorMal

Joeytheparrot wrote: »

No.

I am pointing out that

A) Gay, Straight and Bi are a trinary of sexual orientation but not everyone identifies as gay, straight or bi
People can place themselves into one of the trinary but they may possibly display characteristics associated with one of the others
C) Not everyone fits neatly into one of the trinary labels
D) Because I realise that there is a fluidity associated with the labels I never force them onto other people and I actually think it's really rude to do so. E.g. I would never prescibe the OPs other half as "definitely gay" or "definitely bi" - who am I to appoint myself as an expert on someone else. I also believe if he identifies as straight then he is straight. Many lesbians watch straight porn, many gay men watch straight porn etc etc.

Joey, I'm afraid I disagree entirely. This whole notion of a fluid 'spectrum' is a myth. Nobody is forcing a label on anyone else here.
The point is that a straight man will not get anything from watching gay porn. In fact, it will be difficult for him to watch.
If a man is regularly watching gay porn over an extended time frame, he is gay or bi-sexual. He ain't straight. No, nay, never.
That's not to 'label' him - that's just the facts. And very important for his fiance to know.

rochey84

Summertime8989 wrote: »

How many gay men watch lesbian porn to get off to it? You keep ignoring that as you can't answer. "I also believe if he identifies as straight then he is straight." Yeah because **** to two men sleeping together is really straight. Coming from someone who said ""There are lots of straight men who sometimes fantasise about other men or have sex with other men."it isn't surprising. You must have a fantasy about getting with a "straight" man and this is where it stems from. Do you fantasise about women and sleep with them?

I think you're missing the point that Joey is making, he is saying that we have to respect people's own self identification, I have had encounters with plenty of lads that would identify as straight, in my mind I don't think they are straight but until they are willing to admit that to themselves then there is zero point in me prescribing it to them.

Personally, I agree with you that the OP's fiance does have, at best, bisexual tendancies but if he is closeted enough to ask a woman to marry him then that woman confronting him telling him he must be bi/gay will only push him further into the closet leading him to further identify as straight.

This is the reason that the Blood transfusion service puts a ban on MSM (Men who have had sex with men) instead of "Gay or Bi" men. Because you will have plenty of lads who will identify as straight despite looking for a bloke a couple of times a year donating blood against the rules.

That's my 2cents and I hope I've helped clear things up!

baby and crumble

Just popping my head up above the parapet and stating I'm a lesbian with zero desire to sleep with a man ever, that enjoys gay male porn.

It's very much possible. And a pretty common thing. So why wouldn't the reverse work too?

In any case, maybe the guy is bisexual but committed to his fiance. Just because he may be attracted to men aswell as women doesn't mean he's on Grindr looking to get his end away with a random dude. People fantasise even when in relationships, it's weird if you don't.

TheChizler

LorMal wrote: »

If a man is regularly watching gay porn over an extended time frame, he is gay or bi-sexual. He ain't straight. No, nay, never.
That's not to 'label' him - that's just the facts. And very important for his fiance to know.

That's the dictionary definition of labeling...

And why is it important for the fiance to know? That's a very definitive statement, you should be able to outline the reasons behind it. Is it any more important for her to know than that he might like straight porn?

LorMal

rochey84 wrote: »

I think you're missing the point that Joey is making, he is saying that we have to respect people's own self identification, I have had encounters with plenty of lads that would identify as straight, in my mind I don't think they are straight but until they are willing to admit that to themselves then there is zero point in me prescribing it to them.

Personally, I agree with you that the OP's fiance does have, at best, bisexual tendancies but if he is closeted enough to ask a woman to marry him then that woman confronting him telling him he must be bi/gay will only push him further into the closet leading him to further identify as straight.

This is the reason that the Blood transfusion service puts a ban on MSM (Men who have had sex with men) instead of "Gay or Bi" men. Because you will have plenty of lads who will identify as straight despite looking for a bloke a couple of times a year donating blood against the rules.

That's my 2cents and I hope I've helped clear things up!

Surely then the correct response to this girl is to say the guy is most likely gay. Surely we should 'respect her right' to marry someone in good faith more than t 'respect the right' of th man to lie about his sexuality when entering into a marriage??

LorMal

TheChizler wrote: »

That's the dictionary definition of labeling...

And why is it important for the fiance to know? That's a very definitive statement, you should be able to outline the reasons behind it. Is it any more important for her to know than that he might like straight porn?

Christ almighty! Why is it important for the fiancé to know?????

TheChizler

LorMal wrote: »

Surely then the correct response to this girl is to say the guy is most likely gay. Surely we should 'respect her right' to marry someone in good faith more than t 'respect the right' of th man to lie about his sexuality when entering into a marriage??

If he's attracted and dedicated to her and isn't cheating what's the problem?

TheChizler

LorMal wrote: »

Christ almighty! Why is it important for the fiancé to know?????

Yup, that's what I asked.

LorMal

Given some of the recent responses here, I am beginning to question some gay people's understanding of marriage.
Are you seriously suggesting she should not have to know about her future husbands sexuality? I am missing something here?

LorMal

TheChizler wrote: »

Yup, that's what I asked.

You are either pulling the piss or you are off your trolley.

LegacyUser

TBh the sexuality of the partner is not of big concern to a marriage as long as

1) they have a good sexual relationship together
2) they both respect each other and understand marriage is a commitment to each other

My wife has sexual fantasies about women, this is as much a concern for me as her fantasies about other men. i.e. not an issue, unless she acts on them without discussing with me first. This would be the same viewpoint for her.

This view wouldn't change if she had kept the fact secret. So I don't see how it would affect things. However, I do believe being open and honest in a relationship builds stronger bonds.

NB I've gone anon as I'm not sure if she might want me to post this on Boards.

TheChizler

LorMal wrote: »

Given some of the recent responses here, I am beginning to question some gay people's understanding of marriage.
Are you seriously suggesting she should not have to know about her future husbands sexuality? I am missing something here?

LorMal wrote: »

You are either pulling the piss or you are off your trolley.

Didn't say anything about sexuality, and no I'm not 'pulling the piss' (never heard that phrase before). I'm genuinely wondering why you think that it's very important that a fiance knows that the other person enjoys porn of a different type to the type of relationship they're in.

rochey84

LorMal wrote: »

Surely then the correct response to this girl is to say the guy is most likely gay. Surely we should 'respect her right' to marry someone in good faith more than t 'respect the right' of th man to lie about his sexuality when entering into a marriage??

Forgive my ignorance here, but how did you reach the conclusion from what I wrote that the guy is most likely gay? Do you not think there is equal chance that he is bisexual?

In fact if I was to go to the effort of prescribing a sexuality for him I would say he is bisexual given that he is marrying a woman and I assume sleeping with a woman on a regular basis but only watching gay porn and to the best of our knowledge not acting on it, but then this is why I wouldn't like to prescribe anyone's sexuality to them!

kickthecan

The OP is happy with her conclusion to the problem. That was the point of the tread. Get over yourselves trying to convince everyone you know more about this situation. You don't.