Ireland Team Talk/Gossip/Rumour Thread III

Wang King

bilston wrote: »

What has he scored a hat trick or something?

He's waiting until the Italian game

CatFromHue

Wang King wrote: »

A 13 who knows how to score

Who, Darren Cave?

wp_rathead

Hope we see Earls on Wing for Wolfhounds

thomond2006

wprathead wrote: »

Hope we see Earls on Wing for Wolfhounds

I'd say he will get gametime at both 13 and wing. McFadden, Zebo and Bowe are probably favourites for the wings with Henshaw and Fitzgerald as the preferred centres.

Tox56

bilston wrote: »

What has he scored a hat trick or something?

:pac:

I'd put Earls in the category of player we cannot afford to leave out of the 23 if available, but I'd also put Fitz and Payne in that category. With Henshaw nailed in for one of the centre spots we're kind of running out of space.

aimee1

Deleted User wrote: »

EARLS FOR IRELAND!

it today the longest earls has played on his comeback so far? he needs to get a few 80s under his belt possibly

molloyjh

Tox56 wrote: »

:pac:

I'd put Earls in the category of player we cannot afford to leave out of the 23 if available, but I'd also put Fitz and Payne in that category. With Henshaw nailed in for one of the centre spots we're kind of running out of space.

A great complaint to have!

RoundBox11

I'd feel more comfortable having Payne on the bench rather than Earls but I can see Earls starting on the wing anyway. It does feel a bit wrong to have someone as good as Payne sitting on the bench though. Hopefully we'll get to see him start against Scotland at least.

By the way, I think it was last week i mentioned here that Henderson could likely be at 6 for Italy with POM at 7 and it was dismissed by others. Seems even more likely to me now!

11. Earls
12. Luke
13. Henshaw
14. Bowe
15. Payne

would be an outrageous backline. Can't see Payne ousting Kearney just yet though.

Clegg

It's unfortunate for Earls that he came back a bit too late. Fitzgerald has played well in all his games and even got motm in yesterday's do or die game with Wasps. Earls is right in the reckoning for the 23 though.

aimee1

Clegg wrote: »

It's unfortunate for Earls that he came back a bit too late. Fitzgerald has played well in all his games and even got motm in yesterday's do or die game with Wasps. Earls is right in the reckoning for the 23 though.

I wonder will Earls start the WH game with a view to him playing the full 80 to get his match fitness up a little?

Clegg

aimee1 wrote: »

I wonder will Earls start the WH game with a view to him playing the full 80 to get his match fitness up a little?

I was looking at it from the view of Earls as a centre. I think Henshaw and Fitz have the starting jerseys for the Italy game. Earls could easily start in the wing but I reckon Zebo, Bowe and Kearney will make up the back three. They're all in reasonably good form and have credit in the bank from their November test performances. Payne, Earls and Mc Fadden will scrap it out for the 23 jersey.

bilston

RoundBox11 wrote: »

I'd feel more comfortable having Payne on the bench rather than Earls but I can see Earls starting on the wing anyway. It does feel a bit wrong to have someone as good as Payne sitting on the bench though. Hopefully we'll get to see him start against Scotland at least.

By the way, I think it was last week i mentioned here that Henderson could likely be at 6 for Italy with POM at 7 and it was dismissed by others. Seems even more likely to me now!

Well I will admit that I dismissed it.

After last night I'd say it's very possible.

.ak

Williams for ireland.

RoundBox11

Potential team to face Italy?

McGrath, Best, Moore, Toner, POC, Henderson, POM, Heaslip, Murray, Madigan, Earls, Fitz, Henshaw, Bowe, Kearney

Bench: Healy, Cronin, Ross, Foley, SOB, Marmion, Keatley, Payne

Mahatma Geansai

RoundBox11 wrote: »

Potential team to face Italy?

McGrath, Best, Moore, Toner, POC, Henderson, POM, Heaslip, Murray, Madigan, Earls, Fitz, Henshaw, Bowe, Kearney

Bench: Healy, Cronin, Ross, Foley, SOB, Marmion, Keatley, Payne

Can't leave Zebo out of the side. He been playing very well season, was very good in the Autumn, and was world-class out of position today.

Fireball07

I'd be shocked if SOB was on the bench so quickly, but maybe!


I don't know who I'd pick between Zebo, Earls and McFadden. Harsh to leave any out, but if Earls goes well for the WH, I'd nearly have to opt for him.

aimee1

Clegg wrote: »

I was looking at it from the view of Earls as a centre. I think Henshaw and Fitz have the starting jerseys for the Italy game. Earls could easily start in the wing but I reckon Zebo, Bowe and Kearney will make up the back three. They're all in reasonably good form and have credit in the bank from their November test performances. Payne, Earls and Mc Fadden will scrap it out for the 23 jersey.

im thinking that JS might be reluctant to start a guy who hasnt played 80 minutes this season. How much gametime has Payne had the last few weeks?

Zebo Bowe Kearney is the back 3. I cant see that changing barring injury.

Henshaw and Fitz for me in the centre. Fitz has put in big 80 minute shifts lately and his defence yesterday was brilliant. I dont know where people think we will go looking to tear it up in Rome. We will go there looking to win.

Murray hopefully and Madigan at half back

The bench will be Keatley, Marmion and one of McFadden, Earls, Payne and I think McFadden might get it for Italy.

Wang King

Fireball07 wrote: »

I'd be shocked if SOB was on the bench so quickly, but maybe!


I don't know who I'd pick between Zebo, Earls and McFadden. Harsh to leave any out, but if Earls goes well for the WH, I'd nearly have to opt for him.

If we're playing fantasy rugby,

11 Zebo
12 Earls
13 Fitz
14 Bowe
15 Kearney

RoundBox11

Mahatma Geansai wrote: »

Can't leave Zebo out of the side. He been playing very well season, was very good in the Autumn, and was world-class out of position today.

Who would he replace though?

Mahatma Geansai

TOD must be nailed on for the 7 jersey until SOB returns. He was always the obvious choice, but he had a brilliant game today which should quieten some doubters/critics.

Clegg

aimee1 wrote: »

im thinking that JS might be reluctant to start a guy who hasnt played 80 minutes this season. How much gametime has Payne had the last few weeks?

Zebo Bowe Kearney is the back 3. I cant see that changing barring injury.

Henshaw and Fitz for me in the centre. Fitz has put in big 80 minute shifts lately and his defence yesterday was brilliant. I dont know where people think we will go looking to tear it up in Rome. We will go there looking to win.

Murray hopefully and Madigan at half back

The bench will be Keatley, Marmion and one of McFadden, Earls, Payne and I think McFadden might get it for Italy.

Payne's been fullback for Ulster's last two European games. Don't think he's had a run out in the 13 jersey since returning from injury, but maybe someone who follows Ulster more closely can clarify. He played well against South Africa, but not well enough that Schmidt will throw him straight back into into the starting 15, especially after an injury and little game time at outside centre.

Schmidt sees the centres as interchangeable so we may see Fitz and Henshaw change positions during certain moments of the game.

irishbucsfan

Kearney and Bowe are pretty much nailed on I'd say. For me there is no way we should ever consider omitting Henshaw either. That leaves 1 winger and 1 center.

With Trimble and Kearney out it'll be Earls or Zebo for the wing spot, Earls would be preferable for me if he was fully fit, but I'd doubt that will be the case so it'd be Zebo there in that case and he'll be absolutely fine there.

The other center spot would go to Fitzgerald for me. Henshaw playing inside Fitzgerald in the defensive line.

Clegg

Mahatma Geansai wrote: »

TOD must be nailed on for the 7 jersey until SOB returns. He was always the obvious choice, but he had a brilliant game today which should quieten some doubters/critics.

Jordi Murphy has just as good a chance I think.

Wang King

If Murray is out, I can't see Henshaw and Fitz starting together

thomond2006

Given Schmidt talks about gametime a lot in terms of selection decisions, could he justify selecting Mike Ross if he is suddenly 3rd choice TH at Leinster?

S12b

Mahatma Geansai wrote: »

TOD must be nailed on for the 7 jersey until SOB returns. He was always the obvious choice, but he had a brilliant game today which should quieten some doubters/critics.

Well his direct competitor, Jordi Murphy, was also very good yesterday and importantly, that match was a proper one unlike today's non-event. TOD is certainly right there to start at 7 but nailed on, no chance!!

S12b

Wang King wrote: »

If Murray is out, I can't see Henshaw and Fitz starting together

What's your thinking there?

irishbucsfan

Mahatma Geansai wrote: »

TOD must be nailed on for the 7 jersey until SOB returns. He was always the obvious choice, but he had a brilliant game today which should quieten some doubters/critics.

Murphy also played well yesterday against a better side. I wouldn't rule him out just yet, Murphy has the physical edge which is often the difference maker for 7s at international level.

I personally think TOD is in danger of ending up as Munster's Shane Jennings, and the Sarries game is an example of how that happens to these guys. Talented opensides who begin to struggle against well structured physical opposition at the elite level.

.ak

Mahatma Geansai wrote: »

TOD must be nailed on for the 7 jersey until SOB returns. He was always the obvious choice, but he had a brilliant game today which should quieten some doubters/critics.

Carrying aside I thought he was poor at the breakdown today. Very rarely does he get his head down in there before the opposition. His clear outs are mediocre. If we have in there for a dynamic carrier then fair enough, but other than that I'd have murphy in as he's a more all round open side.