Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Free travel passes not to be touched in budget - Minister Burton
Options
Comments
-
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
Do you automatically get a pass if you're on Disability Benefit? - as various commentators have pointed out the numbers on DB have (for reasons largely unknown) increased dramatically in the last 10 years.
Increased dramatically !....the understatement of the thread....:eek:
Avoiding pedantry concerning Allowance vs Benefit in this context,here's the chapter n verse on who gets the FTP.
http://www.welfare.ie/en/Pages/780_Free-Travel.aspx#1
It's worth reading the entire document,particularly Item 1
782,529 and counting
Men, it has been well said, think in herds; it will be seen that they go mad in herds, while they only recover their senses slowly, and one by one.
Charles Mackay (1812-1889)
0 -
Another tidbit worth noting is the issuing of the NTA's second PSO contract to a Private Sector Operator...
http://www.nationaltransport.ie/news/whartons-travel-crossdoney-wins-contract-for-publicly-funded-bus-route-between-cavan-and-longford/
In the context of this thread however,and the very clear statement of Minister Burton as quoted in the header,this piece may be of some interest....?Adult and Concessionary Fares to be charged have been set by the Authority and broadly match the previous fares charged. As the Free Travel Scheme operated by the Department of Social Protection is closed to new entrants, holders of Free Travel Passes wishing to travel on the service will now be required to pay 50% of the appropriate Adult Fare. The new service is wheelchair accessible.
It remains to be seen whether Minister Burton is liasing with her counterpart in Transport,or indeed with any of the Senior Management of the NTA who,after all do tell us they have set the Fare levels....;)
The Future has already begun.....precedent is everything to these people,and now they have TWO to fall back upon Men, it has been well said, think in herds; it will be seen that they go mad in herds, while they only recover their senses slowly, and one by one.
Charles Mackay (1812-1889)
0 -
What are the current passenger numbers for the Portlaoise service? could it be called a success given that the operator threw in the towel when they had to cover the cost of the service and it now only operates fully funded by the NTA. Do as many free travel pass holders use it as did before the free travel element was removed(is it catering for those it was designed to cater for)?Another tidbit worth noting is the issuing of the NTA's second PSO contract to a Private Sector Operator...
http://www.nationaltransport.ie/news/whartons-travel-crossdoney-wins-contract-for-publicly-funded-bus-route-between-cavan-and-longford/
In the context of this thread however,and the very clear statement of Minister Burton as quoted in the header,this piece may be of some interest....?
It remains to be seen whether Minister Burton is liasing with her counterpart in Transport,or indeed with any of the Senior Management of the NTA who,after all do tell us they have set the Fare levels....;)
The Future has already begun.....precedent is everything to these people,and now they have TWO to fall back upon0 -
Another tidbit worth noting is the issuing of the NTA's second PSO contract to a Private Sector Operator...
http://www.nationaltransport.ie/news/whartons-travel-crossdoney-wins-contract-for-publicly-funded-bus-route-between-cavan-and-longford/
In the context of this thread however,and the very clear statement of Minister Burton as quoted in the header,this piece may be of some interest....?
It remains to be seen whether Minister Burton is liasing with her counterpart in Transport,or indeed with any of the Senior Management of the NTA who,after all do tell us they have set the Fare levels....;)
The Future has already begun.....precedent is everything to these people,and now they have TWO to fall back upon
It will really fall apart when/if the tendering of DB/BE routes is rolled out and the NTA take full control of the farebox and has to make the books balance rather than just throwing the ball into the CIE court and telling them to make the books balance.
Operators will have to be paid on a Km driven basis irrespective of who travels or if no one travels, the NTA will presumably also have the cost of central control and revenue protection and quite possibly depot provision and maintenance as well as fleet replacement.
Upto now the DoT has always been able to just tell the operator to cut costs ( ie routes, staff, terms and conditions etc) irrespective of what they had asked the provider to do the yeaar before, that won't be the case in the future when they have binding contracts with private companies for service provision for fixed terms.
What will the NTA do when the fare box, subvention and money for free travel scheme doesn't meet the operating costs but they are obliged to pay the operators anyway ?0 -
-
mickydoomsux wrote: »Raise fares so that the free travel stays free. That seems to be the most important thing in public transport at the moment.
Raise fares, cut services, cut wages and run services/facilities with no overtime but the cost of a free travel ticket is exactly the same as it was before an unprecedented economic meltdown despite there being more people than ever "entitled" to free travel.
This is known as the "U.K. Model" and is working very well there.....loads n loadsa people getting shiny new Bus Passes ....however...more and more operators shutting-up shop as the funding for the scheme is so poor....Free Travel,but No services on which to use it.....sounds kinda Irish to me...Oh wait....sorry,we're playing catch-up Men, it has been well said, think in herds; it will be seen that they go mad in herds, while they only recover their senses slowly, and one by one.
Charles Mackay (1812-1889)
0 -
-
-
I haven't read this thread entirely but just wanted to add my piece.
As a non OAP I have my pass due to a disability so wherever I want to go I need to use public transport, mine isn't a companion pass so just for myself.
I don't have the option to drive myself due to my medical issues so having my FTP means I can do whatever I want without needing to be concerned about the cost.
On the other side, for OAP's its about social inclusion. Particularly for those living outside urban areas. Again, it means you can go outside your own home without needing to worry about the cost.
I do think for OAPs theres a case for means teasing it in line with the medical card or something like that. Or maybe removing it form short distance journeys that might only cost 2 or 3 euro.
Ryanf1,the issue I am highlighting is nothing to do with individuals or the reasons they have a Free Travel Pass.(Thats for a different thread)
The Thread Title refers to the statements issues by both Leo Varadakar and Joan Burton in recent times.
However whilst the wording of the statements is undoubtably accurate,the experience to date with the NEW NTA PSO Tendered routes indicates otherwise...
The FACT is,that if you present yourself for travel on either the 828/X or 975 services your Free Travel Pass will NOT be honoured in the manner it's title infers.
Instead,presentation of your FREE Travel Pass will allow you to purchase a ticket at 50% discount off the appropriate Adult fare.
The question now hanging in the air,is whether this new "Concessionary" Fare regime is now official NTA policy on PSO tendered routes going forward.....Is it?..or.... is it Not ?
It is a serious issue,as IF the two new PSO routes not accepting the FTP,are NOT typical of the new PSO Contracts countrywide,then those FTP holders using these services are most certainly being singled out for discrimination in terms of accessing Public Transport.
This issue,of itself,has the capacity to throw the NTA's current plans to outsource 10% of the Dublin Bus/Bus Eireann PSO contracts into chaos should some enterprising reporter cotton on to it.....;)
It would now seem that the validity of the FTP will in the first instance be dictated,not by the NTA or the DSP,but by the individual Service Operator,without any contractual requirement to honour the existing entitlement held by the FT Scheme participants.
But the Free Pass itself will,of course,remain untouched by Political Hands....:o
Men, it has been well said, think in herds; it will be seen that they go mad in herds, while they only recover their senses slowly, and one by one.
Charles Mackay (1812-1889)
0 -
-
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
But can those two little used routes be used as a sign of things to come? Remember that on the portlaoise route the operator m&a coaches pulled out of the original deal because they could not make any money at all from the route, not because they had to carry free pass holders but because there are no significant passenger numbers. .....
........Both these routes could be more than adequately covered by a twice a day bus twice a week like hundreds of other routes on bus eireanns rural routes network. ........
I would safely say that many of the older and disabled people who used the old expressway services have made alternative arrangements or have had family neighbours and friends rally around to make sure they were not left paying for a service that was previously free for them. We must remember that before many of these people are able to use free travel at all they must now pay to travel or stay at home. Most do not have the luxury of deciding to cycle or drive.
Quite corrrect......the opening question stands on it's own merit and is proving diifficult to secure an answer for.
So,is the inability of an operator to "Make any money" from a Public Service Obligation route now grounds for the total abandonment of the long-established FREE Travel Scheme ?
If it is grounds in deepest Portlaoise,then we must assume it will equally be grounds in Urban Waterford,Bray,Dun Laoire,Swords and Rialto,something which the NTA,in particular,has steered decidely clear of in it's recent statements.
Bearing in mind that the NTA's 10% proposals do not involve ANY additional buses or services,yet at face value may well involve a considerable alteration in how the services are funded/provided/used,the reluctance to clarify the brave new Tendered World is somewhat interesting.
The Governments ongoing attempts to talk-up an Irish recovery & rebound from economic collapse stands in contradiction to this particular example of questionable policy ?
But,on the bright side...."The FREE Travel Pass has not been touched" Men, it has been well said, think in herds; it will be seen that they go mad in herds, while they only recover their senses slowly, and one by one.
Charles Mackay (1812-1889)
0 -
-
Advertisement
-
Advertisement