Waterford University discussion

16-04-2021 11:01pm

mart 23 wrote: »

Under EU regional areas the Mid-West consists of Clare, Limerick and All of Tipperary since 2014.

You are correct, just about to pop on my tinfoil hat for a moment, moving a population of 159k from the south east to the mid west leaving the south East with the smallest population with the expection of the midlands and border counties.

While the mid west jumps the table significantly. Interesting

Harry Palmr · 16-04-2021 11:05pm

It was probably always going to happen when they abolished the two ridings.

Harry Palmr · 21-04-2021 5:13pm

http://www.thefuse.ie/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/TUSE_press_release_20210416.pdf

FUSE really arrived too late to be of much value I fear. It needed to be up and running and getting the ear of media and politicians well before the last election and better still the one before, forming during the current admin when the biggest decisions are being taken means there's very little leverage available.

SeanieW1977 · 21-04-2021 5:46pm

Harry Palmr wrote: »

http://www.thefuse.ie/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/TUSE_press_release_20210416.pdf

FUSE really arrived too late to be of much value I fear. It needed to be up and running and getting the ear of media and politicians well before the last election and better still the one before, forming during the current admin when the biggest decisions are being taken means there's very little leverage available.

did matt shanahan write that statement?

Or was it just one of his boot boys? :rolleyes:

Another campaign infiltrated by shanahan and his cohorts - ultimately achieved nothing.

what a waste of time.

Harry Palmr · 21-04-2021 5:51pm

Blimey it's a bit of grudge for you! And you're guessing of course so maybe not the best approach.

21-04-2021 6:52pm

Harry Palmr wrote: »

http://www.thefuse.ie/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/TUSE_press_release_20210416.pdf

FUSE really arrived too late to be of much value I fear. It needed to be up and running and getting the ear of media and politicians well before the last election and better still the one before, forming during the current admin when the biggest decisions are being taken means there's very little leverage available.

Absolutely nothing in that gives me any confidence in the TUSE, they were asked to trust the process. Basically told to shut up as we know best by our representatives.

I fear our worst fears.

Since the establishment of DTU and MTU, are both those TU's now toe to toe with DCU, UL, UCC etc???

imacman · 21-04-2021 7:31pm

914 wrote: »

Absolutely nothing in that gives me any confidence in the TUSE, they were asked to trust the process. Basically told to shut up as we know best by our representatives.

I fear our worst fears.

Since the establishment of DTU and MTU, are both those TU's now toe to toe with DCU, UL, UCC etc???

No far from it , I know some staff in CIT and the merger has been a shambles with loads of IR issues and fudges. Things have remained the same on the ground in CIT with just a rebadge in place and the staff in IT Tralee are very unhappy with the CIT domination of the merger.

Harry Palmr · 21-04-2021 8:43pm

Can only hope that ITC staff feel likewise next year.

SeanieW1977 · 21-04-2021 8:44pm

Harry Palmr wrote: »

Blimey it's a bit of grudge for you! And you're guessing of course so maybe not the best approach.

Just sick of the same crap from the same people in waterford & people scratch their heads wondering why we don’t achieve anything by comparison to other cities.

That said, this waterford 2040 video by the council is top class - Michael Walsh is a fair operator , has to be said

22-04-2021 7:04am

imacman wrote: »

No far from it , I know some staff in CIT and the merger has been a shambles with loads of IR issues and fudges. Things have remained the same on the ground in CIT with just a rebadge in place and the staff in IT Tralee are very unhappy with the CIT domination of the merger.

That is what I expected therefore how will the TUSE be any different. It is as simple as our TDs looking at MTU and DTU, if they honestly TUSE will be any different they are delusional

curmudgeonly · 22-04-2021 9:14am

SeanieW1977 wrote: »

Just sick of the same crap from the same people in waterford & people scratch their heads wondering why we don’t achieve anything by comparison to other cities.

That said, this waterford 2040 video by the council is top class - Michael Walsh is a fair operator , has to be said

From that statement can I assume you are going to take a leading role in the near future ,or are you just hurling from the ditch as normal?

imacman · 22-04-2021 10:01am

914 wrote: »

That is what I expected therefore how will the TUSE be any different. It is as simple as our TDs looking at MTU and DTU, if they honestly TUSE will be any different they are delusional

It wont be , it will play out like this ,

Application goes in at the end of April

International panel reviews it and gives their opinion

Minister grants TU status ( as we have seen from MTU a negative review from the panel makes no difference to that )

We become a merged TU in the 1st of January 2022 Local Tds tell us to "trust the process" and it will be alright on the night.

Cue lost of bull**** celebrations with TDs and the likes of IBEC telling us this is a "gamechanger for the southeast"

The attention moves away and both institutes are left with massive IR problems , infighting and distrust as has been the case over the last 5 years .

WIT is the victim of an ITCarlow campaign to lessen its influence supported by the government.

Headquarters is decided by new board to be set up outside Waterford . Local tds tell us its good for the region and WIT is not being sidelined.

If there is any questioning the TU post launch , those people are told they need to become a team player and its all good for the region .

Funding promises are not kept by the government but campuses get built in Wexford and Kilkenny anyway . WIT gets a new engineering building promised since 2009 , local tds tell us this is a vote of confidence in WIT

WIT declines as its staff become disillusioned and the TU turns out to be a lesser orgainisation than WIT was before the merger .

We are told by local Tds to trust the process and it will all work out
We are told by local Tds to trust the process and it will all work out
We are told by local Tds to trust the process and it will all work out
We are told by local Tds to trudt the process and it will all work out

BBM77 · 22-04-2021 11:04am

imacman wrote: »

It wont be , it will play out like this ,

Application goes in at the end of April

International panel reviews it and gives their opinion

Minister grants TU status ( as we have seen from MTU a negative review from the panel makes no difference to that )

We become a merged TU in the 1st of January 2022 Local Tds tell us to "trust the process" and it will be alright on the night.

Cue lost of bull**** celebrations with TDs and the likes of IBEC telling us this is a "gamechanger for the southeast"

The attention moves away and both institutes are left with massive IR problems , infighting and distrust as has been the case over the last 5 years .

WIT is the victim of an ITCarlow campaign to lessen its influence supported by the government.

Headquarters is decided by new board to be set up outside Waterford . Local tds tell us its good for the region and WIT is not being sidelined.

If there is any questioning the TU post launch , those people are told they need to become a team player and its all good for the region .

Funding promises are not kept by the government but campuses get built in Wexford and Kilkenny anyway . WIT gets a new engineering building promised since 2009 , local tds tell us this is a vote of confidence in WIT

WIT declines as its staff become disillusioned and the TU turns out to be a lesser orgainisation than WIT was before the merger .

We are told by local Tds to trust the process and it will all work out
We are told by local Tds to trust the process and it will all work out
We are told by local Tds to trust the process and it will all work out
We are told by local Tds to trudt the process and it will all work out

Who is the international panel? Is it a true independent review? Could they recommend WIT be upgraded on its own?

Or is it just a BS in BS out panel?

imacman · 22-04-2021 12:30pm

BBM77 wrote: »

Who is the international panel? Is it a true independent review? Could they recommend WIT be upgraded on its own?

Or is it just a BS in BS out panel?

The international panel are a group of academics form the UK and Europe who review the TU applications. The report they did on MTU was an interesting read , they questioned the whole project and its preparation and planning .They also said they thought it lacked vision and efforts to make staff buyin to the project was severely lacking.

They couldn't recommend the it to go forward until a list of changes and targets were reached. The HEA themselves said it was a 2-3 year project to reach those targets but the minister had rubber stamped the merger 6 months after the report and it came to existence 4 months later .The panel were never invited back to check if the targets they had set down had been reached , its all got swept under the carpet as the MTU was a "game changer" for Munster.

Those academics on the panel must be a a bit embarrassed that their reports are getting ignored but I'm sure the massive pay they are getting helps them get over it

Bards · 23-04-2021 9:56am

imacman wrote: »

It wont be , it will play out like this ,

Application goes in at the end of April

International panel reviews it and gives their opinion

Minister grants TU status ( as we have seen from MTU a negative review from the panel makes no difference to that )

We become a merged TU in the 1st of January 2022 Local Tds tell us to "trust the process" and it will be alright on the night.

Cue lost of bull**** celebrations with TDs and the likes of IBEC telling us this is a "gamechanger for the southeast"

The attention moves away and both institutes are left with massive IR problems , infighting and distrust as has been the case over the last 5 years .

WIT is the victim of an ITCarlow campaign to lessen its influence supported by the government.

Headquarters is decided by new board to be set up outside Waterford . Local tds tell us its good for the region and WIT is not being sidelined.

If there is any questioning the TU post launch , those people are told they need to become a team player and its all good for the region .

Funding promises are not kept by the government but campuses get built in Wexford and Kilkenny anyway . WIT gets a new engineering building promised since 2009 , local tds tell us this is a vote of confidence in WIT

WIT declines as its staff become disillusioned and the TU turns out to be a lesser orgainisation than WIT was before the merger .

We are told by local Tds to trust the process and it will all work out
We are told by local Tds to trust the process and it will all work out
We are told by local Tds to trust the process and it will all work out
We are told by local Tds to trudt the process and it will all work out

In 10 years time when FG and FF return to Government all the best courses such as Computing and Business will be moved to Wexford and Carlow.. Kilkenny will get the arts school and the only thing left in Waterford will be anything to do with trades.

This is how WIT will be carved up over the next decade or so all in the name of (Waterford must share the spoils) TUSE

SeanieW1977 · 23-04-2021 10:07am

Bards wrote: »

In 10 years time when FG and FF return to Government all the best courses such as Computing and Business will be moved to Wexford and Carlow.. Kilkenny will get the arts school and the only thing left in Waterford will be anything to do with trades.

This is how WIT will be carved up over the next decade or so all in the name of (Waterford must share the spoils) TUSE

as a result Waterford people will vote in sinn fein en masse - sinn fein of course who had the perfect opportuntity to oppose this but didnt

why?

Anything to do with cullinanes former wife & kids being up in Carlow?

Hardly? (genuinely asking)

Can anyone explain to me why the biggest opposition party so badly badly let down the waterford people on this huge issue? Does it suit them for the place to fall to sihte (even more) ?

BBM77 · 23-04-2021 10:58am

Bards wrote: »

In 10 years time when FG and FF return to Government all the best courses such as Computing and Business will be moved to Wexford and Carlow.. Kilkenny will get the arts school and the only thing left in Waterford will be anything to do with trades.

This is how WIT will be carved up over the next decade or so all in the name of (Waterford must share the spoils) TUSE

Sums up how I always felt about the TUSE "process".

Muttley79 · 23-04-2021 5:17pm

https://waterford-news.ie/2021/04/23/wit-staff-reject-tuse-mou/
Hopefully the staff hold firm

Bards · 23-04-2021 5:33pm

Muttley79 wrote: »

https://waterford-news.ie/2021/04/23/wit-staff-reject-tuse-mou/
Hopefully the staff hold firm

SF need to come out now and promise to implement the Port report in Full.. Carlow IT can be TUSE

SeanieW1977 · 23-04-2021 5:38pm

sinn fein need to get the lead out - University of Waterford must be the goal now

they are too complicit with govt on this issue

Harry Palmr · 23-04-2021 5:56pm

Minister Harris will dismiss this with the wave of a hand as the poll is so low and the margin small enough

azimuth17 · 23-04-2021 6:08pm

Harry Palmr wrote: »

Minister Harris will dismiss this with the wave of a hand as the poll is so low and the margin small enough

What's the betting that David Cullinane, Mary Butler, Marc O Cathasaigh and John Cummins all do the same thing? Minister couldn't be bothered to even come to Waterford to explain his position. Crass.

Harry Palmr · 23-04-2021 6:10pm

Alas that's almost certain, one of that gutless quartet needs to clear their throat and address why this has happened rather than pretend it's not important.

Christy Browne · 23-04-2021 6:15pm

https://twitter.com/SeanDefoe/status/1385641520062156806?s=20

Already happening I'm afraid. Will our politicians speak up? Bar Shanahan, fat chance

Edit: Butler has commented:

https://twitter.com/marybutlertd/status/1385645935695470594?s=21
And Cummins at the start of this video:

https://www.facebook.com/johncumminswaterford/videos/1334902036903700/

SeanieW1977 · 23-04-2021 6:15pm

Harry Palmr wrote: »

Alas that's almost certain, one of that gutless quartet needs to clear their throat and address why this has happened rather than pretend it's not important.

What about this FUSE campaign ?

Sure their closing statement was to tell us all to trust the process (& matt is a great fella!)

The Staff in WIT clearly dont trust the process - how much a finger on the pulse did they have!

Govt cannot be let force this through.

curmudgeonly · 23-04-2021 7:18pm

SeanieW1977 wrote: »

What about this FUSE campaign ?

Sure their closing statement was to tell us all to trust the process (& matt is a great fella!)

The Staff in WIT clearly dont trust the process - how much a finger on the pulse did they have!

Govt cannot be let force this through.

Seanie me darling you obviously have not read the attached.

spaceCreated · 23-04-2021 8:53pm

Christy Browne wrote: »

https://twitter.com/SeanDefoe/status/1385641520062156806?s=20

Already happening I'm afraid. Will our politicians speak up? Bar Shanahan, fat chance

Edit: Butler has commented:

https://twitter.com/marybutlertd/status/1385645935695470594?s=21
And Cummins at the start of this video:

https://www.facebook.com/johncumminswaterford/videos/1334902036903700/

Mary Butler would make blood boil, where is the engineering building she promised a few months ago, where is the 24/7 cardiac care. If she could deliver anything she promised she might have some credibility.

Its like a child turning up without homework for 6 years in a row but saying they know whats on the test next week.

BBM77 · 23-04-2021 9:45pm

Who knows what is going to happen now? However, top marks to the TUI members for voting against this sham of a process. At least somebody has said no.

SeanieW1977 · 23-04-2021 9:46pm

curmudgeonly wrote: »

Seanie me darling you obviously have not read the attached.

What did this crowd achieve?

Nothing. A total talking shop full of the usual suspects. Trust the process!

Imagine after 10+ years of TU the best they can come up with is trust the process

“Is there anything to be said for another mass” springs to mind

23-04-2021 9:49pm

azimuth17 wrote: »

What's the betting that David Cullinane, Mary Butler, Marc O Cathasaigh and John Cummins all do the same thing? Minister couldn't be bothered to even come to Waterford to explain his position. Crass.

Surely after 100 odd years,its obvious to all they want to downgrade waterford

Why would they risk coming here to sell a potential positive

Waterford University discussion

Comments