Werewolf: HBO's Deadwood

Drumpot wrote: »

I missed the goal being cancelled. When city got the fifth I turned tv off and went up to the kids. Just seeing it now....

Sorry Guys.

Katie WW wrote: »

There are lies. There are more than 3 unaccounted for. If Mary is good then someone on the NRV list is a wolf.

I’m sol star. Nrv. Believe me. Don’t believe me. But I am sol.

Look back on my posts. Yes I haven’t been as active but ye are a tough crowd. I missed GR1 and despite trying to get involved I was ignored. I tried, but the usual suspects have been involved every other game. Which makes it hard to get involved or give an opportunity to prove my innocence.

Like I said, take me at face value or don’t. I played a **** game, but I am NRV.

Katie who do you suspect as being a wolf and why?

Also you or anyone any ideas how the wolves won GR1 earlier? My other theory I realised doesn’t make sense, I’m really stumped on that one

Katie WW wrote: »

Tbh I don’t see how Gertie is cleared. She is suspicious to me.

Ellsworth was alive at the time. Wolves won GR1 on day 1. Wolves won GR2 on day 1 also and a message said “no gold was found” meaning they blocked the village from winning. Brendan won GR1 on day 2 and we got the message saying “some gold has been found” the same message that happened when Gertie won GR2 that day.

No we didn’t see her prize in game but that’s like saying Brendan getting the same one today means he didn’t win. Nobody else has claimed that prize so in my books Gertie is 100% cleared.

Note: I may have mixed up which GR they won but it’s not relevant to the point I’m trying to make

Desmond WW wrote: »

Be mad if I’d actually peeked you and had a reveal planned for pre munch.

Awh don’t be cryptic now Des :pac:

Today has absolutely fried my brain. Throwing this out before munch tomorrow as I won’t have time in the morning.

GR1

1. Gertie (blocked) By wolf 1
2. Desmond (blocked) By me
3. Brendan (blocked) By wolf 2
4. Mary (won)/(blocked) By/is wolf 3
5. Holly (won)

Literally makes no sense Mary being good? There’s not enough wolves and wouldn’t make sense for them to give it to Holly who in turn wouldn’t use it to kill Phil. We’re missing something big here but I can’t work it out.

GR2

1. Brendan
2. Desmond
3. Gertie
4. Steve

I only realised now Brendan was 1st so the wolves didn’t block this time. Why is that?

I’m going down another rabbit hole and we all know how that turned out earlier. The only explanation I can come up with is either we got the OP wrong and Cy peeks good twice and on the third day peeks bad? Clutching at straws here because the alternative is Des isn’t the seer, the real seer was Gertie and lost her role due to Alice and for some reason can’t talk about it, they sacrificed Tegan as she hadn’t been very active anyway and that would clear them her flipping bad. Des claims Mary is good and that’s them both safe.

That just doesn’t make sense though

If the wolves munch Joanie tomorrow they get another kill. We need to win GR tomorrow and hopefully get a bullet somewhere but we need to be 100% sure we’re targetting the right people. If we get it wrong tomorrow the wolves will have us the following day with another munch and beat down

Abigail WW wrote: »

Gertie won a prize when wolves couldn’t
Brendan also did this and we saw his claimed extra lynch votes in action
Des has not been counter claimed
Mary was cleared by Des twice


Who is most likely to be lying out of those 4 and whose interactions with Katie suggest a possible team?

I know the meer suggestion could get people to rally against me but could a prize be a fake role reveal upon death or something similar. Make the Seer appear as something else (day a NRV to explain the excess) and then “peek” your team mate good.

I know that might not be the most likely explanation but 1 of those 4 have to be lying, can’t see how it’s Gertie or Brendan given when they won their first prizes and Des clears himself and Mary as seer

If I don’t get munched I am voting for Katie today and picking number 3 in both gold rushes.

Not up for debate. I suggest Brendan and one other you know is safe goes number 1 and 2. If I get the gold I kill Katie if a bullet, if I don’t 1 or 2 gets the gold.

If I’m a wolf, and only the wolves know I’m not, then we know that about Abigail is good and useful still so she dies.

Gertrude WW wrote: »

If I don’t get munched I am voting for Katie today and picking number 3 in both gold rushes.

Not up for debate. I suggest Brendan and one other you know is safe goes number 1 and 2. If I get the gold I kill Katie if a bullet, if I don’t 1 or 2 gets the gold.

If I’m a wolf, and only the wolves know I’m not, then we know that about Abigail is good and useful still so she dies.

You and Brendan have to be 2 and 3. No way to manipulate. If a wolf is 1 we’ll know for a fact and know who we’re lynching later.

I feel like we’re going to learn a lot from the munch this morning so it should be interesting. I’m working 10-7 today. I’m going to try work my lunch and break around that so I can make it to the GR but won’t be able to confirm until I take it unfortunately. Will definitely be on for the lynch and will give my thoughts when I’m on my lunch.

Good luck everyone

Steve WW wrote: »

Just seen this, I don’t get this line of thinking though. Why do people think she is a wolf when she won a prize and nobody thinks Brendan is?

In my eyes those two are 100% good and if Gertie turns out to be a wolf I give up :pac:

I suppose we seen Brendans prize he won, never seen Gerties was my logic!

Steve WW wrote: »

I get that but Brendan won the same prize yesterday and I’m assuming with the role blocks they don’t tell us on thread so does that mean he didn’t win it either? I think he did I’m just trying to make a point that with the information we have regarding Ellsworth and the wolves block on winning we need to view them both the same

I'm on the level, so who won the Goldrush yesterday in slots 1-4 where Mary, Des, Gertie and Brendan, one of them won and didn't say a word

Do you have any other info for us Des, share it at 9.59 if so?

Thinking about it last night there were two other ways wolves could win the prize:

- double up on votes and possibly a tie? Eg everybody accidentally voted for more then one number and a tie meant highest number with people won a prize. Possible , but is it likely?

- after the SK died day 1 the prize dynamics changed (as SK was supposed to be in with a shout of winning) allowing wolves to win which would explain Brendan and Gertie being able to win but that would of made Ellsworths role redundant. I don’t want to go down rabbit holes too much but this would explain a lot.

Has anybody got any non gold rush theories to run through?

Morning everyone, a little surprised to still be alive. Sorry about last night, when tegan claimed I knew I’d no time to defend myself and figured enough players doubted me that they’d switch to make sure they kept the option open. I think I’m doing so I didn’t help the village though so sorry

Today gr has to use uncountered role claimants. We can’t give wolves a shot at prizes. Only way I can see yesterday’s events is there was a wolf in the top 3 numbers. Des is clear so that leaves Gertie and/or Brendan as wolves. If Gertie insists otherwise that’s not village play. 2 wolves left, it’s gonna be tight

Best of luck Des

Brendan WW wrote: »

Went on a solo run last night because youse fools weren't helping.

Blocked Abigail which will take effect from 10am

And if Abi is the BG I’m dead!!!

Why no you or Joanie des? They must not believe you’re the seer