Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Derry WW wrote: »

I feel as if I was going to send a secret message to other wolves, it would be something a whole lot more subtle than what I posted tbh. That post was posted shortly after I found out I was hospitalized, but before I knew others were too. In that context, does it make more sense to you?

For what its worth, I'm not buying Dessie's stuff bout you, and I'd think Wendy's story stinks a whole lot more than yours.

Reading back over your previous posts, another thing I saw you mention was the bit about there being some interesting "Thanks". I'd say that was more a reference to someone, not saying who, accidently thanking a post with their mask a little loose :pac:

That’s fair enough Dessie...

A part of me interpreted your message as a note to the sk. Sort of “rememeber you can wait until wolves kill at 10 so you don’t need to risk overlap” but I’ve been down enough rabbit holes the last month to not want to explore that any further..

As I said I looked through Mary’s posts and tried to find things and since you have been such a big part of the village I thought it important to probe you properly.

I’m ok with that, but I think Dessie has some answering to do.

Steve WW wrote: »

Much earlier trip this time tho

Has the same info where you know the others in the hospital been sent to you?

Orla WW wrote: »

So if I asked you to FFA/do a readslist right now (I don't recall you doing one prior to this), how would it look?

Same question to everyone who didn't FFA/provide reads last night actually.

How did you come to a decision to make your vote?

This is a good point. We have 15 players who didn’t give ffas. Would be nice if they could explain how the came up with their vote given there seems to be plenty of independent though in last nights votes

Orla WW wrote: »

So if I asked you to FFA/do a readslist right now (I don't recall you doing one prior to this), how would it look?

Same question to everyone who didn't FFA/provide reads last night actually.

How did you come to a decision to make your vote?

I’ve given plenty of explanation on why I voted Derry and who the people are whom I focused on. I posted an extensive list of notes you can see a page back...

People who interacted with Mary who I found suspect include you as you just made jokes and didn’t help her in anyway as she was trying to figure out the quiz. Possibly a good way to look like you are no threat to her? maybe, maybe not. Day zero banter under normal circumstances but it wasn’t a normal day zero.

That’s a rabbit hole I will leave for others cause I’m determined not to fall into a trap that got me at last village. It’s also a very weak piece of information so I would only remember it if relevant later.

Dessie is going top of my list. Him going at me forced me to look at him closer and I think whatever mistake I made he has a fair bit of answering to do.

Doris actually accused Mary of being a wolf and had a bit of a tit for tat so maybe I would be looking at that.

I missed a lot of the later afternoons drama so am not really up to speed for reading players purposes. I have a general idea of what happened but wanted to get my Mary notes down when Dessie tunneled in on my Jeff was wolf error.

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Anyone who doesn't post FFA again today and who doesn't really start at other players will be going to the top of my suspect pile.

Also I find it very interesting that three of the people who voted to lynch Katie (Brendan, Gertrude and Wendy) didn't sumbit an FFA, while Derry voted for her despite not putting her on his FFA.
I'll be reading a lot in your posts today.

While reading my posts im sure you will come across my ffa... actually my fault i may not have tagged it.

I had gab des and katie with katie being the only one i had solid reasoning for.

Christ the coffee hasn't kicked in yet



Correction:

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Anyone who doesn't post FFA again today and who doesn't really start at state their feelings about other players will be going to the top of my suspect pile.

So i think the SK could work thusly:

He nominates 4 people for hospital before munch.

He can kill one of them later in the day any time between munch and lynch.

He then nominates a replacement for the person he killed the following munch.

If it is that, it would clear those people of being the sk (but not of being wolves).

Only caveat is that I think OP says SK can kill munch to munch?

BG protection MIGHT be 24 hrs that way then. Nominate at lynch, protect till next lynch...?

Gabriel WW wrote: »

So i think the SK could work thusly:

He nominates 4 people for hospital before munch.

He can kill one of them later in the day any time between munch and lynch.

He then nominates a replacement for the person he killed the following munch.

But didn’t Derry already confirm he’s out?

Derry WW wrote: »

Of note, I've not been told I'm out of hospital, 25 hours latter.

Too busy in the backroom :pac:

Orla WW wrote: »

Only caveat is that I think OP says SK can kill munch to munch?

BG protection MIGHT be 24 hrs that way then. Nominate at lynch, protect till next lynch...?

Ah ok munch to munch then. Doesnt make much difference to how i laid it out.

Tegan WW wrote: »

Who said they are all telling the truth. Some could be lying to clear themselves

The only way that would pan out is if they are ALL wolves.

The CC'ing thing yesterday indicates they all verified each other were in hospital.

Abigail WW wrote: »

Did anyone get release papers? maybe it just doesn't happen but if the other 2 living that were hospitalized yesterday could say if they did that could clear it up.

I don't think it's a good idea for people to reveal if they've been released. The SK may not know who's been released either.

Orla WW wrote: »

Well, there's another way people can be killed of being the SK if that's the case then.

The Jailer.

But let's not go into that too much.

Derp, cleared of being SK, not killed :cool:

Ah.

What worries me there, then, is Wendy was obviously someone they thought was rolled, if they took two swings at her