Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Abigail WW · 18-09-2018 10:56am

Riona WW wrote: »

Did not think it (clarification) was needed given the post I responded to but I was likening her NRV claim to claiming to be Spartacus. Does not mean you are him. Apparently I spelt it wrong.

I don't see any mention of the wolves having a gun. Maybe they do but hopefully thats our Vig in play. Not sure why Tegan though?

Gabriel WW · 18-09-2018 10:56am

Isla WW wrote: »

It must be.

That clears up the tinfoil theory I had in my mind

Only other thing i can see is that our vig was blackmailed into shooting tegan.

But for that to be true, the wolves would have to a) be super lucky to pick the vig or b) have found the vig via a peek (again super lucky).

Id be inclined to think its the vig.

I would suggest vig needs to declare who he is shooting before his next shot, to verify himsefl.

Orla WW · 18-09-2018 10:58am

WerewolfGM wrote: »

Tegan WW was shot dead

Abigail WW · 18-09-2018 10:58am

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Only other thing i can see is that our vig was blackmailed into shooting tegan.

But for that to be true, the wolves would have to a) be super lucky to pick the vig or b) have found the vig via a peek (again super lucky).

Id be inclined to think its the vig.

I would suggest vig needs to declare who he is shooting before his next shot, to verify himsefl.

I would not suggest our vig out himself next time he plans to shoot if thats what your suggesting.

Riona WW · 18-09-2018 11:01am

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Only other thing i can see is that our vig was blackmailed into shooting tegan.

But for that to be true, the wolves would have to a) be super lucky to pick the vig or b) have found the vig via a peek (again super lucky).

Id be inclined to think its the vig.

I would suggest vig needs to declare who he is shooting before his next shot, to verify himsefl.

Hmmm, if the Vig only has one more bullet and they have a target it’s no hard in coming out before taking a shot. Effectively an nrv once shot is taken..

Unless of course they come out and then the baddies/sk knows who they are and can either kill (sk can kill anytime) or use a power (blackmail)...

So no I don’t think Vig should come out...

Gabriel WW · 18-09-2018 11:01am

Abigail WW wrote: »

I would not suggest our vig out himself next time he plans to shoot if thats what your suggesting.

He has 1 bullet left, after which he will be an unverifyable NRV.

Declare immediately before shooting, then we have a verified NRV.

Orla WW · 18-09-2018 11:01am

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Only other thing i can see is that our vig was blackmailed into shooting tegan.

But for that to be true, the wolves would have to a) be super lucky to pick the vig or b) have found the vig via a peek (again super lucky).

Id be inclined to think its the vig.

I would suggest vig needs to declare who he is shooting before his next shot, to verify himsefl.

One issue with that. Watson still has the heal power so he shouldn't come out unless he's used it.

I'm struggling to see why Tegan though?

Riona WW · 18-09-2018 11:02am

Orla WW wrote: »

One issue with that. Watson still has the heal power so he shouldn't come out unless he's used it.

I'm struggling to see why Tegan though?

Unless Mary was Watson....

Isla WW · 18-09-2018 11:02am

Gabriel WW wrote: »

He has 1 bullet left, after which he will be an unverifyable NRV.

Declare immediately before shooting, then we have a verified NRV.

On second thought that makes sense too. I was thinking of him being a traditional vig

Gabriel WW · 18-09-2018 11:02am

Orla WW wrote: »

One issue with that. Watson still has the heal power so he shouldn't come out unless he's used it.

I'm struggling to see why Tegan though?

Thats fair enough. Hold on to the bullet until after they use the heal (unless its a repeat power).

Abigail WW · 18-09-2018 11:02am

Gabriel WW wrote: »

He has 1 bullet left, after which he will be an unverifyable NRV.

Declare immediately before shooting, then we have a verified NRV.

He also has the ability to heal.

Isla WW · 18-09-2018 11:03am

But i forgot about the heal, so disregard lol

Orla WW · 18-09-2018 11:03am

Dr. John Watson – He is a crack shot, heralding from his long years in Afghanistan, alongside his 2 bullets he also has the ability to heal.

Yeah I think Watson should stay hidden.

Riona WW · 18-09-2018 11:04am

Riona WW wrote: »

Unless Mary was Watson....

Woops I forgot Watson is Vig and can heal... I thought Mary was claiming Watson just before dieing....

Riona WW · 18-09-2018 11:05am

Abigail WW wrote: »

He also has the ability to heal.

So why not heal somebody the wolves kill? Not himself

Gabriel WW · 18-09-2018 11:05am

I think we can all agree Watson should stay hidden then. He can pop off his next shot whenever he wants, and maybe use his heal to verify himself. Only he will know if that works or not though.

Barbara WW · 18-09-2018 11:06am

Gabriel WW wrote: »

He has 1 bullet left, after which he will be an unverifyable NRV.

Declare immediately before shooting, then we have a verified NRV.

He can heal too. He’s not an nrv after he shoots. Anyone asking him to reveal either hasn’t read the op or is dodgy

Gabriel WW · 18-09-2018 11:06am

Riona WW wrote: »

So why not heal somebody the wolves kill? Not himself

I would imagine maybe the heal power is tied to the hospitalisation? I also doubt its a repeat power - so he would want to be sure about who he is healing, i should imagine.

Riona WW · 18-09-2018 11:07am

Riona WW wrote: »

So why not heal somebody the wolves kill? Not himself

Shoot somebody later and heal maybe tomorrows kill and come out at 9.59??

Gabriel WW · 18-09-2018 11:08am

Riona WW wrote: »

Shoot somebody later and heal maybe tomorrows kill and come out at 9.59??

If only he and the healed knows who was healed, then that will work.

Riona WW · 18-09-2018 11:08am

Gabriel WW wrote: »

I would imagine maybe the heal power is tied to the hospitalisation? I also doubt its a repeat power - so he would want to be sure about who he is healing, i should imagine.

Maybe but it doesn’t seem like much of a power does it? Nothing really happens in the hospital.....

Orla WW · 18-09-2018 11:08am

Ok folks, can we come to some sort of compromise on FFAs/readslists today? Clearly people don't agree with my method so I'm not going to force it.

Whatever the format, I'd prefer more involvement in any form.

Gabriel WW · 18-09-2018 11:09am

Orla WW wrote: »

Ok folks, can we come to some sort of compromise on FFAs/readslists today? Clearly people don't agree with my method so I'm not going to force it.

Whatever the format, I'd prefer more involvement in any form.

What i would like is for everyone to commit to an FFA by 6pm.

If you want to give extended read lists along the way as well, then great.

Barbara WW · 18-09-2018 11:10am

Riona WW wrote: »

Hmmm, if the Vig only has one more bullet and they have a target it’s no hard in coming out before taking a shot. Effectively an nrv once shot is taken..

Unless of course they come out and then the baddies/sk knows who they are and can either kill (sk can kill anytime) or use a power (blackmail)...

So no I don’t think Vig should come out...

Can you explain what you’re trying to say here. Two issues I have I) blackmailing an nrv? Why exactly? II) did you read Watson’s role?

Barbara WW · 18-09-2018 11:12am

Riona WW wrote: »

So why not heal somebody the wolves kill? Not himself

Or, you know, stay hidden and use the heal as a second bodyguard later in the game if we have power roles to protect?

Doris WW · 18-09-2018 11:13am

Riona WW wrote: »

This interaction

The insinuation is that Mary is discussing it in a backroom and that’s why her google brought up 2 results for the clue.

Nope.

I was curious as to why i was getting one hit and others getting more. Then it was suggested that my search settings were not wide enough.

Riona WW · 18-09-2018 11:13am

Gabriel WW wrote: »

If only he and the healed knows who was healed, then that will work.

I mean he comes out at 9.59 so wolves won’t have time to change their chosen victim. Then he immediately heals the person the wolves munched. We know at least that munched person isn’t a wolf and have another confirmed villager in Watson. If wolves try to double bluff it would go bad if Watson hadn’t healed and he is effectively an nrv at that stage so it would be confirming a wolf..

Gabriel WW · 18-09-2018 11:16am

Riona WW wrote: »

I mean he comes out at 9.59 so wolves won’t have time to change their chosen victim. Then he immediately heals the person the wolves munched. We know at least that munched person isn’t a wolf and have another confirmed villager in Watson. If wolves try to double bluff it would go bad if Watson hadn’t healed and he is effectively an nrv at that stage so it would be confirming a wolf..

I think the play is to let the vig stay hidden for now.

Doris WW · 18-09-2018 11:16am

Vig stays hidden until needed, then declares who he is before they take the shot.

No point coming out until needed of definite outing of a wolf

Isla WW · 18-09-2018 11:17am

Riona WW wrote: »

Maybe but it doesn’t seem like much of a power does it? Nothing really happens in the hospital.....

Well Frank was in the hospital yesterday and he died.

So serial killer brings 4 people to hospital, kills 1 and then picks 4 new people.

1 of us probably going to die at the serial killers hands, so if Watson can heal in the hospital, maybe he can save someone from being sk'ed

Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Comments