Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi all! We have been experiencing an issue on site where threads have been missing the latest postings. The platform host Vanilla are working on this issue. A workaround that has been used by some is to navigate back from 1 to 10+ pages to re-sync the thread and this will then show the latest posts. Thanks, Mike.
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Ireland De-Facto Visa

2456712

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,315 ✭✭✭ballooba


    If you can get a job offer it will greatly enhance your chances in my opinion. As for sending in your passport, a decent quality colour copy should be legible? or is the page completely illegible anyway?


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    I sent in a decent copy but the stamp was obviously out of ink that day.... it is extremely faint!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,315 ✭✭✭ballooba


    Try turning up the contrast on a black & white copier. Although photocopying an already faint stamp might bleach it further.


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    sophie4187 wrote: »
    Got letter from INIS in the mail, requesting for a clearer copy of a page in my passport, as well as evidence of all finances available to me (i.e. 6 month bank statements, payslips, etc.)

    I'm confused about the latter, as we sent in a copy of my partner's bank statement, our joint bank statement, as well as my bank statement from the United States. We also included my partner's most recent payslips. I don't have any payslips, as the times I have been here in Ireland, I have not been legally able to work. When I was on my Working Holiday Visa, I was also unable to find work, so I don't have any payslips for myself.

    My partner makes 1200 every 2 weeks and has been supporting me each time I've stayed here.

    Should I just send in bank statements from further back, as well as more payslips from my partner?

    Also, about my passport - it says if the page is hard to read, I'll need to send it in, via registered post, which is fine, however - I have a trip booked to the UK on the 3-5 of November, which I'll need my passport for. Do you think I'll get it back in time?

    Maybe you need to get a relative to put some money in your account, print off a statement and you can send it back to them when you have resubmitted the details to GNIB.

    Try and copy your passport again. I looked at every page I photocopied to make sure it was legible before I posted the app out. Some of the stamps I get in Ireland are ridiculous as they are faded when they stamp it at the airport. Itineraries are handy to reconcile your trips so they can match it with the stamp on your passport. You should have rang them up today (you will have to try again next Thursday) and explain your situation about your UK trip. You should have photocopies of your passport when you travel anyway. The other option is to go up to Burgh Quay and get them to photocopy it there and you will have your passport back.


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    Ya, I thought about having my mom or dad put some money in as my US account doesn't have much in it at all since I use our joint account here.... but won't it look odd with the big amount of money going in?

    About the passport.... I got the letter requesting the other things today, after the helpline had already closed - OF COURSE! I also looked and made sure everything was legible but the stamp was completely faded so I didn't know what to do, so I sent as is.

    Going through all my partner's payslips of the last 6 months and sending them in; along with bank statements from 6 months until now - that's all I can do. I put in the letter that since I am not allowed to work, my partner has been supporting me. I am just unclear as to how I would be making money and adding to my US account if I can't work.

    Trusting everything should be fine when I mail everything back in! Thanks for all the suggestions and help.


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    I got my letter today confirming that I have received a Stamp 4 for 12 months massive relief.
    sophie4187 wrote: »
    Ya, I thought about having my mom or dad put some money in as my US account doesn't have much in it at all since I use our joint account here.... but won't it look odd with the big amount of money going in?

    About the passport.... I got the letter requesting the other things today, after the helpline had already closed - OF COURSE! I also looked and made sure everything was legible but the stamp was completely faded so I didn't know what to do, so I sent as is.

    Going through all my partner's payslips of the last 6 months and sending them in; along with bank statements from 6 months until now - that's all I can do. I put in the letter that since I am not allowed to work, my partner has been supporting me. I am just unclear as to how I would be making money and adding to my US account if I can't work.

    Trusting everything should be fine when I mail everything back in! Thanks for all the suggestions and help.

    A lot of people I know get family members to transfer money in to their account for visa apps. Just as long as it's not a lump sum and it's seeking permission to remain so have to prove that you aren't relient on the state. Do you have VHI or other private insurance cover? That's important too. They should have told you in writing why they are querying your finances, the people at the help desk don't give much away on the phone. I sent in my bank statements from Australia as I had been working there recently.

    If you don't get a response back by Nov 3 you will have to go up to Burgh Quay to get your passport back.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,315 ✭✭✭ballooba


    FalconXV wrote: »
    I got my letter today confirming that I have received a Stamp 4 for 12 months massive relief.
    Congratulations. Your next challenge is to get the physical stamp (and your GNIB card?). You've already had a Stamp 3, so you're familiar with the process?


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    ballooba wrote: »
    Congratulations. Your next challenge is to get the physical stamp (and your GNIB card?). You've already had a Stamp 3, so you're familiar with the process?

    Thanks. Yeah have to wait till the immigration gard is on duty. She works random hours. It will be my fourth GNIB card in the space of 2 years. 150 Euro a pop nice money raising (at least the actual application only cost the price of postage. Australia charges a grand for the similar visa).


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,315 ✭✭✭ballooba


    FalconXV wrote: »
    (at least the actual application only cost the price of postage. Australia charges a grand for the similar visa).
    At least you get what you pay for in Aus. ;)


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    Well maybe. Lad I went to school with waited 6 months for a Fiancee visa for his Scottish lass. Talk about torture. Lucky he was over in Aus working so they didn't have to find a place to live.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,315 ✭✭✭ballooba


    FalconXV wrote: »
    Well maybe. Lad I went to school with waited 6 months for a Fiancee visa for his Scottish lass. Talk about torture. Lucky he was over in Aus working so they didn't have to find a place to live.
    I haven't gone the de-facto route in Aus yet, but have had three separate visas and it's nice to be able to pick up the phone and talk to someone.:D I need to get the finger out and do the de-facto application soon, start chipping away away at the probationary period. I've heard the application is no picnic.


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    FalconXV wrote: »
    I got my letter today confirming that I have received a Stamp 4 for 12 months massive relief.



    A lot of people I know get family members to transfer money in to their account for visa apps. Just as long as it's not a lump sum and it's seeking permission to remain so have to prove that you aren't relient on the state. Do you have VHI or other private insurance cover? That's important too. They should have told you in writing why they are querying your finances, the people at the help desk don't give much away on the phone. I sent in my bank statements from Australia as I had been working there recently.

    If you don't get a response back by Nov 3 you will have to go up to Burgh Quay to get your passport back.


    Congrats! Must be a huge relieft. I am hoping once all this stuff gets mailed in on Monday that it'll be good enough. I do have private medical insurance from the states that will cover me here in Ireland. I sent in a letter from them stating that.

    I have no clue why they are querying about my finances. We sent in our joint bank statement which I have access to, as well as my savings account in the US (which has very little since I don't use it), and my partner's Irish account, in which I use as well. We're not rich by any means but we also have a bit. My partner is a teacher, so has a steady income. I sent in 6 months of payslips from her job. As for me, no jobs available here in tiny ol' Clare while I was on a Working Holiday.

    Fingers crossed!


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    Australian visas are tough. The 9 months to get married fiancee visa puts a lot of pressure on couples and their families and friends. Thankfully I don't have to go down that road. Anyone who hasn't applied yet should do so soon otherwise it's getting closer to Christmas where Government staff take time off which can delay responses. TD's do too and in cases like these you might need their assistance. To save hassle get it in coherent order and include future plans for you and your partner in Ireland so you give them no reason to write back to you asking for more information. In a way you have to show that you want to stay in Ireland long term rather than using it to stay for a couple of years before shifting off elsewhere.
    sophie4187 wrote: »
    Congrats! Must be a huge relieft. I am hoping once all this stuff gets mailed in on Monday that it'll be good enough. I do have private medical insurance from the states that will cover me here in Ireland. I sent in a letter from them stating that.

    I have no clue why they are querying about my finances. We sent in our joint bank statement which I have access to, as well as my savings account in the US (which has very little since I don't use it), and my partner's Irish account, in which I use as well. We're not rich by any means but we also have a bit. My partner is a teacher, so has a steady income. I sent in 6 months of payslips from her job. As for me, no jobs available here in tiny ol' Clare while I was on a Working Holiday.

    Fingers crossed!

    Thanks it's a huge relief.

    Is the bank statement just a print out from your internet banking or is it a bank letterhead one with your Irish address on it? Before I left Australia I changed my address and got them to print it out for me in the branch so I could submit it with my app. I had a feeling they might reject an online banking one.

    Your situation is tough as you would have no PRSI contributions, tax records and employer references as record of your history and contribution in the state. What sort of work were you looking for?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,014 ✭✭✭Monife


    FalconXV wrote: »
    4 months is ridiculous was the whole department on holiday during the summer or something?

    4 months is actually very fast for that incompetent "department". I would love a processing time of 4 months. I am waiting on my husband's (newly married :)) Spouse of Irish national application. In the letter they stated current processing times are 6 to 9 months but that it can take up to a year :(


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    Monife wrote: »
    4 months is actually very fast for that incompetent "department". I would love a processing time of 4 months. I am waiting on my husband's (newly married :)) Spouse of Irish national application. In the letter they stated current processing times are 6 to 9 months but that it can take up to a year :(

    That's just drivel they post on their website (that desperately needs to be updated) to cover themselves.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    Any news Sophie?


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    FalconXV wrote: »
    Australian visas are tough. The 9 months to get married fiancee visa puts a lot of pressure on couples and their families and friends. Thankfully I don't have to go down that road. Anyone who hasn't applied yet should do so soon otherwise it's getting closer to Christmas where Government staff take time off which can delay responses. TD's do too and in cases like these you might need their assistance. To save hassle get it in coherent order and include future plans for you and your partner in Ireland so you give them no reason to write back to you asking for more information. In a way you have to show that you want to stay in Ireland long term rather than using it to stay for a couple of years before shifting off elsewhere.



    Thanks it's a huge relief.

    Is the bank statement just a print out from your internet banking or is it a bank letterhead one with your Irish address on it? Before I left Australia I changed my address and got them to print it out for me in the branch so I could submit it with my app. I had a feeling they might reject an online banking one.

    Your situation is tough as you would have no PRSI contributions, tax records and employer references as record of your history and contribution in the state. What sort of work were you looking for?

    Well I was told that I could only work for 3 months per job I found, if any, with my Working Holiday Visa. I applied everywhere - retail shops, grocery stores, etc. but no jobs were going! Since my partner supported me successfully for the year that I was here, as well as each time I've visited, I thought they would know that I wouldn't depend on welfare. I would be actively looking for a job until I found one, even if it were part-time. I am a full-time student (online courses) so I don't know how that will play.

    As soon as my recent US statement comes in, I am going to send that, along with a 6-month statement from our joint account. I just use my partner's laser if I need anything so our joint account is for savings. My US account is as well, which is why I don't have much in that one.

    I don't see how I should be not allowed to live with my partner that we've proven to have for 3 years because I wasn't able to find a job. Most Irish people can't find jobs at this moment.

    Anyway, sent off my passport yesterday and my extra financial info should be mailed off tomorrow. Praying!


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    sophie4187 wrote: »
    Well I was told that I could only work for 3 months per job I found, if any, with my Working Holiday Visa. I applied everywhere - retail shops, grocery stores, etc. but no jobs were going! Since my partner supported me successfully for the year that I was here, as well as each time I've visited, I thought they would know that I wouldn't depend on welfare. I would be actively looking for a job until I found one, even if it were part-time. I am a full-time student (online courses) so I don't know how that will play.

    As soon as my recent US statement comes in, I am going to send that, along with a 6-month statement from our joint account. I just use my partner's laser if I need anything so our joint account is for savings. My US account is as well, which is why I don't have much in that one.

    I don't see how I should be not allowed to live with my partner that we've proven to have for 3 years because I wasn't able to find a job. Most Irish people can't find jobs at this moment.

    Anyway, sent off my passport yesterday and my extra financial info should be mailed off tomorrow. Praying!

    I think it was 6 months in the one job when I had the working holiday permit (I think it varies for each country). I doubt they really check how long you are with the company and some Irish employers and agencies don't even look at the visas. Were you looking in just Clare or Limerick and Galway too? I had to apply for jobs when I was looking in other counties and there was little going in Clare. Full time student in Ireland or by correspondence? With the Irish student visa you can only work 20 hours per week. I ended up getting a Christmas job when I arrived. You should arrange an appointment with your partner's TD they have different correspondence to the normal channels that we have to put up with and might get your application fast tracked. You end up wasting a load of phone credit trying to ring the INIS helpline every Thursday.


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    sophie4187 wrote: »
    Well I was told that I could only work for 3 months per job I found, if any, with my Working Holiday Visa. I applied everywhere - retail shops, grocery stores, etc. but no jobs were going! Since my partner supported me successfully for the year that I was here, as well as each time I've visited, I thought they would know that I wouldn't depend on welfare. I would be actively looking for a job until I found one, even if it were part-time. I am a full-time student (online courses) so I don't know how that will play.

    As soon as my recent US statement comes in, I am going to send that, along with a 6-month statement from our joint account. I just use my partner's laser if I need anything so our joint account is for savings. My US account is as well, which is why I don't have much in that one.

    I don't see how I should be not allowed to live with my partner that we've proven to have for 3 years because I wasn't able to find a job. Most Irish people can't find jobs at this moment.

    Anyway, sent off my passport yesterday and my extra financial info should be mailed off tomorrow. Praying!

    I think it was 6 months in the one job when I had the working holiday permit (I think it varies for each country). I doubt they really check how long you are with the company and some Irish employers and agencies don't even look at the visas. Were you looking in just Clare or Limerick and Galway too? I had to apply for jobs when I was looking in other counties and there was little going in Clare. Full time student in Ireland or by correspondence? With the Irish student visa you can only work 20 hours per week. I ended up getting a Christmas job when I arrived. You should arrange an appointment with your partner's TD they have different correspondence to the normal channels that we have to put up with and might get your application fast tracked. You end up wasting a load of phone credit trying to ring the INIS helpline every Thursday.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,207 ✭✭✭Pablo Sanchez


    FalconXV wrote: »
    You should arrange an appointment with your partner's TD they have different correspondence to the normal channels that we have to put up with and might get your application fast tracked. QUOTE]

    Exactly whats wrong with politics in this country.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    FalconXV wrote: »
    I think it was 6 months in the one job when I had the working holiday permit (I think it varies for each country). I doubt they really check how long you are with the company and some Irish employers and agencies don't even look at the visas. Were you looking in just Clare or Limerick and Galway too? I had to apply for jobs when I was looking in other counties and there was little going in Clare. Full time student in Ireland or by correspondence? With the Irish student visa you can only work 20 hours per week. I ended up getting a Christmas job when I arrived. You should arrange an appointment with your partner's TD they have different correspondence to the normal channels that we have to put up with and might get your application fast tracked. You end up wasting a load of phone credit trying to ring the INIS helpline every Thursday.

    No, I looked in Ennis and Limerick.... if I am allowed, I will go on to Galway and even Cork! I'm bored just sitting at home doing schoolwork. Even if I could get 2 days a week, I'd be happy. I've read about situations in which students are here on a visa trying to get a de facto - they were given the stamp 4 but were told they were not to rely on welfare if they couldn't find a job. Hoping that will be my case. I am taking online courses online from my college in the US and sent them all the information from that. I'm not just sitting around here doing nothing. I am going to try and call today in regards to my passport! Will be sending in financial docs as they requested today as well.

    I just would hope that they understand that it's hard to get a job in this country for anyone..... I will be actively looking for one! Trust me, I don't like that fact that my partner has had to support me all this time.


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    TDs are there to provide a service to the community. It's no different to having a personal contact inside the department. The phone line and email address is a joke if they aren't going to much detail away. They are basically asking for it as people are forced to go down to Burgh Quay. My immigration gard doesn't even have a direct line to the Department of Justice. Now that's a joke
    sophie4187 wrote: »
    No, I looked in Ennis and Limerick.... if I am allowed, I will go on to Galway and even Cork! I'm bored just sitting at home doing schoolwork. Even if I could get 2 days a week, I'd be happy. I've read about situations in which students are here on a visa trying to get a de facto - they were given the stamp 4 but were told they were not to rely on welfare if they couldn't find a job. Hoping that will be my case. I am taking online courses online from my college in the US and sent them all the information from that. I'm not just sitting around here doing nothing. I am going to try and call today in regards to my passport! Will be sending in financial docs as they requested today as well.

    I just would hope that they understand that it's hard to get a job in this country for anyone..... I will be actively looking for one! Trust me, I don't like that fact that my partner has had to support me all this time.

    Getting a job in Ireland is difficult but it's even more difficult if you don't have the right contacts or relatives. Not relying on welfare is standard for a defacto stamp 4.


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    I hear ya. I know that it's tough but I wouldn't rely on welfare, as I was here for a year on a Working Holiday without finding work and did just fine. We'll see.

    In my opinion, they need to be more clear on their website about ALL the things they are looking for. It just says to prove a durable 2 year relationship, which we have, obviously.

    Spent 10 minutes on hold this morning trying to get info about my passport. Said they were sending it via registered post today, which is something at least!


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    The website needs a complete over haul. It's the definition of clutter. You do have to do your own research to put the app together. The local immigration gards know less than we do and they are supposed to be our local support.


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    Did you get your passport and visa?


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    I did get my passport in time - though the ferryport didn't even check it :rolleyes: as for my visa - sent in all my financial info about 2 weeks ago, got confirmation a day or two later and haven't heard anything since..... it's annoying. i'm going to call tomorrow and see what's going on, especially since my visitor's visa expires in like 4 days.

    what i don't understand is that we obviously satisfied them that we are in a genuine relationship of over 2 years - don't know what the hold up is!


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    They don't check it going in to the UK but coming back there is a good chance the Irish immigration gards will be at the border. Sounds like you have to go to your local immigration gard and get them to stamp it for you. There is a good chance they won't tell you over the phone much.


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    Nope, coming back in was the same story - just walked through a door and out!

    Ya, that's what I told my girlfriend about the phone thing but she insisted that I call :rolleyes:


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    Did you get hold of the GNIB?


  • Registered Users Posts: 207 ✭✭vikingdub


    FalconXV wrote: »
    TDs are there to provide a service to the community. It's no different to having a personal contact inside the department. The phone line and email address is a joke if they aren't going to much detail away. They are basically asking for it as people are forced to go down to Burgh Quay. My immigration gard doesn't even have a direct line to the Department of Justice. Now that's a joke


    Getting a job in Ireland is difficult but it's even more difficult if you don't have the right contacts or relatives. Not relying on welfare is standard for a defacto stamp 4.

    The role of a TD is to sit in the Dail and to legislate, they are not there to write letters and interfere with the running of departments. It is this type of gombeen rural parish pump vote buying that has this country in the state that it is in.

    Immigration matters are handled by INIS, an applicant provides the documentation to prove that he/she meets the conditions of whatever he/she is applying for, the application is reviewed and will be granted or denied based on the facts and the processing time stated. TDs, immigration lawyers, etc cannot change the rules, if the conditions are met the application will be approved, if they are not it will be refused. The same applies in other countries.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    vikingdub wrote: »
    The role of a TD is to sit in the Dail and to legislate, they are not there to write letters and interfere with the running of departments. It is this type of gombeen rural parish pump vote buying that has this country in the state that it is in.

    Immigration matters are handled by INIS, an applicant provides the documentation to prove that he/she meets the conditions of whatever he/she is applying for, the application is reviewed and will be granted or denied based on the facts and the processing time stated. TDs, immigration lawyers, etc cannot change the rules, if the conditions are met the application will be approved, if they are not it will be refused. The same applies in other countries.

    They aren't interfering with running departments and changing rules. The TD also provide a service to the community and that includes public services (and dealing with issues). They are a point of contact. Had I not contacted my TD I would probably be still waiting for my response and be out of money. Being proactive got me my decision and my job back. Sophie submitted her application before me and is still waiting for a decision.


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    FalconXV wrote: »
    Did you get hold of the GNIB?

    I did - got straight through, surprisingly enough. Guy was very nice - said that I was fine if I overstayed, as long as my application was processing. He checked on my application and said his colleague was currently processing it.

    I understand they are busy and have a lot to do, but I submitted my application the 9th of September. I followed what the INIS said to submit and as for proving my relationship, I was successful. If they wanted more financial documents other than recent ones, you would think they would be more explanatory on their website.

    Also, a helpline that is only open 2 1/2 hours a week is not very helpful....


  • Registered Users Posts: 207 ✭✭vikingdub


    FalconXV wrote: »
    They aren't interfering with running departments and changing rules. The TD also provide a service to the community and that includes public services (and dealing with issues). They are a point of contact. Had I not contacted my TD I would probably be still waiting for my response and be out of money. Being proactive got me my decision and my job back. Sophie submitted her application before me and is still waiting for a decision.

    Do you understand the role of a TD? Clearly not, the role of the TD is to legislate not to make phone calls and write letters about passports, medical cards or in your case an immigration issue. A TD (Teachta Dála) is to legislate, not to indulge in gombeen, rural, clientelism, in other words exchanging favours for votes. This culture is anti-democratic and needs to be stamped out. It has come to a sorry state when even non-citizens feel they are entitled to bypass the democratic process and the operations of goverment departments in this manner.


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    vikingdub wrote: »
    Do you understand the role of a TD? Clearly not, the role of the TD is to legislate not to make phone calls and write letters about passports, medical cards or in your case an immigration issue. A TD (Teachta Dála) is to legislate, not to indulge in gombeen, rural, clientelism, in other words exchanging favours for votes. This culture is anti-democratic and needs to be stamped out. It has come to a sorry state when even non-citizens feel they are entitled to bypass the democratic process and the operations of goverment departments in this manner.

    You obviously don't realise that TD's are also there to help the community, secure funding for local projects and voice their opinion, push for job creation. How do you think jobs are created in the first place. TD's have to lobby the IDA and companies to secure jobs. Kerry is going through this with the GPCE. Projects like Kerry General weren't built on private money solely. TD's on behalf of the community to push for funding. Plus your partner is an Irish citizen and voter! We don't just pay them to legislate!!! You are deluded if they are just there to create bills and laws.


  • Registered Users Posts: 207 ✭✭vikingdub


    FalconXV wrote: »
    You obviously don't realise that TD's are also there to help the community, secure funding for local projects and voice their opinion, push for job creation. How do you think jobs are created in the first place. TD's have to lobby the IDA and companies to secure jobs. Kerry is going through this with the GPCE. Projects like Kerry General weren't built on private money solely. TD's on behalf of the community to push for funding. Plus your partner is an Irish citizen and voter! We don't just pay them to legislate!!! You are deluded if they are just there to create bills and laws.

    Your post clearly illustrates all that is wrong with this country, the clientalism and rural gombeen politics. A TDs role is not to secure local funding, local jobs, planning permissions, grants for the gaa, etc. You refer to Kerry which explains a lot, the previous failed governments supped with the devil in the form of the vile and dispicable healy raes in a case study of the worst of Irish political clientalism. Naturally the people who did best out of this disgraceful eposide were the Healy Raes, their businesses, their cronies and other hangers-on. You would probably also favour a return to public service recruitment being run by local TDs and councillors with jobs in their "gift" - of course this system may still prevail in Kerry.

    You may wish to live in a country rife with such lack of values, decency and corruption but I certainly do not.

    The delusion lies with your display of woeful ignorance.


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    vikingdub wrote: »
    Your post clearly illustrates all that is wrong with this country, the clientalism and rural gombeen politics. A TDs role is not to secure local funding, local jobs, planning permissions, grants for the gaa, etc. You refer to Kerry which explains a lot, the previous failed governments supped with the devil in the form of the vile and dispicable healy raes in a case study of the worst of Irish political clientalism. Naturally the people who did best out of this disgraceful eposide were the Healy Raes, their businesses, their cronies and other hangers-on. You would probably also favour a return to public service recruitment being run by local TDs and councillors with jobs in their "gift" - of course this system may still prevail in Kerry.

    You may wish to live in a country rife with such lack of values, decency and corruption but I certainly do not.

    The delusion lies with your display of woeful ignorance.

    http://www.citizensinformation.ie/en/government_in_ireland/national_government/houses_of_the_oireachtas/work_of_a_td.html

    http://www.rte.ie/news/election2011/newtds.html

    I suggest your read those links to cover your own ignorance.

    Such a Dublin centric viewpoint. I suggest you go and spend some time in the west of Ireland to see what work TDs especially do to get jobs, infrastructure, school funding in their communities or do you hope that people have to go to Dublin or Cork to get healthcare, travel on roads covered in potholes, travel up to Dublin just to speak to a Government Department, have poor school facilities and queue up outside social welfare as no jobs are available? People like Dick Spring have brought a lot of business in to Kerry (especially businesses like Fexco), proper health care facilities. Taxpayers don't pay them a 100k a year just to legislate. There is a reason why a lot of Dail sittings have a lot of empty seats. The TDs are out working in their constituencies that's why. How else do you think counties outside of Dublin and Cork secure funding to improve people's standard of living?


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    sophie4187 wrote: »
    I did - got straight through, surprisingly enough. Guy was very nice - said that I was fine if I overstayed, as long as my application was processing. He checked on my application and said his colleague was currently processing it.

    I understand they are busy and have a lot to do, but I submitted my application the 9th of September. I followed what the INIS said to submit and as for proving my relationship, I was successful. If they wanted more financial documents other than recent ones, you would think they would be more explanatory on their website.

    Also, a helpline that is only open 2 1/2 hours a week is not very helpful....

    I would still see the local immigration gard so they don't serve you a deportation notice as some don't know the rules. My immigration gard had no clue when I first saw her. She has no direct contact number with the GNIB to ask them questions. Maybe ask if you can get a Stamp 3. If you get a deportation letter they give you a few weeks grace period to leave if you have overstayed (I don't know what the penalty for overstaying is in Ireland, in the UK they can give you a 10 year ban from entering the country). When I got my Stamp 3 renewed after arriving back in the country I told that gard that I will be applying for the defacto Stamp 4 it's better to let them know your situation.


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    Got letter in the mail today stating that I had gotten my Stamp 4 - Overjoyed is an understatement!!!!!!!!


  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    Well done. Lucky timing take it to the immi gard asap. Thankfully my gard has a chip and pin machine so i can get my GNIB card straight away. When I got my working holiday visa stamped I had to take a money order form down to the bank to pay the 150 euro and it took a week for the money to clear the bank before I could get my stamp and card. Probably too late to apply for Christmas seasonal work


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    Yea, same her - for my Working Holiday it took like a week - I guess we'll see when we go in. Just tricky trying to find time as my partner works all day and her boss is a real pain about letting off!!


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    By the way - I assume I have to get a new PPS number, right? I had one for my Working Holiday.....


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,315 ✭✭✭ballooba


    Nah, a PPSN is for life, not just for Christmas. ;) It's like your SSN (US) or TFN (Aus).


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    Haha ;) Well, I had just heard that if your Working Holiday expired and you were able to get another visa, you'd have to get a new one! Thanks!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,315 ✭✭✭ballooba


    I'd be surprised if that's the case, but I've been surprised before. See Q15 here:
    http://www.welfare.ie/EN/Topics/PPSN/Pages/faq.aspx

    It's not specific regarding what constitutes 'a material change in your circumstances or status.a material change to your circumstances'.

    There's a phone number there anyway.


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    FalconXV wrote: »
    Well done. Lucky timing take it to the immi gard asap. Thankfully my gard has a chip and pin machine so i can get my GNIB card straight away. When I got my working holiday visa stamped I had to take a money order form down to the bank to pay the 150 euro and it took a week for the money to clear the bank before I could get my stamp and card. Probably too late to apply for Christmas seasonal work

    Seemingly it's harder to get a member of authority in the garda station to stamp my passport then it is for my partner to take an hour off! I've called all garda stations close and everyone is out until Friday, or Monday, or Tuesday - you get the picture. Don't know what to do.....


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 163 ✭✭FalconXV


    Immi gards have a habit of breaking their schedule which is a pain. There might be a rule that once you are registered at one Garda station you have to go to the same one. My partner wasn't really needed when I got the stamp the gard already knew who we were.
    sophie4187 wrote: »
    Haha ;) Well, I had just heard that if your Working Holiday expired and you were able to get another visa, you'd have to get a new one! Thanks!

    I am working on the same old one, pretty sure it's to do with your pension as well when you retire (just don't lose it). The only reason why I believe they would give you a new one is if you have been working on a temporary number that they give you if you get a job without a PPS number. No idea what's the story with medical cards not that I need one anyway.


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    FalconXV wrote: »
    Immi gards have a habit of breaking their schedule which is a pain. There might be a rule that once you are registered at one Garda station you have to go to the same one. My partner wasn't really needed when I got the stamp the gard already knew who we were.



    I am working on the same old one, pretty sure it's to do with your pension as well when you retire (just don't lose it). The only reason why I believe they would give you a new one is if you have been working on a temporary number that they give you if you get a job without a PPS number. No idea what's the story with medical cards not that I need one anyway.

    Ya, don't need a new one - heard back today. As for my Stamp 4 - Immigration Officer won't be in until next Thursday! Brill. Rang INIS this morning and let them know - said it was fine...as well as my local garda office.


  • Registered Users Posts: 81 ✭✭sophie4187


    Quick question - we are planning a trip to London in April and then will be going back home to the US for the summer.... do I need to apply for a re-entry visa or anything special?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,315 ✭✭✭ballooba


    sophie4187 wrote: »
    Quick question - we are planning a trip to London in April and then will be going back home to the US for the summer.... do I need to apply for a re-entry visa or anything special?
    If you've got a valid Stamp 4 you don't need anything as far as I am aware.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,014 ✭✭✭Monife


    sophie4187 wrote: »
    Quick question - we are planning a trip to London in April and then will be going back home to the US for the summer.... do I need to apply for a re-entry visa or anything special?

    It depends on your nationality. If you are a US citizen, as far as I am aware, they do not need entry visa's to Ireland.


  • Advertisement
Advertisement