Moderators? do we really need them?

pappyodaniel · 07-09-2009 04:04AM #1

Moderators? do we really need them?

Only messing but I'd like to here what Boards users think about those higher up the food-chain.

What's good about our beloved moderators?

What's bad about our Gestaporators?

REAL LIFE HOOD · 07-09-2009 04:06AM

I'm on forums with other teens that don't require moderators and everything works out fine. Boards which appears to have an older profile seems to have more mods than users.

pappyodaniel · 07-09-2009 04:07AM

that's a good start

orestes · 07-09-2009 04:07AM

Without moderators the site would be a complete disaster. Yes, the site does need them. They stop the place turning into a complete and total cluster-fukk of personal abuse and shite. They are there to make sure the noise:signal ratio is balanced properly.

LadyJ · 07-09-2009 04:20AM

If you actually looked at boards through the uncensored eyes of a mod, you'd understand. It's like the difference between watching Big Brother live and the edited version at night. We filter out all of the crap that no one has any need for and you don't have to watch anyone taking a dump.

pappyodaniel · 07-09-2009 04:27AM

I'd love to see some kind of moderation on the comments section of youtube, it's absolute bedlam

orestes · 07-09-2009 04:29AM

pappyodaniel wrote: »

I'd love to see some kind of moderation on the comments section of youtube, it's absolute bedlam

And that shite is exactily why there are mods here

Dartz · 07-09-2009 04:34AM

Could be worse.

Could be moderated like /b/ .(Which, funnily enough, is)

Jesus Wept · 07-09-2009 04:38AM

your mother+cum

My favourite youtube comment

Overheal · 07-09-2009 04:45AM

pappyodaniel wrote: »

Moderators? do we really need them?

Only messing but I'd like to here what Boards users think about those higher up the food-chain.

What's good about our beloved moderators?

What's bad about our Gestaporators?

http://forums.steampowered.com

if you make it back in one piece, I accept your apology.

pappyodaniel · 07-09-2009 04:45AM

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/howaboutthat/2668997/YouTubes-worst-comments-blocked-by-filter.html

Off original comments but for those with youtube accounts.

Manic Moran · 07-09-2009 06:15AM

I'm on one board which is completely moderation free. It actually seems to work out fairly well, the trolls which show up aren't fed, they get bored, and go elsewhere.

NTM

galwayrush · 07-09-2009 08:16AM

Manic Moran wrote: »

I'm on one board which is completely moderation free. It actually seems to work out fairly well, the trolls which show up aren't fed, they get bored, and go elsewhere.

NTM

I'm on a few particular dedicated subjct sites and they kinda moderate themselves, but for AH, yes, definitely needed.

Rabies · 07-09-2009 08:25AM

REAL LIFE HOOD wrote: »

I'm on forums with other teens that don't require moderators and everything works out fine. Boards which appears to have an older profile seems to have more mods than users.

We have more forums than most.
The last forum has the ID number 1255. That tells you how big Boards is.

Every forum has one or two mods. Some need more than others. There are some forums with no mods.

AH is an exception. Its the playground of Boards. But most of the users here are from the special class and we can't allow them near sharp objects because they hurt themselves and annoy others. Extra mods are needed here.

thomond2006 · 07-09-2009 08:27AM

Moderators do a good job.

/Gets coat

Rabies · 07-09-2009 08:33AM

/closes door on thomond2006

ilovelamp2000 · 07-09-2009 08:48AM

Mods are like football referees, if they're good you don't notice them.

sordino · 07-09-2009 09:14AM

I posted in the 'After Hours' forum yesterday using the word 'SWIM' to stand for a friend who had a very bad trip at the weekend. (SWIM is a standard acronym used on drug forum's meaning 'Someone Who Isn't Me' to protect identities of those involved). Some people don't like it (fair enough) but this was the Rubadub's considered reply to the issue as a so-called Moderator:

"SWIM should have been drowned at birth, can't stand reading posts using it non-stop."

Followed by:

"10 years ago you never had posts with non-stop SWIM or other bull**** in forums on drugs, there were great forums back then before all the teenage assholes came along"

Nice refereeing there Rubadub.

Spear · 07-09-2009 09:23AM

sordino wrote: »

I posted in the 'After Hours' forum yesterday using the word 'SWIM' to stand for a friend who had a very bad trip at the weekend. (SWIM is a standard acronym used on drug forum's meaning 'Someone Who Isn't Me' to protect identities of those involved). Some people don't like it (fair enough) but this was the Rubadub's considered reply to the issue as a so-called Moderator:

"SWIM should have been drowned at birth, can't stand reading posts using it non-stop."

Followed by:

"10 years ago you never had posts with non-stop SWIM or other bull**** in forums on drugs, there were great forums back then before all the teenage assholes came along"

Nice refereeing there Rubadub.

Rubadub is not a mod of AH and wasn't posting as a mod, but as a private user.

Rabies · 07-09-2009 09:38AM

Not an AH mod

Ghost Train · 07-09-2009 09:43AM

Moderators should have cooler nicknames like lightning, thunderbolt and dynorod

The guy · 07-09-2009 09:48AM

Ghost Train wrote: »

Moderators should have cooler nicknames like lightning, thunderbolt and dynorod

Maybe just in the weather forum which must be pretty easy to mod except when people are having shitty days.

philologos · 07-09-2009 09:54AM

pappyodaniel wrote: »

What's good about our beloved moderators?

The good part is that they keep some form of order in the threads, keep trolls away, and ensure that the discussion is kept fair and balanced.

pappyodaniel wrote: »

What's bad about our Gestaporators?

Sometimes moderators can be too restrictive, and stifle what is legitimate discussion, and can be a bit too liberal with the ban stick.

the_syco · 07-09-2009 09:55AM

REAL LIFE HOOD wrote: »

I'm on forums with other teens that don't require moderators and everything works out fine. Boards which appears to have an older profile seems to have more mods than users.

I persoanlly can't wait until Bubbles finds that site. Or he probably already has. As for boards.ie, when you have at least 200 forums, you needs mods, if for no other reason than to direct the b00bs to the correct forum. The amount of people who post in the helpdesk forum looking for info on where to buy stuff is unreal.

Manic Moran wrote: »

I'm on one board which is completely moderation free. It actually seems to work out fairly well, the trolls which show up aren't fed, they get bored, and go elsewhere.

NTM

:eek: Every forum I'm on has mods. Some to keep the spam levels down, others to ensure you post in the correct sections. Others to ensure you're not taking the piss out of the forum, or posting crap that could get it closed down.

Kiera · 07-09-2009 09:56AM

Ghost Train wrote: »

Moderators should have cooler nicknames like lightning, thunderbolt and dynorod

I agree. What's with Rabies and J bo ffs :P

Rabies · 07-09-2009 10:03AM

/walks away.

pffft... real names.

phasers · 07-09-2009 10:07AM

mods are lame

Rabies · 07-09-2009 10:22AM

-_-

Kiera · 07-09-2009 10:24AM

Rabies wrote: »

-_-

Whens the last time you got your eyes checked? All that squinting cant be good.

Kold · 07-09-2009 10:44AM

LadyJ wrote: »

If you actually looked at boards through the uncensored eyes of a mod, you'd understand. It's like the difference between watching Big Brother live and the edited version at night. We filter out all of the crap that no one has any need for and you don't have to watch anyone taking a dump.

Wow, that's an awful comparison. I don't watch that sh*t but if I did, I reckon watching people taking dumps would be the best part.

The site is overmodded for sure, I remember boards being a lot more fun back in the day but that's the cost of the place getting so much bigger. All the funniest trolls are long gone.

DoireNod · 07-09-2009 10:49AM

Mods are helpful. There are too many clowns about to let a forum like boards go unmoderated.

I'm just wondering when 'Impersonating a Moderator' becomes a crime on boards.

Moderators? do we really need them?

Comments