Boards Referendum - English as the first language of Republic of Ireland

Wibbs · 08-12-2008 6:27pm

AvrilLavigne wrote: »

Yes, you agree sheep! Maybe the moaning cheese stick will move next to you and ye can moan away while we live in harmony with the the Irish, English, Polish etc. who like and welcome diversity, difference and fun.

Sieg Heil Wibbs and Cheese! One race! One language! Blue eyes! Blond Hair!

Ehhhhh OK..... Strange person. You say you welcome diversity yet reference and indeed thank god that some morons planning laws specifically restricts diversity. Clearly English is your second language or irony doesn't translate well as Gaelige.

PS Nice cruise around Godwin's law. green eyed and dark haired here. Blondes don't really do it for me, but meh to each their own.

AvrilLavigne · 08-12-2008 6:38pm

Wibbs wrote: »

Ehhhhh OK..... Strange person. You say you welcome diversity yet reference and indeed thank god that some morons planning laws specifically restricts diversity. Clearly English is your second language or irony doesn't translate well as Gaelige.

PS Nice cruise around Godwin's law. green eyed and dark haired here. Blondes don't really do it for me, but meh to each their own.

The laws keep the ignorant moaners like you and cheese out. We speak it, we use it, people who don't move here all the time, just don't bitch about it or how we run things here. Each county is free to decide this. Try moving to Clare; wouldn't take your moaning ass either.

HalloweenJack · 08-12-2008 7:02pm

If Irish still deserves to be an official language, surely recognition should be given to Polish. There must be more Polish speakers in the country by now.

I went to fourteen years of all-Irish and all I got out of it was a good few extra points in the Leaving. That's something that should be changed, imo. It's not fair on kids who go to English schools or immigrants who struggle just trying to learn English.

I do feel proud to be able to speak the language but the fact is it's utterly useless, like Latin. Everybody on this island speaks English.

Wibbs · 08-12-2008 7:09pm

Ahh so you like diversity so long as it agrees with you? Riiiiight. By the by you didn't respond to my points, just witter on erroneously about moaners(or people who don't happen to agree with you). Then bring up something about me not being welcome in Clare? A tad off the point and not a little surreal.

OK lets join the disparate dots of what passes for your argument: Now if those who are not Irish speakers are free to move to Irish only areas(so long as they don't moan apparently)and you're fine with that, what's the rhetoric about the planning laws? Apparently they mean nothing in your mind all of a sudden. O'Cuiv can't be happy being ignored if that's the case(though that would be his default perception of the world).

So which is it? Everyone is welcome, , Polish, English(even them, by heck)so long as no moaners(boo! hiss! Down with that sorta thing) show up. Sounds like an Irish planning law alright. How would you spot me? If I wore a placard(in both languages obviously) denouncing Irish as a sham or something? Sounds workable. Or in the real world, the planning laws actually restrict diversity, while trying to prop up a language, that may or may not be dead. That's fine, that's it's purpose, but your debating skills and points are all over the place.

Maybe you're better in Irish, who knows. The thing is, in the country at large you could be Quiveeeen O'Socrates and frankly about 5000 people would fully understand your erudition and general brilliance..

Anxiously awaits more surrealism......

Acacia · 08-12-2008 7:24pm

HalloweenJack wrote: »

I went to fourteen years of all-Irish and all I got out of it was a good few extra points in the Leaving. That's something that should be changed, imo. It's not fair on kids who go to English schools or immigrants who struggle just trying to learn English.

I agree about reforming the way Irish is taught in schools.

I went to an English school i.e. one where the children are taught through English. I didn't find learning Irish 'unfair' or that it had a negative effect on my Leaving Cert results. I just wish it was taught in a better way.

As for the immigrants struggling to learn English- I hardly see how changing the constitution would affect them. If they have a problem with Irish being the national language (and I can't see how they would), then tough titties, to be honest. If I went to any other country to live, I would respect that they have a different language, or maybe several official languages (as is the case in Spain.) In fact, I know immigrants from many different countries living here. Far from complaining about Irish, many have remarked to me that it's a shame that we don't speak it fluently.Many of them have learned Irish themselves.

Irish is not a dead language. A language is dead when the last speaker of the language dies, taking the language with them. Some of the AmerIndian languages for example, would be dead languages, as there are no living speakers of them.

As for, ''it being of no use outside these shores''- what of German or Finnish or Swedish or Swahili? They're not used very much outside their countries either. Should they stop learning their native languages and only speak English? The European people that I've met usually have excellent English , as well as their own language. I think that duality is something we should strive for here.

futura123 · 08-12-2008 7:33pm

english is the first language in modern ireland ..... the constitution should be changed to reflect this. i have no problem with irish bein demoted to no 2 on the list.

HalloweenJack · 08-12-2008 7:40pm

Acacia wrote: »

I went to an English school i.e. one where the children are taught through English. I didn't find learning Irish 'unfair' or that it had a negative effect on my Leaving Cert results. I just wish it was taught in a better way.

Well, the thing is if you do your Leaving exams through Irish, you get back 10% of the marks you didn't get. Therefore, I got 420 in my leaving. If I'd done it through English, I would've got 390 or something. I don't think that's fair. I know it's an attempt to promote the language but it does discriminate against people who don't want to go to all-Irish schools.

Acacia wrote:

As for the immigrants struggling to learn English- I hardly see how changing the constitution would affect them. If they have a problem with Irish being the national language (and I can't see how they would), then tough titties, to be honest.

It's one thing to learn the lan guage that they'll use in everyday life but what is the point in learning a language that they won't be using everyday?

Acacia wrote:

As for, ''it being of no use outside these shores''- what of German or Finnish or Swedish or Swahili? They're not used very much outside their countries either. Should they stop learning their native languages and only speak English?

The difference with those languages is that they have really high percentages of speakers. English is the language here. Very few people speak Irish everyday or at all. In Finland, Finnish is spoken by the majority, same with Sweden and Germany (although German is also spoken in Switzerland and Austria) and Kenya.

Wibbs · 08-12-2008 7:44pm

HalloweenJack wrote: »

It's one thing to learn the lan guage that they'll use in everyday life but what is the point in learning a language that they won't be using everyday?

Exactly. It would be like being forced to learn Basque and get preferential treatment in exams while living in Barcelona.

javaboy · 08-12-2008 8:26pm

CaptainNegative wrote: »

That's a load of BS.
Myself and the majority of the people I spend time with only speak Gaeilge to one another and we're not in the Gaeltacht, not working for any organisations in which Gaeilge is the primary language in which business is done, but just because we want to and because we can.
Saying anything is dying, merely because it doesn't play a role in your life is the highest form of ignorance. If you want to make broad statements condemning the national language, why don't you do a bit of research first and you'll find that you're wrong.
A leithéad de phlóta ni fhaca mé riamh.

Why does the language need preferential treatment so? Why can it not stand on its own two feet if its not dying?

Also Starring LeVar Burton · 08-12-2008 8:31pm

javaboy wrote: »

Why does the language need preferential treatment so? Why can it not stand on its own two feet if its not dying?

I never claimed to agree with the government on their treatment of the language. Gaeilge would not die out if the government cut all grants tomorrow. Nowhere in any of my posts did I comment on the goverment grants in regards to Gaeilge.
The post you quoted was me saying your argument was of the upmost ignorance - which I'll stand by. You have yet to give a shred of evidence that it is a dying language.

javaboy · 08-12-2008 9:43pm

CaptainNegative wrote: »

I never claimed to agree with the government on their treatment of the language. Gaeilge would not die out if the government cut all grants tomorrow. Nowhere in any of my posts did I comment on the goverment grants in regards to Gaeilge.
The post you quoted was me saying your argument was of the upmost ignorance - which I'll stand by. You have yet to give a shred of evidence that it is a dying language.

You're accusing me of ignorance? You were the one earlier saying I think the language is dying "merely because it doesn't play a role in your life". That's nothing to do with it. There a million different things that play no role in my life. I wouldn't use it as a basis for an argument that those things are dying.

I don't know where you plucked that assumption from tbh. Was it based on just one post I made? I didn't mention anything at all about whether it plays a role in my life.

And if you read my posts you'll see I never claimed the language is dying. I said it is being kept alive by artificial supports. There's no way for either of us to know whether it would survive as a language without them. My guess is that it wouldn't. I can't provide evidence either way while those artificial supports are in place.

kiffer · 08-12-2008 9:48pm

I hear random snippets of irish every so often on the bus, in the street and in pubs.

I'm seeing an upswing in usage/interest and I've discovered a number of people I know actively use Irish when they can... but they don't generally make this known. They aren't preachy about it they just use it when they are about people they know understand it (and also aren't going to go on about it being a dead language).

If you're in the "I wish I could speak irish" or the "I can but don't bother" camps I urge you to make this known to people around you... Don't make a big issue about it, just throw out a couple of sentences here and there you might be suprised at the number of people around you that respond positively.

I've known people for years without knowing that they actively speak irish fluently and only found out because of a chance comment by a friend.
Now irish speakers seem to be coming out of the wood work and I know a suprising number.

My irish is really awfull, I wish it was good enough that I could impove it with out looking so stupid... 14 years in school and I can't say more than a few stock phrases and conjugate some verbs and a preposition or two... Screw grammar, it's lack of vocab that's crippling.

Wibbs · 08-12-2008 9:57pm

CaptainNegative wrote: »

I never claimed to agree with the government on their treatment of the language. Gaeilge would not die out if the government cut all grants tomorrow. Nowhere in any of my posts did I comment on the goverment grants in regards to Gaeilge.
The post you quoted was me saying your argument was of the upmost ignorance - which I'll stand by. You have yet to give a shred of evidence that it is a dying language.

I don't think it would die out, but I think it would make it more evident how actually relevant or not, it was for people. I suspect it would dwindle quite a bit if it lost all government support, if it was no longer required as part of the syllabus or required in certain professions if there were no grants for irish speaking areas etc. Or it may actually grow the language.

culabula · 08-12-2008 10:48pm

HalloweenJack wrote: »

If Irish still deserves to be an official language, surely recognition should be given to Polish. There must be more Polish speakers in the country by now.

I

I would have said that Polish has considerable recognition.....I see signs written in it everywhere, information distributed in it, a mini-TV station, radio, Polish music and goods on sale and an Evening Herald supplement.

culabula · 08-12-2008 10:51pm

HalloweenJack wrote: »

I do feel proud to be able to speak the language but the fact is it's utterly useless, like Latin. Everybody on this island speaks English.

Latin was one of the most useful subjects ever and it is a disgrace that it was removed from curriculae; I would argue that language skills in Ireland (and in Britain) would be considerably improved had Latin been retained.

A wonderful and beautiful language in no small way which lives on in millions of contemporary speakers' mouths.

culabula · 08-12-2008 11:07pm

Domo230 wrote: »

Are you serious.

One language would be great. Whats wrong with wanting to be able to easily communicate with every race and culture in the world.

Everything -it will squash all cultures, manners, ways of life.

Look at the 'uptalk' of young Irish people. look at the words 'small, medium, everyday, commonplace, ordinary, normal, common-or-garden', all being replaced by the ubiquitous 'regular', simply because McDonalds was embarrassed by the word small. It impoverishes vocabulary.

Look how the new Google Mobile Search App won't work by voice unless you speak American to it.

No thanks.

08-12-2008 11:14pm

culabula wrote: »

I would have said that Polish has considerable recognition.....I see signs written in it everywhere, information distributed in it, a mini-TV station, radio, Polish music and goods on sale and an Evening Herald supplement.

I think it's fair to say that interest is only transient, as the Polish speakers are a migrant group. The reason for the Polish language media is simply because there is money in it!

Give it a couple of years, after which they have either integrated into the general population (speak English as a first language etc) or have gone home (more likely due to the emerging depression), then this Polish media will disappear, Tescos have already dropped the "Polska" section.

culabula · 08-12-2008 11:22pm

Deleted User wrote: »

I think it's fair to say that interest is only transient, as the Polish speakers are a migrant group. The reason for the Polish language media is simply because there is money in it!

Give it a couple of years, after which they have either integrated into the general population (speak English as a first language etc) or have gone home (more likely due to the emerging depression), then this Polish media will disappear, Tescos have already dropped the "Polska" section.

That's correct, but the recognition is nonetheless there, there is hardly any room for complaint.

Contrast this with the Irish Government's recent new lnaguage policies which have only come in after 80-odd years -too little too late.

Having said that, I, as an Irish speaker love to be greeted in irish in Heuston, love to hear it on onboard announcements, love to experience some of the more positive developments of recent years. And I respond.

Still plenty of Polska sections in Tesco and elsewhere round this manor, squire :-)

culabula · 08-12-2008 11:34pm

Domo230 wrote: »

Because culturally were the exact same as England just because we speak the same language.

What has that to do with other nations speaking the same language?

But I thought were the exact same as them because of our shared language

?? What's to be confused about? That is what is happening......

Tar.Aldarion · 08-12-2008 11:44pm

Don't make a fuss about Irish, it will die itself.

Wibbs · 09-12-2008 12:14am

Or live. It depends on the will of those who choose to speak it.

AvrilLavigne · 09-12-2008 11:13am

Wibbs wrote: »

Or live. It depends on the will of those who choose to speak it.

You are correct in everything you say wibbs. How can one argue with someone who spends so much time online? You really know what is going on. You look great on your webcam!

Tar.Aldarion · 09-12-2008 11:16am

I think each generation will care less about speaking it. Even those I know that can speak it, do not speak it. More people want to, and do, speak Elvish than Irish. Living in Galway you can see people grow up in the Gaeltacht speaking Irish their whole life, move out of home and never speak it again. Maybe they will if they visit home for a few days, but their kids won't. PC of people who can speak Irish from my gf's schoool: 100%. Number who ever will again, practically none. Unless somebody lives in the Gaeltacht, where there is like 20, 000 people in all of Ireland. They will teach their kids Irish and so on. This could go on for some time, but i think it will die out in the long run.

Actually avril I'm hot, want to have sex?

AvrilLavigne · 09-12-2008 11:36am

Tar.Aldarion wrote: »

I think each generation will care less about speaking it. Even those I know that can speak it, do not speak it. More people want to, and do, speak Elvish than Irish. Living in Galway you can see people grow up in the Gaeltacht speaking Irish their whole life, move out of home and never speak it again. Maybe they will if they visit home for a few days, but their kids won't. PC of people who can speak Irish from my gf's schoool: 100%. Number who ever will again, practically none. Unless somebody lives in the Gaeltacht, where there is like 20, 000 people in all of Ireland. They will teach their kids Irish and so on. This could go on for some time, but i think it will die out in the long run.

gaelscoil.jpg

Tar.Aldarion wrote: »

Actually avril I'm hot, want to have sex?

Probably not.

themadchef · 09-12-2008 12:05pm

Firstly I think the posters coming on here, making a statement in Irish and not translating it need to cop on.

I can only speak for my own love of the language here and my experience with it. I grew up listening to Irish, i went to school taught through English, got a weak honor in the LC, went to college and forgot all about Irish.

My Irish was as basic as any one's. You do forget how to speak it fluently when you stop speaking it for a while. But it's part of who i am. I'm back in college now part time doing a degree in Irish....because it's that important to me. I feel embarassed when i cant find the right Irish words and get lost in conversation. I'm Irish ffs, we all speak English sure, but we're Irish.

Someone mentioned grants for business. Yes, there are. If you live in the Gaeltacht, and can provide new jobs... I'm quite sure grants can be had. For an existing business, if half your signage is "as Gaeilge" you get a 50% grant. I work in the service industry. When we speak Irish to each other (the staff) people often comment how nice it is to hear it, especially foreigners. It is nice to hear the old songs and poetry in Irish. Not every session in the gaeltacht will include wonderwall and the likes

.

I want to ask all the non Irish speakers a question.

Is it really that the Irish language means nothing to you or is it your inability to speak it that makes you feel in some way inferior. If you found in the morning, that magically, you were a fluent Irish speaker. Tell me you wouldint use it in a load of different situations! You lash out saying it's meaningless to our country as a whole, and the future generations because THE MAJORITY don't understand it? That's their choice, we choose to understand it.

Are those of us who use it in every day life more Irish? No, obviously. We're just a bit mad

, eccentric perhaps. If this went to referendum tomorrow i doubt very much anything would change because even though most people can't or don't speak it, they wouldn't want to see it "officially" die, even if in reality (for the majority) it's been dead for decades.

Paulgar · 09-12-2008 12:20pm

I am originally from Dublin, but have lived in Thailand for the last six years and before that I lived in Saudi. Maybe many people might think that this should exclude me from the debate, but I am still proud to be from Ireland and will always consider myself to be Irish no matter how long I stay away.

I always find the Irish language debate to be a bit bemusing. It is like Irish people are ashamed of their own language which when I lived there was mostly English. I always found it unusual in Ireland that there is an undercurrent sense of shame with our mother tongue -English.

I know that this is an emotional subject, but I am sure there would be a lot less fuss about the whole thing if people thought it through properly. English is a Germanic language which migrated to English and then to Ireland. Ireland has had a great impact on the language and we should be proud of this, because this language belongs to Irish people as much as it does anybody else.

The original inhabitants of Ireland did not speak Irish so why don't the Irish rehabilitate that language. It shouldn't be too hard and probably only involves learning a few grunts. English has more of a claim to being Ireland's language because this is what most people speak.

I actually think that there would be far more interest in Irish language if it wasn't shoved down people's throats.

So I do hope that Irish people one day stop basing their culture on just not being English. There is something wrong with not being proud of the language most of grew up with as out mother-tongue.

AvrilLavigne · 09-12-2008 12:34pm

Paulgar wrote: »

out mother-tongue.

Your mom trying to shift ya? :eek:

Paulgar · 09-12-2008 12:43pm

Freudian slip. I'll get back to you if I ever discover what it means.

topper75 · 09-12-2008 12:44pm

Ní poncánach mé.
Ní sasanach mé.
Is Gael mé.

Sí mo chéad theangasa ar aon nós, agus is cuma liom faoi sibhse.

Más maith libh bheith i bhur bponcánaigh nó sasanaigh, téigh go SAM nó go Sasana agus ná taraigí ar ais.

Kirnsy · 09-12-2008 12:47pm

tá an ghaeilge rí-thabhachtach i mo thuairimse!

agreed the teaching in English speaking schools is less than adequate and the leaving cert course especially is extremely difficult with not enough emphasis on the SPOKEN Gaeilge, however gaelscoileanna and secondary schools through Gaeilge have produced wonderful academic results with the examples in the papers recently.

However for people to just give up on the language and pronounce it a dead language are wrong. Tá Gaeilge sa bhfaisiún arís! With the likes of Carlsberg - i think - (cáca milis?) - and Des Bishop cashing in on Gaeilge its clear that the language is beginning to revive itself.

for people to say its not important for our sense of culture and identity, reveals they are hugely mistaken, Gaeilge is a massive part of being unique, having our own native language whether you can speak one or one hundred words of it makes us all the more Irish :cool:

Paulgar · 09-12-2008 12:55pm

I didn't realise that culture was a stagnant thing. I thought that cultures evolved and were added to all the time. Is Irish culture only about a certain point in time? When exactly was that? Is Ireland meant to return to that 'special' time? What is wrong with now?

Wibbs · 09-12-2008 12:56pm

AvrilLavigne wrote: »

You are correct in everything you say wibbs. How can one argue with someone who spends so much time online? You really know what is going on.

Maybe actually try to engage those you disagree with using cogent non scatterbrained arguments? You know, like others here. Just a thought. If that's hard to pick through for you maybe there's a creche forum around here.

You look great on your webcam!

A tad banal an example, but cheers, better than your usual standard that you go for?

themadchef wrote:

Is it really that the Irish language means nothing to you or is it your inability to speak it that makes you feel in some way inferior. If you found in the morning, that magically, you were a fluent Irish speaker. Tell me you wouldint use it in a load of different situations!

That's a good question. Honestly, not speaking it is not really an inferiority issue. For me anyway and for a simple reason. If I did magically become fluent I can only think of one, maybe two people I would know that could answer me in the language. If I was surrounded by Irish speakers then yes I would feel excluded from everyday discourse, but the simple fact is I'm not. Again let's take the Basque example; if I was living in northern Spain or Southern France and I could speak Spanish say fluently, but my Basque was as good as my Irish, then I would feel and be culturally inferior and excluded. Again because it would be a useful language to know as it is used on a daily basis by a significantly large part of the population. The simple fact is, regardless of the stats thrown around the place by supporters or detractors, Irish is not a living language by comparison to Basque or other minority languages. That's the unvarnished truth. It has vocal support and governmental support, but living languages don't require it. They survive and thrive largely on their own because the people want and need to speak it.

Actually many if not all of those minority languages were just as restricted in the past as Irish was here, yet today they're vibrant and alive and used. The former soviet satellite states are a really obvious example of how a nation that wants to, brings languages back from the brink in a very short time. 10/15 year timespan. How long has Irish been pushed in this country? Indeed Irish it could be argued was very similar to Russian in those former states. Forced in school, required for government positions, civil service and the law and look what happened to Russian when people had free choice. Dosvidania baby. Is the majority language of this country English? That would be a yes. Is it supported in any way? No. Yes it is pervasive in the culture, no doubt, but so is Spanish and French(and English) in the Basque country.

You lash out saying it's meaningless to our country as a whole, and the future generations because THE MAJORITY don't understand it? That's their choice, we choose to understand it.

Well it's usually the Irish speakers doing the lashing out TBH. A weird mix of inferiority and superiority with not a little of that historical dichotomy regarding English thrown in. There have been many languages on this little island. Should we feel less "Irish" because they're gone or we don't speak them? Do you feel inferior as an Irish person because your medieval Irish is not up to par? Nope. Irish needs to grow and adapt to survive. It will only do that if more people use it daily. At the moment they quite simply don't. They may like to think they do, due in part to that aforementioned dichotomy, hence the census returns, but they don't.

Nehaxak · 09-12-2008 12:57pm

Methinks there be many a duplicate account being used to vote yes in this poll...

cornbb · 09-12-2008 12:59pm

I don't necesessarily disagree with those of you who say that the government's policies regarding the Irish language should be somehow reformed, but I'm just sad that you don't recognise that Irish is naturally a fundamental part of life for many Irish people, leaving aside any talk of grants, compulsory teaching etc.

I'm surprised at how frequently I hear people speaking Irish out and about in Galway city, in the last few weeks I've heard Irish spoken at the changing rooms in the gym, between a mother and toddler in a shoe shop, and on the street outside a pub. The other day I was in a shop in the Gaelteacht and heard an old man speaking Irish who could not speak English! I know this is rare. But it would be nice if some of you could acknowledge that Irish is not in fact dead and it is not only being spoken by people who are having it forced upon them.

Wibbs · 09-12-2008 1:02pm

Kirnsy wrote: »

agreed the teaching in English speaking schools is less than adequate and the leaving cert course especially is extremely difficult with not enough emphasis on the SPOKEN Gaeilge, however gaelscoileanna and secondary schools through Gaeilge have produced wonderful academic results with the examples in the papers recently.

Of course they have. Smaller class sizes and more involved teachers. Not Irish. Compare like with like.

However for people to just give up on the language and pronounce it a dead language are wrong. Tá Gaeilge sa bhfaisiún arís! With the likes of Carlsberg - i think - (cáca milis?) - and Des Bishop cashing in on Gaeilge its clear that the language is beginning to revive itself.

Well des bishop would put me off:D The caca milis example is hardly a good one if you think more on it, is it? A better example for the against side really.

for people to say its not important for our sense of culture and identity, reveals they are hugely mistaken, Gaeilge is a massive part of being unique, having our own native language whether you can speak one or one hundred words of it makes us all the more Irish :cool:

Eh nope it doesn't. It would if this debate wasn't happening. The fact that it is speaks volumes. Having one word of irish hardly makes me or anyone else unique and just bolsters this elitist nonsense that will kill the language for many.

AvrilLavigne · 09-12-2008 1:05pm

Wibbs wrote: »

If I did magically become fluent I can only think of one, maybe two people I would know that could answer me in the language.

LOL! What a surprise!

online-living.jpg

Also Starring LeVar Burton · 09-12-2008 1:10pm

Nehaxak wrote: »

Methinks there be many a duplicate account being used to vote yes in this poll...

I agree

themadchef wrote: »

Firstly I think the posters coming on here, making a statement in Irish and not translating it need to cop on.

Is dóigh liomsa gur cóir d'éinne a bhfuil fadhb acu leis an easpa aistriúcháin é a rá le m'aghaidh.

To be fair, we're making our points in English, to include everyone. If someone really wanted to know what the rest of the statements meant - they could pick up a dictionary or easier yet, quote the text in question and ask for a translation - I'd be more than happy to translate. That's what I do if someone speaks to me in German and I don't understand. I have very little German, but if I was speaking to a German I'd try my best to speak in German and when I'm having trouble - merely express that.
It's good to hear that you've gone back to college to study Gaeilge, madchef. What college are you in?

Kirnsy · 09-12-2008 1:20pm

Adamcp898 wrote: »

Children who go to gaelscoileanna that speak Irish all day won't have as good a command of the English language as those who speak English all day.

Wibbs i meant my point bout the results at this ignorant quote above.

i feel that Gaeilge makes US as a nation unique..the fact that no other country in the world speaks our language. Nothing elitist there... i don't agree with people having to learn the language but i disagree strongly with people saying that the language is both dead and useless.

there are plenty of people using it, maybe no where near as many who speak english but its an insult to their efforts to call it a dead language.(not saying you did Wibbs, haven't figured out the multi quote function yet!)

Also Starring LeVar Burton · 09-12-2008 1:21pm

Wibbs wrote: »

Of course they have. Smaller class sizes and more involved teachers. Not Irish. Compare like with like.

Wrong. Same class sizes in most cases, if not more.

Wibbs wrote: »

Well des bishop would put me off:D The caca milis example is hardly a good one if you think more on it, is it? A better example for the against side really

Wrong. Shows us that other cultures want to hear us speaking Gaeilge.

Wibbs wrote: »

Eh nope it doesn't. It would if this debate wasn't happening. The fact that it is speaks volumes. Having one word of irish hardly makes me or anyone else unique and just bolsters this elitist nonsense that will kill the language for many.

Wrong. I have about 2 phrases in Polish, 4 phrases in Spanish, several words in Latin, can speak a bit of French and German and am fluent in Irish and English. According to all sources that makes me unique and doesn't seem to be killing any of the above languages. FYI, Latin is not a dead language, otherwise it wouldn't appear in legal documents, university degrees, etc.

getz · 09-12-2008 1:21pm

javaboy wrote: »

Why does the language need preferential treatment so? Why can it not stand on its own two feet if its not dying?

in my eyes a dead language means a language that is not changing ;irish cornish;welsh ect- unlike english that is taking on new words every year;but i do think every culture should promote is own-it would be a shame to lose the old language,

Also Starring LeVar Burton · 09-12-2008 1:23pm

getz wrote: »

in my eyes a dead language means a language that is not changing ;irish cornish;welsh ect- unlike english that is taking on new words every year;but i do think every culture should promote is own-it would be a shame to lose the old language,

Who says Irish isn't changing - I know words that suggest otherwise.

AvrilLavigne · 09-12-2008 1:27pm

Adamcp898 wrote: »

There's nothing wrong with my usage of any of the words you have emboldened.

ROFL! :rolleyes:

Adamcp898 wrote: »

No it certainly does not always improve one's command of a primary language. In certain related languages it can help yes for example with French, Italien and Spanish.

It's spelt Italian you tit!

Adamcp898 wrote: »

Children who go to gaelscoils that speak Irish all day won't have as good a command of the English language as those who speak English all day.

Great point, they will not be able to understand the tv, their parents, etc. They are fecked! What gael school did you go to?

themadchef · 09-12-2008 1:35pm

CaptainNegative wrote: »

madchef. What college are you in?

NUIG. Student card discounts at 34yrs of age ftw

dr.bollocko · 09-12-2008 1:38pm

AvrilLavigne wrote: »

ROFL! :rolleyes:

It's spelt Italian you tit!

Great point, they will not be able to understand the tv, their parents, etc. They are fecked! What gael school did you go to?

That's a mighty thin line you're on there Avril. Any more personal abuse = meanie mod time.

Wibbs · 09-12-2008 1:49pm

AvrilLavigne wrote: »

LOL! What a surprise!

online-living.jpg

Ehhhhh? So you're agreeing with my point then? You're not really the sharpest at this stuff

CaptainNegative wrote:

Wrong. Same class sizes in most cases, if not more.

You can say that, but it's not the case, especially in urban areas. Indeed there have been complaints raised that parents are sending their kids to these schools for precisely that reason and less comfortable reasons such as far fewer of our new arrivals kids go to them.

Wrong. Shows us that other cultures want to hear us speaking Gaeilge.

Sorry you're wrong, or at least blinkered. It shows that while other cultures may expect us to know Irish, the whole premise and joke is that we simply don't, unless sharon ni bhaoloin actualy means something I'm unaware of(leave it:D).

Wrong. I have about 2 phrases in Polish, 4 phrases in Spanish, several words in Latin, can speak a bit of French and German and am fluent in Irish and English. According to all sources that makes me unique and doesn't seem to be killing any of the above languages. FYI, Latin is not a dead language, otherwise it wouldn't appear in legal documents, university degrees, etc.

Sorry again you're missing my point. I was responding to Kirnsy and his notion that whether I know one or a hundred words in Irish, makes me more Irish. Knowing "2 phrases in Polish, 4 phrases in Spanish, several words in Latin, can speak a bit of French and German" does not make you Polish, Spanish, Roman, French or German, does it?

Actually that raises another point; if I did strive to become fluent in Irish and actually got to that point, how would I know I was speaking like a native? I couldn't and I wouldn't be. I could live in France for 30 years, be fluent in French, yet a French person will pretty quickly spot I'm not a local.

Let's say we decided to revive French here(the Normans spoke it) and we learned French and taught it to our kids. French people would spot the difference. Would we be anymore French?

So what we have is not really Irish anymore for the most part. It's a melding of dialects spoken and taught by non natives and is in effect a partially new language. Which kinda kills much of the "culture" angle.

getz · 09-12-2008 1:59pm

CaptainNegative wrote: »

Who says Irish isn't changing - I know words that suggest otherwise.

dont misunderstand me what i mean to say is that any country that has to pass laws to keep its language going says to me that the language is dead even in spain language laws are passed, in france tv and radio has to conform ,to goverment regulation on how much english is to be used in the boardcasts

javaboy · 09-12-2008 2:01pm

themadchef wrote: »

I want to ask all the non Irish speakers a question.

Is it really that the Irish language means nothing to you or is it your inability to speak it that makes you feel in some way inferior. If you found in the morning, that magically, you were a fluent Irish speaker. Tell me you wouldint use it in a load of different situations! You lash out saying it's meaningless to our country as a whole, and the future generations because THE MAJORITY don't understand it? That's their choice, we choose to understand it.

It's not an inferiority thing for me anyway. And it's not that the language means nothing to me or that I think it's meaningless to the country as a whole either. I'm not proposing the language be eradicated or scrubbed from the constitution. It's part of our history, heritage and culture. Just like growing spuds, building crannógs and playing hurling. That doesn't mean those things should be artificially preserved outside of museums. If people want to learn Irish, there's nothing stopping them and nor should there be. My main gripe is with the artificial supports Irish receives. It should be allowed to live or die on its own.

If I woke up tomorrow morning and could speak fluent Irish, I'd be delighted actually. Not because of any cultural benefit but because if and when I have kids and they are forced to learn Irish like I was, I can help them out a little more so they can do better in the exam.

themadchef · 09-12-2008 2:28pm

javaboy wrote: »

If I woke up tomorrow morning and could speak fluent Irish, I'd be delighted actually. Not because of any cultural benefit but because if and when I have kids and they are forced to learn Irish like I was, I can help them out a little more so they can do better in the exam.

There are at least 4 people in my class because they want to help their kids out with Irish.

AvrilLavigne · 09-12-2008 2:38pm

Wibbs wrote: »

Ehhhhh? So you're agreeing with my point then? You're not really the sharpest at this stuff

It relates to your lack of real life (friends)!

javaboy · 09-12-2008 2:43pm

themadchef wrote: »

There are at least 4 people in my class because they want to help their kids out with Irish.

My parents tried to do the same thing with evening classes but we learned quicker than they did so it didn't work.

Helping my future kids with Irish for school is the only non-hypocritical reason I can ever see for me learning Irish.

Boards Referendum - English as the first language of Republic of Ireland

Comments