Trevor Deely case - new witness

20Wheel · 09-12-2019 11:22PM

Fr Tod Umptious wrote: »

But why was this man in black no supposed to lose sight of Trevor, the tall, strong, young, junior IT engineer, who had been drinking but was not "legless" ?

What made Trevor such a target for this guy and his associates ?

I'm in fear of using by 10,000 post answering this rubbish

If you can't understand by now then please by all means just don't bother reading my posts.

Its really not that hard.

2 people ambush one person. Coming from both front and back.

I'll keep watching in the meantime for you to proffer something better than he jumped in the water coz reasons.

I think it will be quite a wait. Since you have contributed precisely zero to the thread thus far.
If this thread were a ship you'd be a barnacle. Going along for the journey, being slightly inconvenient and offering nothing.

Same to noodler. Just bench warming. Booing from the safety of the sidelines.

oneilla · 09-12-2019 11:24PM

RollieFingers wrote: »

The gates and layout are still the exact same as the time of this incident. Well the actual gate itself might be different, I'm not sure, but the layout hasn't changed. I don't actually know if it is still BOI in there, always presumed it is. Whatever company is there the building is still fully operational, they have their Xmas tree up.

There's still even CCTV cameras in the same places.

MonkieSocks · 09-12-2019 11:28PM

Fr Tod Umptious wrote: »

I now what you linkedis from the Gardai but as I said another Garda said on RTE that they were not sure.
I can't find a link to it but it was discussed on the old thread.

It is inconclusive, which is a pity because MIB at BOIAM and the guy walking doen Haddington Rd have never been identified

Think it's this one "Crimecall Trevor Deely April 2017"

noodler · 09-12-2019 11:28PM

20Wheel wrote: »

If you can't understand by now then please by all means just don't bother reading my posts.

Its really not that hard.

2 people ambush one person. Coming from both front and back.

I'll keep watching in the meantime for you to proffer something better than he jumped in the water coz reasons.

I think it will be quite a wait. Since you have contributed precisely zero to the thread thus far.
If this thread were a ship you'd be a barnacle. Going along for the journey, being slightly inconvenient and offering nothing.

Same to noodler. Just bench warming. Booing from the safety of the sidelines.

Perhaps this is where you have the thread all wrong.

It's not here for you constantly outdo yourself with more and more outlandish theories of spotters in Bucks, cars etc.

Certainly, no one is required to offer an alternative to your creative writing efforts in order to discredit them.

But go on, say again how anyone pouring cold water on your theories must be a paid lackie...or something

tdf7187 · 09-12-2019 11:31PM

https://extra.ie/2017/08/15/news/irish-news/i-dont-want-cash-reward-trevor-found-says-informant#foobox-1/2/trevor-deely-cctv.jpg

I think the girl in the photo on the right was not identified, or am I wrong?

20Wheel · 09-12-2019 11:31PM

noodler wrote: »

Perhaps this is where you have the thread all wrong.

It's not here for you constantly outdo yourself with more and more outlandish theories of spotters in Bucks, cars etc.

Certainly, no one is required to offer an alternative to your creative writing efforts in order to discredit them.

But go on, say again how anyone pouring cold water on your theories must be a paid lackie...or something

What's your theory then? Or even your contribution of any kind?

Other than changing 'car' to 'cars' and 'spotter' to 'spotters'.

noodler · 09-12-2019 11:33PM

20Wheel wrote: »

What's your theory then? Or even your contribution of any kind?

Are you under the impression someone needs to offer a theory to be "contributing" here?

By God, maybe you really do think this is creative writing 101.

Peter Flynt · 09-12-2019 11:41PM

I'm sure the crime families operating in the area at the time were, and still are, well known to the Gardaí and I've no doubt that AGS probably know exactly what happened to Trevor Deely but just have no further evidence (like a crime scene) to bring about prosecutions or any form of justice.

I do feel Trevor was being watched - definitely on the night he went missing but possibly for days or even weeks before.

If he did come to harm because of his association with working with Bank of Ireland then I can only assume it was because of some form of stupidity and/or incompetence on the part of the criminals. Did they think there were huge sums of money at Wilton Terrace? A safe that Trevor could lead them to?

It's possible that Trevor was abducted by a passing car in accomplice with MIB at WT/HR but once realising Trevor could not deliver what they wanted from him then they just panicked and did something completely unnecessary whilst out of their heads on coke/alcohol.

20Wheel · 09-12-2019 11:44PM

noodler wrote: »

Are you under the impression someone needs to offer a theory to be "contributing" here?

By God, maybe you really do think this is creative writing 101.

There's no rule, but I think most people know that sitting on the sidelines acting like you could do any better, and then not having the sack to make any effort is like being the fat bloke at the bar shouting at the football screen that he could score from there.

Is that you?

Come on give it a shot big man.

Noodlers contribution in 3... 2.... 1....

Fr Tod Umptious · 09-12-2019 11:44PM

MonkieSocks wrote: »

Think it's this one "Crimecall Trevor Deely April 2017"

Thank you, that's exactly it

2min 40sec in.

Keelan Shanley - "Are you definite that was the same male seen outside the bank talking to Trevor"

AGS - "No Keelan, we cannot definitely say that this is the same male but he would have the same appearance as the male in the earlier footage"

smelly sock · 09-12-2019 11:46PM

Peter Flynt wrote: »

I'm sure the crime families operating in the area at the time were, and still are, well known to the Gardaí and I've no doubt that AGS probably know exactly what happened to Trevor Deely but just have no further evidence (like a crime scene) to bring about prosecutions or any form of justice.

I do feel Trevor was being watched - definitely on the night he went missing but possibly for days or even weeks before.

If he did come to harm because of his association with working with Bank of Ireland then I can only assume it was because of some form of stupidity and/or incompetence on the part of the criminals. Did they think there were huge sums of money at Wilton Terrace? A safe that Trevor could lead them to?

It's possible that Trevor was abducted by a passing car in accomplice with MIB at WT/HR but once realising Trevor could not deliver what they wanted from him then they just panicked and did something completely unnecessary whilst out of their heads on coke/alcohol.

Its also possible Trevor had interactions with these criminals before and they were sick of him. A lot of things are possible. I'm not sure that this was premedtiated though. Who knows. I think we'd have to accept AGS when they say a chance altercation with a well known criminal gang. But how did it come about on haddington rd ffs.

20Wheel · 09-12-2019 11:47PM

Gardaí believe that the male acting suspiciously outside of Trevor’s place of work is the same male that is seen passing the Bank of Ireland ATM on Haddington Road at 4.14

https://www.garda.ie/en/Crime-Prevention/Crimecall-on-RTE/Crimecall-Episodes/2017/April-24/Missing-Person-Trevor-Deely.html

TheW1zard · 09-12-2019 11:49PM

Any updates on the new witness?

Fr Tod Umptious · 09-12-2019 11:50PM

20Wheel wrote: »

If you can't understand by now then please by all means just don't bother reading my posts.

Its really not that hard.

2 people ambush one person. Coming from both front and back.

I'll keep watching in the meantime for you to proffer something better than he jumped in the water coz reasons.

I think it will be quite a wait. Since you have contributed precisely zero to the thread thus far.
If this thread were a ship you'd be a barnacle. Going along for the journey, being slightly inconvenient and offering nothing.

Same to noodler. Just bench warming. Booing from the safety of the sidelines.

But why Trevor ?

Why the 22 year old big strong guy ?

Why wait 30+ mins for him in the rain with plenty of other targets ?

And why only Dec 8th 2000 ?

Why not every weekend night ?

If there was a spate of muggings by two people in the area it would be common knowledge and there would be warnings about it ?

Fr Tod Umptious · 09-12-2019 11:51PM

20Wheel wrote: »

Gardaelieve that the male acting suspiciously outside of Trevor’s place of work is the same male that is seen passing the Bank of Ireland ATM on Haddington Road at 4.14

https://www.garda.ie/en/Crime-Prevention/Crimecall-on-RTE/Crimecall-Episodes/2017/April-24/Missing-Person-Trevor-Deely.html

Yes their information on whether they believe the guys are the same person are totally ambiguous

smelly sock · 09-12-2019 11:52PM

Fr Tod Umptious wrote: »

Thank you, that's exactly it

2min 40sec in.

Keelan Shanley - "Are you definite that was the same male seen outside the bank talking to Trevor"

AGS - "No Keelan, we cannot definitely say that this is the same male but he would have the same appearance as the male in the earlier footage"

Interesting the amount of traffic and pedestrians in the footage. Across the road when Trevor is entering the bank you can clearly see pedestrians. You can also see cars. Same at the ATM. A car drives by. It was busy enough.

I know its neen clarified before but how did MIB get to the gate before Trevor?

STB. · 09-12-2019 11:53PM

smelly sock wrote: »

But how did it come about on haddington rd ffs.

"An informant who provided gardai with information that sparked a massive search for missing Trevor Deely has pointed the blame at a crime gang linked to the murder of a prostitute.

It is understood the notorious gang were involved in prostitution and heroin dealing at the time of Mr Deely's disappearance in December 2000.

A senior member of this gang is considered to be a dangerous criminal who was known to work as a pimp in the area where the Kildare man went missing.

This individual is understood to have been viewed as a suspect in the unsolved murder of prostitute Sinead Kelly - from Santry - in June 1998.

"It is understood the individual did identify the killer as a criminal and drug dealer who operated around the Baggot Street Bridge area" at that time.

The suspect identified is part of a Crumlin crime family responsible for bringing a contaminated consignment of heroin into Dublin from the UK in the 1980s, which led to the deaths of a number of heroin addicts in the city.

SOURCE: https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/gang-linked-to-womans-knifing-murdered-and-buried-missing-trevor-36052259.html

smelly sock · 09-12-2019 11:53PM

20Wheel wrote: »

Gardaí believe that the male acting suspiciously outside of Trevor’s place of work is the same male that is seen passing the Bank of Ireland ATM on Haddington Road at 4.14

https://www.garda.ie/en/Crime-Prevention/Crimecall-on-RTE/Crimecall-Episodes/2017/April-24/Missing-Person-Trevor-Deely.html

AGS totally contradict themselves. Guessing is all.

Peter Flynt · 09-12-2019 11:54PM

Fr Tod Umptious wrote: »

Thank you, that's exactly it

2min 40sec in.

Keelan Shanley - "Are you definite that was the same male seen outside the bank talking to Trevor"

AGS - "No Keelan, we cannot definitely say that this is the same male but he would have the same appearance as the male in the earlier footage"

As the website shows AGS believe that MIB 1 & 2 are the same person.

That Garda says he cannot definitely say but then qualifies it with a "but etc. . "

I'd be more inclined to agree with the Garda website which definitively states that they believe MIB 1/2 are the same person.

Muahahaha · 09-12-2019 11:55PM

Fr Tod Umptious wrote: »

I now what you linkedis from the Gardai but as I said another Garda said on RTE that they were not sure.
I can't find a link to it but it was discussed on the old thread.

It is inconclusive, which is a pity because MIB at BOIAM and the guy walking doen Haddington Rd have never been identified

I think that comes from the CCTV experts in the UK who said something along the lines that it is more than likely that MIB is the same in both outside BOIAM CCTV and the Haddington Rd CCTV. So there isnt 100% certainty just a strong possibility.

I would imagine the only way the CCTV experts could arrive at that conclusion is to find out the distance between the cameras and the point on the ground where he is standing and then do some triangulation to find out a rough idea of his height, distance between his shoulders, etc and then do that again with the Haddington Road footage and then compare the two measurements to arrive at their more that likely conclusion. Also both figures dressing entirely in black and both following TDs movements and the chances of it being the same person in both CCTV tapes goes up and up. But they can never say it with 100% certainity, just a high probability.

smelly sock · 09-12-2019 11:56PM

STB. wrote: »

"An informant who provided gardai with information that sparked a massive search for missing Trevor Deely has pointed the blame at a crime gang linked to the murder of a prostitute.

It is understood the notorious gang were involved in prostitution and heroin dealing at the time of Mr Deely's disappearance in December 2000.

A senior member of this gang is considered to be a dangerous criminal who was known to work as a pimp in the area where the Kildare man went missing.

This individual is understood to have been viewed as a suspect in the unsolved murder of prostitute Sinead Kelly - from Santry - in June 1998.

"It is understood the individual did identify the killer as a criminal and drug dealer who operated around the Baggot Street Bridge area" at that time.

The suspect identified is part of a Crumlin crime family responsible for bringing a contaminated consignment of heroin into Dublin from the UK in the 1980s, which led to the deaths of a number of heroin addicts in the city.

SOURCE: https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/gang-linked-to-womans-knifing-murdered-and-buried-missing-trevor-36052259.html

I mean the interaction with Trevor didnt happen by chance surely. There must be a little more to it. Not premeditiated in the days leading up to it but TD must have had reason to interact with them. A mugging ending up with a murder and a body being vanished.

tdf7187 · 09-12-2019 11:56PM

Fr Tod Umptious wrote: »

But why Trevor ?

Why the 22 year old big strong guy ?

Why wait 30+ mins for him in the rain with plenty of other targets ?

And why only Dec 8th 2000 ?

Why not every weekend night ?

If there was a spate of muggings by two people in the area it would be common knowledge and there would be warnings about it ?

Take it up with AGS.

Peter Flynt · 09-12-2019 11:58PM

smelly sock wrote: »

Its also possible Trevor had interactions with these criminals before and they were sick of him.

Probably unlikely though simply because there's no evidence to back that up.

There is evidence that dodgy characters were watching BoI and taking/receiving phone calls as Trevor arrived at BoI and appearing to be following him in the final footage.

They made their way to him.
Not the other way around.

smelly sock · 09-12-2019 11:59PM

Fr Tod Umptious wrote: »

But why Trevor ?

Why the 22 year old big strong guy ?

Why wait 30+ mins for him in the rain with plenty of other targets ?

And why only Dec 8th 2000 ?

Why not every weekend night ?

If there was a spate of muggings by two people in the area it would be common knowledge and there would be warnings about it ?

In certain circumstances victims might not report muggings.

smelly sock · 10-12-2019 12:00AM

Peter Flynt wrote: »

Probably unlikely though simply because there's no evidence to back that up.

There is evidence that dodgy characters were watching BoI and taking/receiving phone calls as Trevor arrived at BoI and appearing to be following him in the final footage.

They made their way to him.
Not the other way around.

One dodgy character though Pete.

STB. · 10-12-2019 12:03AM

smelly sock wrote: »

I mean the interaction with Trevor didnt happen by chance surely. There must be a little more to it. Not premeditiated in the days leading up to it but TD must have had reason to interact with them. A mugging ending up with a murder and a body being vanished.

According to someone who provided information in 2017, yes, that's exactly what happened.

These things can and do actually happen!

20Wheel · 10-12-2019 12:04AM

Fr Tod Umptious wrote: »

But why Trevor ?

Why the 22 year old big strong guy ?

Why wait 30+ mins for him in the rain with plenty of other targets ?

And why only Dec 8th 2000 ?

Why not every weekend night ?

If there was a spate of muggings by two people in the area it would be common knowledge and there would be warnings about it ?

1.Cause they know him from him working in their area. Know him to be a civil, mild type. A young country lad.

2.Cause they know his route home. And that he'd had a few drinks. And that he's been to the atm.

3.their history of crimes are unknown. Although there's something to that. If there was a sudden dip in petty crimes, if someone turned into a regular saint immediately after the 8th then it could suggest heads being kept down.

4.multiple possibilities. Why do anything on a given day.

Who says it needs to be part of a spate. Endless possibilities. Maybe they lost at the bookies. Maybe they were behind on rent. You name it.

What do think happened and how does it line up with anything we know for certain, or that the gardai say.

smelly sock · 10-12-2019 12:04AM

STB. wrote: »

According to someone who provided information in 2017, yes, that's exactly what happened.

These things can and do actually happen!

Oh i know. And i agree. But getting rid of the body like that doesnt just happen.

STB. · 10-12-2019 12:06AM

smelly sock wrote: »

Oh i know. And i agree. But getting rid of the body like that doesnt just happen.

Getting rid of bodies happens all the time!

We only read about the ones that get caught or where the body turns up.

smelly sock · 10-12-2019 12:08AM

STB. wrote: »

Getting rid of bodies happens all the time!

We only read about the ones that get caught or where the body turns up.

No it doesnt. Maybe to drug dealers and such it does but not to a young innocent chap. That doesnt happen that much at all.

Trevor Deely case - new witness

Comments