Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Please note that it is not permitted to have referral links posted in your signature. Keep these links contained in the appropriate forum. Thank you.

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2055940817/signature-rules

ESB eCars pricing introduction

1192022242543

Comments

  • Moderators Posts: 12,424 ✭✭✭✭Black_Knight


    celtic_oz wrote: »
    My car wont take FCP.

    I cant believe this is not known for definite.. if the slow ones will continue to work if you dont sign up

    As far as I remember, the free ones will still work even if you don't sign up.

    Do you depend that heavily on the slow chargers? Sounds like good reason to add fees to the SCP :P


  • Moderators, Motoring & Transport Moderators, Regional East Moderators Posts: 8,264 Mod ✭✭✭✭liamog


    celtic_oz wrote: »
    My car wont take FCP.

    I cant believe this is not known for definite.. if the slow ones will continue to work if you dont sign up

    This is probably the most relevant bit
    Will my existing Northern Ireland (ecarNI) charge point access card work?
    Your existing charge point access card will continue to work on the AC charge points in Ireland, as well as on the AC and rapid units in Northern Ireland. However you will need to sign up via the ESB ecar connect app or via the ESB ecars website to use the fast charger network in Ireland.

    So sounds like an unregistered eCars card should be ok on the AC network


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 116 ✭✭Northumberland


    Is it just me that does not really understand how to use the ESB rapid chargers from Monday 18th Nov onwards?

    I was already registered with an 'old card' which worked fine. I re-registered on the ESB website last week and entered the number for my old card, got a confirmation email, replied to it (no answer), but see from the ESB website that my account is set up, complete with my debit card info. I even see that charges that I made in the last month or two are recorded under my account, with zero cost. So far so good.

    Now - my questions - to ESB or to any Board participant that knows, or thinks they know, any of the answers -

    a) Is there any physical change to the charger hardware being installed? That is, when I go across to my nearest fast charger, on the N2 North outside of Monaghan town, will I notice anything different there at all? My presumption is NO.

    b) When I go to that charger today, I place my 'old card' over the reader, and the machine instructs me to proceed, I can leave my car there for as long as I feel like- if I had no care for other users, (although the connector automatically disconnects when car almost completely charged). When I go to that same charger on Monday 18th, what happens? will I notice anything different? or do I just scan my same 'old ESB card' wait until told to connect, connect up and the car starts charging. And, when I log in to my ESB account some time later, I will see that I have been charged so much for so many kWh used at that charger. Is that the way it will work? If that is correct, why do ESB eCars not make that clear, or have they and I have just missed seeing it?

    c) related to the above I suppose, but if the answer to the above is YES, that is the way it will work, then I assume that I DO NOT NEED to travel with my DEBIT card or show it to the machine when I need a charge - the only card I will need is the same old trusty ESB card that I was issued with over a year ago? If this is the case, I wonder why ESB have chosen to base their charging system on debit cards rather than storing bank details? Also, I registered my wife's debit card on my account as well as my own, my own is listed as 'default' or something - so I assume that my card will be charged whenever the ESB charge card is read, and my wife's car will only be charged if I change the 'default' online. And what happens if my debit card has insufficient funds to pay for the charge? will the charge be refused? or will an attempt be made to charge the 'secondary' card that I have registered?

    c) What about the 'overstay' charge, is that also being implemented on Monday 18th Nov? So, if I leave my car at that same Monaghan charger on Monday for say 90 minutes, will I find that there is an additional overstay charge debited to my account?.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,569 ✭✭✭ethernet


    Is there any physical change to the charger hardware being installed?
    Don't think so. Probably just changes to the firmware on the device. The AC units are being updated though - swapped out for different models.
    b) When I go to that charger today, I place my 'old card' over the reader, and the machine instructs me to proceed, I can leave my car there for as long as I feel like- if I had no care for other users, (although the connector automatically disconnects when car almost completely charged). When I go to that same charger on Monday 18th, what happens? will I notice anything different? or do I just scan my same 'old ESB card' wait until told to connect, connect up and the car starts charging. And, when I log in to my ESB account some time later, I will see that I have been charged so much for so many kWh used at that charger. Is that the way it will work? If that is correct, why do ESB eCars not make that clear, or have they and I have just missed seeing it?
    Same process. Use your membership card to start and stop the charge session. I imagine it will work that way - check online (or the app, whenever it finally arrives) to check usage for a particular session; presumably along with the associated cost. They have a video showing how to charge. It didn't seem to highlight any changes.
    c) related to the above I suppose, but if the answer to the above is YES, that is the way it will work, then I assume that I DO NOT NEED to travel with my DEBIT card or show it to the machine when I need a charge - the only card I will need is the same old trusty ESB card that I was issued with over a year ago? If this is the case, I wonder why ESB have chosen to base their charging system on debit cards rather than storing bank details? Also, I registered my wife's debit card on my account as well as my own, my own is listed as 'default' or something - so I assume that my card will be charged whenever the ESB charge card is read, and my wife's car will only be charged if I change the 'default' online. And what happens if my debit card has insufficient funds to pay for the charge? will the charge be refused? or will an attempt be made to charge the 'secondary' card that I have registered?
    Just keep using your ESB eCars card - no using bank cards at the machine (at least for launch - it would be nice for very casual users). You can also use the website or app (again, when it finally arrives on all platforms). I'd rather tie it to a card rather than a bank account but that's just me - I'm sure there's a good reason they've made this decision: security implications or obligations, costs, etc. Regarding payment, if you read the T&Cs, you'll see they reserve the right to stop you using the service and pass your details onto debt collectors if you don't settle your account. Also, if makes sense that all changes default to the one card registered to the account. Really, a lot of your questions come down to the system implementation - and we have no detailed insight into that right now.
    c) What about the 'overstay' charge, is that also being implemented on Monday 18th Nov? So, if I leave my car at that same Monaghan charger on Monday for say 90 minutes, will I find that there is an additional overstay charge debited to my account?.

    It should come into effect then, yes. And don't try to circumvent it either by stopping before the max time and starting another session as that is also prohibited as per the T&Cs.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 13,837 ✭✭✭✭JPA


    So using any RFID has worked in the past, was this resolved or will it just not work anymore from Monday?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 116 ✭✭Northumberland


    JPA wrote: »
    So using any RFID has worked in the past, was this resolved or will it just not work anymore from Monday?

    I think you will find that 'any RFID card' will not even work today, at least on the fast chargers, perhaps on all the chargers. I think that ESB did something a month or two ago so that the chargers now actually do need a proper ESB card to work. I say this because my new online ESB e-cars account has a record of my charging activity over the last two months. No way they could have got that information without reading my ESB issued RFID card and relating it back to the info I gave them at sign up. So, the good old days of just using a discarded hotel key card to get a free charger are over.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,081 ✭✭✭fricatus


    I say this because my new online ESB e-cars account has a record of my charging activity over the last two months.

    How did you see this information? When I go into https://myaccount.esbecars.com and access Profile > Charge History, there's nothing listed for the period (which is set to all of 2019).

    In fairness, the last time I used a public charger was 28 October, but if they started gathering the information two months ago, as your data seems to suggest, some public charger use should show in my record.

    Maybe I have a "stealth card" and will be able to charge for free! :D


  • Moderators Posts: 12,424 ✭✭✭✭Black_Knight


    Is it just me that does not really understand how to use the ESB rapid chargers from Monday 18th Nov onwards?

    Sounds like you've a pretty decent idea about how to use rapid chargers from Monday 18th.

    Only you mentioned it I wouldn't of known there was/is a charging history in your online account. Neat


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 726 ✭✭✭kaahooters


    ive a possible dumb question.

    in work we have ecars 7kw points, activated by the ecard card.

    are they going to be charged, no one in works seems to know, and our rep hasn't gotten back to us on it


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 66,659 ✭✭✭✭unkel


    No. For the moment it is only fast charge points that will be charged. There is no date set yet for when slow charge points will be charged. Maybe sometime next year. You will get plenty of notice on this forum when that happens :)


  • Advertisement
  • Moderators Posts: 12,424 ✭✭✭✭Black_Knight


    fricatus wrote: »
    How did you see this information? When I go into https://myaccount.esbecars.com and access Profile > Charge History, there's nothing listed for the period (which is set to all of 2019).

    In fairness, the last time I used a public charger was 28 October, but if they started gathering the information two months ago, as your data seems to suggest, some public charger use should show in my record.

    Maybe I have a "stealth card" and will be able to charge for free! :D

    Earliest charge I have on mine is 2nd Nov. Tis nice detail in it. Time, location, duration, connector used, kWh used and cost. Includes the slow chargers too.

    Gives a nice summary up the top. Total kWh, Total time and total cost.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 116 ✭✭Northumberland


    I just checked again, yes, the info that I got is from PROFILE -> CHARGE HISTORY. I have three entries on my charge history, the first is actually from 31st October, and it is labelled 'type 2' - which seems to mean the AC slow charger. So we may both be correct, and that they only started recording charge history linked to our accounts after 28th October but before the 31st October. I have two more entries appearing on 9th November, both for using the CHAdeMO fast charger in Blanchardstown. My 2 conclusions remain the same 1) any random RFID card will no longer work on EITHER the slow AC or the fast chargers now and 2) registered users should be able to see a complete charge history, for both paid for and for free charges on AC, from 31st October 2019 onwards.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 116 ✭✭Northumberland


    Just looked again at the new ecars charging map online, which will perhaps be what will appear on the App when it is finally released. Is it just me again, or have others noticed?. On the new map, with complex colour coding, I found it impossible to quickly determine where the fast chargers were compared to all chargers. It is only when you click on a selected charger that you learn what it's capacity is. This seems to me to be a backward step. On the old ecar connect, map, which I still have on my ipad, the single most useful thing for me is to see the location of the CHAdeMO DC 50kW chargers in clear blue colour and the rest of the Type-2 AC Socket 22kW chargers in a clear green colour. If others agree that this functionality has been lost on the new map which is online, perhaps there is a way to communicate this to eCars before they finalise the app? Or is this possibly a deliberate move to 'hide' the location of the fast chargers for some reason?


  • Moderators Posts: 12,424 ✭✭✭✭Black_Knight


    Just looked again at the new ecars charging map online, which will perhaps be what will appear on the App when it is finally released. Is it just me again, or have others noticed?. On the new map, with complex colour coding, I found it impossible to quickly determine where the fast chargers were compared to all chargers. It is only when you click on a selected charger that you learn what it's capacity is. This seems to me to be a backward step. On the old ecar connect, map, which I still have on my ipad, the single most useful thing for me is to see the location of the CHAdeMO DC 50kW chargers in clear blue colour and the rest of the Type-2 AC Socket 22kW chargers in a clear green colour. If others agree that this functionality has been lost on the new map which is online, perhaps there is a way to communicate this to eCars before they finalise the app? Or is this possibly a deliberate move to 'hide' the location of the fast chargers for some reason?

    Use the filter. In the search bar, on the right. The colour coding is now used to denote charger state, rather than type.


  • Moderators, Motoring & Transport Moderators, Regional East Moderators Posts: 8,264 Mod ✭✭✭✭liamog


    Use the filter. In the search bar, on the right. The colour coding is now used to denote charger state, rather than type.

    That's probably something that CCS users are more used to, on the old map we always had to switch as it showed CHAdeMO by default.


  • Moderators Posts: 12,424 ✭✭✭✭Black_Knight


    liamog wrote: »
    That's probably something that CCS users are more used to, on the old map we always had to switch as it showed CHAdeMO by default.

    Viva la revolution!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 116 ✭✭Northumberland


    Thanks, obvious once you know! I have never seen an icon showing a funnel as the toggle for showing the FILTER to select different types of charger, but remember my chemistry days now, filter funnel!

    With reference to my earlier questions about how exactly to start a charge on a fast charger as from next Monday, my confusion was increased by the bold statement on the online map - CONNECT CHARGE CABLE, SWIPE TO CHARGE? Swipe what I am thinking, my debit card, my ESB card, swipe it where? But the video makes it clear, you are supposed to swipe across the 'app' on your smartphone to start the charge - very good - but it does not look like the app will be available by Monday, so in the meantime, use the old charge card, tap on the machine as before. Now I get it, I think!


  • Moderators Posts: 12,424 ✭✭✭✭Black_Knight


    Thanks, obvious once you know! I have never seen an icon showing a funnel as the toggle for showing the FILTER to select different types of charger, but remember my chemistry days now, filter funnel!

    With reference to my earlier questions about how exactly to start a charge on a fast charger as from next Monday, my confusion was increased by the bold statement on the online map - CONNECT CHARGE CABLE, SWIPE TO CHARGE? Swipe what I am thinking, my debit card, my ESB card, swipe it where? But the video makes it clear, you are supposed to swipe across the 'app' on your smartphone to start the charge - very good - but it does not look like the app will be available by Monday, so in the meantime, use the old charge card, tap on the machine as before. Now I get it, I think!

    I'll give you the benefit of the doubt here and assume you're not trolling, but the "swipe" refers to the big "CONNECT & SWIPE TO START" slider they implemented.

    7846e433d85c80a1f8ecc8cbce27de41.png


  • Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 7,308 Mod ✭✭✭✭charlieIRL


    When i check my charging history on the ecars website it only list 3 times i've used public charging. I've used it about 10 times!!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 129 ✭✭Mupchease


    charlieIRL wrote: »
    When i check my charging history on the ecars website it only list 3 times i've used public charging. I've used it about 10 times!!

    It shows only once for myself since I registered the card for the new payments. Did you do all 10 while registered ?

    Just a heads up for others it would be no harm getting the Bosch app. I had to use it a few days ago at a charger that the rfid card wasn’t working on. After 16 minutes waiting for ecars to answer the phone I gave up and used the app.


  • Advertisement
  • Administrators, Computer Games Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 32,784 Admin ✭✭✭✭✭Mickeroo


    Mupchease wrote: »
    It shows only once for myself since I registered the card for the new payments. Did you do all 10 while registered ?

    Just a heads up for others it would be no harm getting the Bosch app. I had to use it a few days ago at a charger that the rfid card wasn’t working on. After 16 minutes waiting for ecars to answer the phone I gave up and used the app.

    Is that still working on the rapid chargers?


  • Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 7,308 Mod ✭✭✭✭charlieIRL


    Mupchease wrote: »
    It shows only once for myself since I registered the card for the new payments. Did you do all 10 while registered ?

    Just a heads up for others it would be no harm getting the Bosch app. I had to use it a few days ago at a charger that the rfid card wasn’t working on. After 16 minutes waiting for ecars to answer the phone I gave up and used the app.

    Its showing 2 from before i registered and one after.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 129 ✭✭Mupchease


    Mickeroo wrote: »
    Is that still working on the rapid chargers?

    I’ve used it only on rapids. I’ve never got stuck needing it for a destination charger.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 66,659 ✭✭✭✭unkel


    Before the start of this month, I had maybe public fast charged once or twice in the last year. But have done so 4 times this month. The first time, I needed as driving beyond the range of my car. The other times were just because I could (had to be at the location of the fast chargers anyway and they were free)

    All 4 were neatly recorded, duration, kWh consumed, everything. Nice!


  • Administrators, Computer Games Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 32,784 Admin ✭✭✭✭✭Mickeroo


    Mupchease wrote: »
    I’ve used it only on rapids. I’ve never got stuck needing it for a destination charger.

    Ah right, just wondering as someone had said to me it stopped worknig since they updated the chargers in preparation for the charges.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 116 ✭✭Northumberland


    I'll give you the benefit of the doubt here and assume you're not trolling, but the "swipe" refers to the big "CONNECT & SWIPE TO START" slider they implemented.

    7846e433d85c80a1f8ecc8cbce27de41.png

    No, Black Knight, I am not trolling - just trying to understand what I will have to do next Monday or Tuesday stuck at a fast charger in the cold and rain and hoping to start charging. I thought it might be better to learn as much as I can from my desk. OK, I see the nice big CONNECT AND SWIPE TO START slider on the new ESB online map when you select the charger. So, it looks like that IF I have a good internet connection when I am at the fast charger, and I can download the new ESB map on my phone or ipad at that time, i can plug the car in and swipe to charge - great, I will try it. But my understanding is that the new ESB app has not been released yet, just checked and it still seems to be the old one, with no Swipe to Charge, so we are still waiting for that, which will presumably be more convenient than having to download from the ESB website each time you want to charge - or stop charging. In the meantime seems more practical to just use the card I suppose.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,492 ✭✭✭McGiver


    No, Black Knight, I am not trolling - just trying to understand what I will have to do next Monday or Tuesday stuck at a fast charger in the cold and rain and hoping to start charging. I thought it might be better to learn as much as I can from my desk. OK, I see the nice big CONNECT AND SWIPE TO START slider on the new ESB online map when you select the charger. So, it looks like that IF I have a good internet connection when I am at the fast charger, and I can download the new ESB map on my phone or ipad at that time, i can plug the car in and swipe to charge - great, I will try it. But my understanding is that the new ESB app has not been released yet, just checked and it still seems to be the old one, with no Swipe to Charge, so we are still waiting for that, which will presumably be more convenient than having to download from the ESB website each time you want to charge - or stop charging. In the meantime seems more practical to just use the card I suppose.
    I've found a bug. You can swipe the thingy even though you're not connected. It will make the charger stuck for a while (I'd say 1 minute) and it will show it as occupied as well in the meantime...not smart.


  • Moderators, Motoring & Transport Moderators, Regional East Moderators Posts: 8,264 Mod ✭✭✭✭liamog


    No, Black Knight, I am not trolling - just trying to understand what I will have to do next Monday or Tuesday stuck at a fast charger in the cold and rain and hoping to start charging. I thought it might be better to learn as much as I can from my desk. OK, I see the nice big CONNECT AND SWIPE TO START slider on the new ESB online map when you select the charger. So, it looks like that IF I have a good internet connection when I am at the fast charger, and I can download the new ESB map on my phone or ipad at that time, i can plug the car in and swipe to charge - great, I will try it. But my understanding is that the new ESB app has not been released yet, just checked and it still seems to be the old one, with no Swipe to Charge, so we are still waiting for that, which will presumably be more convenient than having to download from the ESB website each time you want to charge - or stop charging. In the meantime seems more practical to just use the card I suppose.

    An Internet connection is required for the app to work too, the only system that will work without you having an Internet connection is the registered RFID card.


  • Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 7,308 Mod ✭✭✭✭charlieIRL


    McGiver wrote: »
    I've found a bug. You can swipe the thingy even though you're not connected. It will make the charger stuck for a while (I'd say 1 minute) and it will show it as occupied as well in the meantime...not smart.

    Hope you can't stop someone's charge the same way.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,492 ✭✭✭McGiver


    charlieIRL wrote: »
    Hope you can't stop someone's charge the same way.

    Nope you can't. But it's wrong that you can block any charger for a minute.


Advertisement