Something called eSports on Sky Sports

scamalert · 30-03-2019 5:28pm

Mrcaramelchoc wrote: »

Sport : definition

an activity involving physical exertion and skill in which an individual or team competes against another or others for entertainment.

Ill just leave that there.

Esports me arse.

if you imagine pressing any keys fast is considered pro give it a shot and let us know once you replace working for living punching buttons to being pro and getting paid 5 digits for that.

Potential-Monke · 30-03-2019 5:33pm

Comfy Af Atm Tbh wrote: »

Computer games are an amusing diversion for children, that's it really.

Wow... You could practice playing Through the Fire and the Flames on Guitar Hero for years and still not be able to play it without mistakes. Stupid analogy.

Again, funny hearing someone call another person childish for being a gamer, which in itself is a childish remark. Top points.

scamalert · 30-03-2019 5:47pm

Potential-Monke wrote: »

Wow... You could practice playing Through the Fire and the Flames on Guitar Hero for years and still not be able to play it without mistakes. Stupid analogy.

Again, funny hearing someone call another person childish for being a gamer, which in itself is a childish remark. Top points.

no point explaining as old generation only thinks theres value in sweat and hard work, same people will say trading isnt a job either surely those few in 1% are just fcking around with buy and sell. Now imagine kid 13yr old making more per match then someone who grind in life for decades to make same amount per year and you'll get millions reasons why smth isn't to their liking.
Just because it seems that something doesnt require skill and high IQ never mind reaction and motor skills involved strategy, i could name hundreds sports/professions where id say they are pushing pen and paper for a living, seems easy yet only few get to do it.

JohnnyFlash · 30-03-2019 5:57pm

Potential-Monke wrote: »

Wow... You could practice playing Through the Fire and the Flames on Guitar Hero for years and still not be able to play it without mistakes. Stupid analogy.

Again, funny hearing someone call another person childish for being a gamer, which in itself is a childish remark. Top points.

You still aren’t playing guitar though. Just a simulation of it.

Potential-Monke · 30-03-2019 6:17pm

JohnnyFlash wrote: »

You still aren’t playing guitar though. Just a simulation of it.

K

the_pen_turner · 30-03-2019 6:24pm

If someone has cancer and can't speak for themselves but uses one of those boxes that speaks for them.

Are you really having a conversation with them or is it only a computer simulation.

Potential-Monke · 30-03-2019 6:28pm

Here, if its so easy to be a gamer so, off with ye, buy either a PC and VR headset (really expensive) or a PS4 and PSVR, get Beat Saber and 100% this without missing anything. By the way, you have 2 controllers which are like the hilt of the sabers you can see in this, so you're physically swinging your arms to cut the blocks of the same colour in the direction of the arrow. This one is only out a couple of weeks, so you have time to get it done before anyone else and make money from it (as Beat Saber is about to take off imo).

If this game becomes professional, and people start making money off it (people made money off Guitar Hero), is it still not a sport, even though there's a physicality to it, you get out of breath and sweat, just like 'real' sports?

sonic85 · 30-03-2019 7:35pm

How did this turn into gamers calling people out of touch and non gamers saying these games are not real? None of that has anything to do with the OP.

I 100% agree with the OP - if I pay a sub for Sky Sports I want to see soccer, american football, basketball, MMA etc. I definitely don't want to turn on and see lads playing video games. It's as simple as that

sk8erboii · 30-03-2019 7:50pm

sonic85 wrote: »

How did this turn into gamers calling people out of touch and non gamers saying these games are not real? None of that has anything to do with the OP.

I 100% agree with the OP - if I pay a sub for Sky Sports I want to see soccer, american football, basketball, MMA etc. I definitely don't want to turn on and see lads playing video games. It's as simple as that

Because its true. You’d have to be out of touch to ignore the esports industry

https://www.investopedia.com/news/booming-esports-industry-hit-138b-2018/

Nobody’s taking anything away from you. All theyre doing is adding in another revenue stream and a younger audience.

Its really not that hard to understand. Unless youre out of touch.

cdeb · 30-03-2019 8:16pm

sonic85 wrote: »

I 100% agree with the OP - if I pay a sub for Sky Sports I want to see soccer, american football, basketball, MMA etc. I definitely don't want to turn on and see lads playing video games. It's as simple as that

I dunno. If I paid for a sub for Sky Sports and got American football, basketball and MMA, I'd be fairly pissed off. I definitely don't want to turn on and watch stuff which would get a 5-year jail sentence in real life. Horses for courses like.

I don't have any interest in egaming/esports - there's issues over videogame addiction for one; they're not really team sports, which may give rise to general social interaction and cooperation issues; and I think FIFA (one of the most popular esports I think) is actually quite **** compared to actually going to a real football game - but I think the competition is legitimate. It goes further back than the last ten years too; wiki says the first computer game tournament was in 1972, and there was Gamesmaster on Channel 4 for 6 years in the 90s. It's probably only in the last decade that it's become effectively pro though.

I think there's poor arguments on both sides in this thread; the "grumpy out-of-touch old men" and the nonsense about multiple genders on the pro side, and the "anyone can master a computer game" stuff on the contra side. Neither side is really helping themselves with comments like that.

sonic85 · 30-03-2019 9:48pm

cdeb wrote: »

I dunno. If I paid for a sub for Sky Sports and got American football, basketball and MMA, I'd be fairly pissed off. I definitely don't want to turn on and watch stuff which would get a 5-year jail sentence in real life. Horses for courses like.

I don't really know what you're trying to say here to be honest. If you turned on Sky Sports and seen sports you'd be pissed off? You don't like MMA I presume which is grand but it's a sport. You can't say the same for a lad playing Fifa 2019 or NBA 2k.

I have nothing against computer games. I used to play them quite a lot myself - I just don't think a dedicated sports channel is the place for them

sonic85 · 30-03-2019 9:54pm

sk8erboii wrote: »

Because its true. You’d have to be out of touch to ignore the esports industry

https://www.investopedia.com/news/booming-esports-industry-hit-138b-2018/

Nobody’s taking anything away from you. All theyre doing is adding in another revenue stream and a younger audience.

Its really not that hard to understand. Unless youre out of touch.

Nobody's ignoring it man - if it's huge it's huge and fair play to the lads that are making money from it. It's not a sport though and you can't argue that fact. And the constant out of touch jibes are just coming across as really childish TBH

cdeb · 30-03-2019 9:57pm

sonic85 wrote: »

I don't really know what you're trying to say here to be honest. If you turned on Sky Sports and seen sports you'd be pissed off? You don't like MMA I presume which is grand but it's a sport. You can't say the same for a lad playing Fifa 2019 or NBA 2k.

I have nothing against computer games. I used to play them quite a lot myself - I just don't think a dedicated sports channel is the place for them

Yeah, MMA is bollox. That's another thread of course, and I'm not going to try persuade you otherwise if you like it.

Is it a sport? Yeah, it is (though I hate to really call it a sport as most sports tend not to be utterly illegal if played by kids on the green in a housing estate)

But my point is that people like different things - I don't like most of the sports you mentioned, so I would be annoyed if I turned on the TV and that's all that was on. Snooker, a League of Ireland game, a bit of hurling - great. But others would be annoyed if those were on of course.

I do find the idea that people would want to watch other people playing computer games weird - partly because I don't think FIFA is even that realistic, so it pales compared to watching an actual football game - but if there's money there, then I can understand sports TV stations showing eSports. If you don't want to watch, there's 752 other channels to choose from - or you could go for a walk, read a book or even play some sport. I'm not sure anyone is claiming they're actual sports, and I certainly wouldn't be giving government funding to them in the way regular sports are financed.

Skylinehead · 30-03-2019 10:02pm

FrankieFeeler wrote: »

They are not real as sports because the sport that is being contested in an e-sport is not happening just a simulation of the sport based on a computer program that has been designed by somebody.

In madden e-sport competition a football is not being thrown, players are not catching the ball, there is no running or tackling.In a real game of a american football all of those things happen.

99% of the work in an e-sport is done by the person who has designed the game if the game is designed badly nothing happens. 100% of the work in a real sport is being done by the person playing it. Nobody apart from Lionel Messi causes him to pass a ball accurately for an accurate pass to be executed in the FIFA computer game a programmer must design a program properly so that when a button is pressed what is supposed to happen will happen.

Technically this conversation isn't 100% real as once again it depends on a computer program to be programmed correctly. What if when I input the letter A the program for boards is designed badly and so the output is B on the other side.Everything I type here depends on the program for boards to work properly, everything I say in reality is 100% based on me .

Is motorsport sport? The driver presses the accelerator, which tells a computer to make the car go faster...

sk8erboii · 30-03-2019 10:05pm

Game Changer wrote: »

You're comparing playing a guitar with taping buttons on a piece of plastic?

You realise that's like comparing masturbation with making love to a beautiful woman, right?

Mastrbation is a sport (;

sonic85 · 30-03-2019 10:06pm

cdeb wrote: »

Yeah, MMA is bollox. That's another thread of course, and I'm not going to try persuade you otherwise if you like it.

Is it a sport? Yeah, it is (though I hate to really call it a sport as most sports tend not to be utterly illegal if played by kids on the green in a housing estate)

But my point is that people like different things - I don't like most of the sports you mentioned, so I would be annoyed if I turned on the TV and that's all that was on. Snooker, a League of Ireland game, a bit of hurling - great. But others would be annoyed if those were on of course.

I do find the idea that people would want to watch other people playing computer games weird - partly because I don't think FIFA is even that realistic, so it pales compared to watching an actual football game - but if there's money there, then I can understand sports TV stations showing eSports. If you don't want to watch, there's 752 other channels to choose from - or you could go for a walk, read a book or even play some sport. I'm not sure anyone is claiming they're actual sports, and I certainly wouldn't be giving government funding to them in the way regular sports are financed.

Yeah let's just give the MMA thing a wide berth. I like it and know it's not for everyone - I just used it as an example. To call it bollocks is a load of bollocks though but it's your opinion.

Hold on though - most of the other 752 stations I don't have to pay for and that's the point. That's why I pay for Sky or BT or whatever - for sports not computer games. There was actually a channel at one stage that showed gaming. Not sure if it still exists but it was there at one point in time. If gaming is that popular which some people in this thread are suggesting - wouldn't it make more sense to have a dedicated channel for it?

cdeb · 30-03-2019 10:12pm

But why should paying for a channel give you carte blanche to decide what's on it?

I don't like MMA (and let's use this as a general example). If I pay for a Sky Sports sub and there's MMA on, that doesn't give me the right to give out. You just watch something else.

I get that you don't consider eSports an actual sport, and I tend to agree, but then there's poker on Sky as well. Is that a sport? I don't think so (though I'm aware I defended chess as a sport earlier in the thread, so I may be contradicting myself here). But that doesn't mean I'm entitled to complain that my money is being wasted because there's poker on the sports channel I pay for.

It's just horses for courses.

Turtwig · 30-03-2019 10:22pm

Each to their own. Nobody gets a monopoly on what is and isn't a sport. All aspects of human skill and dexterity should be appreciated. Nothing more exciting in my eyes than people at the peak of their abilities competing with and against one another.Esports deserves an audience. Whether it's a "sport" or not is immaterial.

Now if we could complain about the shoutcasting commentary then I'd agree that sh1t needs to be killed with fire!

sonic85 · 30-03-2019 10:22pm

cdeb wrote: »

But why should paying for a channel give you carte blanche to decide what's on it?

I don't like MMA (and let's use this as a general example). If I pay for a Sky Sports sub and there's MMA on, that doesn't give me the right to give out. You just watch something else.

I get that you don't consider eSports an actual sport, and I tend to agree, but then there's poker on Sky as well. Is that a sport? I don't think so (though I'm aware I defended chess as a sport earlier in the thread, so I may be contradicting myself here). But that doesn't mean I'm entitled to complain that my money is being wasted because there's poker on the sports channel I pay for.

It's just horses for courses.

I don't really know why were arguing here because I think our opinions aren't radically different.

I never said I want carte blanche to decide what's on - there's loads of stuff on sports channels I have no interest in whatsoever but even though I have no interest in them they are sports and they have their place on sports channels. Gaming of any description doesn't belong on dedicated sports channels IMO. And I agree chess or poker or any of that type of sh!te shouldn't be aired on them either. Again, IMO

aaronjumper · 30-03-2019 10:39pm

JohnnyFlash wrote: »

who would actually sit down and watch two fat lads play computer games? Am I missing something?

At least Liverpool were hammering Manchester United in the final, so there's that I suppose.

OP can't fathom people that would sit down and watch other people play a video game.

OP talks about sitting down and watching other people play football.

As to whether or not it should be considered a sport, I don't know.
I don't really care. It just slightly amuses me when people that regularly watch sports condemn watching gaming.
Different strokes.

I'm sure OP is a WUM from other posts on here but I wanted to answer anyway.

Cookie_Monster · 30-03-2019 10:48pm

To those who dismiss esports, what think ye of drone racing? It of course contains some real world physical drones and courses but at the same time you basically use a joy pad and vr headset. No fitness required, just a lot of skill.
Does it qualify enough to be a real sport?

aaronjumper · 30-03-2019 10:52pm

Cookie_Monster wrote: »

To those who dismiss esports, what think ye of drone racing?
It or course contains some real world physical drones and courses but at the same time you basically use a joy pad and vr headset. No fitness required, just a lot of skill.
Does it qualify enough to be a real sport?

Gave that a watch the other day.
Can get pretty dizzying when they cut to a camera on a drone.
Looks good though.

Necro · 30-03-2019 11:24pm

It's not a sport. But I think that even the gamers are essentially acknowledging that hence the 'E' tagged on in front.

I'm not a fan of it at all tbh, I just dont get the appeal of sitting around watching people gaming when I can be doing it myself.

Cant do that with Gaelic football or soccer as I'm a **** player and my ankles are fooked. But I can watch that and enjoy it.

Do I care if esports are on the Sports channels? Nope. I have to put up with sh1te like cricket, golf and fooking horse racing so what's one more thing to avoid :pac:

FrankieFeeler · 30-03-2019 11:31pm

Nixonbot wrote: »

Is motorsport sport? The driver presses the accelerator, which tells a computer to make the car go faster...

E-Sports are simulations of potential real life events.

When you drive a car you are actually driving a car.One of the main aspects of motor racing is having the bravery to drive a car that fast, you don't need any of that to do the e-sport version of it.

My issue with e-sports is they are simulations of real things and not actually the real thing.

To be honest the point I was making is really not that difficult to understand.

30-03-2019 11:40pm

If all commercial "sports" could be sent to some sports radio and sports tv gulag and stop cannibalising mainstream news - the 10 minutes "sports" bulletins on Morning Ireland at 7:30am being a case in point - radio would be infinitely more tolerable.

TV is a lost cause in its entirety, in large part because the "sport" business has been imposing its business agenda on the rest of us for decades now under the guise of being some sort of community spiritual endeavour rather than the big money and big gambling racket which it is in its entirety.

And this lark of sneering at a follower of some other commercial "sport" for not being a serious "sports" fan. Jesus, my head.

FrankieFeeler · 30-03-2019 11:46pm

Deleted User wrote: »

If all commercial "sports" could be sent to some sports radio and sports tv gulag and stop cannibalising mainstream news - the 10 minutes "sports" bulletins on Morning Ireland at 7:30am being a case in point - radio would be infinitely more tolerable.

TV is a lost cause in its entirety, in large part because the "sport" business has been imposing its business agenda on the rest of us for decades now under the guise of being some sort of community spiritual endeavour rather than the big money and big gambling racket which it is in its entirety.

And this lark of sneering at a follower of some other commercial "sport" for not being a serious "sports" fan. Jesus, my head.

If people want to watch it that's fine, but it doesn't mean they are sports.

Skylinehead · 30-03-2019 11:47pm

FrankieFeeler wrote: »

E-Sports are simulations of potential real life events.

When you drive a car you are actually driving a car.One of the main aspects of motor racing is having the bravery to drive a car that fast, you don't need any of that to do the e-sport version of it.

My issue with e-sports is they are simulations of real things and not actually the real thing.

To be honest the point I was making is really not that difficult to understand.

You're driving a computer that drives the car.

the_pen_turner · 30-03-2019 11:47pm

FrankieFeeler wrote: »

E-Sports are simulations of potential real life events.

When you drive a car you are actually driving a car.One of the main aspects of motor racing is having the bravery to drive a car that fast, you don't need any of that to do the e-sport version of it.

My issue with e-sports is they are simulations of real things and not actually the real thing.

To be honest the point I was making is really not that difficult to understand.

thats the thing. i can put on gran tourismo and drive a ferrari are 200mph and set blistering fast laps, in reality i would be upsidown in a ditch at the first corner.
i agree there is a lot of skill etc in e sports but its not the same as actually doing it.

FrankieFeeler · 30-03-2019 11:48pm

Nixonbot wrote: »

You're driving a computer that drives the car.

The car is moving from point A to Point B.

On a computer game nothing moves from one point to another which is the entire purpose of driving a car.

Skylinehead · 30-03-2019 11:53pm

FrankieFeeler wrote: »

The car is moving from point A to Point B.

On a computer game nothing moves from one point to another which is the entire purpose of driving a car.

Electricity moves

Something called eSports on Sky Sports

Comments