Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

1…6566687071…103

Comments

  • #2012
    Gabriel WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,048 ✭✭✭Gabriel WW


    This has been a very skeptical game for me.

    I'm 90% on board with clodagh and Brendan.

    I'm 55% on board with wini. Eva could be telling the truth but wini might not be. He could be able to send messages, but that's no proof he is who he says he is, nor that the death if he messages a baddie thing is real, nor that any of the people he messages are good.


  • #2013
    Nigel WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,864 ✭✭✭Nigel WW


    Winifred WW wrote: »
    That's it. I could have picked a wolf day 1, and died without being any use, but I didn't.

    How many times can you do this? Can you continue even now that you're outted?


  • #2014
    Gabriel WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,048 ✭✭✭Gabriel WW


    Nigel WW wrote:
    The OP does hint at secret stuff:


    I'm on board with secrets. But winis power is very strong, and it's tied to a minor character. I'm just not convinced.


  • #2015
    Winifred WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 1,276 ✭✭✭Winifred WW


    Nigel WW wrote: »
    How many times can you do this? Can you continue even now that you're outted?

    Yeah once each night after the lynch.


  • #2016
    Derry WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,830 ✭✭✭Derry WW


    Winifred WW wrote: »
    I dunno who you are, but I can't communicate with anyone, only send a note. I just have my backroom all to myself.

    As I said, I have two confirmed villagers already, but I don't want to reveal them on thread unless I have to.

    Why not?

    From your point, you should want them to step forward immediately. You shouldn't name them. They should volunteer.

    If all you know is they are good, guess what; the wolves know that too.

    Whats the risk in people coming forward saying they got notes and are good? That's info the wolves already have, right?


  • Advertisement
  • #2017
    Nigel WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,864 ✭✭✭Nigel WW


    Winifred WW wrote: »
    Why shoot me? Cos I said you weren't clever?

    Thanks for outing me, like you gave the BG to the wolves...

    I'm Janine Hawkins, friend/bridesmaid of your wife and a former assistant of Charles Augustus Magnussen.

    Cos of my ties to both, I get to send anon notes each night to players, but if they're evil I die 12 hours later.

    I have sent three so far, Eva was last night/this morning. I'm not revealing the other two but they should know who I am.

    I was trying to form a village core but it looks like just the 4 of us will have to do now.

    Winifred WW wrote: »
    I dunno who you are, but I can't communicate with anyone, only send a note. I just have my backroom all to myself.

    As I said, I have two confirmed villagers already, but I don't want to reveal them on thread unless I have to.

    Two or three?


  • #2018
    Liam WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,250 ✭✭✭Liam WW


    Derry WW wrote: »
    How did Wini identify themselves on thread?

    Eva/Wini can you confirm this? Its a pertinent question


  • #2019
    Winifred WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 1,276 ✭✭✭Winifred WW


    Nigel WW wrote: »
    Two or three?

    Two - won't know about Eva until tonight, as I said.


  • #2020
    Abigail WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,056 ✭✭✭Abigail WW


    Winifred WW wrote: »
    Yeah once each night after the lynch.




    So if we tell you to send a note to Phil WW (not active this game) in 12hrs we would either find out that you died or that Phil is team village assuming your on the level? When can you next send a note?


  • #2021
    Clodagh WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,231 ✭✭✭Clodagh WW


    So how many messages can you send in a day?

    Also how does this explain your strange voting antics?


  • Advertisement
  • #2022
    Liam WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,250 ✭✭✭Liam WW


    Nigel WW wrote: »
    Two or three?

    She has sent 3 notes. One to Eva and 2 others who are still secret.


  • #2023
    Winifred WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 1,276 ✭✭✭Winifred WW


    Liam WW wrote: »
    Eva/Wini can you confirm this? Its a pertinent question

    I used the identifying word, candyfloss. Mentioned it in the note to Eva as well.


  • #2024
    Winifred WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 1,276 ✭✭✭Winifred WW


    Abigail WW wrote: »
    So if we tell you to send a note to Phil WW (not active this game) in 12hrs we would either find out that you died or that Phil is team village assuming your on the level? When can you next send a note?

    After the lynch, yeah I can send it to who the village wishes.


  • #2025
    Abigail WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,056 ✭✭✭Abigail WW


    Winifred WW wrote: »
    Two - won't know about Eva until tonight, as I said.




    Is there and exact time? i.e if you die at this time Eva is bad, if not shes good. Or of course the third it's all bullplop option


  • #2026
    Clodagh WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,231 ✭✭✭Clodagh WW


    Nigel WW wrote: »
    Two or three?

    She very clearly said thee in the first post.
    She said she contacted Eva and that she wouldn't reveal the other two...


  • #2027
    Derry WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,830 ✭✭✭Derry WW


    Winifred WW wrote: »
    I used the identifying word, candyfloss. Mentioned it in the note to Eva as well.

    So, not knowing if Eva was good or not, you outed yourself to her as a rolled villager?


  • #2028
    Winifred WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 1,276 ✭✭✭Winifred WW


    Clodagh WW wrote: »
    So how many messages can you send in a day?

    Also how does this explain your strange voting antics?

    Again, I have... reasons. I was trying to be as covert as possible, although I knew it didn't look great but I have you to thank for that, shooting Desmond mucked up my plans.


  • #2029
    Clodagh WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,231 ✭✭✭Clodagh WW


    Winifred WW wrote: »
    After the lynch, yeah I can send it to who the village wishes.
    Also, what time did you send your first message?


  • #2030
    Winifred WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 1,276 ✭✭✭Winifred WW


    Derry WW wrote: »
    So, not knowing if Eva was good or not, you outed yourself to her as a rolled villager?

    Makes no difference. If she's a wolf, she knows I'd die 12 hours later as I told her.


  • #2031
    Brendan WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,377 ✭✭✭Brendan WW


    Gabriel WW wrote: »
    This has been a very skeptical game for me.

    I'm 90% on board with clodagh and Brendan.

    I'm 55% on board with wini. Eva could be telling the truth but wini might not be. He could be able to send messages, but that's no proof he is who he says he is, nor that the death if he messages a baddie thing is real, nor that any of the people he messages are good.

    I agree a bit here - just because she can send messages it doesn't mean she is team village, could just as easily be a wolf and has now integrated herself with some villagers (Could be Irene Adler)


  • Advertisement
  • #2032
    Winifred WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 1,276 ✭✭✭Winifred WW


    Clodagh WW wrote: »
    Also, what time did you send your first message?

    I sent all my messages so far about 9am, can't confirm what time mods sent it though.

    In the night phase.


  • #2033
    Eva WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,927 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Winifred WW wrote: »
    Won't know about Eva until about 9pm tonight, I only sent it this morning, can't be certain what time it was received.

    It was timestamped 9:24am, but I didn't see it until a fair while after that (my own fault of course), until almost too late.
    Abigail WW wrote: »
    Lads I am worried. The above is what I posted a few posts after Clodagh outed our BG. I clearly saw what he did even if he didn't. So did a lot of people on thread from what they said. I would have to assume one of them would be a wolf. I am worried because unless they are idiots and missed a post from our recently outed Vig that was thanked by a few people they intentionally did not try to kill either our Vig or BG... did they go for a better target in Barbara?... Sherlock!

    I asked that in the last hour, could the wolves be munching according to Moriarty's peek results? Maybe they found a juicier target in Barbara.

    Gabriel WW wrote: »
    This has been a very skeptical game for me.

    I'm 90% on board with clodagh and Brendan.

    I'm 55% on board with wini. Eva could be telling the truth but wini might not be. He could be able to send messages, but that's no proof he is who he says he is, nor that the death if he messages a baddie thing is real, nor that any of the people he messages are good.

    I can see it starting to be a very skeptical game for you, but a dose of that does no harm. We have potentially an unreal village core building between Wini's claim and Clodagh and Brendan's, it almost seems too good to be true so we should be questioning everything to an extent.

    No, I can't confirm that Winifred is good and that this isn't some devious plan of hers, just that I got that message. But there are other villagers who can back her up if it comes to it. She has claimed something which in fairness, if it comes to her naming names, these people can confirm. There are other roles she could have claimed where she wouldn't be relying on people to support her.

    If those revealed names turn out to be a mix of me, Orla and others who seem like they definitely would NOT be on a wolf team conspiring in the BR, well then maybe we should start to take Wini's claim seriously.

    I can confirm that she sent me that PM, and if her word is true, I can promise her that she won't be dead at 9pm tonight because I was confirmed as wolf.


  • #2034
    Derry WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,830 ✭✭✭Derry WW


    Winifred WW wrote: »
    Makes no difference. If she's a wolf, she knows I'd die 12 hours later as I told her.

    Did you confirm your identity to others too?
    Why did you choose Eva?


  • #2035
    Gabriel WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,048 ✭✭✭Gabriel WW


    Can you give us exact input times please wini. Useful to verify things later.


  • #2036
    Eva WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,927 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Derry WW wrote: »
    Why not?

    From your point, you should want them to step forward immediately. You shouldn't name them. They should volunteer.

    If all you know is they are good, guess what; the wolves know that too.

    Whats the risk in people coming forward saying they got notes and are good? That's info the wolves already have, right?

    That's a fair point Derry.
    Liam WW wrote: »
    Eva/Wini can you confirm this? Its a pertinent question

    I see that Wendy answered this, but yes it was the word candyfloss.
    Derry WW wrote: »
    So, not knowing if Eva was good or not, you outed yourself to her as a rolled villager?

    Well Derry, if that's her role, that's the game. She has to send a message and take a chance. If she was wrong about me, she'd be dead in 12 hours, not like if I was a wolf I could munch her the following morning.


  • #2037
    Eva WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,927 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Edit to Liam: I can see that Wini answered this.


  • #2038
    Winifred WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 1,276 ✭✭✭Winifred WW


    Eva WW wrote: »
    It was timestamped 9:24am, but I didn't see it until a fair while after that (my own fault of course), until almost too late.



    I asked that in the last hour, could the wolves be munching according to Moriarty's peek results? Maybe they found a juicier target in Barbara.




    I can see it starting to be a very skeptical game for you, but a dose of that does no harm. We have potentially an unreal village core building between Wini's claim and Clodagh and Brendan's, it almost seems too good to be true so we should be questioning everything to an extent.

    No, I can't confirm that Winifred is good and that this isn't some devious plan of hers, just that I got that message. But there are other villagers who can back her up if it comes to it. She has claimed something which in fairness, if it comes to her naming names, these people can confirm. There are other roles she could have claimed where she wouldn't be relying on people to support her.

    If those revealed names turn out to be a mix of me, Orla and others who seem like they definitely would NOT be on a wolf team conspiring in the BR, well then maybe we should start to take Wini's claim seriously.

    I can confirm that she sent me that PM, and if her word is true, I can promise her that she won't be dead at 9pm tonight because I was confirmed as wolf.

    Seeing as you mention it repeatedly...

    Orla was who I messaged Monday.

    I identified myself by saying I'd vote for them in the lynch. I figured day 1, not too risky, and if I was revealed to priest and Orla was a wolf then people might figure it out.

    But I couldn't really roll back in on my attack on Orla (when Desmond was my real target, I keep calling him the smart wolf if you read my posts).

    So when Desmond got shot, I had to vote Babs off my FFA


  • #2039
    Abigail WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 3,056 ✭✭✭Abigail WW


    Eva WW wrote: »



    I asked that in the last hour, could the wolves be munching according to Moriarty's peek results? Maybe they found a juicier target in Barbara.






    If those revealed names turn out to be a mix of me, Orla and others who seem like they definitely would NOT be on a wolf team conspiring in the BR, well then maybe we should start to take Wini's claim seriously.


    Thankfully im not the only one worried about this, like with a lot of this game there has been a lot of distractions but the wolves not going for an outed BG & Vig to instead go for an unknown seems very odd to me and def has me worried.


    Orla being one of the others is one of the few things that would make sense of Wini not voting for Orla. That said why would Wini think Orla a villager given how she acted towards her, just keeping up appearances after spotting something we missed?


  • #2040
    Winifred WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 1,276 ✭✭✭Winifred WW


    Gabriel WW wrote: »
    Can you give us exact input times please wini. Useful to verify things later.

    9.03am Monday.

    07.15am Tuesday (I was really busy at work and had to send things out)

    09.04am this morning.


  • Advertisement
  • #2041
    Derry WW
    Forum Games Player Posts: 4,830 ✭✭✭Derry WW


    Orla, confirmation?

    Also, Wini, with these notes, did you leave hints over the last few days whereby if you had died from picking wrong, we'd have known why you died?


Advertisement