Off Topic Chat. (MOD NOTE post# 3949 and post#5279)
Comments
-
Cass, you nailed it :cool:
Well said !0 -
Walter Mittys Brother wrote: »How can you tell? Do they have passports etc?
Because they said that's who they're complaining about. Also, "refugee" and "economic migrant" are handled very differently at the border for decent reasons, and the rules about the latter preclude the guy floating in a dingy in the middle of the med from claiming that status.
Seriously, the "mistrust the refugees" argument literally is the Gardai's argument that we are all criminals who've not been caught yet because we have guns, just applied to people fleeing a war zone.0 -
Blacks make up 14% of the population of the US. Of that some 21 million are male so that is 7% of the total population. They are responsible for 62% of robberies, 57% of the total murders, and 45% of assaults (the number is actually less than 7% as its not all black men involved).
We've all seen the video footage of black suspects doing absolutely nothing wrong, complying with the officers involved and then being murdered on camera. Hands empty and on display, complying with instructions, doing nothing - hell, even lying down on the ground with hands in the air (and in that case it was a nurse caring for a guy with mental health issues). We've seen videos of police literally start shooting out the windscreen of their car before stopping. And when you look at things like how much training those police get (the average is around 12 weeks), how little data is shared between forces over officer's track records (nearly none which several police departments say is a causal factor in these things because someone can be involved in a shooting, be found at fault, get fired, go to another state and join their police force and they'll no nothing of this), and the amount of military hardware they're being issued, it's not exactly surprising this goes on.As for Antifa.............. any thoughts?
Unless you class Mossad as lefties...Who said the far left, i said the left, the Dems, the Donkeys, the "progressives", the "liberals".The EU made a comprehensive decision to allow uncontrolled, unrestricted immigration.Only this week it was announced that 25 African families would be brought into Ireland, given a 6 week induction course as some facility, granted citizenship, a handout of €5,000, a house to live in, and full employment benefits.There are people on streets i their thousands.
And y'all might remember, at some point we are going to be called to answer for things like the direct provision system to our kids in the same way we called the catholic church to answer for Ferns, and we won't have the easy out they got. We're running what are basically concentration camps for refugees right now. It's beyond a disgrace - 30C and we're selling them drinking water. We are not so damn poor we need to do that, but someone got a nice little earner of a contract to run the place, and we have a pattern of going along with those kinds of things - it's what we did with the laundries.That resentment festers and grows
So long as people don't like refugees, direct provision continues and people make a small mint off the taxpayer. So a few quid bunged to the tabloids to call them migrants when they're not, to spread around fake stories about huge grants and free houses and citizenship and how them durty foreigners are getting stuff we're not? That few quid pays off in spades for the lads with the contracts.I'm sick of this leftist bias about President Trump.
You have guys like John McCain voting against him for feck's sakes, and he's hardly a long-haired commie hippie tree-hugger.The lies and bias of the leftist media was once again highlighted only this week by Time magazine. No one is forcing people to cross illegally. They know the risks associated with it, but choose to do this rather than go a centre or consul where they can start the process legally.0 -
None of which actually matter when you measure what percentage of black suspects are shot and killed versus what percentage of white suspects are.
Blacks commit a huge percentage of crime compared to their demographic size yet you and the left think it's racist when a larger than normal amount of blacks are shot during the proceeds of these crimes? :rolleyes:We've all seen the video footage of black suspects doing absolutely nothing wrongWell, they originated in London when Jews decided that Mosley's meetings needed to be broken up and nobody else was going to do it, so they're not exactly newfangled or left-wing.
Unless you class Mossad as lefties...Come on. The Democrats are as left wing as Thatcher.No, they absolutely did not. They made a decision to shelter refugees which is not the same thing.
They have been working on a migration agenda since 1999 and the influx of migrants from 2015 has sparked a reinvigoration of this agenda. Led by Jean Claude-Drunkard, Merkel and the likes, and their plan of allowing millions and millions of people in with little to no security checks or scrutiny.They're refugees and we're giving them shelter not citizenship.They will be first brought to an induction centre such as at Ballaghadereen for six weeks before they are allocated full citizenship of Ireland, payment of up to 5000 Euro each under Emergency Needs, as well as the full dole.And y'all might remember, at some point we are going to be called to answer for things like the direct provision system to our kids in the same way we called the catholic church to answer for Ferns, and we won't have the easy out they got.
As for this :We're running what are basically concentration camps for refugees right now.It grows because it's fed by people who profit off it.
Secondly don't confuse me now, or ever, with some mullet wearing sh*t kicker going around mumbling "they took our jobs". I don't hate them for who they are, what they've done, where they're from or where they're going.
In short i'm fed up of the double standards and media manipulation of these stories. If a country decides it doesn't want to take in refugees, migrants, whatever, they should be free to refuse and not demonized because of it. The "won't someone think of the children" excuse does not justify the perceptions and actions that such mass immigration causes.I'm not sure it's leftist or rightist bias when half his own party are walking out in protest.And yes, quite a lot of the daft **** is older than he is (the wall, their policy towards illegal immigration, and a few others), but I don't remember any administration being this joyously cruel and petty about everything.You might not like Clinton but did he ever go on and on about being interviewed by Fox?Did Bush ever talk about his own party members the way Trump does?Did Bush Sr ever go after the press the way Trump has?
Even so called fact checking sites like Snopes are biased. When you check on the "baby bus" they claim it as true, but don't elaborate that it was done under Obamas tenure. You can figure out quite quickly it was, but they never mention it or him.This isn't some lefty thing, this guy is something nastier than anyone's seen before, it's why there's opposition to him from both parties.You have guys like John McCain voting against him for feck's sakes, and he's hardly a long-haired commie hippie tree-hugger.
McCain went against Trump and his party to vote against repealing Obamacare [twice] even though he canvassed on repealing it and was a strong critic of it since it's creation. Trump and McCain have had a long feud with both exchanging petty quips at each other.You missed the bit where they're being murdered on the other side of the border because of things started on the US side.Not to mention that there are documented cases of people doing everything completely legally and still being treated as illegals.And part of that comes down to stupid technical stuff that indicates that nobody on the US side is interested in having legal migration - ICE literally disabled the part of their computer system that gave an okay when doing risk assessments of migrants. Before the change, the system either said "probably fine" or "probably criminal" and they literally turned off the first option. https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-immigration-court/
Again he [Obama] done much worse than Trump or any other President and he is pardoned the scrutiny Trump is receiving for continuing that trend.Forum Charter - Useful Information - Photo thread: Hardware - Ranges by County - Hunting Laws/Important threads - Upcoming Events - RFDs by County
If you see a problem post use the report post function. Click on the three dots on the post, select "FLAG" & let a Moderator deal with it.
Moderators - Cass otmmyboy2 , CatMod - Shamboc , Admins - Beasty , mickeroo
0 -
So the facts don't matter.
I mean, it's like the difference between there being 1700 more pistols licenced in Ireland today than in 1972 and there being a lower pistol ownership rate in Ireland today than in 1972. Both are true. But you can't compare the numbers directly because they're measuring different things.
In this case, if you see a thousand suspects of race A being arrested and a hundred of race B; but 70% of those in race A get shot during the arrest and 7% of race B; you have to ask a question or two because those two percentages should not be that far apart.No. Not saying itdoesn't happen or that every shooting is justified but according to stats its not even among the top 20 of "most deadly" causes of black deaths.Well deflected, but in case you need a refresher i'm talking about these f**kwits
I don't think we're required to pick a side, but if you held me to the flame on it, I suspect I'd come down on the side that isn't literally the American Nazi Party.If you want to be pedantic then i'll rephrase it. The "left" as the democratic party and their ilk are commonly referred to.Yes they did, and no it's not.
They have been working on a migration agenda since 1999 and the influx of migrants from 2015 has sparked a reinvigoration of this agenda. Led by Jean Claude-Drunkard, Merkel and the likes, and their plan of allowing millions and millions of people in with little to no security checks or scrutiny.As per the article:
http://www.citizensinformation.ie/en/moving_country/asylum_seekers_and_refugees/the_asylum_process_in_ireland/rights_and_obligations_of_asylum_seekers_in_ireland.htmlYou are taking the piss if you think rampant child sexual abuse is even close to what "migrants" are getting in terms of support and aid.With "good ould Catholic ireland" you also have institutional failures as well as corruption from within the Government and GardaA trend that continues today, with our own people.
Mind you, if the bastards can keep everyone at each other's throats, we never look at it that way and they get to go buy their own fecking islands...That is the same sick and twisted logic i see spouted in the states about the detention centres for ILLEGALS. How can anyone trivialize the death and depravity that was seen in the concentration camps as comparable to holding centres for criminals and illegals?Secondly don't confuse me now, or ever, with some mullet wearing sh*t kicker going around mumbling "they took our jobs".If a country decides it doesn't want to take in refugees, migrants, whatever, they should be free to refuse and not demonized because of it.
I mean, as solutions go, it's a ****ty one, with the sole redeeming feature that it has so far worked slightly better than anything we've tried in the last two thousand years or so.
Which isn't as big as even that offhanded comment makes out, but it's big enough that the whole free-migration-within-the-EU thing is not just some idea on paper for a lot of people, it's a Big Thing to them.
As to refugees, we kindof have international law on that point which says, more or less, "don't be that country, m'kay?". So saying "no, we're not taking them, we'll machine-gun them if they try to get in here", well, you have to be Turkey for that and who the hell wants to live there?Walking out of what?Granted President Trump can be a douche at times, but the resistance he has faced since becoming President has never been seen by any other.Clinton, Obama, even Killary called for walls and strengthening of borders and when Trump tries it they call him a racist.However i fail to see the "joy" you say he gets from this. Show me what you mean.Might want to pick someone else as your poster boy for etiquette.if someone with no political experience can come in and solve some problems that "seasoned" politicians have been saying for decades cannot be fixed easily or at all, then they'll be shown up as the frauds they are.
Pretty huge IF there though, given that so far, he's not managed to do any such thing.Support your argument with facts. What has he done that is nastier than anything before him?Doing it legally or have completed the process and are legal? Unless its the latter they are still illegal and that is still a crime.
Grandmother and last surviving granddaughter flee after the parents and siblings were murdered by gangs, they take the granddaughter and send her off to a tender age shelter, and refuse to acknowledge the grandmother has custody despite documentation.
So now the grandmother is in one holding camp and the granddaughter is in one of the child holding camps in Texas, only they're not sure exactly where.
There's a reason the US courts think this sort of thing is inhumane and have ordered it to be stopped.0 -
Advertisement
-
These are getting too long. I'm going to start shortening them to single words or just emojis shortly...... the point is that the absolute figures can't be directly compared to the percentages because they're not mathematically the same.
Black men are more involved in violent crimes and murder. That is not racist its a simple fact. As i said before if 7% of the population is responsible for 57% of the murders then you cannot blame the stats for the higher proportion of shootings among those involved in those crimes.
Muslim men of Asian decent in the UK are responsible for 84% of rape/grooming gangs. Less than 5% of the total population responsible for 84% of gang rapes. Is this racist because whites are not raping as much? FFS, the facts are facts, and the % is the %. No amount of side stepping will diminish the truth of it.Um.
Rank | Cause | Percentage
1) | Heart disease | 23.9
2) | Cancer | 21.4
3) | Unintentional injuries | 6.5
4) | Homicide | 4.9 ** Not Police **
5) | Stroke | 4.2
6) | Diabetes | 3.1
7) | Chronic lower respiratory diseases | 4.9
8) | Alzheimer’s disease | 2.5
9) | Influenza and pneumonia | 2.0
10) | Chronic liver disease| 1.9I'd probably use the same word, but I notice they've not killed anyone and the people they're protesting have.
If they protested extremist groups then so be it, but they protest anything they don't agree with. From free speech, to Trump supporters, to anything resembling conservative/traditional values and of course they're violent as f**k. They are described as such by all sources:They engage in violent protest tactics, which has included property damage and physical violence. They tend to be anti-capitalist and they are predominantly far-left and militant left.Short for militant leftists, or occasionally far leftists and radical leftists, often used as a generalization of people who commit to acts of violence against those on the Right side of the political spectrumI don't think we're required to pick a side, but if you held me to the flame on it, I suspect I'd come down on the side that isn't literally the American Nazi Party.It's not that pedantic - they think a liberal policy is letting everyone buy health insurance. And they're happy to live with child marriage and child labour within their own borders. And a dozen other things we'd see as being up there with the Penal Laws and Cromwell if you tried imposing them on us today. The Dems are just not a shining light leading towards a nicer world.They literally can't do that legally; and the people we're talking about are refugees fleeing Assad, and handled under a different body of law. And frankly, we (meaning the EU) backed Assad so we'd have someone fighting ISIS as a buffer zone. The real world is ****ty and so on, okay, that's another argument; but we don't get to do that and then treat refugees fleeing sarin gas dropped by the guy we backed as if the refugees were nothing to do with us at all.
So tell me again how the EU has nothing to do with this? How the EU are not responsible for the mass influx of refugees/migrants/any other PC name?
By the way don't try to pass the EU off as all countries having equal say, it doesn't happen except in the Unicorn and Rainbow world that those in la-la land live in.I don't know what article you're citing, but it's flat-out wrong
Try rationalize that to the people with "calm down, i'll explain the financing behind it" will not mean spit.Funnily enough, I'm not. It's not even an analogy : http://www.thejournal.ie/abuse-is-reported-at-direct-provision-centres-across-ireland-1023749-Aug2013/
Leads back to what i said above about grooming gangs in the UK as well as other stories of a similar nature by other "refugees" in other countries such as this and this.First off, direct provision is for refugees. They're not criminals, they're not illegals, .................So they literally can't, not legally. Within the EU, free migration from EU state to EU state is one of the few principles the continent will literally die on ..............Pretty sure the latter is a result of the former; and the former is not exactly new; ............. it's pretty much a recipe for getting everyone pissed off at you.
Some might have been pissed off at him, but some are outright against him simply because he won, and Killary didn't. Calls for sedition, attacks on Trump's staff, his supporters, calls for a recession so just so Trump fails, etc. The madness is out of hand and the TDS is strong with most of them.Well, none of them led off with "mexicans are all rapists" to be fair...Trump wrote:When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best. They’re not sending you. They’re not sending you. They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people.Seriously, read his twitter feed for a day, tell me you don't see someone delighting in being nasty.Didn't call him a poster boy for anything, just said he wasn't as bad as Trump and neither has anyone else been since the late 1700s and those guys were literally killing each other in duels.- Only the second President in history to be impeached, but yeah he was delight. :rolleyes:
- He doubled the federal prison population by making crack cocaine a more serious offense than powder cocaine. Crack cocaine was much cheaper and largely used by Blacks.
- He signed in NAFTA.
- He allowed logging in national forests.
- He was hesitant to take action to stop a genocide in Rwanda. While he failed to act, more than half a million Tutsis were murdered.
- He gave China Most Favored Nation (MFN) status despite their terrible human rights record
- He granted North Korea concessions in exchange for a promise to discontinue their nuclear weapons program
- He failed to deal with the threat of Osama bin Laden as he was too distracted by scandals & impeachment to take action against Al Qaeda. We all know how that ended.
Indeed.
Pretty huge IF there though, given that so far, he's not managed to do any such thing.- 12 appellate court judges (a first for any President in his first year)
- A supreme court justice and another in the coming months.
- Tax reform/improved economy
- Repealing individual mandate from obamacare
- Travel ban
- Defeating ISIS
- Recognition of Jerusalem something every other president refused to to address even though it was law since 1996
Oh come on, you don't even have to work hard on that one.......... they take the granddaughter and send her off to a tender age shelter, and refuse to acknowledge the grandmother has custody despite documentation.
All that is moot. Her claim is being examined and will be ruled on when it's ruled on. those "hopping" the fence have no such protections, and you don't seriously expect any country to allow illegal immigrants unchecked freedoms while their case is being reviewed?Forum Charter - Useful Information - Photo thread: Hardware - Ranges by County - Hunting Laws/Important threads - Upcoming Events - RFDs by County
If you see a problem post use the report post function. Click on the three dots on the post, select "FLAG" & let a Moderator deal with it.
Moderators - Cass otmmyboy2 , CatMod - Shamboc , Admins - Beasty , mickeroo
0 -
Because they said that's who they're complaining about. Also, "refugee" and "economic migrant" are handled very differently at the border for decent reasons, and the rules about the latter preclude the guy floating in a dingy in the middle of the med from claiming that status.Seriously, the "mistrust the refugees" argument literally is the Gardai's argument that we are all criminals who've not been caught yet because we have guns, just applied to people fleeing a war zone.
Odd that there arent very many,if at all women and kids with these refugees. They seem to be all young or middle-aged men,of a certain religion,and even more odd that as there are Christians in that conflict zone there are few if any of those with them. Even odder enough have lost everything including ALL documentation,but have kept their cell phones.Now a suspicious mind might have a few questions on those points...
Also, could anyone inform me,I must have missed this one..What oppression or civil war is going on in Jamaica or Ghana?"If you want to keep someone away from your house, Just fire the shotgun through the door."
Vice President [and former lawyer] Joe Biden Field& Stream Magazine interview Feb 2013 "
0 -
Well, they originated in London when Jews decided that Mosley's meetings needed to be broken up and nobody else was going to do it, so they're not exactly newfangled or left-wing.
Actually NO! They came about in the 1930s as an off shoot of Communism in Berlin.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antifaschistische_Aktion
Ironic that they call everyone Nazis as these Mom spare room dwelling thugs,[and that's not hyperbole BTW a survey done in Berlin a few years ago has over 75% of ANTIFA males still living at home with their unmarried/divorced mothers.] Use the same tactics as the brownshirts but in the name of Communism.Either way, they wouldn't know a genuine Nazi if he planted a jackboot up their black-clad asses.Unless you class Mossad as lefties..."If you want to keep someone away from your house, Just fire the shotgun through the door."
Vice President [and former lawyer] Joe Biden Field& Stream Magazine interview Feb 2013 "
0 -
Some of his greatest hits:
Only the second President in history to be impeached, but yeah he was delight.
He doubled the federal prison population by making crack cocaine a more serious offense than powder cocaine. Crack cocaine was much cheaper and largely used by Blacks.
He signed in NAFTA.
He allowed logging in national forests.
He was hesitant to take action to stop a genocide in Rwanda. While he failed to act, more than half a million Tutsis were murdered.
He gave China Most Favored Nation (MFN) status despite their terrible human rights record
He granted North Korea concessions in exchange for a promise to discontinue their nuclear weapons program
He failed to deal with the threat of Osama bin Laden as he was too distracted by scandals & impeachment to take action against Al Qaeda. We all know how that ended.
That's very short list Cass.
You can add at least 100 more things he did in conjunction with his witch of a wife. Going back all the way to his governorship on Arkanshaw and involvement in the Mena airport and Drug runners like Barry Seal and the "Dixie Mafia"[The film American made is based on those times]
We could add.
Whitewater,
Furnituregate[Nicking 300k worth of furniture out of the White House]
Travelgate,
Filegate
Troopergate
Vince Foster.
Paula Jones,
Monica Lewinsky.
Gennifer Flowers
Sydney Blumenthal
Juniata Brodderick
The fuk up of BlackHawk Down..Billy was too busy on the golf course to order armour out to rescue the crewmen.
Waco,Ruby Ridge.in not reigning in that hag Janet Reno and her control of both ATFE and FBI on both occasions."If you want to keep someone away from your house, Just fire the shotgun through the door."
Vice President [and former lawyer] Joe Biden Field& Stream Magazine interview Feb 2013 "
0 -
Looks like immigration is going to be the death of the EUSSR. Seehofer looks likely to walk away from Mama Merkel, and even if he does not, that deal done last week is as much use as a chocolate teapot and will last just as long. Whoever thought we would live to see the return of the far right in Germany ? But the open borders lunacy looks likely to be the straw that broke the camels back.
As to why the bile against Trump, simple, the big money on wall street was backing aged wharf whore Hilary Clinton. She was also the one who pushed Hussain Obama to rid libya of Gadafi, he did not want to initially, but she wanted it as it was a major plus for her in her own election attempt. Gadafi said himself that libya was the "cork in the bottle", in other words, without him sub saharan africa would rush towards europe. He was right.
The Irish are not innocent in all this, it was our own FG backer Peter sutherland who was agitating the eu to allow open borders. It was ok for him, he was coming towards the end of his money grubbing life, everyone else has to put up with the consequences. Our cut price trudeau wannabe veruca salts has taken to this idea with gusto.
0 -
Advertisement
-
The "far right" as MSM calls them in Germany are not going to get into power,ever again. Those are groups that are proscribed organisations like NPD,Wehrsport Gruppe Hoffmann etc.IOW they have to be two goose steps to the right of Hitler and total neo-Nazis.Anything that gets too antsy gets shut down very quickly by the German Govt.
CSU in Bavaria[The "Fuk You Berlin" since German reunification in 1850 state] is the equivalent of Fianna Fail on steroids. Conservative, big business, farmers, Catholic values of government.Seehofer himself has said it "it is impossible to work with that woman[Merkel] on the immigration issues."
Hardly a bunch of Seig heiling ,goose-stepping Burgerbrau Keller dwelling SA goons.s to why the bile against Trump, simple, the big money on wall street was backing aged wharf whore Hilary Clinton.
Seeing that the Clinton foundation is under IRS investigation and bankrupt, Trump is in the House and Denis is out millions...Is it anyway surprising that every article on President Trump in any of his MSM rags in Ireland are full of bile?
https://www.irishtimes.com/news/ireland/irish-news/denis-o-brien-used-clinton-connections-to-help-haiti-relief-efforts-1.2826072
http://freebeacon.com/blog/oh-denny-boy-how-the-clintons-helped-an-irish-telecom-tycoon-makes-millions-in-earthquake-ravaged-haiti/
https://fora.ie/denis-obrien-clinton-foundation-haiti-3022451-Oct2016/"If you want to keep someone away from your house, Just fire the shotgun through the door."
Vice President [and former lawyer] Joe Biden Field& Stream Magazine interview Feb 2013 "
0 -
So it looks like FF will back the Frances Black / SF bill to start boycotting Israeli products. The shows how FF will sell out anything or anyone if they think it is worth it to get back votes on the left / hard left. A worrying fact for gun owners in Ireland.0
-
FF.FG.SF..All-Pro EU butt kissers...Please , anyone from those parties, spare us any more sanctimonious claptrap about Ireland having any sort of independent or arbitrary powers to do anything on the international stage without any say so from the EU. Looking at you Micheal Martin in particular after your disgusting toadying speech in the Dail when the big boss dropped in:mad:
"If you want to keep someone away from your house, Just fire the shotgun through the door."
Vice President [and former lawyer] Joe Biden Field& Stream Magazine interview Feb 2013 "
0 -
F**k it.
Come on England.
/awaits abuseForum Charter - Useful Information - Photo thread: Hardware - Ranges by County - Hunting Laws/Important threads - Upcoming Events - RFDs by County
If you see a problem post use the report post function. Click on the three dots on the post, select "FLAG" & let a Moderator deal with it.
Moderators - Cass otmmyboy2 , CatMod - Shamboc , Admins - Beasty , mickeroo
0 -
-
-
-
Always a good idea NOT to write your letter of protest before you know who it's going to be against. :rolleyes:
Forum Charter - Useful Information - Photo thread: Hardware - Ranges by County - Hunting Laws/Important threads - Upcoming Events - RFDs by County
If you see a problem post use the report post function. Click on the three dots on the post, select "FLAG" & let a Moderator deal with it.
Moderators - Cass otmmyboy2 , CatMod - Shamboc , Admins - Beasty , mickeroo
0 -
I hope the TDs enjoy their well earned summer break, all 67 days of it. I mean they must be exhausted having passed a grand total of 13 pieces of new legislation. Not to mention having sat for a whole 64 days this year so far, it must be truly exhausting.
To put my "subtle" sarcasm in context they have passed 60% LESS legislation than in the previous years, have sat for 25% FEWER days than in the previous years, but have managed to give themselves €5,500 pay increase because "they're entitled to it".Forum Charter - Useful Information - Photo thread: Hardware - Ranges by County - Hunting Laws/Important threads - Upcoming Events - RFDs by County
If you see a problem post use the report post function. Click on the three dots on the post, select "FLAG" & let a Moderator deal with it.
Moderators - Cass otmmyboy2 , CatMod - Shamboc , Admins - Beasty , mickeroo
0 -
All posts from #562 onward were split from this thread.
Forum Charter - Useful Information - Photo thread: Hardware - Ranges by County - Hunting Laws/Important threads - Upcoming Events - RFDs by County
If you see a problem post use the report post function. Click on the three dots on the post, select "FLAG" & let a Moderator deal with it.
Moderators - Cass otmmyboy2 , CatMod - Shamboc , Admins - Beasty , mickeroo
0 -
Advertisement
-
Like anyone, LE purchasing officers are prone to sales hype too.
Don't mention SPAS12s and a certain film starring the future governor of California and said SPAS12, and coincidently of course the ERU and ARW acquiring said guns in the same year the film was released in Ireland. While suffering a "Idontlike de look o dat now"ban for us mere civilians.:rolleyes: Said SPAS's are now armoury rack queens gathering dust and collectors value.
The Hk MP7 is a supposedly body armour piercing round.4.6X30. According to the HK blurb "The new high-performance calibre penetrates the NATO CRISAT TARGET (1.6 mm titanium and 20 layers of kevlar) even at 200 m" I would tip on another fact,4.6 is so uncommon around here that the gun would be useless for anyone after expanding any ammo with it, whereas a 9mm, you could probably scrounge up some rounds around here or there.
TBH it is a better choice than the UZI, which is a CQB battlefield weapon that while slow for an SMG is still hardly a gun for civilian urban situations.This HK is controllable and more appropriately a personal defence weapon,but still a battlefield gun ,but the risk of over penetration from both is still horrendeous."If you want to keep someone away from your house, Just fire the shotgun through the door."
Vice President [and former lawyer] Joe Biden Field& Stream Magazine interview Feb 2013 "
0 -
I am genuinely curious as to why AGS even have access to such a weapon.
According to the internet, they are using an MP7A1.
Capable of 960 rpm / 16 rps and a capacity of 20, 30, or 40 rounds. This gives an effective mag life of 1.25 to 2.5 seconds on full auto.
How, in any scenario is this useful (except maybe in the hands of a criminal or terrorist)?
Yea it's great fun in Airsoft to have a MP "hedge trimmer" but the mag can hold several hundred rounds... Any firearms experience I've had WRT full auto weapons is that the only shot that counts is the first one, the rest are indiscriminate. That was from friends I went to ranges with in the US who had either military or police training.
You don't have to empty a magazine, burst fire is available too. You could also keep it on semi automatic.
What else would you suggest they use instead?0 -
Moderators, Category Moderators, Entertainment Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 22,584 CMod ✭✭✭✭Join Date:Posts: 21207
What else would you suggest they use instead?
My question was, why the need for a fully automatic weapon and what possible advantage would this give? What situation would it ever pay them to use it in?
I'm sure you have done way more CQB in airsoft than I have and know that the ability to blind fire an automatic gun around a corner of a building will result in more kills but in real life and where law enforcement is concerned, that is not possible.0 -
Moderators, Category Moderators, Entertainment Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 22,584 CMod ✭✭✭✭Join Date:Posts: 21207
A weapon limited to semi automatic.
My question was, why the need for a fully automatic weapon and what possible advantage would this give? What situation would it ever pay them to use it in?
I'm sure you have done way more CQB in airsoft than I have and know that the ability to blind fire an automatic gun around a corner of a building will result in more kills but in real life and where law enforcement is concerned, that is not possible.
To expand on that, If I was a front line soldier at war faced with a wave of oncoming enemy then yes, a fully automatic weapon has a purpose.
It has no use that I can see as a civilian peacekeeping tool, in fact, it the danger of it's loss to criminals - as apparent in this case - is far greater than any apparent potential usefulness.0 -
To expand on that, If I was a front line soldier at war faced with a wave of oncoming enemy then yes, a fully automatic weapon has a purpose.
So, as you say, it's very hard to think of a scenario where such a tool should be used by a civilian police force, especially in a city where there are people living pretty much everywhere that a stray round - or an over-penetrating round - could go.
It is not a thought that leaves me with the warm and fuzzies.0 -
A weapon limited to semi automatic.
My question was, why the need for a fully automatic weapon and what possible advantage would this give? What situation would it ever pay them to use it in?
I'm sure you have done way more CQB in airsoft than I have and know that the ability to blind fire an automatic gun around a corner of a building will result in more kills but in real life and where law enforcement is concerned, that is not possible.
Buddy airsoft really?... jesus christ. Adrenaline is a mighty drug(also someone could be on actual drugs like PCP) so it often takes more than one round to actually stop something or someone, and also i dont think mp7s come in semi auto only:pac:0 -
A weapon limited to semi automatic.
My question was, why the need for a fully automatic weapon and what possible advantage would this give? What situation would it ever pay them to use it in?
I'm sure you have done way more CQB in airsoft than I have and know that the ability to blind fire an automatic gun around a corner of a building will result in more kills but in real life and where law enforcement is concerned, that is not possible.
By the same rational, the ERU cars should be limited to 80mph.
That's the maximum allowable speed in this country.
But wait, there is a device to regulate the speed, called the accelerator.
Its operated by the Garda drivers right foot.
In the same vein, the weapon in question also had a device to regulate it's speed of fire.
It's called the selector switch.
It's operated by the Garda's finger or thumb, and used in conjunction with the trigger to regulate the rate of fire.0 -
I am genuinely curious as to why AGS even have access to such a weapon.
According to the internet, they are using an MP7A1.
Capable of 960 rpm / 16 rps and a capacity of 20, 30, or 40 rounds. This gives an effective mag life of 1.25 to 2.5 seconds on full auto.
How, in any scenario is this useful (except maybe in the hands of a criminal or terrorist)?
Yea it's great fun in Airsoft to have a MP "hedge trimmer" but the mag can hold several hundred rounds... Any firearms experience I've had WRT full auto weapons is that the only shot that counts is the first one, the rest are indiscriminate. That was from friends I went to ranges with in the US who had either military or police training.
The normal force does not have access to automatic weapons. The drug cartels have an abundance of fully automatic weapons in the country. Do you really need to ask why the ERU use fully automatic weapons?0 -
The normal force does not have access to automatic weapons. The drug cartels have an abundance of fully automatic weapons in the country. Do you really need to ask why the ERU use fully automatic weapons?
Yes. Because the drug gangs aren't supposed to be looking out for the well-being of the public, while the armed garda units are. Also, the armed gardai's tools are bought with public money, so frankly, whether we're buying the best tools for the job is something the public are allowed to question, and "best" in this case is not a metric set solely by the Gardai. We, the backstop, are part of that metric as well, so things like accuracy and over-penetration and the safety of the general public are factors.0 -
Advertisement
-
[QUOTE=o1s1n;107513008]You don't have to empty a magazine, burst fire is available too. You could also keep it on semi-automatic.
What else would you suggest they use instead?
You are dealing with two different doctrines of firearms usage. Military and police.
the military is designed for mass production, expend ammo,a lot of ammo, at a target,or group of targets in a trench,or enclosed area. You don't need a superior target rifle, when you have yourself,a squad,a designated marksman,a light support machine gunner, a "door kicker" CQB guy who carries a shotgun as well as breaching tools, and a radioman to call in artillery if you cant take or hold a position. Not to mind,you are expecting to have people being killed.A total opposite to any police operation. Look at the way the AK is laid out on the fire selector. Safe, FULL auto,Semi. The reason is simple. Its a doctrine of using full auto to storm positions, and then use semi to finish off any other survivors.
Police work OTOH is a whole different kettle of fish.The first edict of it is to save lives and not shoot at all,if at all possible.If say it is a hostage situation, you have it contained and cordoned off. Your snipers can pick their locations, have bags of time to set up and range estimate and do all the rest behind their super accurate and heavy rifles that are capable of ultra sub-MOA cold bore shots at a given distance. Compare a police sniper rifle to a military sniper rifle and you will see what I mean, two different doctrines and environments for a gun to be used in.
Its why the Germans developed the HK PSG1,a super accurate SA police rifle after Munich, where they discovered that surplus M1carbines with 4power scopes were not good police sniper weapons at Furstenfeldbruck airfield when the Black September lit up the Israeli hostages.But the PSG1 is way too heavy for a military sniper.At almost 12lbs you would be hard pushed to do a Gunny Hathcock 5day crawl to target with that lump.
So translating all of this to what we have here.A sub gun is by its nature not accurate,as most inc the AGS UZI are open bolt design. While simple does not lend to accuracy irrespective on semi or full.HK with their delayed roller back does give you better accuracy in their personal defence weapon which is what the 7 is.
[There is a difference now between PDW and SMG, usually more now with caliber rather than design and usage.A PDW is more used by military personnel who don't need a full assault rifle all the time.IE tank crews, radiomen, cooks, REMF's:) etc, and ignoring the logistics of supplying two different calibre ammo... But again .how accurate can you be resting your cheek on a wire strut? If you are going to be doing headshots from 10 to 100 meters over iron sights off a wire frame stock and can assure 100% hits. I doff my cap to you Sir.
Next problem, human reaction under stress fire. There is plenty of evidence of US police officers literally emptying their service pistols into a victim, reloading, and shooting another mag into the corpse. Their after action reports make interesting reading and even under questioning a variation of this is"I thought I had only fired 4or 5shots and didn't even realise I had reloaded"
IOW in the time when the bullets are flying, people can go into shutdown mode and go to instinct and training takes over.So how easy could it be for someone to hit the full switch and not realise it?
Finally, our policing using firearms is totally different to the rest of the worlds armed police.An incident occurs with armed police, the first officer on the scene's job is to access and if possible contain the situation while radio in for backup, guaranteeing that more armed help is on the way within minutes.
Here our unarmed police have to radio in for armed support,who might be nowhere near,and the situation could have changed dramatically in minutes. Ergo, having full auto won't contain the situation much better,and going by incidents like Athy and Garde Effie getting shot by friendly fire, it sounds like the last thing you want in a situation involving civilians.
Ultimately, who is responsible for someone using a full auto weapon and the shots go and hit some innocent party. We are responsible every time we pull the trigger on single shot.I'd hate to be the person in the witness box or the chief commissioner or the justice minister explaining why my burst of 9mm managed to miss my target,but riddled Mrs Murphy's kitchen window, her dog and the late Mr Murphy by mistake.
So what do we need to arm our AGS properly?I would say a short barrelled carbine in semi-auto with 308 and the proper ammo[Black tip armour piercing] if facing barricaded or Kevlar, and literally HUNTING ammo hollow point boat tail for nigh on one shot ending of situations. Ironically, police forces CAN use HP ammo as the Hauge and Geneva conventions only refer to military prohibitions on its use.
In fact, HK made a perfectly good rifle for this the HK SLB 2000.30.06. It's accurate for police work, detachable box mag, a calibre that has plenty of AP and frangible bullets to prevent over penetration."If you want to keep someone away from your house, Just fire the shotgun through the door."
Vice President [and former lawyer] Joe Biden Field& Stream Magazine interview Feb 2013 "
0