Low Breastfeeding rates linked to Catholic Guilt

JupiterKid · 06-12-2016 12:24AM #1

According to a study, Ireland has the lowest breastfeeding rates in the developed world and this is very closely linked to its Catholic heritage. Despite breastfeeding being widely acknowledged as best for babies, less than half of Irish women have tried it. In the 1970s, breastfeeding reached a low of 11%.

Here's a link to the article about the study;
http://www.irishtimes.com/news/health/religion-cited-as-influencing-low-breastfeeding-rates-1.2894194

So it looks like despite all the changes here in the past 25 years, Irish Catholic guilt is still alive and well.

BoJack Horseman · 06-12-2016 12:35AM

Where is 'guilt' mentioned?

Being a product of the 80's I wasn't breast-fed.... but that was largely because my mother couldn't be arsed & she would be just dropping fag-ash on me all the time anyway!

I don't think guilt was an issue..

RobertKK · 06-12-2016 12:36AM

Catholic guilt is a load of rubbish and an excuse, a lot of women want the men to help feed the baby and a lot of women don't want to milk or 'express' their milk. They would rather go dry.

btw I think babies should get their mother's milk if the situation allows.

darkpagandeath · 06-12-2016 12:39AM

Does Ireland not produce a load of formula ? And don't they give you formula and that in the basket you get from the maternity hospital ?

FortySeven · 06-12-2016 12:39AM

The 70s was the height of Catholic oppression?

Isn't it more to do simply with the availability of alternatives?

Next they'll be saying elective c sections are growing due to salafism taking hold.

FortySeven · 06-12-2016 12:42AM

Being an atheist I never experienced Catholic guilt but then I suppose, both my kids were breastfed.

Bloody Catholics, starving the babies and such. Barbarians, the lot of ya!

Subcomandante Marcos · 06-12-2016 12:42AM

I'd say it has more to do with us producing a massive percentage of the worlds dairy based formula, the marketing push around the same in the 70's and the convenience it brought for mothers.

Cupcake_Crisis · 06-12-2016 12:42AM

I don't buy the Catholic guilt thing, especially with women in my age group. Anyone I know who didn't breast feed didn't do it because it was too painful or they just didn't want to.

fatknacker · 06-12-2016 12:45AM

Maybe it's just not convenient or possible for lots of women to have baldy hanging off their tit all the time.

drunkmonkey · 06-12-2016 12:50AM

Cupcake_Crisis wrote: »

I don't buy the Catholic guilt thing, especially with women in my age group. Anyone I know who didn't breast feed didn't do it because it was too painful or they just didn't want to.

How about the women that did, what was their motivation.

FortySeven · 06-12-2016 12:51AM

drunkmonkey wrote: »

How about the women that did, what was their motivation.

They gave a ****.

GreenFolder2 · 06-12-2016 12:51AM

I would have thought it was more of a case of Ireland clinging to British Victorian puritanical views of the body for far longer than it should have.

I find a lot of British studies and commentary can be a bit fixated on Catholic vs Protestant.

The flavour of religious conservatism found here in the past was basically a catholic version of extreme Victorian puritanical notions about terror of nudity, fear of sexuality etc etc

Goya · 06-12-2016 12:52AM

I see a Waterford Whispers headline in the pipeline: "Atheists significantly more obsessed with catholic guilt than actual catholics are".

drunkmonkey · 06-12-2016 12:54AM

GreenFolder2 wrote: »

I would have thought it was more of a case of Ireland clinging to British Victorian puritanical views of the body for far longer than it should have.

I find a lot of British studies and commentary can be a bit fixated on Catholic vs Protestant.

The flavour of religious conservatism found here in the past was basically a catholic version of extreme Victorian puritanical notions about terror of nudity, fear of sexuality etc etc

Or how about Irish women are way to obsessed with keeping themselves looking good even when it comes to boobs we never see bar the odd roaster of a day in may.

FortySeven · 06-12-2016 12:54AM

GreenFolder2 wrote: »

I would have thought it was more of a case of Ireland clinging to British Victorian puritanical views of the body for far longer than it should have.

I find a lot of British studies and commentary can be a bit fixated on Catholic vs Protestant.

The flavour of religious conservatism found here in the past was basically a catholic version of extreme Victorian puritanical notions about terror of nudity, fear of sexuality etc etc

Blaming the Brits? That's a low blow right there.

rgace · 06-12-2016 12:55AM

Cupcake_Crisis wrote: »

I don't buy the Catholic guilt thing, especially with women in my age group. Anyone I know who didn't breast feed didn't do it because it was too painful or they just didn't want to.

I am not sure if Catholic guilt is the correct term but I have discussed this with women who saw it as a sexual act and inappropriate for a baby. We were all young at the time of the discussion so it could be a maturity thing.

What reasons do those who just didn't want to have?

drunkmonkey · 06-12-2016 12:56AM

Supping milk from your mammy is not a sexual act. Jesus what are these women thinking.

GreenFolder2 · 06-12-2016 12:58AM

FortySeven wrote: »

Blaming the Brits? That's a low blow right there.

Well the uk does have the lowest breastfeeding rates in the world. It's hardly surprising given the cultural links Ireland does too.

http://www.britishscienceassociation.org/news/breastfeeding-rates-in-uk-are-the-lowest-in-the-world

Goya · 06-12-2016 12:58AM

rgace wrote: »

I am not sure if Catholic guilt is the correct term but I have discussed this with women who saw it as a sexual act and inappropriate for a baby. We were all young at the time of the discussion so it could be a maturity thing.

What reasons do those who just didn't want to have?

As Cupcake said, too painful. It can be very difficult with baby just not latching on and/or severe soreness. Depends on the breasts. My mother started working as a nurse in the 60s - said choosing not to breastfeed due to the pain (not modesty or wanting to keep boobs looking perky) was always a thing, and something she never found objectionable as it's not manageable for all women (even though she breastfed all her children).

RobertKK · 06-12-2016 12:59AM

rgace wrote: »

I am not sure if Catholic guilt is the correct term but I have discussed this with women who saw it as a sexual act and inappropriate for a baby. We were all young at the time of the discussion so it could be a maturity thing.

What reasons do those who just didn't want to have?

Far from sexual... I mean does one see a lamb sucking the tit of the ewe as sexual, or a suckler cow with her calf. I mean we are all mammals.

I was not breasted, but then I grew up on a dairy farm and we had lots of cows milk...

FortySeven · 06-12-2016 01:00AM

drunkmonkey wrote: »

Supping milk from your mammy is not a sexual act. Jesus what are these women thinking.

It's part of the rape culture. Us men are using our children to oppress and abuse them.

Didn't you get the memo from the brotherhood about the most effective way to deploy a newborn?

drunkmonkey · 06-12-2016 01:00AM

GreenFolder2 wrote: »

Well the uk does have the lowest breastfeeding rates in the world. It's hardly surprising given the cultural links Ireland does too.

God gave British women the biggest boobs in Europe. What was he thinking.

BoJack Horseman · 06-12-2016 01:01AM

rgace wrote: »

I have discussed this with women who saw it as a sexual act and inappropriate for a baby. We were all young at the time of the discussion so it could be a maturity thing

So..... the bottles teat is the newborn equivalent of the fleshlight.

Where did you find these 'women'?

FortySeven · 06-12-2016 01:02AM

drunkmonkey wrote: »

God gave British women the biggest boobs in Europe. What was he thinking.

Sadly, he didn't give them long enough arms to hold the baby down there.

rgace · 06-12-2016 01:06AM

Flimpson wrote: »

As Cupcake said, too painful. It can be very difficult with baby just not latching on and/or severe soreness. Depends on the breasts. My mother started working as a nurse in the 60s - said choosing not to breastfeed due to the pain (not modesty or wanting to keep boobs looking perky) was always a thing, and something she never found objectionable as it's not manageable for all women (even though she breastfed all her children).

I would assume that is the reason in the majority of cases. I could be wrong but mothers probably spend less time in hospital after giving birth nowadays, time which could be used to practice breastfeeding with the help of a midwife if they are struggling

Cupcake_Crisis · 06-12-2016 01:13AM

drunkmonkey wrote: »

How about the women that did, what was their motivation.

They wanted to?

FortySeven wrote: »

Blaming the Brits? That's a low blow right there.

As is insinuating that women who don't breast feed don't give a **** about their babies, but there you go.

rgace wrote: »

I am not sure if Catholic guilt is the correct term but I have discussed this with women who saw it as a sexual act and inappropriate for a baby. We were all young at the time of the discussion so it could be a maturity thing.

What reasons do those who just didn't want to have?

That's their business, not mine!

darkpagandeath · 06-12-2016 01:14AM

drunkmonkey wrote: »

God gave British women the biggest boobs in Europe. What was he thinking.

Balances out with the teeth though ?

FortySeven · 06-12-2016 01:17AM

Cupcake_Crisis wrote: »

As is insinuating that women who don't breast feed don't give a **** about their babies, but there you go.

when done for convenience and comfort?

Against all that we know about it being beneficial to development and immunity?

Yes, selfish as ****.

Cupcake_Crisis · 06-12-2016 01:23AM

FortySeven wrote: »

when done for convenience and comfort?

Against all that we know about it being beneficial to development and immunity?

Yes, selfish as ****.

Any woman who's gone through a 9 month pregnancy and a labour has earned the right to decide to be comfortable. We also know that there are perfectly good substitutes for breast milk so that the baby still gets everything it needs.

Some mothers don't produce enough milk, their milk is lacking in certain vitamins, is bad for the baby or its just too painful. Maybe give it a second thought before you tell them they don't give a ****.

drunkmonkey · 06-12-2016 01:31AM

Should be mandatory, people step toe around mums, time to get tough on the ones who won't get their boobs out of the babs.
The figures don't lie, Irish women just aren't doing it left to themselves.

FortySeven · 06-12-2016 01:33AM

Cupcake_Crisis wrote: »

Any woman who's gone through a 9 month pregnancy and a labour has earned the right to decide to be comfortable. We also know that there are perfectly good substitutes for breast milk so that the baby still gets everything it needs.

Some mothers don't produce enough milk, their milk is lacking in certain vitamins, is bad for the baby or its just too painful. Maybe give it a second thought before you tell them they don't give a ****.

Bunch of crybabies these 'modern' mum's really. Generations managed this simple task over and over again. Modern mums need rests, alternatives, substitutes..

There are NO better alternatives to breastmilk.

Having a child is the most natural thing in the world and for all the hatred I have for my ex I will say this for her, there was none of this nonsense. She carried, birthed and fed my kids like a trooper.

None of this whinging malarkey and pretending it is something special. It's breeding. It's what we do as a race. We're really successful at it.
At least we used to be. Now it's become an industry and a talking shop of nonsense.

We're animals. We breed. It's not special.

Low Breastfeeding rates linked to Catholic Guilt

Comments