Guess which one?

Sherifu

Youve already said the two men know each other and know the person whos arm it is.
Is this relevant to answer?

monkeyfudge

Modified wrote:

Youve already said the two men know each other and know the person whos arm it is.
Is this relevant to answer?

This is HIGHLY relevant... yes... ha

Sherifu

monkeyfudge wrote:

This is HIGHLY relevant... yes... ha

Finally

Sherifu

Are they friends?

monkeyfudge

No. They're not really friends. But they would know each other very well.

Sherifu

workmates?

Spalk0

members of a cult? organisation?

monkeyfudge

Trigger! wrote:

members of a cult? organisation?

Cult? No. Organisation? No. Workmates? No.

There is another word out there for you to find.

Brothers in arms?!

penguinbloke

Comrades in arms

->insert tumble weed here<-

I feel so dirty

[edit]Damn you papa smut[/edit]

Sherifu

1 legged pimps?

monkeyfudge

All 3 men have a full compliment of legs.

And to the best of my knowledge none of them ever enjoyed gainful employment in the pimping industry...

Sherifu

penpals?
irc buddies?

monkeyfudge

Modified wrote:

penpals?
irc buddies?

Ah yes... how many times has having a budy on irc led to arm amputations... people need to watch themselves out there...

But this isn't the case this time around.

Sherifu

monkeyfudge wrote:

Ah yes... how many times has having a budy on irc led to arm amputations... people need to watch themselves out there...

But this isn't the case this time around.

So your saying their relationship caused the amputation?

monkeyfudge

Modified wrote:

So your saying their relationship caused the amputation?

Hmmm... that's a tough one... Let's just say that it is a combination nature of the relationship and circumstances that led to it.

penguinbloke

Was it the doctors arm?

Sherifu

monkeyfudge wrote:

Hmmm... that's a tough one... Let's just say that it is a combination nature of the relationship and circumstances that led to it.

I see blood in the water.
*circles for kill*

monkeyfudge

penguinbloke wrote:

Was it the doctors arm?

finally... yes.. it was the doctors arm.

monomaniac

monkeyfudge wrote:

Ah yes... how many times has having a budy on irc led to arm amputations... people need to watch themselves out there...

But this isn't the case this time around.

Brilliant!!

Glad to see the puzzling is still continuing.
The 2 men both have limbs missing - did they both lose limbs in the same event? Or has the loss of limbs brought them together - hospital, support group etc.

And are they both missing arms? Or different limbs?

Do all 3 men live in the same town/county/country? Is this relevant?

monomaniac

Did the doctor amputate his own arm? And what motivated him to post his arm. Does he "want" to be amputated to have some connection with the other two men?

monomaniac

monomaniac wrote:

Did the doctor amputate his own arm? And what motivated him to post his arm. Does he "want" to be amputated to have some connection with the other two men?

How does he feel about his father?

monkeyfudge

monomaniac wrote:

Brilliant!!

Glad to see the puzzling is still continuing.
The 2 men both have limbs missing - did they both lose limbs in the same event? Or has the loss of limbs brought them together - hospital, support group etc.

And are they both missing arms? Or different limbs?

Do all 3 men live in the same town/county/country? Is this relevant?

Both the men who received the arm in the post are each missing an arm.

They pretty much lost their in the same event. The loss of the arms was not what brought them together though.

It doesn't really matter where they all live.

Hmm.. going out on a limb here *couldn't resist!* Were they Siamese twins?

penguinbloke

due to the actions of the doctor each man lost an arm. and after years of guilt the doctor cuts off his own arm and mails it to the first man who understand and sends it to his buddy.

So the doctor did it
firstly to appease his guilt
but mainly because he's an idiot.

monkeyfudge

monomaniac wrote:

Did the doctor amputate his own arm? And what motivated him to post his arm. Does he "want" to be amputated to have some connection with the other two men?

Well, the doctor needed assistence from a collegue to amputate his arm.

The connection was already there before he had his arm amputated.

He also resents his father for not buying him that pony when he turned 'sweet sixteen'... but this isn't important... ha

And no siamese twins, sorry... but a VERY nice try all the same...

monkeyfudge

penguinbloke wrote:

due to the actions of the doctor each man lost an arm. and after years of guilt the doctor cuts off his own arm and mails it to the first man who understand and sends it to his buddy.

So the doctor did it
firstly to appease his guilt
but mainly because he's an idiot.

The doctors actions are partly the cause of the other men losing an arm each. But guilt has nothing to do with it.

They're all brothers, The arm is the only remains of a brother who died in an explosion. They examine to make sure it is, then give it a burial in the woods, like it was requested..

Hmmm?

Sherifu

Have to go now.
Pity i won't see this one cracked.
The end is nigh for it.

Sherifu

Papa Smut wrote:

They're all brothers, The arm is the only remains of a brother who died in an explosion. They examine to make sure it is, then give it a burial in the woods, like it was requested..

Hmmm?

Except theyre not related as i recall!