Favorite Old School WWF Wrestler

wrestlemaniac

Undertaker.

Tough one to call. Both men have had stand out matches, rivalries and longevity but Taker just shades it for me.

Chuck Noland

Missed all today’s action. Austin going out was a shock!

HBK here for me

Jayesdiem

Undertaker

Christ, that's a tough one.

I had to flip a coin. It was tails.


The Sexy Boy wins.

Too Tough To Die

HBK. The best to ever do it. Could have a great match with anyone. Always found taker a little one dimensional.

Why no mention of Goldust or his dad Dusty Rhodes?

Lewis_Benson

Undertaker, the tombstone, and later the last ride were devastating,


Sweet chin music is a girls move.

Reberetta

HBK for his legendary overselling against the Hulkster.

Omackeral

Undertaker buries Shawn Michaels. Who's he gonna meet in the final? Stay tuned, that'll be decided next.

Omackeral

Mankind




VS


Macho Man Randy Savage

Rikand

Two great wrestlers. Either could win it out for me.

I'll go HBK just to make it a contest

Rikand

Macho man randy savage. Mankind transcended multiple eras, but macho man was everything that was brilliant about the 90s

Nunu

Can’t believe I’m saying this but Mankind.

Mainly because Hell in a Cell revisited is just too tasty a finale.

I will never ever forget watching that live. Possibly the most engrossing head in hands entertainment broadcast I’ve ever witnessed.

Necro

Mankind.

How Savage beat Austin is just a crazy travesty.

Mankind had the better career, was the better worker, cut a better promo (as three different characters, four including Foley)

Undertaker VS Mankind was a fantastic feud and would be a fantastic final.

Mrs Foley's Baby Boy!!

Sultan of Bling

Randy Savage all the way.

The flying elbow and the beautiful sidekick.

Oh miss Elizabeth

Sultan of Bling

HBK

Tough call but it's just a personal preference. Just enjoyed watching him more.

PsychoPete

Mankind, mainly because his daughter is a beautiful specimen

Mankind. Aside from maybe commentary, I cannot think of a single facet of wrestling in which Macho Man was better.


And I want to annoy the Macho Men.

Wuff Wuff

Mankind

Mankind, for reasons given in an earlier round, plus...


Undertaker v Mankind final!

wrestlemaniac

Mankind and all his various incarnations trumps Macho man

Macho Man trying to pin Yoko at the conclusion of the 1993 Rumble is still some funny shít almost 30 years later.

Mankind for me, too. Much more versatile a character. Could be scary and funny, even in the same promo.


Never forget his Orton 'spit' promo (skip to about 5 mins)


https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x4fhlpn

Kolido

Macho man for me. He had it all, the look, the entrence, promo, worker. Mankind was great also but he worked with great opponents. Macho man at his peak was just so much better.

Macho man

everlast75

Looks like it's a Hell in a cell final folks!

Omackeral

It comes down to these two.

They've every match you can imagine.

Boiler Room Brawl



Buried Alive



and most famously, Hell in a Cell



But who do you prefer. That's the question. Let this roll til 11PM. Most votes win.

Chuck Noland

Taker

Streaks, Entrances, deadman or biker

Bearer or Ministry of darkness

He’s been great

Living legend

Wuff Wuff

Taker

Their fued was great but he edge's it for me

Necro

Hmmmm...

I think I have to vote for Mankind here.

Looking back over both careers it's clear Taker went on (and is still doing so) for at least 5 years too long which has sullied his reputation imo.

Taker was better in the ring

Mankind by far the better promo

If you asked me this question around the time of the HBK matches there would only be one winner, and that's Undertaker

But now....

I'm going to vote for Mrs Foley's Baby Boy

Boy that'll put bums on seats

Kolido

Gotta be the Taker. 30+ years and he is still going. He has beat them all, Hogan, Bret, Shawn, Hunter, Damien Demento.

Great final but easy choice

Longevity does it for The Undertaker.