Werewolf: HBO's Deadwood

Brendan WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

I wonder did the wolves get a list of claimable nrvs to counter a claim fest

Reason I included my name was for clarity as it doesn't really matter as much now the SK is dead tbh.

Phil WW

NRVs should never out themselves like that. By doing so, if good, you've narrowed down the list of targets for baddies.

You've started a narrative that you're utterly unimportant, and volunteered a role claim super quickly.

Wendy WW

Mary WW wrote: »

Someone help me with my logic here. It does rely on me not being a wolf but I know that’s true so I’m going to run with it

Gr1:
Mary
Vernon
Des
Eva
Conor

Gr2:
Brendan
Conor
Vernon
Ewan
Des

From gr2 we know there’s a wolf in Brendan Conor and ewan

If Brendan or Conor are wolves it’s unlikely ewan is since he volunteered for gr2 to ensure we had coverage. Similarly if ewan is a wolf it’s unlikely Brendan or Conor are.

If Conor is a wolf and the wolves relied on a slip by Vernon in gr1 then it’s impossible for him to pick 5 in gr1 and still use that strategy.

But if he didn’t pick 5 and there was no slip he’d be caught when number 6 won the prize

So Conor is unlikely to be a wolf
Which gives one wolf from ewan and Brendan

I don't see why its unlikely that Ewan is a wolf ?

Surely the wolves can get people into the list to try and win prizes for themselves. If they win all they have to say is that they didn't win

Mary WW

Phil WW wrote: »

repost it :P



Oh, I don't like that at all.....

Go on....

Brendan WW

Phil WW wrote: »

NRVs should never out themselves like that. By doing so, if good, you've narrowed down the list of targets for baddies.

You've started a narrative that you're utterly unimportant, and volunteered a role claim super quickly.

Oh sorry did you write the book on how to play Werewolf now :rolleyes:

Wendy WW

There's nothing to atop villagers going rogue and picking unassigned numbers. In fact, I think for future sessions we shouldn't assign people to numbers. All we're doing is showing the wolves where the villagers are picking. I think in a task like this, wolves having very little information is far better than them having lots of it. And it's very very unlikely that we're going to get all 5 villagers in the top 5 pick list

Brendan WW

By the way, I absolutely hate players that say NRVs are utterly unimportant. Because it's bullsh1t.

Shows a basic lack of understanding of the game to be honest and an over reliance on roled players to dig people out of holes.

Praytell Phil, you were also criticising Eva iirc for outing as the Doc yesterday.

Sorry we don't all add up to your perfect play.

Or am I just closing the net on your wolf buddy Ewan I wonder...

Mary WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

I don't see why its unlikely that Ewan is a wolf ?

Surely the wolves can get people into the list to try and win prizes for themselves. If they win all they have to say is that they didn't win

Read what I actually wrote- if Brendan or Conor are wolves then a wolf ewan shouldn’t volunteer. If they’re village then a wolf ewan does volunteer. It’s an either/or

Wendy WW

Brendan WW wrote: »

Reason I included my name was for clarity as it doesn't really matter as much now the SK is dead tbh.

Well you included A name. Whether its your name or not, time will tell

Mary WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

There's nothing to atop villagers going rogue and picking unassigned numbers. In fact, I think for future sessions we shouldn't assign people to numbers. All we're doing is showing the wolves where the villagers are picking. I think in a task like this, wolves having very little information is far better than them having lots of it. And it's very very unlikely that we're going to get all 5 villagers in the top 5 pick list

Wendy your posts this morning are troubling me greatly

Wendy WW

Mary WW wrote: »

Read what I actually wrote- if Brendan or Conor are wolves then a wolf ewan shouldn’t volunteer. If they’re village then a wolf ewan does volunteer. It’s an either/or

My point is, is that I don't necessarily agree with what you wrote

Phil WW

Brendan WW wrote: »

By the way, I absolutely hate players that say NRVs are utterly unimportant. Because it's bullsh1t.

Shows a basic lack of understanding of the game to be honest and an over reliance on roled players to dig people out of holes.

Praytell Phil, you were also criticising Eva iirc for outing as the Doc yesterday.

Sorry we don't all add up to your perfect play.

Or am I just closing the net on your wolf buddy Ewan I wonder...

Did I criticize Eva for outing as Doc? I wasn't even online when it happened, and my memory is I haven't made comment on it either.

Snark, btw, is going to get you absolutely nowhere here. If anything, it's going to dig your hole a bit quicker....

Phil WW

Mary WW wrote: »

Wendy your posts this morning are troubling me greatly

Oh, that's not just me then? That's a relief....

Wendy WW

Mary WW wrote: »

Wendy your posts this morning are troubling me greatly

Because you're a wolf and I'm trying to win the game for the village. Yes, if I was in your position as a wolf, that would trouble me greatly

Mary WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

My point is, is that I don't necessarily agree with what you wrote

Explain the flaw in my logic so. I’ve put it in simple steps and included my assumptions.

Brendan WW

Phil WW wrote: »

Did I criticize Eva for outing as Doc? I wasn't even online when it happened, and my memory is I haven't made comment on it either.

Snark, btw, is going to get you absolutely nowhere here. If anything, it's going to dig your hole a bit quicker....

Ah, apologies on that - it was Angus, your avatars are similar.

I just hate when players call NRVs unimportant. A single NRV can solve the game for the village, they are not unimportant.

As Gertrude said, all villager lives matter.

Wendy WW

Mary WW wrote: »

Wendy your posts this morning are troubling me greatly

Well take your scenario where you say that we might have a wolf, Ewen in the list from 1-4

Do you know what, I'm going to stop this train of thought right here.

The assigned numbers does work. I was thinking of a 5 wolf wolf team

Steve WW

Okay everyone, I’ve reread everything I quickly went over last night and have a few thoughts.

Perhaps I should explain as it’s been said a couple of times and while I was catching up I was ready to explain this to Vernon who brought it up first. RIP Vern. I threw an idea out for goldrush, there wasn’t a lot of traffic on thread at the time and I believed it was random and fair. I said I wouldn’t be available today but am for both over the next two days indefinitely.

Hell it wasn’t a complete bust anyway, we now know for a fact at least one of the top 4 is a wolf and that’s something the seer can look into and leave us breadcrumbs for without revealing themselves.

If anyone has a better idea for today then I’m all ears?.

Lynch tonight should be interesting, So going by those 4 we have Brendan, Mary and Conor as possible wolves? I have a few suspicions of my own, I need a large cup of coffee and another read over to gather more detail but I’ll be a lot more active today and will share my thoughts shortly.

Abigail WW

Didn't see that reveal coming, I had been suspicious of Des, Ewan and maybe Mary but that does suddenly shine more of a light on Bren

Wendy WW

Mary WW wrote: »

Explain the flaw in my logic so. I’ve put it in simple steps and included my assumptions.

I was wrong and thinking wrong and I'd like to pull out right now

Holly WW

WerewolfGM wrote: »

Vote results:

Vernon WW (6) - Wendy WW, Angus WW, Katie WW, Conor WW, Holly WW, Phil WW
Desmond WW (3) - Abigail WW, Brendan WW, Tegan WW
Brendan WW (2) - Ewan WW, Frank WW
Ewan WW (1) - Mary WW
Holly WW (1) - Vernon WW
Wendy WW (1) - Gertrude WW
Mary WW (1) - Desmond WW

Did not Vote - Steve WW

Ewan on Brendan
Brendan on Des
Conor on Vernon
Des on Mary


Just as the 4 on goldrush to see where they voted. Interestingly Frank on Brendan who we know is the sheriff.

Brendan was also extremely defensive last night close to lynch, my concern here is if he was worried as a wolf he would have hopped on Vernon aswell but it seemed to be between him Vernon and Des so Des is a good second shout for a scared wolf to dive on in a potential close lynch vote

Mary WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Because you're a wolf and I'm trying to win the game for the village. Yes, if I was in your position as a wolf, that would trouble me greatly

Ah Wendy, aren’t you going to at least try to dance a little before letting the mask slip.

Go on so, let’s have you make a case.....

Wendy WW

Gertrude, if you're a new player, you are allowed to change your vote when you realise that you are wrong

Wendy WW

Mary WW wrote: »

Ah Wendy, aren’t you going to at least try to dance a little before letting the mask slip.

Go on so, let’s have you make a case.....

Keep reading lol

I was thinking along the lines of wolves being able to cover all 5 slots. I was mistaken

Conor WW

Brendan WW wrote: »

By the way, I absolutely hate players that say NRVs are utterly unimportant. Because it's bullsh1t.

Shows a basic lack of understanding of the game to be honest and an over reliance on roled players to dig people out of holes.

Praytell Phil, you were also criticising Eva iirc for outing as the Doc yesterday.

Sorry we don't all add up to your perfect play.

Or am I just closing the net on your wolf buddy Ewan I wonder...

Can't find Phil doing any criticizing of Eva yesterday chief.

Holly WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Keep reading lol

I was thinking along the lines of wolves being able to cover all 5 slots. I was mistaken

And what, even if they could cover all 5 slots the strategy wouldn't change massively other than to allocate an extra number!

Anyone in gold rush yesterday should be out of first 5 today, I'd also suggest leaving Wendy out too

Wendy WW

Holly WW wrote: »

Ewan on Brendan
Brendan on Des
Conor on Vernon
Des on Mary


Just as the 4 on goldrush to see where they voted. Interestingly Frank on Brendan who we know is the sheriff.

Brendan was also extremely defensive last night close to lynch, my concern here is if he was worried as a wolf he would have hopped on Vernon aswell but it seemed to be between him Vernon and Des so Des is a good second shout for a scared wolf to dive on in a potential close lynch vote

If wolves were seer hunting last night, then they definitely could have been going all in on Brendan wolf

Brendan WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Keep reading lol

I was thinking along the lines of wolves being able to cover all 5 slots. I was mistaken

It was technically possible when the SK was alive.

I say technically, as the OP has no mention of a shared backroom, which makes me think they couldn't communicate.

Wendy WW

Holly WW wrote: »

And what, even if they could cover all 5 slots the strategy wouldn't change massively other than to allocate an extra number!

Anyone in gold rush yesterday should be out of first 5 today, I'd also suggest leaving Wendy out too

Like I've said since yesterday, I can't commit to the times for gold rush so I am out anyways.

I was mis thinking the strategy completely, partly through a miscount on the numbers and partly through a misunderstanding of the strategy and as stated, I have bailed out on this train of thought

Conor WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

If wolves were seer hunting last night, then they definitely could have been going all in on Brendan wolf

I don't understand your point here?