Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Orla WW

Riona WW wrote: »

I need to go back home aswell . . Ive spent waaaaayyy too long in here . .

Nigel WW

Urgh, Pete Burns

Riona WW

Conor WW wrote: »

Steve is looking very suspect.

I saw Stevie live in concert in the O2 a few years ago . . He's an exceptional entertainer even if he is dodgy . .

Abigail WW

Riona WW wrote: »

Its my jeff was a wolf, gaff all over again . :pac:

could be another one alright unless im reading it wrong how could Brendan protect him if he (Brendan) is being protected via being in Jail where powers don't work?

D.I Lestrade – Geoff , Graham, Giles, Gavin Lestrade. Its Greg by the way. Can jail someone every night phase, jailed people lose backroom access and all powers during the night phase but cannot be killed while jailed. Can only jail the same player once.

Nigel WW

#FFA4:

Steve - gotta be consistent, voted for him last two nights and nothing has convinced me of him being good since, rather more stuff against him (his weird exchange with Eva)
Isla - too damn quiet, a second low-lying wolf?

I don't really have a third, which worries me if there's four wolves left. There are some seriously deep hidden wolves out there. I'd be surprised if they're low posters as I think we already have two in the above (so, thinking two of Orla, Eva, Riona, Derry, Gabriel), but where they are I find really hard to judge and couldn't necessarily put one in as a third over any of the others.

Riona WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

#FFA4

Steve: Was on my FFA yesterday, the person I voted ahead of him is dead and Steve himself was one of the people pushing for him (re:Evas point he is also the person who drew attention on another now confirmed NRV in Doris pre her lynch), he fits the low lying wolf perfectly and I had almost no read on him until yesterday as a result. He was very odd when talking about his hospitalisation too

Riona: I think there was probably a wolf snuck in with Wini/Irene's core of villagers and tbh it's not easy choosing between Riona, Orla & Eva for who is the talkative wolf. Since the formation of that group Riona stood out a bit more than the others (she didn't that much for me before then) for me esp seemingly trying to counter Conors priest reveal but it is very tight between Riona and Orla while Eva has gotten more of a village lean from me since her sub reveal. Maybe it's too Meta but Orla for me is just playing an Orla style game although she has gone quieter as it's gone on.

Isla: Also made my FFA yesterday and the reasons still hold true now esp as she has continued to be quiet, would also fit the low lying wolf role but ive less of a read on her than Steve

I am guessing I have finally said something that's peaked the interest of the wolves. Between you and Derrys wafer thin ice cream reasons for going after me, I am happy to see how this plays out tonight . .

Everybody can see my Conor reaction and me explain exactly why it happened. . Tell you what, what in Conors reveal puts me under suspicion ? Why would I immediately react so negatively to Conors reveal if I was in a calculated wolf pack trying to look villagey ?

Look how active I was around munch. I was the only villager on thread . . I was the only villager who actually responded to Conor. Sure it was impulsive, but it wasn't staged. I didn't know Conor was coming out. If I was a wolf surely I would of taken a step back to see what I could get out of Conors reveal ?

Nigel WW

Actually, scratch that. Just checking my FFA compilation (just four so far, so it's not long yet) and see Derry didn't include Steve on his, which I think is sus, so am putting him for my third, so, #FFA4:

Steve
Isla
Derry

But I'm voting for Steve.

Abigail WW

Riona WW wrote: »

I am guessing I have finally said something that's peaked the interest of the wolves. Between you and Derrys wafer thin ice cream reasons for going after me, I am happy to see how this plays out tonight . .

Everybody can see my Conor reaction and me explain exactly why it happened. . Tell you what, what in Conors reveal puts me under suspicion ? Why would I immediately react so negatively to Conors reveal if I was in a calculated wolf pack trying to look villagey ?

Look how active I was around munch. I was the only villager on thread . . I was the only villager who actually responded to Conor. Sure it was impulsive, but it wasn't staged. I didn't know Conor was coming out. If I was a wolf surely I would of taken a step back to see what I could get out of Conors reveal ?

it simply came down to 1 of you, Eva & Orla as I think Wini/Irene would have tried to get one of her wolves into her village core. Since that reveal you have stood out the most.



I do not intend to vote for you if I am honest because I have already voted and as stated I usually weight my FFAs, but I will always put 3 names down if I can

Orla WW

Riona WW wrote: »

I am guessing I have finally said something that's peaked the interest of the wolves. Between you and Derrys wafer thin ice cream reasons for going after me, I am happy to see how this plays out tonight . .

Everybody can see my Conor reaction and me explain exactly why it happened. . Tell you what, what in Conors reveal puts me under suspicion ? Why would I immediately react so negatively to Conors reveal if I was in a calculated wolf pack trying to look villagey ?

Look how active I was around munch. I was the only villager on thread . . I was the only villager who actually responded to Conor. Sure it was impulsive, but it wasn't staged. I didn't know Conor was coming out. If I was a wolf surely I would of taken a step back to see what I could get out of Conors reveal ?

You know, your defense there reminded me of a movie I was watching the other day.

Are you the bearded lady?

Isla WW

Hey guys

Isla WW

For once I have been able to keep up on my reading, just a busy day once again so couldn't post

Gabriel WW

Isla WW wrote:

For once I have been able to keep up on my reading, just a busy day once again so couldn't post

Great! Thoughts?

Riona WW

8-4 as it stands if Conor is correct

Alive after Tonight's Lynch = 11 after tonight Best case 8-3 - worst case 7-4
Alive after Tomorrow munch = 10 - Best case 7-3, worst case 6-4
Alive after tomorrow Lynch = 9 - Best case 7-2 , Worst case 5-4
Sat 8 - Alive after Munch and Jeff = 7 - Best case 5-2, worst case game over

IF Village gets 2 lynches correct next 3 nights and Jeff isn't killed
After tonight = 8-3
After Tomorrow = 7-2
After Saturday = 4-2
After Sunday wolf kills = 2-2

Course assumes Jeffs 50/50 gets a kill so its not that clear cut .

Riona WW

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Great! Thoughts?

Just a quick scan and at least 6% of Hollys posts are greeting people

Isla WW wrote: »

Hey guys

Isla WW wrote: »

Hi holly

Isla WW wrote: »

Hey guys

Isla WW wrote: »

Hey guys

Orla WW

I haven't a clue who to FFA, to be totally honest. Between the argument with Eva and the Winifred stuff yesterday, it's totally thrown me off my usual game.

Was always skeptical of Winnie, but the note and others getting the note kinda blew all my theories out of the water.

So, I go back to the wagons, I guess.

#FFA4

Steve - Eva's points against him make sense, it's a weird conversation and I'd like a response from Steve about that tbh.

Eva - Soz Eve, but it could also be a decent wolf play to cast doubt on Steve. As mentioned, it kind of implicates one or both of you.

Gertie - In and out of the thread, questions a lot but not much provided in the way of gamesolving from what I have read.


Gone off Gabs being a wolf tbh, I don't see him and Winnie as w/w interactions, and according to Conor SK is long dead so happy enough for now.

Nigel's posting has improved so far even though I still have doubts about that day 1 vote (yep, still on about it)

Isla... pfft, yeah no idea. Would be on my FFA only I have deeper suspicions about Gertie tbh.

I've spoken about Derry before - even though he obviously ignores my posts I don't see him as a wolf. If he is, I'm very much pocketed.

Riona.... hmmmm.... maybe. Playing the diligent villager card a lot. Confused about the OP a LOT. Into conspiracy theories. Could be playing the village contrarian role a bit too much though.

Abi - again, active - but I'm not sure I recall a lot of what she says. Hasn't been super obvious either way which is worrying at this late stage.

Conor & Brendan - I buy their stories. Call me crazy, whatever. Generally if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it's a duck. I've town read Conor from early on and nothing in their reveal or behaviour changes that. Brendan? Yep, well he kinda proved himself today.

Riona WW

Of course I meant Islas posts . . Another jeff was dead derp . .

Isla WW

I was a big backer of Steve's but that was against the idea that Doris was a wolf. Now that it appears its the total opposite as per Conor, I have nothing else villager about him.

Isla WW

Hey guys is my standard daily greeting. Very easy to tell who I am across games from it

Isla WW

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Great! Thoughts?

I don't want to appear quiet to your question, I'll post comprehensive thoughts in a bit when I'm not left handed phone posting while bottle feeding a baby

Conor WW

Riona WW wrote: »

Of course I meant Islas posts . . Another jeff was dead derp . .

It bothers me how many times you've mentioned Jeff in your posts today.

Riona WW

Conor WW wrote: »

It bothers me how many times you've mentioned Jeff in your posts today.

Why ?

Isla WW

I am surprised the wolves killed holly, especially if she was nrv. She would have been a great mislynch target for them. Makes me think there's potentially strong active hidden wolves and they feel they have a nice pool of low hanging fruit to choose from for lynches

Conor WW

Because I'm suspicious AF about everyone. I'm concerned it's a task. Hit a certain number and get your pill kill back.

Conor WW

Isla WW wrote: »

I am surprised the wolves killed holly, especially if she was nrv. She would have been a great mislynch target for them. Makes me think there's potentially strong active hidden wolves and they feel they have a nice pool of low hanging fruit to choose from for lynches

I'm not surprised they targeted Holly. I think they were role hunting there.

Conor WW

Wow...thread's gone quiet. I'm having a nice long read back to see what I missed. Found something already. Hopefully I'll find more.

Riona WW

Conor WW wrote: »

Because I'm suspicious AF about everyone. I'm concerned it's a task. Hit a certain number and get your pill kill back.

9. THERE ARE NO TASKS, so feel free to have fun, make memes, take the piss and try to enjoy the game.

I was only just trying to have some fun Conor . . Maybe I will just go home if I am not wanted . .

Conor WW

Back to your den? :P

Riona WW

Conor WW wrote: »

Back to your den? :P

Gertrude WW

#ffa4

Steve
Riona
Eva

Im so sorry guys I dont have time to give big paragraphs for these. The first two are pretty much the same reasons as last night. I've added Eva because i think winnie had one wolf on her list, eva helped the scenario the most but tbh when i have more time after work to read through today/last night I could come with a different third.

Vote will be between the first 2 anyway baring any major development on thread.

Conor WW

So reading back on the thread with the assumption that Winnie was Irene Adler, certain things are starting to come into focus. If anyone else has a chance, could you have a look back and see what you spot?
Also, is there ANY possible way Wini was not Irene? Can anyone see anything? I've tried to entertain this but can't see it but open to ideas.