Sherlock - A game of Werewolf!

Barbara WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

So, your definition of badgering is asking somebody a question. He obliged, and answered that his suspicions are currently on abigail. Would you prefer if that suspicion remained off the thread?

How would you prefer I play this game? By not asking people questions?

Do you feel that I am badgering you at this moment in time?

I think you’ve badgered several people this game. If that down to your play style fine, I just want to keep an eye that you’re not a wolf looking to stir things and slink away

Desmond WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

They had different names, chosen by Jeff. One called Holmes, one Watson.

Abigail WW wrote: »

You would have to ask Wendy but I never said Jeff made up the names. I said even the names of the pills, A Shelock & Watson pill, were kinda generic as would be the obvious story of Jeff using pills exactly as he did in the show. Which does not mean it would not be the case, infact it just means it's very believable



Do you know something Des? Does your backroom mate name his pills? Cos I said she gave them those names not Jeff which you have eluded to.

See quoted post, which is an answer to a question I directed at Wendy WW soon after the pill story.

Wendy WW

Also, I came out and told the village about a failed wolf attack. Holly at least seems to be turning that and my previous post back against me. Sounds like a wolf trying to turn a missed kill in to a lynch to me.

Winifred WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Also, I came out and told the village about a failed wolf attack. Holly at least seems to be turning that and my previous post back against me. Sounds like a wolf trying to turn a missed kill in to a lynch to me.

Grand, we lynch Holly so after Orla. Vig can shoot Gab and Des.

You scratch my back, I scratch yours.

Gabriel WW

Ahhh was wondering who wini was. Just got it.

Gabriel WW

It's a balls out move for a wolf cotton. Let's see if it pays off.

Abigail WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

See quoted post, which is an answer to a question I directed at Wendy WW soon after the pill story.

Ahh I thought you were coming at me not Wendy, which tbh had me confused. It is odd that she would be told that he named the pills and what would happen to the wolf if she survived a peril we don't even know was real. That does not mean her reveal is a lie but we have nothing but her word to verify it.

Katie WW

evening y'all. crazy day in work hence the no posting

Winifred WW

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Ahhh was wondering who wini was. Just got it.

I'm a villager. Gonna smoke all you wolfies out.

Holly WW

Orla WW wrote: »

Interesting. Is that on touch or full site? Can't say I've had that issue tbh.

Happens with specific threads more than a from one page to the next issue. Its really annoying Touch normally but I think ive seen it on the desktop, cant rightly remember

Holly WW

Winifred WW wrote: »

No, it's clearly Orla you and Gabby as w/w/w. Leading the village on a merry dance.

Peek me, I'll lead this village to glory.



So, for having a job and not being able to post at work I'm suspicious? Thanks for basically saying you have no clue who to FFA.



Once again, you FFA me for being silent.

Orla is a wolf, Desmond is a wolf.

Gabriel is probably a wolf, or a silly silly boy telling everyone he's NRV this early when if true he should be giving cover to the RVs.


This readslist stuff from Orla is crap, it's a smokescreen to act busy. Des is her coven buddy and I'm not gonna be suprised about Gabriel being a wolf/evil if that's the case.

I was wrong about Mary, so sue me.

Why do you think Desmond is a wolf?

Doris WW

Winifred WW wrote: »

No, it's clearly Orla you and Gabby as w/w/w. Leading the village on a merry dance.

Peek me, I'll lead this village to glory.



So, for having a job and not being able to post at work I'm suspicious? Thanks for basically saying you have no clue who to FFA.



Once again, you FFA me for being silent.

Orla is a wolf, Desmond is a wolf.

Gabriel is probably a wolf, or a silly silly boy telling everyone he's NRV this early when if true he should be giving cover to the RVs.


This readslist stuff from Orla is crap, it's a smokescreen to act busy. Des is her coven buddy and I'm not gonna be suprised about Gabriel being a wolf/evil if that's the case.

I was wrong about Mary, so sue me.

Can you explain to me in simple language why you think they are wolves?

Abigail WW

We just had our first person ask to be peeked. How do we approach the Irene Adler situation? or even the Mycroft (appears bad iirc) one.

Derry WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

Ahh I thought you were coming at me not Wendy, which tbh had me confused. It is odd that she would be told that he named the pills and what would happen to the wolf if she survived a peril we don't even know was real. That does not mean her reveal is a lie but we have nothing but her word to verify it.

The "naming" part, I can 100% understand.

Being told the benefits of surviving beyond surviving is interesting though.

Winifred WW

Holly WW wrote: »

Why do you think Desmond is a wolf?

Doris WW wrote: »

Can you explain to me in simple language why you think they are wolves?

Orla for her sh1tposting, total display of wolfy arrogance. Readslists.. all a smokescreen.

Dessie for casting shade on me calling her out on it.

Gab for running interference with the FFA/readslists argument.

Simples. Wolf 1, 2 and 3 right there.

Holly WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Also, I came out and told the village about a failed wolf attack. Holly at least seems to be turning that and my previous post back against me. Sounds like a wolf trying to turn a missed kill in to a lynch to me.

Reread the last post I made in response to you, I'm suss of you over something else, the pills are why I dont have you as a wolf lean.

Tegan WW

Winifred WW wrote: »

No, it's clearly Orla you and Gabby as w/w/w. Leading the village on a merry dance.

Peek me, I'll lead this village to glory.



So, for having a job and not being able to post at work I'm suspicious? Thanks for basically saying you have no clue who to FFA.



Once again, you FFA me for being silent.

Orla is a wolf, Desmond is a wolf.

Gabriel is probably a wolf, or a silly silly boy telling everyone he's NRV this early when if true he should be giving cover to the RVs.


This readslist stuff from Orla is crap, it's a smokescreen to act busy. Des is her coven buddy and I'm not gonna be suprised about Gabriel being a wolf/evil if that's the case.

I was wrong about Mary, so sue me.

See I feel you are much more a matter of fact when it comes to your reading of players. I have my doubts. But maybe I should be more like you and just say this is my read and ignore my doubts.

Im sticking with my FFA.

It wasnt because you were silent though, it was the fact that I think your good and possibly you being a clever wolf who has me thinking your good.

Suspect the least likely of suspects.

Tegan WW

Winifred WW wrote: »

I'm a villager. Gonna smoke all you wolfies out.

It wouldnt be unheard of for a wolf to accuse and railroad fellow wolves early on.

Call me a fence sitter but i dont know what to think of anyone with a certainty yet.

Orla WW

Winifred WW wrote: »

Orla for her sh1tposting, total display of wolfy arrogance. Readslists.. all a smokescreen.

Dessie for casting shade on me calling her out on it.

Gab for running interference with the FFA/readslists argument.

Simples. Wolf 1, 2 and 3 right there.

Ok, I'm just gonna let you drown in this tunnel of nonsense without going apesh1t.

Do what you like, dear Winnie, you know best.

Wendy WW

Holly WW wrote: »

Reread the last post I made in response to you, I'm suss of you over something else, the pills are why I dont have you as a wolf lean.

I see now. I had to mention in the open as people seemed to be thinking that solving puzzles = villager. It's a silly assumption to make.

Winifred WW

Tegan WW wrote: »

It wouldnt be unheard of for a wolf to accuse and railroad fellow wolves early on.

Call me a fence sitter but i dont know what to think of anyone with a certainty yet.

That's fine Tegs, baby - follow me to glory. Or eat me because I'm rustling your wolf den. Either way I'll figure out the other two.

Gabriel WW

Winifred WW wrote: »

Orla for her sh1tposting, total display of wolfy arrogance. Readslists.. all a smokescreen.

Dessie for casting shade on me calling her out on it.

Gab for running interference with the FFA/readslists argument.

Simples. Wolf 1, 2 and 3 right there.

Desmond WW

#FFA1

Slot CYAN:
I see that there may be a wolf in here, but only 1 wolf, if any.
Gabriel WW - not w/w with clodagh
Clodagh WW - not w/w with gabs.

Slot MAGENTA
Doris WW - misinformation about Moriarty

Slot LILAC
Katie WW - where's our credit?

My slots are not numbered and should not be read with any preference to order.

Winifred WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

#FFA1

Slot CYAN:
I see that there may be a wolf in here, but only 1 wolf, if any.
Gabriel WW - not w/w with clodagh
Clodagh WW - not w/w with gabs.

Slot MAGENTA
Doris WW - misinformation about Moriarty

Slot LILAC
Katie WW - where's our credit?

My slots are not numbered and should not be read with any preference to order.

They say that wolves always FFA one of their partners. You seem smarter though, maybe there's three on your list?

Are you the smart wolf?

Wendy WW

Possibly being naïve but I got the feeling from Orla and Gabriel that they were genuine villagers trying to sort out how best to organise the village.

Desmond WW

Winifred WW wrote: »

They say that wolves always FFA one of their partners. You seem smarter though, maybe there's three on your list?

Are you the smart wolf?

Maybe I've named the whole coven.

Doris WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

#FFA1

Slot CYAN:
I see that there may be a wolf in here, but only 1 wolf, if any.
Gabriel WW - not w/w with clodagh
Clodagh WW - not w/w with gabs.

Slot MAGENTA
Doris WW - misinformation about Moriarty

Slot LILAC
Katie WW - where's our credit?

My slots are not numbered and should not be read with any preference to order.

Misinformation?

Gabriel WW

Desmond WW wrote:

My slots are not numbered and should not be read with any preference to order.

Well I'm glad the FFAs aren't being gamed today anyways.

Jesus Christ. Cyan. Oh no. Hope I don't get upgraded to burgundy.

Imronburgundy.jpg

Winifred WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

Maybe I've named the whole coven.

You conveniently left Orla off your list though... call me crazy but you've got some misinformation in there.

Tegan WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Possibly being naïve but I got the feeling from Orla and Gabriel that they were genuine villagers trying to sort out how best to organise the village.

See this is my issue.

My gut tells me that they are playing in a way that is helpful to the villager, or too brazen and carefree to be a wolf.

But thats the point, if I read players like that then one of the wolves may go "lets try this and see what happens".

The standard of players in this game has my doubts about whats good and whats bad.