Rate my Team Thread 2017/2018

dsmythy

What I'm on at the mo

Foster Elliot

Alonso Ake Yoshida Lowton Rosenior

Pogba Fabregas Sane Walters Tadic

Lukaku Jesus Firmino

I've an itch on Alonso Sane and Firmino though. Lack of a traditional monster in midfield troubles slightly too.

Can accept small rotation with the players picked as they are now.

skippy15

dsmythy wrote: »

What I'm on at the mo

Foster Elliot

Alonso Ake Yoshida Lowton Rosenior

Pogba Fabregas Sane Walters Tadic

Lukaku Jesus Firmino

I've an itch on Alonso Sane and Firmino though. Lack of a traditional monster in midfield troubles slightly too.

Can accept small rotation with the players picked as they are now.

I think you need solid mids early on, they all seem slightly risky at minute points wise apart from Fab (I prefer William but could go either way). Also, Id change firmino to a pool mid instead, and I think KDB is a must. Downgrade walters to a 4.5m, wasted 1m sitting on bench

dahat

Deleted User wrote: »

This one was put up about 2 weeks ago and I said Sane & Kane.

Today I'm saying neither because Sane and Aguero are not guaranteed game time and that's a no go from me.

I think Pep likes Sane and correct me if i'm wrong aren't his LM/LF options a bit limited?

dahat

dahat wrote: »

I think Pep likes Sane and correct me if i'm wrong aren't his LM/LF options a bit limited?

I think it's too hard to call what Pep will do. I'd rather avoid it.

What happen if he plays wing backs too ?

I'd imagine KDB would be the safest way to cover City.

dahat

Deleted User wrote: »

I think it's too hard to call what Pep will do. I'd rather avoid it.

What happen if he plays wing backs too ?

I'd imagine KDB would be the safest way to cover City.

KDB looks the safest route but that's reflected in his price at 10.00. I think City will score alot of goals so cover is needed.

It's a minefield.

extra gravy

Deleted User wrote: »

On my FPL notes from last season I have a insisted to myself to start this season with Chadli.

He's not in my team at the moment but my note was rather aggressive as if future me would ignore my advice.

I think I will have to start him as there are a shed load of players in that price bracket that could do well and it's an easy swap over if Chadli doesn't work out. But past me seems really convinced he'll do really well this season.

Ya I remember getting him in just before he got injured last season, he looked a great option. As you said, so many options in that price range it's going to be tricky to pick the right one.

Raoul

Thoughts?

stephenl15

Raoul wrote: »

Thoughts?

Not a huge fan. Sanchez unlikely to start the season so I'd downgrade him to save a couple of mil. Downgrade Cedric to a 4.5 as you have Yosh and he's also unlikely to start the season. Not sure how many defs you're going with but you need to upgrade the strikers so I'd also downgrade Walker to save a million or so leaving you with 3 mid price defenders and find a way to get in Lukaku or Kane instead of one of Austin or Jrod imo. I wouldn't like owning neither Kane or Lukaku.

Although if it's your preference with the two cheap strikers to get Sanchez then by all means, it's different and could work out

MagicIRL

With their prices so high, you need to have one of Kane/Lukaku in case they start scoring. Once that happens, and the price rices, you'll struggle to fit them in.

On the off chance that you have one, or both, and they don't perform, then you can drop them with money left over. It's a win-win really.

Raoul

stephenl15 wrote: »

Not a huge fan. Sanchez unlikely to start the season so I'd downgrade him to save a couple of mil. Downgrade Cedric to a 4.5 as you have Yosh and he's also unlikely to start the season. Not sure how many defs you're going with but you need to upgrade the strikers so I'd also downgrade Walker to save a million or so leaving you with 3 mid price defenders and find a way to get in Lukaku or Kane instead of one of Austin or Jrod imo. I wouldn't like owning neither Kane or Lukaku.

Although if it's your preference with the two cheap strikers to get Sanchez then by all means, it's different and could work out

Why won't Sanchez start? And Cedric is just in there as a placeholder actually, I know he might not start.

I just don't think there is any value in Lukaku. Kane is excellent but I have Alli in there for Spurs coverage.

My thinking was to go a bit different this year and load up on midfield rather than attack. Last year I had Kane, Costa and Aguero. I did really well though so not sure why I am changing haha.

tailgunner

Raoul wrote: »

Why won't Sanchez start?

He's only just back training this week. Good chance he won't be there beyond September as well.

extra gravy

tailgunner wrote: »

He's only just back training this week. Good chance he won't be there beyond September as well.

Wenger today: “The only thing I can tell you is he is focused. My decision is clear. He will stay, it’s as simple as that and he will respect that.”

Nothing to indicate he's going anywhere, all speculation.

Father Hernandez

extra gravy wrote: »

Wenger today: “The only thing I can tell you is he is focused. My decision is clear. He will stay, it’s as simple as that and he will respect that.”

Nothing to indicate he's going anywhere, all speculation.

One of my favourite FPL players is San(C)hez, I dunno what I'm going to do to try fit him in.

I'd feel dirty leaving him out..

tailgunner

Granted, but still a question mark over whether he'll be fit enough to make GW1.

And yeah, definitely my favourite FPL player too. I'd be more than happy to tear my team up to fit him in!

Speaking of which, this is the first draft I'm reasonably happy with:

Foster, (Elliott)

Alexander-Arnold, Jones, Trippier (Manquillo, Long)

Salah, Fabregas, De Bruyne, Ramsey (Carroll)

Lukaku, Kane, Austin

A few question marks over the defence, but I'd be planning for an early wildcard.

Raoul

tailgunner wrote: »

Granted, but still a question mark over whether he'll be fit enough to make GW1.

And yeah, definitely my favourite FPL player too. I'd be more than happy to tear my team up to fit him in!

Speaking of which, this is the first draft I'm reasonably happy with:

Foster, (Elliott)

Alexander-Arnold, Jones, Trippier (Manquillo, Long)

Salah, Fabregas, De Bruyne, Ramsey (Carroll)

Lukaku, Kane, Austin

A few question marks over the defence, but I'd be planning for an early wildcard.

Is Jones definitely going to start? Can say the same for AA.

How good is Salah going to be, never seen him in the premier league. So it is always risky with new players. I always like Ramsey myself but been burned by him a few times.

Up front is lethal obviously.

tailgunner

I'd expect Jones to start in the league for a few weeks at least, seeing as he's suspended in Europe, and Alexander-Arnold should come in for Clyne. Far from guaranteed in either case of course, but hopefully things will be clearer next week.

I'm 50/50 between Salah and Coutinho to be honest. Coutinho seems to be playing a bit deeper, which makes him less appealing.

Not 100% sold on Ramsey either, but I have no Arsenal cover otherwise.

Raoul

I don't really believe in coverage. Just pick the players who are going to score the most points.

Cartman78

Raoul wrote: »

I don't really believe in coverage. Just pick the players who are going to score the most points.

That's actually a good point imho - I tend to spend a lot of time trying to shoehorn players into my team for the sake of it.

eg Monreal - only there because he plays for Arsenal, have now got rid and made a couple of other changes as well

Forster Elliot

Bailly Vertonghen Long TAA Ake

KDB Fabregas Salah Zaha Carroll

Lukaku Jesus J-Rod


Gradually getting happier with my team....:pac:

Shedite27

Think I've settled on the bulk of my team for now (aiming for GW7 wildcard), just need to work on the bargain bin defense ....

Foster Elliott --> Rotate well and cheap as chips
Duffy Clarke Mee Hegazi Fodder --> I've .5 left to upgrade one of these. Need to do some study to figure out where that money is best spent.
De Bruyne Pogba Ince Zaha Mane --> 3 big hitters, and love the form and fixtures of Ince/Zaha
Kane Lukaku Fodder

Only 1 sub each week realistically.

Basically giving up on clean sheets, they always start off slow as teams get used to each other.

No Chelsesa/Arsenal but not convinced Willian/Cesc/Rambo will start, so taken Zaha instead. Had Ozil for a while but prefer Mane/KDB.

Basically going with 5 big hitters, 2 potentials, and then a GK/DEF (including double Newcastle and WBA) that anything is a bonus.

bezuaua

Elliott | 4.0 Fodder

Trippier | Cedric | Phil Jones | Mee | 4.0 Fodder

KDB | Salah | Fabregas | Ramsey | 4.5 Fodder

Kane | Lukaku | Austin

Any opinions?

Bleating Lamb

Seems Ramsey is yellow flagged.

Cartman78

What are people's thoughts on Matic??

Not exactly a points machine I know but a guaranteed starter and 3 point returner at 5m surely (??)

A recent defensive reshuffle has left me with a whopping 0.5m to play with....currently have Carroll as 5th mid

caviardreams

Cartman78 wrote: »

What are people's thoughts on Matic??

Not exactly a points machine I know but a guaranteed starter and 3 point returner at 5m surely (??)

A recent defensive reshuffle has left me with a whopping 0.5m to play with....currently have Carroll as 5th mid

As a United fan, I would have Carroll ahead of him. Carroll is great value at 4.5m imo - gets the odd attacking return and may do even better if Siggy leaves. Could see Carrick getting the odd game ("easier" fixtures) still, especially with Champions League games etc.

spock.

Cartman78 wrote:

What are people's thoughts on Matic??

Not exactly a points machine I know but a guaranteed starter and 3 point returner at 5m surely (??)

A recent defensive reshuffle has left me with a whopping 0.5m to play with....currently have Carroll as 5th mid

Carroll + 0.5 over Matic any day for me.
Probably more attacking threat and doesn't take up a Man Utd spot.

farranreeboy

Thought's De Gea Trippier Bertrand Danilo Willian Ali Pogba De Bruyne Lacazette Firmino Chicharito

km79

farranreeboy wrote: »

Thought's De Gea Trippier Bertrand Danilo Willian Ali Pogba De Bruyne Lacazette Firmino Chicharito

Can't really comment until we see your full squad??????? But I'm not crazy about the frontline !

fermanagh_man

Settled on this.

I did have Kane but changing him for Lacazette give me 2m to play with

sanket

Decent starting team, what is your bench

sanket

Thoughts??
Ddg elliot
Trippier Danilo hegazi mee rangel
Kdb alli salah ramsey barry
Lukaku batshyai austin.

Hegazi typical pulis player l. he and mee rotate easily. Have doubts over batshuyai starting, but with pedro and hazard on the sidelines 2 weeks is guaranteed. Will get a clearer picture on sunday. Other than that satisfied with the overall team. Had planned to cover atleast 1 player of top 6 in attack as my initial strategy.

Shanotheslayer

sanket wrote: »

Thoughts??
Ddg elliot
Trippier Danilo hegazi mee rangel
Kdb alli salah ramsey barry
Lukaku batshyai austin.

Hegazi typical pulis player l. he and mee rotate easily. Have doubts over batshuyai starting, but with pedro and hazard on the sidelines 2 weeks is guaranteed. Will get a clearer picture on sunday. Other than that satisfied with the overall team. Had planned to cover atleast 1 player of top 6 in attack as my initial strategy.

Barry? As in Barry off Everton? If soz, get rid of him you absolute lunatic :pac: won't play much and even if he does bot a goal threat and gets a yellow every 2nd game.