Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

2017 Free Agency/Off Season

  • 24-01-2017 8:29am
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,317 ✭✭✭HigginsJ


    I see the Browns have tied down Jamie Collins long term with a 4 year $50 million contract ($26 million guaranteed). It really was a deal the Browns had to get done after trading for him so a good bit of business for them. The Browns are currently projected to have over $100 million in cap space this year. You can imagine that tieing down Terelle Pryor will be next up on their to do list.

    The Giants really only have 2 players of note hitting free agency but it is one hell of a pair, Jonathan Hankins and JPP are currently set for free agency.

    JPP has already came out and said that he has proved himself and wants to be paid, no more 1 year deals. With our large investment in Jenkins, Snacks & Vernon last year I feel that we won't be able to offer him top dollar & honestly I wouldn't want to. JPP is very good but not the beast he once was. I think he will be playing elsewhere next year.

    Big Hank is able to get a lot of pressure up the middle on the QB for a man his size, if we could tie him down next to Snacks for the next few years our D would have a great base. Considering the power of the O-Line in Dallas it must be a priority, one way or another I think he will be with Big Blue next year.

    I don't think the Giants will be big players in free agency this year, we don't really have the cap space and after last years splurge and successful draft I think we continue to build through the draft. Also our Achilles's heel (the O-line) is offering little in free agency.


«13456710

Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,719 ✭✭✭JaMarcusHustle


    HigginsJ wrote:
    I see the Browns have tied down Jamie Collins long term with a 4 year $50 million contract ($26 million guaranteed). It really was a deal the Browns had to get done after trading for him so a good bit of business for them. The Browns are currently projected to have over $100 million in cap space this year. You can imagine that tieing down Terelle Pryor will be next up on their to do list.

    That's not a bad deal. Certainly not the Von Miller money that he was supposed to be looking for.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,017 ✭✭✭Leslie91


    That's not a bad deal. Certainly not the Von Miller money that he was supposed to be looking for.

    Yeah I thought the same... but u have to wonder why (apart from him being so replaceable for cheaper) Belicheat had him out the door so fast. I wonder might he down tools when the $26m hits his account.

    The Charger's Melvin Ingram is the next big OLB FA..... will be very interesting to see what he can get on open market.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,719 ✭✭✭JaMarcusHustle


    Very important player for the LA Chargers. Wouldn't be surprised to see him go to a bigger team to have a chance at the playoffs.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 45,433 ✭✭✭✭thomond2006


    Alshon Jeffery is a free agent after playing under the franchise tag this year. He was suspended for 4 games for PEDs but he'll surely get big offers.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,017 ✭✭✭Leslie91


    Very important player for the LA Chargers. Wouldn't be surprised to see him go to a bigger team to have a chance at the playoffs.

    You won't see too many Chargers fans sorry to see him go if he gets anywhere close to Von Miller offer... he is simply not worth it. Has some of the physical tools but cannot finish... misses so many sacks and tackles it is unreal.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,004 ✭✭✭✭Realt Dearg Sec


    Alshon Jeffery is a free agent after playing under the franchise tag this year. He was suspended for 4 games for PEDs but he'll surely get big offers.

    Bears FO seem intent on keeping him around if their EOS press conference is any indication. With Kevin White being anything but a sure thing, they probably feel they need to hold onto what talent they have here. Cap wise we can afford it but depending on Jeffery's demands (which are rumoured to be that he wants to be paid top 10 money) I dunno if we can do it. He's not worth top 10 money (certainly with his record of games missed, and his lack of production this past year even while on the field), but somebody might give it to him.

    My feeling is that if we get in a new QB, which seems almost certain, they will want to keep him as a reliable target for the new guy. If we are rolling with a backup, particularly Hoyer, there is no need to have Jeffery because Hoyer just doesn't throw the ball to him.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,328 ✭✭✭the baby bull elephant


    The Lions have a number of dilemmas coming up in free agency.

    Firstly I'd hope we return Boldin but not on an amount exceeding his hit this year. Rafael Bush and Josh Bynes are similar stories solid players that are starters but especially with Bynes I'd be hoping we upgrade at their position in the draft. Bush had some impressive plays but I'd be able to live with Wilson and already fan favourite Killebrew.

    The really big problem however will come on the offensive line. Both Warford and Reiff are both starters and just coming off their rookie contracts. Unfortunately the odds of keeping them both are exceedingly low. Warford had an excellent rookie season before regressing but is till a competent starter. He does seem to not quite be a fit for the Lions blocking scheme and could demand a fair sum in free agency. He's not someone I'd break the bank for and hope that Tomlinson moving across to his natural RG position would allow him to at least in some way live up to his first round billing. Reiff meanwhile is someone I really do want us to re-sign and I don't mind slightly overspending for. This is a young line that is finally coming together removing 2/5 of it would be a bad idea. There's also no one on the Lions to replace him and this will apparently be a weak draft for tackles. The one problem may be that Reiff will not play LT for the Lions with Decker seeming to be the LT of the future here. Reiff has 4 years as a starter at LT in the league so may look for free agent LT money. Which would be too much. Mid range LT money would be the absolute ceiling I would go for him.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,977 ✭✭✭mikemac2


    Baltimore Ravens

    Keep
    Brandon Williams DT - The guy is a flat out beast. Ozzie Newsome hit gold with this 3rd round pick from Divison II Missouri Southern. He's a class act with zero character concerns and a leader on defence. Doesn't have flashy stats and I don't think has much league wide recognition with fans but Ravens fans know his worth. I'd pay top 10 DT money but I think he'll want to test the market and leave. DT franchise tag money is a shade under 11 million and that's unlikely but possible

    Ricky Wagner RT
    I don't know much about college football but I know Wisconsin produce good lineman. This 5th round pick made the RT spot his own and has done very well. I think he'll test the market and the Ravens tend to let offensive linemen walk with the exception of Marshal Yanda. I'd like him to stay but don't believe it will happen.

    Anthony Levine FS
    Has started at corner and free safety for injury cover but mostly plays special teams. Very competent at this and I hope to keep for a 2 year deal a bit over minimum

    Let test the market and maybe try to match

    Kyle Juszcyk FB - How do you know an NFL player went to Harvard? The commentator will want to drone on about it every single game!! Juice is a modern kind of fullback, can block of course but more used for check downs too. A popular member of the team I think he will look at offers and get a matching offer from Baltimore

    Lawrence Guy DE. I don't remember him at the Chargers, he joined Baltimore and quietly worked his way to be starter. Only 26 and it's a premium position. I think he won't be back and will get his payday

    Release to FA
    Ryan Mallett QB - first things first was a model pro and yes, he never slept though practice :p After his winning start over Pittsburgh there was talk of shopping for picks but it never happened. I'd release to FA, I hope we draft a QB late and Mallet might be around later this offseason

    Vlad Ducasse G
    I'm not the best at grading linesmen. Some say he was a turnstile, some say competent. The Ravens have some young guards and I would prefer they get a bump up the depth chart.

    Kamar Aiken WR - Became the Ravens no 1 through injuries in 2015 and did well but in 2016 was pretty much a no 4. He deserves better elsewhere

    Jerraud Powers CB - big reputation from Arizona, never delivered

    Drive to the airport!!
    Matt Elam SS - called out Calvin Johnson as old and washed up when he was a rookie, dumbass. Did nothing for years through injury and incompetence. First round BUST


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,317 ✭✭✭HigginsJ


    http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2687501-nfl-free-agency-2017-breaking-down-each-teams-cap-situation

    Bleacher Report have broken down the available cap space teams have. The top 3 with most space are the Browns ($100 million), Bucaneers ($84 million) and the 49ers ($83 million, although they can free up another $14 releasing Kaep)

    Those in the worst positions are the Chiefs ($3.2 million, Dontari Poe & Eric Berry are impending free agents) Cowboys (negative $5 million, trading Romo clears $24 millions, releasing him clears $5 millions) and finally the J.E.T.S (negative $6 million, The team could release high-profile names such as Brandon Marshall, Darrelle Revis, David Harris and Ryan Clady. By releasing those four, the Jets will save $33.533 million against the cap)

    The cap is expected to be $168 million.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 22,477 ✭✭✭✭Knex*


    Buccs with 84m. That's insane for a team that already has a decent base about it, and a young franchise QB. a decent FA and draft this year could see them push properly for the playoffs, and in two years time they should really be a force.

    Be interesting to see how they fair.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,317 ✭✭✭HigginsJ


    Knex. wrote: »
    Buccs with 84m. That's insane for a team that already has a decent base about it, and a young franchise QB. a decent FA and draft this year could see them push properly for the playoffs, and in two years time they should really be a force.

    Be interesting to see how they fair.

    These rookie QB's are an absolute steal, if you can hit one you have 3-4 years to hit gold. The Pats also have an insane amount of cap space, the 5th most space on the list.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,352 ✭✭✭conor222


    The numbers being thrown out on that article are not very realistic, they involve all current members on current deals to stay on at those current deals.

    E.g. That Chiefs number includes them paying Nick Foales 10.7 million next year, whereas they can cut him for no dead money (as the team designed the contract to be drawn up).

    Just from the Chiefs one as I know them the best,
    Foales 10.7
    Colquitt 4.1
    Charles 6.1

    Theres an additional 20 million in space already (net of dead money), not even considering moving around contracts, multiple smaller cuts etc.

    Dont read too much into Cap coverage yet, we havent even hit the point where teams start publicly discussing out what they can spend this season.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,317 ✭✭✭HigginsJ


    conor222 wrote: »
    The numbers being thrown out on that article are not very realistic, they involve all current members on current deals to stay on at those current deals.

    E.g. That Chiefs number includes them paying Nick Foales 10.7 million next year, whereas they can cut him for no dead money (as the team designed the contract to be drawn up).

    Just from the Chiefs one as I know them the best,
    Foales 10.7
    Colquitt 4.1
    Charles 6.1

    Theres an additional 20 million in space already (net of dead money), not even considering moving around contracts, multiple smaller cuts etc.

    Dont read too much into Cap coverage yet, we havent even hit the point where teams start publicly discussing out what they can spend this season.

    Not at all familiar with the Chiefs so that is good to know, def no way Foles would be kept around on that sort of money, we are similar in that we have about $20 million but cutting Victor Cruz (which will happen) saves $7.5 million.

    That being said it does give at least an indicator as to who has what available and is a good starting point. No matter how much wheeling and dealing the Chiefs or Giants do our cap space would be dwarfed by the Bucs, Pats, Browns etc.




  • HigginsJ wrote: »
    These rookie QB's are an absolute steal, if you can hit one you have 3-4 years to hit gold. The Pats also have an insane amount of cap space, the 5th most space on the list.

    Unless like the eagles you are giving your backup starter money therefor negating any benifit


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,644 ✭✭✭D9Male


    At least they got shut of Bradford. I can completely see why the Vikings did the trade, but the Eagles were very fortunate that Teddy got hurt.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,317 ✭✭✭HigginsJ


    Unless like the eagles you are giving your backup starter money therefor negating any benifit

    I didn't think Chase Daniel was on that much, thought it was a 3yr $21 million contract? $7 million, while high for a back-up, is well shy of even mid tier starter money.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 22,477 ✭✭✭✭Knex*


    I hope Redskins pay over the top for Cousins. Not that I necessarily think that he's a bad QB, but I hate seeing them with so much cap space.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,004 ✭✭✭✭Realt Dearg Sec


    Knex. wrote: »
    I hope Redskins pay over the top for Cousins. Not that I necessarily think that he's a bad QB, but I hate seeing them with so much cap space.

    I'm sure they will, there's going to be a huge market for his services, and unlike Garropolo (or McCarron), there's no necessity to give up draft picks to get them.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,333 ✭✭✭brinty


    Knex. wrote:
    I hope Redskins pay over the top for Cousins. Not that I necessarily think that he's a bad QB, but I hate seeing them with so much cap space.


    I hear ye mate
    Least the cowboys haven't cap room either says you
    Was doing my sums and we'll not he cutting Romo before 1 June as its an extra 5m cap saving. The saving for cutting him now would still leaves neutral. By the 1 June mark they'll not be able to get any good free agency players so it'll be smart drafting for us again
    We'll restructure a few things and that'll bring us within cap before the season.

    Em what happens if players retire? What's the cap hit if any to the team??


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,719 ✭✭✭JaMarcusHustle


    For the Patriots, Dont'a Hightower is the main priority. And I think Bill has shown as much with letting Collins and Jones walk. Hightower has fit perfectly into the Bruschi/Mayo defensive leader mould, and we've never been shy about rewarding that position. We extended Mayo in 2011 by making him the second highest paid ILB in the league so I wouldn't be surprised to see Hightower sign a big 5 year deal. Worst case scenario, he gets franchised tagged but he won't be playing anywhere else next year.

    Malcolm Butler is a restricted free agent after the season. I'd love him to stay, but I don't think it will necessarily be as straight forward as a new contract offered and signed. I can see us tendering him to a first round offer sheet. An original round tender won't happen given he was undrafted, and I think more teams will be put off making on offer on a first round tender which hopefully means we get another year out of him for between $3m and $4m. Anyone willing to make an offer on that will likely be paying him top 5 CB money if they're giving up that high a pick, so I can't see us matching any offers.

    Jabaal Sheard is likely going to be let walk. He's been disappointing this year, and his snap count backs that up. He's only been on the field for 55% of snaps, which is disappointing considering he was there for 51% last year despite Chandler Jones ahead of him on the depth chart. I think we all thought he'd contribute a lot more given Jones' trade, but it just hasn't happened. His play has dropped and it's looked ominous since he was health scratch for the 49ers game.

    Martellus Bennett loves it here, and I think we'd like him to stay given Gronk has missed 24 games in 5 years, excluding the playoffs. I just hope he doesn't ask for ludicrous money - he seems a bit happier here than he has on his other teams so hopefully that counts for something. I can unfortunately see someone else with cap money to burn offering him more than he warrants, and his own injury concerns might prevent us from offering too much.

    Sebastian Vollmer won't be back. I wouldn't be surprised to see him retire tbh. He's been a great servant and one of our all-time value draft picks, but injuries have caught up with him. He's achieved a lot here so I wonder how much desire he has to remain in the league given a lot of his career goals will probably have been accomplished by now.

    Michael Floyd won't be brought back either, unless there's zero interest elsewhere and we get him on a vet minimum. Even then it's doubtful. Being a healthy scratch as soon as Amendola and Mitchell were fit again is writing on the wall for me. I think picking him up was a kicking-the-tyres exercise while we were down a few players at that position.

    Chris Long should be back. I often think of him as pushing 34/35 for some reason, he seems to have been around forever but he's only 31. He has plenty of miles left in the tank as this season has shown and is a great presence in the locker room by all accounts. I think it's in our interest to work out a team friendly deal with him for another year or two. It's not as if we're stacked at that position either. We've shown willingness before to keep veterans after their one-year deal if it works out.

    Alan Branch has been a really good player for us. I'd like him back - he's in a similar boat to Chris Long in that I always think of him as being much older than 32. But I can see someone else making him an offer of more than we're willing to, and maybe of a longer duration than we'd like to.

    Logan Ryan is a tricky one. I'd like him to stay but he's very inconsistent. He was really, really good last year and was then terrible to start this year. He's recovered somewhat and has put together a few good games, but again we've seen some average to above-average corner backs get obscene contracts the past couple of years and it wouldn't surprise me if someone blew us out of the water compared to what we were willing to offer him. Ultimately, I think he moves on to a bigger contract somewhere else. What he has in his favour is leverage giving how poor Eric Rowe and Cyrus Jones have been for us this year.

    Brandon Bolden is a pretty much exclusively special teams now. We obviously like him, but up to this season he would feature as relief at running back at least - 62, 28, 55 and 56 carries from 2012 to 20125. He only had 1 carry this year. Matthew Slater already takes up one "special teams only" spot on the roster, I wonder if we can afford to carry Bolden in the same role. I doubt it.

    LeGarrette Blount - well, we've been here before. On one hand, we've seen he has no problem taking the bigger offer elsewhere. On the other hand, teams have seen that it didn't work out well for Pittsburgh. Ultimately, Blount has been playing for close to vet minimum for a few years now, and after the best season of his career I won't blame him for taking one last big contract. Or if not big, at least the biggest one he gets offered which won't be from us I'm afraid.

    Duron Harmon will have to be content with a backup role if he wants to stay. On one hand, we don't have much behind McCourty so it's a pretty safe role he has as backup. On the other hand, he may want to see if anyone is willing to try him as a starter. I don't know if he's shown enough for anyone to do that, so maybe someone can offer him more snaps at least. I'd like him to stay in his current role.

    James Develin is one of the better full backs in the league. Another one I'd like to keep and being a full-back there may not be much clamour for him.

    Barkevious Mingo - I've really no thoughts on. Special Teams only, he'll likely not be extended.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,644 ✭✭✭D9Male


    These are great, thanks. I'll have a go at the Vikings tomorrow.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,333 ✭✭✭brinty


    Fair plays lads
    I'll do up a cowboys one too




  • D9Male wrote: »
    At least they got shut of Bradford. I can completely see why the Vikings did the trade, but the Eagles were very fortunate that Teddy got hurt.

    One of the more fortunate trades in recent memory for any team Im not entirely sure the fact that Philly is hosting the draft this year didn't play a part




  • HigginsJ wrote: »
    I didn't think Chase Daniel was on that much, thought it was a 3yr $21 million contract? $7 million, while high for a back-up, is well shy of even mid tier starter money.

    ''Tis a lot for a guy that looked awful not to mention the fact that the eagles will likely have to restructure/cut some guys I'd rather they didn't in order to maintain cap flexability


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,905 ✭✭✭TOss Sweep


    For the Patriots, Agree on Dont'a Hightower I expect us to pay him and I feel we will get a deal done with out Franchising him.

    Malcolm Butler is a restricted free agent after the season. This is where our Tag will I feel to get one more year out of him.

    Jabaal Sheard became such a waste. Had huge hopes for him but I really would like to know the full story behind his season. I believe there is more to it but agree he will be let go

    Martellus Bennett We win the Superbowl and he is definitely staying and I can see him take a performance based contract that give him close to what he wants but benefits both parties. With Gronk a year by year doubt to hard to let Bennett walk.

    Sebastian Vollmer I see him as a 50/50 shot. I think it will come down to if he decides to leave will it be for more money or as JMH said retirement. I think we might see him stick around for at least one more season on a low vet contract.

    Michael Floyd IF the price is right I would like to gamble on Floyd and bring him through camp at least and see can he give his full abilities. Im hoping we get a bargain basement deal done with him.

    Chris Long I actually think Long should be on the high priority list. Not at the top of it but definitely look for a contract that suits both parties.

    Alan Branch I agree JMH I would like a deal done with Branch. He was fantastic against Bell last week and all round solid all season long.

    Logan Ryan The guy we love to hate. Such a frustrating player and there is times he is god awful and then times he is fantastic. Definitely a hot and cold player but as JMH said the guys around him will be the reason we might do a deal with him. Rowe and Jones were terrible. (Watch Rowe light it up in the bowl :pac:)


    Brandon Bolden he has become another Slater. Happy to be part of the team and he is doing a good job. Cheap deal id say will be done here.

    LeGarrette Blount - I just dont know with LGB. For me it will come down to money and what he expects. If he is smart he will look for a long contract that see his career out and pay him enough. But there will be other teams wanting to get him on board.

    Duron Harmon His days in a Pats uniform will come down to wether or not we find his replacement in the Draft or FA. Then again our draft needs will come down to who we keep and dont keep

    James Develin not a lot of teams use FB anymore so we should be able to keep him.

    Barkevious Mingo - Same as JMH I hoped he would live p to something but these also have really no thoughts on him. Special Teams only, he'll likely not be extended.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,510 ✭✭✭Hazys


    On Chris Long, he took a pay-cut ($1m base salary) to play with us this year because he wanted to be on a contender. If we win the Super Bowl, I think he's less likely to stay than if we lose, he could see it as he got his ring, now he can get one last pay day. On the flip side, he's now got the taste for success, no way he could go back to a losing franchise.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,438 ✭✭✭j8wk2feszrnpao


    The Pats might prioritise Hightower, but I think it should be Butler.
    He gets put on the oppositions No1 receiver and should have been a Pro Bowl selection.
    Ryan is a No2 corner who often gives up plays; imaging him and Rowe as our 1&2, if we lost Butler, would be a return to the 3rd and long completions D that we had for years.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,905 ✭✭✭TOss Sweep


    The Pats might prioritise Hightower, but I think it should be Butler.
    He gets put on the oppositions No1 receiver and should have been a Pro Bowl selection.
    Ryan is a No2 corner who often gives up plays; imaging him and Rowe as our 1&2, if we lost Butler, would be a return to the 3rd and long completions D that we had for years.

    History tells us we wont pay Butler what he will probably want and tagging him might be the only way around it.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,333 ✭✭✭brinty


    TOss Sweep wrote:
    History tells us we wont pay Butler what he will probably want and tagging him might be the only way around it.

    I'd take Butler to big d
    Gets him out of the afc for Pats
    Dunno if we could pay his worth but we need corners


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,905 ✭✭✭TOss Sweep


    Looking at the Free Agency the amount of quality with expiring contracts. Quite a Large Amount

    Offensive

    Quarterbacks
    Matt Schaub, Atlanta Falcons
    Ryan Mallett, Baltimore Ravens
    EJ Manuel, Buffalo Bills
    Brian Hoyer, Chicago Bears
    Matt Barkley, Chicago Bears
    Mark Sanchez, Dallas Cowboys
    Kellen Moore, Dallas Cowboys
    Dan Orlovsky, Detroit Lions
    Case Keenum, Los Angeles Rams
    T.J. Yates, Miami Dolphins
    Shaun Hill, Minnesota Vikings
    Josh Johnson, New York Giants
    Ryan Nassib, New York Giants
    Ryan Fitzpatrick, New York Jets
    Geno Smith, New York Jets
    Matt McGloin, Oakland Raiders
    Landry Jones, Pittsburgh Steelers
    Kellen Clemens, San Diego Chargers
    Blaine Gabbert, San Francisco 49ers
    Christian Ponder, San Francisco 49ers
    Thad Lewis, San Francisco 49ers
    Mike Glennon, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Matt Cassel, Tennessee Titans
    Kirk Cousins, Washington Redskins

    Running backs
    Chris Johnson, Arizona Cardinals
    Stepfan Taylor, Arizona Cardinals
    Andre Ellington, Arizona Cardinals
    Reggie Bush, Buffalo Bills
    Cedric Peerman, Cincinnati Bengals
    Rex Burkhead, Cincinnati Bengals
    Darren McFadden, Dallas Cowboys
    Lance Dunbar, Dallas Cowboys
    Justin Forsett, Denver Broncos
    Joique Bell, Detroit Lions
    Eddie Lacy, Green Bay Packers
    Christine Michael, Green Bay Packers
    Jonathan Grimes, Houston Texans
    Jordan Todman, Indianapolis Colts
    Robert Turbin, Indianapolis Colts
    Denard Robinson, Jacksonville Jaguars
    Knile Davis, Kansas City Chiefs
    Benny Cunningham, Los Angeles Rams
    Chase Reynolds, Los Angeles Rams
    Matt Asiata, Minnesota Vikings
    Brandon Bolden, New England Patriots
    LeGarrette Blount, New England Patriots
    Tim Hightower, New Orleans Saints
    Travaris Cadet, New Orleans Saints
    Bobby Rainey, New York Giants
    Latavius Murray, Oakland Raiders
    DeAngelo Williams, Pittsburgh Steelers
    Le'Veon Bell, Pittsburgh Steelers
    Danny Woodhead, San Diego Chargers
    Dexter McCluster, San Diego Chargers
    Ronnie Hillman, San Diego Chargers
    Shaun Draughn, San Francisco 49ers
    DuJuan Harris, San Francisco 49ers
    Jacquizz Rodgers, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Antone Smith, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

    Fullbacks
    Patrick DiMarco, Atlanta Falcons
    Kyle Juszczyk, Baltimore Ravens
    Jerome Felton, Buffalo Bills
    Zach Line, Minnesota Vikings
    James Develin, New England Patriots
    John Kuhn, New Orleans Saints
    Marcel Reece, Seattle Seahawks
    Will Tukuafu, Seattle Seahawks

    Wide receivers
    Jeremy Ross, Arizona Cardinals
    Eric Weems, Atlanta Falcons
    Aldrick Robinson, Atlanta Falcons
    Kamar Aiken, Baltimore Ravens
    Percy Harvin, Buffalo Bills
    Justin Hunter, Buffalo Bills
    Robert Woods, Buffalo Bills
    Ted Ginn Jr., Carolina Panthers
    Brenton Bersin, Carolina Panthers
    Alshon Jeffery, Chicago Bears
    Deonte Thompson, Chicago Bears
    Marquess Wilson, Chicago Bears
    Brandon LaFell, Cincinnati Bengals
    Terrelle Pryor, Cleveland Browns
    Terrance Williams, Dallas Cowboys
    Brice Butler, Dallas Cowboys
    Jordan Norwood, Denver Broncos
    Marlon Brown, Marlon Brown
    Anquan Boldin, Detroit Lions
    Andre Roberts, Detroit Lions
    Bryan Walters, Jacksonville Jaguars
    Arrelious Benn, Jacksonville Jaguars
    Kenny Britt, Los Angeles Rams
    Brian Quick, Los Angeles Rams
    Stedman Bailey, Los Angeles Rams
    Kenny Stills, Miami Dolphins
    Cordarrelle Patterson, Minnesota Vikings
    Michael Floyd, New England Patriots
    Andre Holmes, Oakland Raiders
    Michael Johnson, Philadelphia Ealges
    Markus Wheaton, Pittsburgh Steelers
    Jeremy Kerley, San Francisco 49ers
    Rod Streater, San Francisco 49ers
    Quinton Patton, San Francisco 49ers
    Vincent Jackson,Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Russell Shepard, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Cecil Shorts, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Kendall Wright, Tennessee Titans
    Marc Mariani, Tennessee Titans
    Pierre Garcon, Washington Redskins
    DeSean Jackson, Washington Redskins

    Tight ends
    Jermaine Gresham, Arizona Cardinals
    Jacob Tamme, Atlanta Falcons
    Levine Toilolo, Atlanta Falcons
    Logan Paulsen, Chicago Bears
    Gavin Escobar, Dallas Cowboys
    Clay Harbor, Detroit Lions
    Matthew Mulligan, Detroit Lions
    Timothy Wright, Detroit Lions
    Jared Cook, Green Bay Packers
    Ryan Griffin, Houston Texans
    Jack Doyle, Indianapolis Colts
    Jordan Cameron, Miami Dolphins
    MarQueis Gray, Miami Dolphins
    Dominique Jones, Miami Dolphins
    Dion Sims, Miami Dolphins
    Martellus Bennett, New England Patriots
    John Phillips, New Orleans Saints
    Larry Donnell, New York Giants
    Kellen Davis, New York Jets
    Mychal Rivera, Oakland Raiders
    David Johnson, Pittsburgh Steelers
    Jeff Cumberland, San Diego Chargers
    Jim Dray, San Francisco 49ers
    Brandon Williams, Seattle Seahawks
    Luke Willson, Seattle Seahawks
    Brandon Myers, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Anthony Fasano, Tennessee Titans
    Vernon Davis, Washington Redskins

    Offensive tackles
    Earl Watford, Arizona Cardinals
    Ricky Wagner, Baltimore Ravens
    Jordan Mills, Buffalo Bills
    Mike Remmers, Carolina Panthers
    Mike Adams, Chicago Bears
    Nick Becton, Chicago Bears
    Matt McCants, Chicago Bears
    Andrew Whitworth, Cincinnati Bengals
    Eric Winston, Cincinnati Bengals
    Riley Reiff, Detroit Lions
    Don Barclay, Green Bay Packers
    David Quessenberry, Houston Texans
    Jeffrey Linkenbach, Jacksonville Jaguars
    Sam Young, Miami Dolphins
    Matt Kalil, Minnesota Vikings
    Jake Long, Minnesota Vikings
    Andre Smith, Minnesota Vikings
    Sebastian Vollmer, New England Patriots
    Tony Hills, New Orleans Saints
    Will Beatty, New York Giants
    Marshall Newhouse, New York Giants
    Ben Ijalana, New York Jets
    Menelik Watson, Oakland Raiders
    Bradley Sowell, Seattle Seahawks
    Gosder Cherilus, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Byron Bell, Tennessee Titans

    Guards
    Evan Mathis, Arizona Cardinals
    Chris Chester, Atlanta Falcons
    Tom Compton, Atlanta Falcons
    Vladimir Ducasse, Baltimore Ravens
    Chris Scott, Carolina Panthers
    Ted Larsen, Chicago Bears
    Eric Kush, Chicago Bears
    Kevin Zeitler, Cincinnati Bengals
    Austin Pasztor, Cleveland Browns
    Ronald Leary, Dallas Cowboys
    Larry Warford, Detroit Lions
    T.J. Lang, Green Bay Packers
    Oday Aboushi, Houston Texans
    Hugh Thornton, Indianapolis Colts
    Luke Joeckel, Jacksonville Jaguars
    Patrick Omameh, Jacksonville Jaguars
    Jermon Bushrod, Miami Dolphins
    Tim Lelito, New Orleans Saints
    Jahri Evans, New Orleans Saints
    Brian Winters, New York Jets
    Andrew Gardner, San Francisco 49ers
    Chance Warmack, Tennessee Titans


    Centers
    A.Q. Shipley, Arizona Cardinals
    Ryan Wendell, Carolina Panthers
    JC Tretter, Green Bay Packers
    Mike Person, Kansas City Chiefs
    Cody Wallace, Pittsburgh Steelers
    Joe Hawley, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Brian Schwenke, Tennessee Titans
    John Sullivan, Washington Redskins


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,905 ✭✭✭TOss Sweep


    Defensive and ST

    Defensive Ends
    Calais Campbell, Arizona Cardinals
    Lawrence Guy, Baltimore Ravens
    Charles Johnson, Carolina Panthers
    Mario Addison, Carolina Panthers
    C.J. Wilson, Chicago Bears
    Cornelius Washington, Chicago Bears
    Margus Hunt, Cincinnati Bengals
    Wallace Gilberry, Cincinnati Bengals
    Stephen Paea, Cleveland Browns
    Jack Crawford, Dallas Cowboys
    Vance Walker, Denver Broncos
    Billy Winn, Denver Broncos
    Devin Taylor, Detroit Lions
    Antonio Smith, Houston Texans
    Kendall Reyes, Kansas City Chiefs
    Jarvis Jenkins, Kansas City Chiefs
    Cam Thomas, Los Angeles Rams
    Dion Jordan, Miami Dolphins
    Andre Branch, Miami Dolphins
    Jason Jones, Miami Dolphins
    Justin Trattou, Minnesota Vikings
    Jabaal Sheard, New England Patriots
    Chris Long, New England Patriots
    Greg Scruggs, New England Patriots
    Darryl Tapp, New Orleans Saints
    Jason Pierre-Paul, New York Giants
    Damion Square, San Diego Chargers
    Glenn Dorsey, San Francisco 49ers
    Tony Jerod-Eddie, San Francisco 49ers
    Damontre Moore, Seattle Seahawks
    John Hughes, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    William Gholston, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Chris Baker, Washington Redskins
    Cullen Jenkins, Washington Redskins
    Ziggy Hood, Washington Redskins

    Defensive tackles
    Frostee Rucker, Arizona Cardinals
    Jonathan Babineaux, Atlanta Falcons
    Brandon Williams, Baltimore Ravens
    Corbin Bryant, Buffalo Bills
    Leger Douzable, Buffalo Bills
    Kawann Short, Carolina Panthers
    Kyle Love, Carolina Panthers
    Domata Peko, Cincinnati Bengals
    Brandon Thompson, Cincinnati Bengals
    Terrell McClain, Dallas Cowboys
    Sylvester Williams, Denver Broncos
    Stefan Charles, Detroit Lions
    Tyrunn Walker, Detroit Lions
    Vince Wilfork, Houston Texans
    Devon Still, Houston Texans
    Tyson Alualu, Jacksonville Jaguars
    Abry Jones, Jacksonville Jaguars
    Jordan Hill, Jacksonville Jaguars
    Dontari Poe, Kansas City Chiefs
    Alan Branch, New England Patriots
    Nick Fairley, New Orleans Saints
    Johnathan Hankins, New York Giants
    Stacy McGee, Oakland Raiders
    Bennie Logan, Philadelphia Eagles
    Ricardo Mathews, Pittsburgh Steelers
    Sean Lissemore, San Diego Chargers
    Tony McDaniel, Seattle Seahawks
    John Jenkins, Seattle Seahawks
    Sealver Siliga, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Akeem Spence, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Karl Klug, Tennessee Titans
    Kedric Golston, Washington Redskins

    Outside linebackers
    Chandler Jones, Arizona Cardinals
    Alex Okafor, Arizona Cardinals
    Courtney Upshaw, Atlanta Falcons
    Dwight Freeney, Atlanta Falcons
    Philip Wheeler, Atlanta Falcons
    Ramon Humber, Buffalo Bills
    Lorenzo Alexander, Buffalo Bills
    Lerentee McCray, Buffalo Bills
    Sam Acho, Chicago Bears
    Andrew Gachkar, Dallas Cowboys
    DeMarcus Ware, Denver Broncos
    Dekoda Watson, Denver Broncos
    Josh Bynes, Detroit Lions
    Armonty Bryant, Detroit Lions
    Julius Peppers, Green Bay Packers
    Nick Perry, Green Bay Packers
    Datone Jones, Green Bay Packers
    John Simon, Houston Texans
    Trent Cole, Indianapolis Colts
    Erik Walden, Indianapolis Colts
    Akeem Ayers, Indianapolis Colts
    Chris Carter, Indianapolis Colts
    Spencer Paysinger, Miami Dolphins
    Jelani Jenkins, Miami Dolphins
    Chad Greenway, Minnesota Vikings
    Barkevious Mingo, New England Patriots
    Paul Kruger, New Orleans Saints
    Michael Mauti, New Orleans Saints
    Mark Herzlich, New York Giants
    Corey Lemonier, New York Jets
    Josh Martin, New York Jets
    Bryan Braman, Philadelphia Eagles
    Jarvis Jones, Pittsburgh Steelers
    James Harrison, Pittsburgh Steelers
    Melvin Ingram, San Diego Chargers
    Tourek Williams, San Diego Chargers
    Mike Morgan, Seattle Seahawks
    David Bass, Tennessee Titans
    Junior Galette, Washington Redskins

    Inside Linebackers
    Kevin Minter, Arizona Cardinals
    Sio Moore, Arizona Cardinals
    Paul Worrilow, Atlanta Falcons
    Sean Weatherspoon, Atlanta Falcons
    LaRoy Reynolds, Atlanta Falcons
    Zach Brown, Buffalo Bills
    Ben Jacobs, Carolina Panthers
    A.J. Klein, Carolina Panthers
    Rolando McClain, Dallas Cowboys
    Justin Durant, Dallas Cowboys
    Jon Bostic, Detroit Lions
    Akeem Dent, Houston Texans
    Donald Butler, Miami Dolphins
    Audie Cole, Minnesota Vikings
    Dont'a Hightower, New England Patriots
    Jason Trusnik, New Orleans Saints
    Sam Barrington, New Orleans Saints
    Keenan Robinson, New York Giants
    Kelvin Sheppard, New York Giants
    Bruce Carter, New York Jets
    Malcolm Smith, Oakland Raiders
    Perry Riley, Oakland Raiders
    Daren Bates, Oakland Raiders
    Stephen Tulloch, Philadelphia Eagles
    Najee Goode, Philadelphia Eagles
    Lawrence Timmons, Pittsburgh Steelers
    Steven Johnson, Pittsburgh Steelers
    Manti Te'o, San Diego Chargers
    Michael Wilhoite, San Francisco 49ers
    Nick Bellore, San Francisco 49ers
    Gerald Hodges, San Francisco 49ers
    Daryl Smith, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Sean Spence, Tennessee Titans
    Nate Palmer, Tennessee Titans
    Terence Garvin, Washington Redskins

    Cornerbacks
    Mike Jenkins, Arizona Cardinals
    Marcus Cooper, Arizona Cardinals
    Blidi Wreh-Wilson, Atlanta Falcons
    Jerraud Powers, Baltimore Ravens
    Stephon Gilmore, Buffalo Bills
    Corey White, Buffalo Bills
    Teddy Williams, Carolina Panthers
    Leonard Johnson, Carolina Panthers
    Johnthan Banks, Chicago Bears
    Dre Kirkpatrick, Cincinnati Bengals
    Chykie Brown, Cincinnati Bengals
    Brandon Boykin, Cincinnati Bengals
    Josh Thomas, Dallas Cowboys
    Morris Claiborne, Dallas Cowboys
    Kayvon Webster, Denver Broncos
    Asa Jackson, Detroit Lions
    A.J. Bouye, Houston Texans
    Darius Butler, Indianapolis Colts
    Darryl Morris, Indianapolis Colts
    Prince Amukamara, Jacksonville Jaguars
    Trumaine Johnson, Los Angeles Rams
    Chimdi Chekwa, Miami Dolphins
    Captain Munnerlyn, Minnesota Vikings
    Terence Newman, Minnesota Vikings
    Logan Ryan, New England Patriots
    Kyle Wilson, New Orleans Saints
    Sterling Moore, New Orleans Saints
    Leon Hall, New York Giants
    Coty Sensabaugh, New York Giants
    Trevin Wade, New York Giants
    D.J. Hayden, Oakland Raiders
    Dwayne Gratz, Philadelphia Eagles
    Nolan Carroll, Philadelphia Eagles
    Robert McClain, San Diego Chargers
    Josh Robinson, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Valentino Blake, Tennessee Titans
    Greg Toler, Washington Redskins

    Safeties
    Tony Jefferson, Arizona Cardinals
    D.J. Swearinger, Arizona Cardinals
    Dashon Goldson, Atlanta Falcons
    Kemal Ishmael, Atlanta Falcons
    Matt Elam, Baltimore Ravens
    Anthony Levine, Baltimore Ravens
    Colt Anderson, Buffalo Bills
    James Ihedigbo, Buffalo Bills
    Robert Blanton, Buffalo Bills
    Colin Jones, Carolina Panthers
    Michael Griffin, Carolina Panthers
    Chris Prosinski, Chicago Bears
    Jordan Poyer, Cleveland Browns
    Barry Church, Dallas Cowboys
    J.J. Wilcox, Dallas Cowboys
    Rafael Bush, Detroit Lions
    Micah Hyde, Green Bay Packers
    Quintin Demps, Houston Texans
    Don Jones, Houston Texans
    Mike Adams, Indianapolis Colts
    Duke Williams, Indianapolis Colts
    Johnathan Cyprien, Jacksonville Jaguars
    Eric Berry, Kansas City Chiefs
    T.J. McDonald, Los Angeles Rams
    Michael Thomas, Miami Dolphins
    Duron Harmon, New England Patriots
    Roman Harper, New Orleans Saints
    Jamarca Sanford, New Orleans Saints
    Shiloh Keo, New Orleans Saints
    Nate Allen, Oakland Raiders
    Brynden Trawick, Oakland Raiders
    Shamarko Thomas, Pittsburgh Steelers
    Jahleel Addae, San Diego Chargers
    Jeron Johnson, Seattle Seahawks
    Kelcie McCray, Seattle Seahawks
    Chris Conte, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Bradley McDougald, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    Daimion Stafford, Tennessee Titans
    Rashad Johnson, Tennessee Titans
    Donte Whitner, Washington Redskins
    Duke Ihenacho, Washington Redskins

    Kickers
    Connor Barth, Chicago Bears
    Randy Bullock, Cincinnati Bengals
    Zach Hocker, Cincinnati Bengals
    Nick Novak, Houston Texans
    Greg Zuerlein, Los Angeles Rams
    Robbie Gould, New York Giants
    Phil Dawson, San Francisco 49ers
    Steven Hauschka, Seattle Seahawks

    Punters
    Britton Colquitt, Cleveland Browns
    Shane Lechler, Houston Texans
    Jeff Locke, Minnesota Vikings
    Bryan Anger, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

    Long snappers
    Thomas Gafford, Denver Broncos
    Don Muhlbach, Detroit Lions
    Brett Goode, Green Bay Packers
    John Denney, Miami Dolphins
    Justin Drescher, New Orleans Saints
    Zak DeOssie, New York Giants
    Tanner Purdum, New York Jets
    Jon Condo, Oakland Raiders
    Greg Warren, Pittsburgh Steelers
    Mike Windt, San Diego Chargers
    Nick Sundberg, Washington Redskins


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,017 ✭✭✭Leslie91


    Vincent Jackson, San Diego Chargers?.... once upon a time yes.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,905 ✭✭✭TOss Sweep


    Leslie91 wrote: »
    Vincent Jackson, San Diego Chargers?.... once upon a time yes.

    Sure there are more mistakes NFL.com piss poor at proof reading


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,905 ✭✭✭TOss Sweep


    Apparently Browns are considering Garoppolo

    http://www.cleveland.com/browns/index.ssf/2017/01/browns_qb_buzz_on_jimmy_garopp.html

    Looks like the Pats may have found a winner. Wouldn't surprise me in the slightest for the Browns to give the Pats that first round pick :D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,317 ✭✭✭HigginsJ


    TOss Sweep wrote: »
    Apparently Browns are considering Garoppolo

    http://www.cleveland.com/browns/index.ssf/2017/01/browns_qb_buzz_on_jimmy_garopp.html

    Looks like the Pats may have found a winner. Wouldn't surprise me in the slightest for the Browns to give the Pats that first round pick :D

    What would the thinking be of a fair price for Garoppolo?

    I would give up something like a 2nd & 4th or a pair of 3's, in no world would I give a 1st, especially not a top 12 pick (which Bill would undoubtedly turn into 14 2nd's that he could use to draft obscure corners & safeties!!)


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,004 ✭✭✭✭Realt Dearg Sec


    A lot of bears fans debating this very issue. Consensus seems to be they'll want a first and a fourth, and with the way things are going they might just get exactly that (not from Chicago though, I wouldn't say). My problem is that his record is way too slim to be giving up such a price. So I expect the browns to soil themselves again of course and continue helping to pad out the new England roster for years to come. Whether he's worth the price or not, I think he'll command that kind of price in the current climate


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,328 ✭✭✭the baby bull elephant


    TOss Sweep wrote: »
    Apparently Browns are considering Garoppolo

    http://www.cleveland.com/browns/index.ssf/2017/01/browns_qb_buzz_on_jimmy_garopp.html

    Looks like the Pats may have found a winner. Wouldn't surprise me in the slightest for the Browns to give the Pats that first round pick :D

    If they give a first rounder it'll be their second one. Garret and JG would automatically upgrade them a lot but it would still be a crazy trade.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,905 ✭✭✭TOss Sweep


    HigginsJ wrote: »
    What would the thinking be of a fair price for Garoppolo?

    I would give up something like a 2nd & 4th or a pair of 3's, in no world would I give a 1st, especially not a top 12 pick (which Bill would undoubtedly turn into 14 2nd's that he could use to draft obscure corners & safeties!!)

    Pats want 1st round for him. Hard to say what is a 'Fair' price though given how teams bite on ridiculous trades all the time. I think what we see as fair and what teams with needs see as fair are two different things. My opinion would be 3rd or 4th round pick but when I add the factors of the stupidity and needs of NFL teams the Pats will easily get a 2nd round pick for him and I wouldn't be surprised if someone trades down in draft and gets extra lower round picks and then gives the Pats their lower 1st round pick for Jimmy G.

    Or the Browns will just straight up give us their 1st round pick.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 39,450 ✭✭✭✭eagle eye


    HigginsJ wrote: »
    What would the thinking be of a fair price for Garoppolo?

    I would give up something like a 2nd & 4th or a pair of 3's, in no world would I give a 1st, especially not a top 12 pick (which Bill would undoubtedly turn into 14 2nd's that he could use to draft obscure corners & safeties!!)
    Garoppolo has already shown he can play at a high level in the NFL and there are no outstanding prospects at the position in this draft. Imo it's more than just the first round pick.

    I'd be of the opinion that you'd want to be giving me a 2nd and a 4th for Brissett but no chance you get Jimmy G for anything like that.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,905 ✭✭✭TOss Sweep


    eagle eye wrote: »
    Garoppolo has already shown he can play at a high level in the NFL and there are no outstanding prospects at the position in this draft. Imo it's more than just the first round pick.

    I'd be of the opinion that you'd want to be giving me a 2nd and a 4th for Brissett but no chance you get Jimmy G for anything like that.

    And this is the same mentality that teams have and why so many give up so much for guys with very little experience. Jimmy G may be worth a 1st round pick in the current climate but it is incredibly hard to say that is exactly what he is worth.

    Same as Premier League Overpaying for players because it is the current climate and thing to do to get your man.

    We all know there is a difference between True Value and the Inflated Value caused by current climate and needs. Be a fool to think otherwise really.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,317 ✭✭✭HigginsJ


    eagle eye wrote: »
    Garoppolo has already shown he can play at a high level in the NFL and there are no outstanding prospects at the position in this draft. Imo it's more than just the first round pick.

    I'd be of the opinion that you'd want to be giving me a 2nd and a 4th for Brissett but no chance you get Jimmy G for anything like that.

    He can play at a high level, in that system. Bill is a genius, he can game plan like no-one else IMO. My opinion is if the Pat's believed he was the heir apparent they wouldn't consider trading him as Brady has max 1 to 2 seasons left.

    What would you want for Garoppolo?

    In terms of high level prospects in the draft, there are obviously a number of guys who are going to grade out a lot higher than Garoppolo did when he was coming out.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 39,450 ✭✭✭✭eagle eye


    HigginsJ wrote: »
    He can play at a high level, in that system. Bill is a genius, he can game plan like no-one else IMO. My opinion is if the Pat's believed he was the heir apparent they wouldn't consider trading him as Brady has max 1 to 2 seasons left.

    What would you want for Garoppolo?

    In terms of high level prospects in the draft, there are obviously a number of guys who are going to grade out a lot higher than Garoppolo did when he was coming out.
    Right there are a couple of parts to this question.

    Brady might be done shortly or he could go on for another five or six years. He really does put the work in to keep himself in shape. All the stretching he does is insane but clearly it works.

    Now here is the big thing to consider, look back at Jimmy G and see how similar he looked to Brady in the pocket. This is the most important thing when grading. He was able to step around the pocket effortlessly just like the man who he sat behind for a couple of seasons. He threw four tds and no ints, he had a completion percentage of circa 71%.

    You mention how he was graded in his draft year, that doesn't matter now that he has been seen in action in the NFL. I mean if Brady was up for trade a couple of seasons back are you going back to his draft year to decide whether to take him or some college prospect?

    Even at that, I don't think there will be anyone grading out higher than he did anyways. This is a very poor QB draft class.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,961 ✭✭✭✭AbusesToilets


    The question is, who represents more of a risk, the QB who has spent the last 3 years developing and learning or the rookie straight out of college? The rookie is Obv better from a financial perspective, but Jimmy has shown he can play at an NFL level, albeit in a brief window.

    As a Pats fan I'm pretty torn tbh. I watched him play in Phoenix and he looked good, and only improved against Miami.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,004 ✭✭✭✭Realt Dearg Sec


    A really, really brief window. I mean if we're taking his time as starter as representative (0 interceptions etc), we can also note that he was injured 50℅ of the time. We can't cherry pick stats so we have to accept that we don't have enough information. I mean Matt Barkley put up 27 points against the packers and only barely lost due to some rodgers magic. A record number of wide receiver drops also cost him a win against Tennessee. Unfortunately he didn't get injured so we ended up seeing that he's an interception machine as well, but if I only had those two games to go on I'd be happy to spend a low first or a second on him.

    What I do know is that the patriots have a history of trading back up qbs that looked pretty good until playing for someone else, for nice ransoms. We also know that they nearly never come out worse in a trade (I can think of one minor exception off the top of my head, but nothing anyone would care about).

    Garopolo might live up to the promise, I don't know, I'm not a great reader of quarterback play. if you think he's going to be your guy, well then he is, by definition, worth a first round pick, I suppose. If I was the browns I'd want my first round picks, and for that matter I wouldn't want my team shielding more than a second rounder on him either


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,905 ✭✭✭TOss Sweep


    A really, really brief window. I mean if we're taking his time as starter as representative (0 interceptions etc), we can also note that he was injured 50℅ of the time. We can't cherry pick stats so we have to accept that we don't have enough information. I mean Matt Barkley put up 27 points against the packers and only barely lost due to some rodgers magic. A record number of wide receiver drops also cost him a win against Tennessee. Unfortunately he didn't get injured so we ended up seeing that he's an interception machine as well, but if I only had those two games to go on I'd be happy to spend a low first or a second on him.

    Very true even look at Matt Flynn. Guy hand a couple of solid games in place of Rodgers and teams were throwing money at him and where is he today?
    What I do know is that the patriots have a history of trading back up qbs that looked pretty good until playing for someone else, for nice ransoms. We also know that they nearly never come out worse in a trade (I can think of one minor exception off the top of my head, but nothing anyone would care about).

    As much as I think Jimmy could come good eventually this is the key tht everyone seems to forget. The Patriots are one of the best teams in the business of adjusting to suit the personnel they have. This is why we have the system QB crap come out from those who don't like Brady. But it works and gets the most out of all the QBs we have used.
    Garopolo might live up to the promise, I don't know, I'm not a great reader of quarterback play. if you think he's going to be your guy, well then he is, by definition, worth a first round pick, I suppose. If I was the browns I'd want my first round picks, and for that matter I wouldn't want my team shielding more than a second rounder on him either

    I agree I love Jimmy and I hope he does well and goes on to a solid career but it really is too early to tell and if I am being honest the Browns is the worst place he could go especially with the pressure of being traded for a 1st round pick.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 22,477 ✭✭✭✭Knex*


    I don't think Garoppolo is worth a first, but I'd certainly rather spend a first on him than any of the QBs in this year's draft.

    Even look at what the Rams and the Eagles gave up last year for Wentz and Goff. That type of ransom can cripple a franchise if the QB is a bust.

    There's talk even of some teams being daft enough to trade for the number 1 pick this year to select Mitch Trubisky. If that happens, and the Browns do a separate trade for Jimmy G, I think they'll be doing alright.

    Missing out on Myles Garrett would be the only negative, but I'm sure they'd be well compensated.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,173 ✭✭✭cosatron


    I don't think any back up qb is worth a first round pick. The Browns would be best served to put the pieces in place this year for drafting a qb next year assuming the class is better next year or take a punt on a qb in the second round and he might be another Wilson or Prescott


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,317 ✭✭✭HigginsJ


    The Browns should take Myles Garrett, from everything I have read and seen he is a stud (watch him flame out in Cleveland), there seems to be little to no debate that he is the best player in this draft. It is the 12 pick that they need to decide what to do with.

    Ideal world trade down to mid 20's and make a QB decision, I would say trade down, add picks and take Pat Mahomes. They need a new QB, RGIII can't be relied on and not hearing convincing things about Cody Kessler.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,644 ✭✭✭D9Male


    I think a combination of RG3 and Cody Kessler is enough to hold the fort for another year - draft best players available and build for a quarter back next year.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,317 ✭✭✭HigginsJ


    D9Male wrote: »
    I think a combination of RG3 and Cody Kessler is enough to hold the fort for another year - draft best players available and build for a quarter back next year.

    Waiting for a quarterback is always a risky game, what looks great now can, & very often does, change quickly. They should draft a QB regardless this year, even if only a mid rounder, as they might strike lightning in a bottle.

    That being said, they could have ARod at QB next year and they would be lucky to get 6 wins.


  • Advertisement
Advertisement