New context to rape tape in Mayo

swordofislam

I don't understand. Are these tapes forgeries made by splicing unrelated words together? If not the police were making a joke about rape.

GerM

Logical Fallacy wrote: »

While i understand what you are trying to say i don't really think your point is valid unless it was the same people involved in both incidents.

I would be surprised if those that released the tape weren't fully informed of the situation and were ignorant that protest supporters had, at any time, used rape as an accusatory weapon. Of course, I am making some assumptions here but I would think the odds that they knew their supporters had made such claims whilst being arrested are pretty good.

epgc3fyqirnbsx

swordofislam wrote: »

I don't understand. Are these tapes forgeries made by splicing unrelated words together? If not the police were making a joke about rape.

They were, context being that they were being accused of rape.
In any case people joke around in private, but to publicly accuse someone of rape or of threatening to do so is pretty despicable

montane

"Protesters had released part of a recording from a camcorder that had been seized by gardai and was still running when the 'rape' conversation took place inside the squad car. This received massive media coverage.

However, the background to the remarks and context in which the gardai were jokingly referring to rape was not made public.

According to garda sources at least one unidentified woman protester used the word repeatedly as she was being moved from the site."

I wonder why the Irish Times only focused on one section of the original tape?

GerM

montane wrote: »

"However, the background to the remarks and context in which the gardai were jokingly referring to rape was not made public.

According to garda sources at least one unidentified woman protester used the word repeatedly as she was being moved from the site."

I wonder why the Irish Times only focused on one section of the original tape?

How much of the original tape were they provided with?

7sr2z3fely84g5

Funny how at the moment the offical shell to sea site has nothing about this in the news section,but has the garda tapes in news archives..

tayto lover

I always thought there was something very fishy going on regarding those tapes.
It now looks like the Gardai had an in-house joke about rape after being accused about it several times. it would explain everything and make the whole thing more logical.

montane

I await eaglerly a statement of condemnation from the National Women's Council, and various media outlets on false accusations of rape being hurled by protesters at gardai trying to their job in extremely difficult circumstances.

hatrickpatrick

“We know that rapes in recent years have become more violent and often imitate actions of pornographic imagery. This clearly shows how normalised sexual violence is and we believe that this is linked to the pervasive sex industry in Ireland.

*facepalm*

Young people especially have to be more aware of the seriousness of issues such as rape, sexual assault, prostitution, human trafficking and pornography.

Two of these things are consensual and have nothing whatsoever to do with sexual coercion. Can AH spot the rogues?

Seriously though, bracketing rape in with porn and prostitution is utterly ridiculous. All it does is trivialize rape. (note: I do not include trafficking or forced prostitution in this statement.)

Comparing an act of coercion to a consensual act is quite frankly moronic.

Duggy747

Surprise, surprise.

It's pretty disheartening when everybody I mentioned this story to immediately spat acid and accused the Gardaì as "utter fùckin' scum". The seeds already planted thanks to the well-placed wordings of ill-informed Facebook groups and shìtty tabloids.

The inherent dislike for the Gardaì made this accusation all the more easier to swallow for people.

Killer Pigeon

Activist: "Ah, I'm being lifted down off a tractor, ah! Ah, I feel something hard against my thigh, ah!"

Garda: "That's my baton, now please get down off the tractor! It's private property!"

Activist: "Ah, he's going to rape me with his baton, ah!"

Killer Pigeon

Meanwhile, gardai are now investigating the actual rape of a 22-year-old English woman, now living in Ireland, at a mini-festival run by protesters last Sunday week.
The woman was found naked and in a very distressed state behind a row of portaloos by other people at the Party Against the Pipe festival at Aughoose on the bank holiday weekend.

Hmmm...
Will an actual incident of rape get more attention...
Welcome to Ireland.

CoolHat

Mavis Cool Karaoke wrote: »

A garda lifts a woman off a tractor, which I'm assuming was private property, and gets accused of rape.
This shows just how much some of those protestors are willing to trivialise something as serious as rape just to get their shrill voices heard

pretty much says it all.


it sad, we live in a world where a person would say anything :rolleyes: granted not every person.... but still, such a thing as rape should never be falsely accused.

Eric Cartman

My name is URL wrote: »

heh.. in fairness some of them are just normal local people who genuinely believe they have something which is worth protecting

that is a tiny tiny minority , and their concerns are not voiced by S2S , the only people the media give any time to or biased tripe websites like indymedia publish anything about are lying nutjob media whores like maura harrington, willie corduff or the protest anything crew. The locals with perhaps valid concerns and a right to protest are not the ones being arrested or taken off tractors by gardai or on the television / radio or videod on the internet attacking and injuring gardai and being called heros by other nutjobs.

The saddest thing about the S2S debacle is the poor gardai and employees of shell just trying to do their jobs and not get involved in the politics and being assaulted like they personally decided the pipe was to be built

Logical Fallacy

Eric Cartman wrote: »

The locals with perhaps valid concerns and a right to protest are not the ones being arrested

Actually, quite a few locals have been arrested, especially from the local fishing community.

Eric Cartman

Logical Fallacy wrote: »

Actually, quite a few locals have been arrested, especially from the local fishing community.

I said the locals with valid concerns (sorry, it reads badly) , there are loopers in the local community too

mconigol

Well this certainly puts things into context...

banquo

Order of events:

1. There are some general protesters who just love protesting, will protest anything and who's culture involves hating the Gardaí. These are not in Mayo.
2. Something happens in Mayo that genuinely should be protested at (imho)
3. Non-local protesters go to Mayo and turn the conversation away from 'Should Shell be allowed there' to 'Are you pro- or anti- Gardaí'.

The locals deserve a much bigger say in what happens in their area tbh, and these guys are doing them more harm than good. It's completely selfish.

creative100

ColeTrain wrote: »

I wonder if they would shout "rape" if a Garda was saving them from a burning building. Probably not.

Somehow I doubt the Gardai would be interested in saving any of these from a burning building.

gerrycollins

still have not heard anything about this on the news, suppose it would be hard to put into context but the whole thing makes sense now.

Ya cant wait for those with voices that are listened to (rape crisis center etc) to come forward and voice their concerns over the abuse of using the word rape like it was an swear word almost against people.

AudreyHepburn

The saddest thing about all of this is it is going to impact negatively on real rape victims because the protesters are reducing rape to nothing more than a form of protest and a method of turning public opinion against those charged with capturing sex offenders.

tayto lover

AudreyHepburn wrote: »

The saddest thing about all of this is it is going to impact negatively on real rape victims because the protesters are reducing rape to nothing more than a form of protest and a method of turning public opinion against those charged with capturing sex offenders.

Exactly. To them the protest has become more important than the crime. Its a very sad state of affairs and the people who pushed that agenda plus the willing media have a lot to answer for. Real victims must be feeling very bad as a result of such a heinous crime being used in this way.

bc dub

****'em, they're only crusties. the sooner the better shell get the job done and we can start earning some shekels for Norway's taxpayers, the better.

without Garda there protecting the Norwegians interests, this thing could go on forever. its not rape if the Gard is good looking.

Irishgoatman

Surely the whole point of this issue is not that anyone cried rape but that one garda commented to another, in what he thought was private, that a woman needed to be raped!.
This is unacceptable, if true.
I hope that no-one reading this thread would find rape funny enough to joke about it to a work mate or friend.

If the tape is real then the garda in question needs repremanding and re-educating but the whole thing seems to have growing out of all proportion.

Mayo Ireland

Hi Guys.

I agree with all of the above. FYi: The video of the Gardai removing the women from the tractor, together with the Jim Cusack article can be found at www.rapearrest.wordpress.com and on YouTube at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLW_qKZTtc8

TBH, I'm delighted to have this context as I was so unsure when I heard about the tape. I just don't know any men who make jokes like this, or ever have. Perhaps I'm hanging out with the right crowd. Who knows.

And also, is it true that the women have refused to release the full tapes. Someone said this is because there was other stuff on them that didn't reflect well on their accusations. Perhaps there are other mentions of the word rape from the women, as there were on the tractor. In short, the Gardai may have been making light of a barrage of accusations.. Yeah, you don't joke about this sort of stuff, but one has to consider how stressful all of this would be on young Gardai (and old). We live in a PC which is a nightmare, and if you're a man you can be accused of anything. That's my opinion anyway.

Logical Fallacy

Eric Cartman wrote: »

I said the locals with valid concerns (sorry, it reads badly) , there are loopers in the local community too

Well yeah, i mean local fishermen being concerned about the effect the project will have on local waters clearly marks them out as loopers.

Itsdacraic

Did someone really get raped at a festival entitled "Party Against The Pipe"

Paparazzo

Makes the context of the last recording of the 3 guards in the squad car much more clear. Every time a woman is touched down they shout "rape". Pathetic.

Even worse was people wanted the GS that made the comments sacked!

Mayo Ireland

Yes.. two weekends ago someone was raped during the Party against the Pipe music festival.

It's clear the protesters have more to worry about from those within their ranks, rather than the Gardai. I don't think there's a tape of the 'real' rape, so it hasn't got anything like the coverage of the women hurling abuses and the Gardai jokes using the 'word' rape.

How mad is that. Some poor girl is actually abused, but the media value of the 'rape tape' makes the physical attack pale into insignificance against a propoganda value of a word for the protest community.

Protesters seriously need to re-calibrate their ethical standards and get incensed and up in arms about something truly awful that actually happened.

Logical Fallacy

Mayo Ireland wrote: »

Protesters seriously need to re-calibrate their ethical standards and get incensed and up in arms about something truly awful that actually happened.

http://partyagainstthepipe.wordpress.com/urgent-appeal-information-regarding-the-sexual-assault/

I have no idea why other members of the media are not reporting the issue, especially places like Indymedia who can obviously reach many of the people who would have been present at the event and may be able to provide important details to the Gardai.

I've actually sent them an email asking them why no mention has been made of the event on their site when it could be very beneficial to the investigation.