Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Where do you find rest?

  • 26-04-2011 1:41am
    #1
    Closed Accounts Posts: 954 ✭✭✭Donatello


    I wonder where folks who do not believe in God find rest, peace, joy?

    I think that the most convincing proof that there is a God is the spiritual void that is in each person. Material goods, drugs, sex, alcohol - none of these things are effective remedies against the emptiness that is inside. Yes, they feel good in the moment, but they do not endure. They exhaust themselves, and the soul grows bored.

    If you have a lot of money, you can buy distractions - cars, for instance, or houses. Or women. Whatever.

    But you are just distracting yourself. You have the money to do it. Great. But even then, you are fooling yourself if you think this is some kind of permanent solution or an effective remedy.

    I see the emptiness of the people around me. I see them doing what I do when I stray from my walk with God. They seek to lose themselves in whatever distractions they can find.

    But only in my walk with God have I experienced true joy - an up-welling in my soul of pure joy. This is not something that comes from myself, but rather it comes from my closeness to God and is a gift from Him. If I walk with God, I experience His joy. When I stray from Him, I feel the pull of materialism and sensuality - the desire to fill myself with whatever I can find. I seek to fill the emptiness some other way, though I know it is futile. Only God satisfies.

    I'm interested in hearing your thoughts on this, for those of you who do not believe in God.

    “O Lord, you have made us for yourself, and our hearts are restless until they find their rest in you.”
    - St. Augustine of Hippo


«134

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,129 ✭✭✭kirving


    Why couldn't someone substitute God for a real person?


    (Damnit! Was on my phone and the video link didn't paste in)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,872 ✭✭✭strobe


    Donatello wrote: »
    I wonder where folks who do not believe in God find rest, peace, joy?

    I think that the most convincing proof that there is a God is the spiritual void that is in each person. Material goods, drugs, sex, alcohol - none of these things are effective remedies against the emptiness that is inside. Yes, they feel good in the moment, but they do not endure. They exhaust themselves, and the soul grows bored.

    If you have a lot of money, you can buy distractions - cars, for instance, or houses. Or women. Whatever.

    But you are just distracting yourself. You have the money to do it. Great. But even then, you are fooling yourself if you think this is some kind of permanent solution or an effective remedy.

    I see the emptiness of the people around me. I see them doing what I do when I stray from my walk with God. They seek to lose themselves in whatever distractions they can find.

    But only in my walk with God have I experienced true joy - an up-welling in my soul of pure joy. This is not something that comes from myself, but rather it comes from my closeness to God and is a gift from Him. If I walk with God, I experience His joy. When I stray from Him, I feel the pull of materialism and sensuality - the desire to fill myself with whatever I can find. I seek to fill the emptiness some other way, though I know it is futile. Only God satisfies.

    I'm interested in hearing your thoughts on this, for those of you who do not believe in God.

    “O Lord, you have made us for yourself, and our hearts are restless until they find their rest in you.”
    - St. Augustine of Hippo

    I do not see the difference between how you describe God in the above paragraphs and how I have heard heroin addicts I have worked with describe diacetylmorphine. I see no difference between how you describe the material things people use as distractions and how you use God as a distraction.

    But if you want what does it for me? People mainly. Friends, family, interesting strangers, give me 'peace, joy'.

    Also, music is nice.

    (case in point)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,353 ✭✭✭Goduznt Xzst


    Donatello wrote: »
    I wonder where folks who do not believe in God find rest, peace, joy?

    ...

    I see the emptiness of the people around me. I see them doing what I do when I stray from my walk with God. They seek to lose themselves in whatever distractions they can find.

    I find my rest in reading XKCD

    sheeple.png


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 30,746 ✭✭✭✭Galvasean


    What is this, ask obvious bloody questions week?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 560 ✭✭✭virmilitaris


    I wonder if you are interested. Let's see.

    Peoples belief in god, allah, thor, fairies etc is all the same. You have an imaginery friend with characteristics supplied by someone else which you approve of.

    The only joy and solace you gain from this is caused by your own mind.

    Where do I get my joy from? Kissing my wife goodnight, playing with my dog, having a meal with my parents, meeting good friends, watching an hour of Carl Sagan or listening to a clip of Stephen Hawkings.

    Eating some new delicious food, drinking some good wine, listening to good music or a beautiful poem.

    Any and all of which I would take over your god any day of the week, whether he is imaginary or not.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,718 ✭✭✭The Mad Hatter


    Donatello wrote: »
    But only in my walk with God have I experienced true joy - an up-welling in my soul of pure joy.

    Then, truly, you have my pity.

    I find joy in this amazing world - in great writing and great art, in the discoveries of science, in helping people, in good conversation and jokes and silly things. Watching a Carl Sagan documentary or reading a story by Joyce or wondering at the intricacies of a fugue by Bach, leaves me feeling whole and fulfilled. Joy is knowing that I have friends and family, and that we are all (more or less) healthy and happy, and we care for each other. I felt joy and bliss and tranquility lying with my girlfriend on the beach of the Baie des Anges in Nice, and I feel even more when I know that those feelings can be brought back to me by simply running my thumb across the smooth surface of a pebble that she gave me there. There's joy in nature - in the peace of a forest in late Summer, and in the majesty of galaxies - but in technology too: my parents, who live at the other side of the country, I can see face-to-face at the touch of a button. Isn't that incredible? How can you fail to find joy in a marvel like that?

    If you need to look outside of the universe to find joy, then yours must be a miserable existence.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 954 ✭✭✭Donatello


    Why couldn't someone substitute God for a real person?
    Is it too much to ask of another person, as ordinary and mortal as you are, to fulfil your every desire?
    strobe wrote: »
    I do not see the difference between how you describe God in the above paragraphs and how I have heard heroin addicts I have worked with describe diacetylmorphine. I see no difference between how you describe the material things people use as distractions and how you use God as a distraction.
    Heroin is not liberating - it is enslaving and destructive. It is an escape from reality. God, on the other hand, and faith in Him, is sustainable and life-giving.
    Where do I get my joy from? Kissing my wife goodnight, playing with my dog, having a meal with my parents, meeting good friends, watching an hour of Carl Sagan or listening to a clip of Stephen Hawkings.

    Eating some new delicious food, drinking some good wine, listening to good music or a beautiful poem.
    Those things are good, of course. Well, I'm not so sure about Sagan or Hawkins. :)
    Then, truly, you have my pity.

    I find joy in this amazing world - in great writing and great art, in the discoveries of science, in helping people, in good conversation and jokes and silly things. Watching a Carl Sagan documentary or reading a story by Joyce or wondering at the intricacies of a fugue by Bach, leaves me feeling whole and fulfilled. Joy is knowing that I have friends and family, and that we are all (more or less) healthy and happy, and we care for each other. I felt joy and bliss and tranquility lying with my girlfriend on the beach of the Baie des Anges in Nice, and I feel even more when I know that those feelings can be brought back to me by simply running my thumb across the smooth surface of a pebble that she gave me there. There's joy in nature - in the peace of a forest in late Summer, and in the majesty of galaxies - but in technology too: my parents, who live at the other side of the country, I can see face-to-face at the touch of a button. Isn't that incredible? How can you fail to find joy in a marvel like that?
    Of course there is joy and peace in sunsets and swallows and rainbows. But these things, in themselves, do not satisfy all the aspirations and hopes of the human heart. They point to something more. Even in the best of times - perhaps especially in the best of times - there is this thought of 'Is this it? Is this as good as it gets?' An exam success, a new exciting job opportunity, a new girlfriend, a new house, holidays etc... None of these things, as good as they might be, fulfils absolutely. It would be too much to ask of any created thing of absolute and permanent fulfilment. None of these things last forever.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,038 ✭✭✭sponsoredwalk


    Donatello wrote: »
    I wonder where folks who do not believe in God find rest, peace, joy?

    We actually don't, we're quite envious of those who take comfort in
    knowing there's a being there who would have drowned them had they
    been born in a certain era (time of the flood y'know).
    Donatello wrote: »
    But even then, you are fooling yourself if you think this is some kind of permanent solution or an effective remedy.

    If god was such a permanent solution then you wouldn't be continually
    straying from him. People fall off the wagon & return to the bottle in the
    way you're describing.
    Donatello wrote: »
    I see the emptiness of the people around me. I see them doing what I do when I stray from my walk with God. They seek to lose themselves in whatever distractions they can find.

    Not all of us see our families, friends, passions as distractions from our
    solitary walks of happiness. It's nice of you to argue that true happiness
    only comes when you view your family as a distraction, but some of us
    don't buy it.
    Donatello wrote: »
    But only in my walk with God have I experienced true joy - an up-welling in my soul of pure joy. This is not something that comes from myself, but rather it comes from my closeness to God and is a gift from Him. If I walk with God, I experience His joy.
    When I stray from Him, I feel the pull of materialism and sensuality - the desire to fill myself with whatever I can find. I seek to fill the emptiness some other way, though I know it is futile. Only God satisfies.


    Sounds to me like you're like every human being on the planet who gets
    that feeling when they go for a walk , if you didn't view everything else
    in this world as a triviality/distraction you might also get the feeling from
    other things as well.

    In fact, I have musical evidence people get that feeling from going
    from a walk outside (:p) here:



    (Don't know how something like that is just a distraction).
    Donatello wrote: »
    IMaterial goods, drugs, sex, alcohol - none of these things are effective remedies against the emptiness that is inside.

    None of those were ever seriously claimed to be effective remedies
    against the emptiness inside. Yeah people use some/all of these as a
    means to try to medicate themselves but that doesn't mean they will
    work or that they are supposed to work. I don't take some elitist
    perspective of people who use those things as ways to find happiness
    though...

    It's another thing I've noticed, "the emptiness that is inside" - that is
    something you'd hear from either a depressed person or a religious
    person. It's no surprise either, the cultish practices foster depression
    & division, I mean you're arguing that your family/friends etc... are
    just distractions! It doesn't surprise me that someone who has already
    decided that everything in this life is simply a triviality, merely a
    distraction, would be depressed. I just don't accept the idea that you
    can argue all of us who don't think like you are without joy - peace &
    rest can come when you get old - I mean you're going to have to take
    a step back, take off the beer goggles & realize how hateful this
    fundamentalist ideology is - making you view outsiders as joyless, your
    family as a distraction & your god as nothing but a drug that hilariously
    exemplifies all the common traits of a drug (running out, letting it's user
    stray from indulgence for a while only to come back harder than before).


    ---

    Heard this awesome song a few days ago, really seems appropriate
    right now!



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8,758 ✭✭✭Stercus Accidit


    I wonder if you are interested. Let's see.

    Peoples belief in god, allah, thor, fairies etc is all the same. You have an imaginery friend with characteristics supplied by someone else which you approve of.

    The only joy and solace you gain from this is caused by your own mind.

    Where do I get my joy from? Kissing my wife goodnight, playing with my dog, having a meal with my parents, meeting good friends, watching an hour of Carl Sagan or listening to a clip of Stephen Hawkings.

    Eating some new delicious food, drinking some good wine, listening to good music or a beautiful poem.

    Any and all of which I would take over your god any day of the week, whether he is imaginary or not.

    Brilliantly put, thanks.

    I have to say, not feeling guilty for being human, flaws and all, is a big load off of my mind too, try to find that kind of contentedness while trying to please a petty god.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,718 ✭✭✭The Mad Hatter


    Donatello wrote: »
    Of course there is joy and peace in sunsets and swallows and rainbows. But these things, in themselves, do not satisfy all the aspirations and hopes of the human heart. They point to something more. Even in the best of times - perhaps especially in the best of times - there is this thought of 'Is this it? Is this as good as it gets?' An exam success, a new exciting job opportunity, a new girlfriend, a new house, holidays etc... None of these things, as good as they might be, fulfils absolutely. It would be too much to ask of any created thing of absolute and permanent fulfilment. None of these things last forever.

    Neither, according to your OP ("I see them doing what I do when I stray from my walk with God."), does the joy you find in God.

    I would agree with your assertion that the joy I feel in any of those things is permanent - of course it's not. But if by "absolute" you mean "unsurpassable" then I disagree utterly.

    And it's Hawking.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,082 ✭✭✭Pygmalion


    Donatello wrote: »
    Heroin is not liberating - it is enslaving and destructive. It is an escape from reality. God, on the other hand

    I lol'd.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 954 ✭✭✭Donatello


    Pygmalion wrote: »
    I lol'd.

    I knew you would.

    Not all of us see our families, friends, passions as distractions from our
    solitary walks of happiness. It's nice of you to argue that true happiness
    only comes when you view your family as a distraction, but some of us
    don't buy it.
    The Christian faith holds the family in high esteem. I am not denigrating the family. We love and serve God through our love and service of our families.

    What I am saying is that we cannot fill our emptiness with the empty pursuit of pleasure, nor can we fulfil ourselves with the pursuit of money, power, academic achievement etc...


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,082 ✭✭✭Pygmalion


    You seem to need God to be happy.
    I don't.

    Clearly you're not going to accept this, and will continue to insist I'm terribly unfulfilled.
    I can see this going around in circles.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 560 ✭✭✭virmilitaris


    Donatello wrote: »
    Of course there is joy and peace in sunsets and swallows and rainbows. But these things, in themselves, do not satisfy all the aspirations and hopes of the human heart.

    And religion / belief in your god / worship of your god does ?

    I could argue that it doesn't in other people since you have stated yourself that sometimes you stray from your god meaning he doesn't always satisfy your aspirations or hopes.

    But I'll leave that and instead explain my own opinion on the subject.

    I do not believe in your god but let's imagine for a moment that I do. If your god was real then not only would I not find it fulfilling or good, I would find it reprehensible and evil.

    I would not worship your god even if you could prove to me that it was real. I get no comfort or solace from the belief that I am a slave to some other being regardless of his position or powers. I would find such a belief to be the exact opposite, I would find it to be a cause of sorrow not joy.

    If the christian god was real it would not fill any emptiness, it would create one. I can think of nothing more empty than the thought of living my life to please some other jealous petty being. But fear not because you are not alone in your desires to do so. North Korea is full of people who do just that, they live their lives to please another jealous petty being.

    The way christians talk about god and Jesus is indistinguishable from the way 'loyal' North Koreans talk about Kim Il-Sung and Kim Jong-Il. You just need to substitute the word 'god' and 'Jesus' for 'The Great Leader' and 'The Dear Leader' and there would be no difference.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,353 ✭✭✭Goduznt Xzst


    Donatello wrote: »
    Heroin is not liberating - it is enslaving and destructive. It is an escape from reality. God, on the other hand, and faith in Him, is sustainable and life-giving.

    You're a dyed-in-the-wool Catholic (safe to assume given your sig). Well I can tell you one destructive quality of your faith right off the bat without even getting into the crippling doctrines therein, it's obviously destroyed the reasoning centers of your brain that should of seen how your definition of Heroin is exactly what Catholicism is.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 365 ✭✭doriansmith


    I really don't understand this idea some religious people have that there's no joy in life without God.

    Growing up Catholic & believing in God never brought me peace or joy. I actually find more 'peace' now as an atheist. I find joy in people - family & friends and the moments & memories shared with them. And in learning more about, exploring & seeing more of this amazing world we live in.

    I feel a lot luckier to be alive knowing that I'm here by chance, than I would by believing that a God designed me & planned for me to be here.

    Happiness is in the here & now, not in living life in the hope that there'll be something better afterwards.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 831 ✭✭✭achtungbarry


    You seem to talk a lot about 'our emptiness' when I think you mean 'my emptiness'. Projecting ?

    There is so much in the world that gives me joy: my wife, my family, friends, music, photography, travel etc. I also get great joy from learning: learning about the world and universe around us. Real knowledge is so much more fulfilling and awe inspiring than 'god did it'.

    I find rest in simply going for a walk or reading a book.

    Open your eyes and broaden your mind and you will find much joy in the real world. I feel sorry for you if you can't.


  • Moderators Posts: 51,922 ✭✭✭✭Delirium


    Donatello wrote: »
    I wonder where folks who do not believe in God find rest, peace, joy?
    Music, books, movies, spending time with friends and family.
    I think that the most convincing proof that there is a God is the spiritual void that is in each person. Material goods, drugs, sex, alcohol - none of these things are effective remedies against the emptiness that is inside. Yes, they feel good in the moment, but they do not endure. They exhaust themselves, and the soul grows bored.
    why do religious people always presume that non-religious people turn to drugs, sex and/or alcohol? It's as if you can only equate belief in god with being in an altered state.
    If you have a lot of money, you can buy distractions - cars, for instance, or houses. Or women. Whatever.

    But you are just distracting yourself. You have the money to do it. Great. But even then, you are fooling yourself if you think this is some kind of permanent solution or an effective remedy.
    Thats all based on the assumption that other people feel an emptiness that religious people felt before joining their respective religion.
    I see the emptiness of the people around me. I see them doing what I do when I stray from my walk with God. They seek to lose themselves in whatever distractions they can find.
    Sounds like you're projecting what you want to see.
    But only in my walk with God have I experienced true joy - an up-welling in my soul of pure joy. This is not something that comes from myself, but rather it comes from my closeness to God and is a gift from Him. If I walk with God, I experience His joy. When I stray from Him, I feel the pull of materialism and sensuality - the desire to fill myself with whatever I can find. I seek to fill the emptiness some other way, though I know it is futile. Only God satisfies.

    I'm interested in hearing your thoughts on this, for those of you who do not believe in God.
    I feel sorry for you that you only have your religion to give you joy. It sounds like you use your religion as comfort blanket because you can't enjoy life.

    If you can read this, you're too close!



  • Posts: 0 CMod ✭✭✭✭ Luka Dazzling Stockade


    Donatello wrote: »
    I wonder where folks who do not believe in God find rest, peace, joy?

    I think that the most convincing proof that there is a God is the spiritual void that is in each person.

    Donatello you may feel a "spiritual void" but please do not project it onto the rest of us. The "emptiness" of the people around you? You sound like a depressed person who needs help, not preaching.
    Filling an emptiness with whatever you can find - what a worrying post.


  • Moderators, Social & Fun Moderators Posts: 42,362 Mod ✭✭✭✭Beruthiel


    Donatello wrote: »
    Material goods, drugs, sex, alcohol - none of these things are effective remedies against the emptiness that is inside. Yes, they feel good in the moment, but they do not endure. They exhaust themselves, and the soul grows bored.

    Total and utter hogwash.
    If you suffer from 'emptiness inside' then it is because you have yet to know yourself fully.
    There is no emptiness in me, I know who I am.
    I am surrounded by beauty and people I love.

    People who feel the need to lean on an imaginary sky god have yet to gain full confidence and strength in themselves. They live with delusion. Filling their emptiness with a delusion. That couldn't be more empty imo.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 506 ✭✭✭Waking-Dreams


    Donatello wrote: »
    But these things, in themselves, do not satisfy all the aspirations and hopes of the human heart.

    Says you.

    Ask around, lots of people have found meaning in life without the almighty sky fairy.
    Donatello wrote: »
    What I am saying is that we cannot fill our emptiness with the empty pursuit of pleasure, nor can we fulfil ourselves with the pursuit of money, power, academic achievement etc...

    Our emptiness? If you're convinced everyone is miserable inside without god how do you explain the people who are miserable and believe in god? Religious people are not free from the same woes you like to point out in humankind. Many of them are miserable because of their faith - they feel unworthy, that they are sinners, unclean and should be punished.

    Pass!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 34,734 ✭✭✭✭Penn


    Masturbation. Because I know God isn't watching me.


  • Moderators, Category Moderators, Arts Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 50,894 CMod ✭✭✭✭magicbastarder


    Donatello wrote: »
    God
    Material goods
    drugs
    sex
    alcohol
    money
    cars
    houses
    women
    this is a list of things from your first post which you list as candidates which can/cannot bring us inner peace.

    you seem to be lacking a lot of things in your life. maybe god is filling that hole.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,438 ✭✭✭TwoShedsJackson


    Donatello wrote: »
    I think that the most convincing proof that there is a God is the spiritual void that is in each person.

    So the most convincing proof that God exists is something which can in no way be examined or quantified, and is entirely subjective depending on the observers beliefs and/or morals?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,517 ✭✭✭axer


    Donatello wrote: »
    I wonder where folks who do not believe in God find rest, peace, joy?
    Bed


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,762 ✭✭✭smokingman


    Thank you Donatello. You've explained as clear as day the crux of religious belief - depression and self loathing.

    Tell us more of this "emptiness" you feel?
    Why does it exist in the first place?
    Do you consider yourself not "worthy" to be alive?
    Do you feel daily guilt about everything you do?
    Why does your family not fulfill you?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,208 ✭✭✭fatmammycat


    I feel sorry for somebody whose life is so empty that they need to believe in a made up entity to achieve peace of mind. I really do.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,780 ✭✭✭liamw


    There's joy in nature - in the peace of a forest in late Summer, and in the majesty of galaxies

    Indeed there is. Here's a 'materialist' for you Donatello...



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,517 ✭✭✭axer


    Donatello wrote: »
    If you have a lot of money, you can buy distractions - cars, for instance, or houses. Or women. Whatever.
    What about the vatican then? They are supposed to have a god but yet seem to have a need for wealth, expensive art, accomodation etc. Is god not enough for them?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,649 ✭✭✭b318isp


    To be fair to the OP, many people do get answers to their own questions of self-worth, death and aspects of ethics from God or religions.

    As I have aged, I have seen less sense in and evidence of a God, even though I had relatively high immersion in RCism for a long time. A sense of fulfilment has come from aligning my reasoning with how I view the world around me - I feel less contradictions now.

    I'm comfortable enough with not knowing how or why the universe and everything in it is here. I admit, it was a little hard and saddening getting to get to the point where I realised that everything I grew up with was false, but so be it. I'd also add that this has given me a sense of modesty - I'm not here because of God, God doesn't look at me specifically, I'm no better or worse than the next person (and as much a fluke as they are) and I realise that I have more in common with people of other cultures/creeds/race than I have differences.

    As for fulfilment, I now can focus on getting on with life. If I can turn around and say "that was a great weekend", then I know I have done well. I seem to take pleasure in simple things - laughter, a cloud, a good conversation, getting a compliment, going for a walk, getting a job done well, a sense of wonder.

    I agree that there is little fulfilment in material things. It's what we do and how we do it that counts.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,327 ✭✭✭AhSureTisGrand


    You only think everyone has a God-shaped hole in their hearts because you believe in God


  • Posts: 0 CMod ✭✭✭✭ Luka Dazzling Stockade


    You only think everyone has a God-shaped hole in their hearts because you believe in God

    I have a coffee handle shaped space in my hand, clearly I was born to drink coffee :cool:


  • Moderators, Social & Fun Moderators Posts: 42,362 Mod ✭✭✭✭Beruthiel


    b318isp wrote: »
    I agree that there is little fulfilment in material things.

    Oh I donno. A great film on a home cinema surround sound system turned up loud is pretty awesome!


  • Posts: 0 CMod ✭✭✭✭ Luka Dazzling Stockade


    Beruthiel wrote: »
    Oh I donno. A great film on a home cinema surround sound system turned up loud is pretty awesome!

    Or driving with the top down :o:D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,327 ✭✭✭AhSureTisGrand


    b318isp wrote: »
    I agree that there is little fulfilment in material things. It's what we do and how we do it that counts.

    Isn't everything material though, ultimately?


  • Advertisement
  • Moderators, Arts Moderators Posts: 10,520 Mod ✭✭✭✭5uspect


    You only think everyone has a God-shaped hole in their hearts because you believe in God

    Is that you, Derren?


  • Moderators, Music Moderators Posts: 25,872 Mod ✭✭✭✭Doctor DooM


    Isn't everything material though, ultimately?

    What about finding joy in music?

    I mean there's nothing there, other than fleeting soundwaves.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,327 ✭✭✭AhSureTisGrand


    5uspect wrote: »
    Is that you, Derren?

    You were watching Channel 4 as well last night :L


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,327 ✭✭✭AhSureTisGrand


    What about finding joy in music?

    I mean there's nothing there, other than fleeting soundwaves.

    And the brain is stimulated and releases endorphins which make us feel happy


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,517 ✭✭✭axer


    What about finding joy in music?

    I mean there's nothing there, other than fleeting soundwaves.
    They have actually seen the effect of music on the brain via MRI so it is proven to give joy to some people.


  • Advertisement
  • Moderators, Arts Moderators Posts: 10,520 Mod ✭✭✭✭5uspect


    You were watching Channel 4 as well last night :L

    Yes, depressing stuff.


  • Moderators, Music Moderators Posts: 25,872 Mod ✭✭✭✭Doctor DooM


    And the brain is stimulated and releases endorphins which make us feel happy

    Of course the reaction is totally material (as it is for those who get joy out of thinking about the big G too. )

    But the stimulus which causes it exists as a bitstream on a disc, not as the music which caused the reaction.

    Of course I could be looking at this the wrong way because the disc does have to exist :D
    axer wrote: »
    They have actually seen the effect of music on the brain via MRI so it is proven to give joy to some people.

    again missing my point- the music which causes the reaction doesn't actually exist. Im not debating whether it generates joy, was just wondering if you could argue it's something immaterial which creates joy.


  • Moderators, Category Moderators, Arts Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 50,894 CMod ✭✭✭✭magicbastarder


    axer wrote: »
    What about the vatican then? They are supposed to have a god but yet seem to have a need for wealth, expensive art, accomodation etc. Is god not enough for them?
    to be fair to the OP, (s)he never specifically mentioned catholocism, so it's not really a point against it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,649 ✭✭✭b318isp


    Beruthiel wrote: »
    Oh I donno. A great film on a home cinema surround sound system turned up loud is pretty awesome!

    Ah, but you're getting value from the film and the sound! The HT is not much use without those! It's the end, not the means, that is important. :p

    BTW, Pink Floyd's Pulse gave my HT a real workout on Sunday.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,649 ✭✭✭b318isp


    Isn't everything material though, ultimately?

    Of course, but the OP, I think, is pointing out the fallacy of those who focus on material goods for the sake of the goods themselves. Their motivation is the possession, not the use.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 26,928 ✭✭✭✭rainbow kirby


    Where do I find rest? My bed. Duh.


  • Posts: 0 CMod ✭✭✭✭ Luka Dazzling Stockade


    b318isp wrote: »
    Of course, but the OP, I think, is pointing out the fallacy of those who focus on material goods for the sake of the goods themselves. Their motivation is the possession, not the use.

    OP might do well to look in the buddhism forum then :pac::pac:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,650 ✭✭✭sensibleken


    The only way i can fill my inner void* is with delicious delicous baby

    *teeheehee


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,517 ✭✭✭axer


    again missing my point- the music which causes the reaction doesn't actually exist. Im not debating whether it generates joy, was just wondering if you could argue it's something immaterial which creates joy.
    and I was backing up you assertion that music can cause joy - not debating it.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7 bazman05


    Donatello wrote: »
    I wonder where folks who do not believe in God find rest, peace, joy?

    I think that the most convincing proof that there is a God is the spiritual void that is in each person. Material goods, drugs, sex, alcohol - none of these things are effective remedies against the emptiness that is inside. Yes, they feel good in the moment, but they do not endure. They exhaust themselves, and the soul grows bored.

    If you have a lot of money, you can buy distractions - cars, for instance, or houses. Or women. Whatever.

    But you are just distracting yourself. You have the money to do it. Great. But even then, you are fooling yourself if you think this is some kind of permanent solution or an effective remedy.

    I see the emptiness of the people around me. I see them doing what I do when I stray from my walk with God. They seek to lose themselves in whatever distractions they can find.

    But only in my walk with God have I experienced true joy - an up-welling in my soul of pure joy. This is not something that comes from myself, but rather it comes from my closeness to God and is a gift from Him. If I walk with God, I experience His joy. When I stray from Him, I feel the pull of materialism and sensuality - the desire to fill myself with whatever I can find. I seek to fill the emptiness some other way, though I know it is futile. Only God satisfies.

    I'm interested in hearing your thoughts on this, for those of you who do not believe in God.

    “O Lord, you have made us for yourself, and our hearts are restless until they find their rest in you.”
    - St. Augustine of Hippo

    Why should you care what we think? Just because you need to believe in fantasy (it's a nice thing to believe to cope with reality better, but so is the idea of having super powers), doesn't mean you have to either take digs at Atheist's and Agnostics or just spark a heated debate where theirs no winner.

    Religions are man made constructions and with every version of it comes a different interpretation of the after-life, so how do you know your version is the right one?

    When you die, you're dead, you're worm food. I couldn't care less. That's my reality and I don't need fantasy to hide from that fact.


  • Advertisement
Advertisement