Boards.ie uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more x
Post Reply  
 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
21-05-2019, 09:15   #1
grahambo
Subscriber
 
grahambo's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 2,171
Fine Gael TD sues Dublin Hotel after falling off swing

You actually couldn't make this sh*t up!

Fine Gael TD Maria Bailey has sued the Dean after falling off Sophies swing.

She's looking for €60,000.

When the Politicians are making dodgey insurance claims, you know for sure that the country is absolutely fooked!

If they take away that swing, what the hell are the Dublin Girls of Tinder going to do!?

https://www.herald.ie/news/courts/td...-38131916.html

Quote:
Fine Gael TD Maria Bailey was holding items in both of her hands when she fell out of a swing, a hotel she is suing over the incident claims.
Ms Bailey (43) has sued the Dean Hotel in Dublin for damages of up to €60,000 over injuries she alleges she suffered to her head, back and hip.

The Dun Laoghaire TD says she fell backwards out of an indoor swing while having her photo taken during a night out with friends in 2015.

In circuit court proceedings, she accused the hotel of negligence, saying the swing was "unsupervised" and there were no signs to instruct patrons how to safely use it.

Pain

Ms Bailey claimed she can no longer sit or stand for long periods without experiencing pain or discomfort. She also said she used to run 70km a week before the fall, but has had to reduce this to less than 20km.

The hotel is denying liability, saying that if any injury was suffered, this was due to Ms Bailey's own negligence or contributory negligence.

In defence papers filed with the court, the hotel alleged she failed to use the swing in a proper manner and held items in both hands, restricting her ability to balance and preventing her from holding rope grips properly.

The indorsement of claim filed in court by Ms Bailey's solicitors makes no mention of her holding anything in her hands when she fell.

Details of the case have emerged at a time when there is considerable political focus on personal injury awards and high insurance costs.

Ms Bailey's case was briefly mentioned before the County Registrar at Dublin Circuit Civil Court yesterday.

Grainne Berkery BL, for Holtend Limited, trading as the Dean Hotel, told the registrar that on consent Ms Bailey had six weeks to file an affidavit of discovery.

It is understood this is to satisfy a request for medical and dental records for the three years prior to the alleged incident. Discovery is a routine part of such cases.

Ms Bailey was not in court. She is being represented by Madigan Solicitors, a law firm run by a brother of Culture Minister Josepha Madigan. Ms Madigan, a solicitor, stepped away from the firm after becoming a TD.

In her action, lawyers for Ms Bailey, of Woodside Road, Sandyford, Dublin 18, said she was at the trendy Harcourt Street hotel with a group of friends on July 13, 2015. They said that at around 9pm, her party went to the top floor, where there was "a swing unit".

Her solicitors said she was sitting on a swing "unsupervised", having her photo taken by friends, "when she was caused to fall backwards".

She struck the ground, with her hip, lower back and head taking the brunt of the impact, according to the claim.
grahambo is offline  
Advertisement
21-05-2019, 09:17   #2
amcalester
Registered User
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 3,968
€60K is the maximum payout the court can award, it’s not necessarily what she’s asking for.

If her claim is that she fell off a swing then she should **** off. But if the swing fell while she was on it and she was injured that may not be her fault.
amcalester is offline  
21-05-2019, 09:19   #3
FrancieBrady
Registered User
 
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 21,924
No fan of FG, but would it not be correct to wait until the case concludes?
FrancieBrady is offline  
(3) thanks from:
21-05-2019, 09:19   #4
Johnny Dogs
Registered User
 
Johnny Dogs's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2017
Posts: 5,571
Now now OP there's not much evidence that her claim is dodgy (at the moment)


Alan Farrel on the other hand.......

Double facepalm for Alan mind you as he actually took part in a campaign to put an end to spurious claims.
Johnny Dogs is offline  
21-05-2019, 09:19   #5
gmisk
Registered User
 
Join Date: Sep 2012
Posts: 6,317
Quote:
Originally Posted by amcalester View Post
€60K is the maximum payout the court can award, it’s not necessarily what she’s asking for.
It's kind of not really the point...do you think they should have someone supervising adults on the swing?.
It will make her a laughing stock and rightly so, but doubt she will care as she is laughing all the way to the bank
gmisk is offline  
(110) thanks from:
A Tyrant Named Miltiades!, AdamD, Aglomerado, ahnowbrowncow, alchemist33, Andrew76, Augme, banquo, BK92, blackbox, blinding, blingrhino, boardz, bottlebrush, Catmaniac, CB19Kevo, christy c, Church on Tuesday, Conchir, Cyclonius, daithi7, danjo-xx, dark crystal, davycc, Deadlift kid, deadlineday, DebDynamite, Deebles McBeebles, Deja Boo, dermo888, dotsman, Dtp1979, EmptyTree, enfant terrible, Flex, FreshCoffee, fullstop, GarIT, gerrybbadd, GoneHome, grahambo, Greentopia, happyoutscan, holyhead, InstaSte, IrishGrimReaper, jmayo, JMNolan, jmreire, josephsoap, JOSman, Juanito13, JupiterKid, KevRossi, Kivaro, kowloon, Kraft.l, listermint, lunamoon, maebee, marcusgunn, markpb, Matt Barrett, Mickiemcfist, Millypenny, nuac, Odyssey 2005, Oops!, overkill602, PaddyWilliams, PandaPoo, peekachoo, pm1977x, Posy, Potential-Monke, R00ster, rawn, RDM_83 again, RustyNut, saintsaltynuts, SaltSweatSugar, Sarn, Season 2, seligehgit, SexBobomb, Sheep breeder, Skid X, SM01, smurgen, Snow Garden, Stark, steddyeddy, Stoner, SuperS54, take everything, Tangatagamadda Chaddabinga Bonga Bungo, tespor, Teyla Emmagan, Thargor, The Diddakoi, Tom44, Touchee, Ursus Horribilis, VicMackey1, Vowel Movement, W0LFMAN, whiskeyman, WoollyRedHat, yermandan, ygolometsipe
Advertisement
21-05-2019, 09:20   #6
razorblunt
Registered User
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 12,821
She sat on a swing with items in both her hands.
Rule no12 of the playground, always grab on when getting on a swing.
Eejit.
razorblunt is offline  
(176) thanks from:
2smiggy, A Dub in Glasgo, A Tyrant Named Miltiades!, Accumulator, ahnowbrowncow, Aisling(",), An Ri rua, Andrew76, artvanderlay, Ashill5, Aska, Atoms for Peace, Augme, banquo, barneystinson, BattleCorp, beno619, Bigbagofcans, BK92, blinding, blindside88, blue note, bottlebrush, Brendan Filone, cal naughton, Capt'n Midnight, Catmaniac, CB19Kevo, cherryghost, Chinese whospers, clancywigam, Conchir, CrabRevolution, Cyclonius, D.J., danjo-xx, Danzy, DavidLyons_, Deadlift kid, deadlineday, DebDynamite, Deebles McBeebles, Deja Boo, Deub, Dingaan, dotsman, Dtp1979, dublincelt, El Tarangu, EmptyTree, enfant terrible, ExoPolitic, FanadMan, Filmer Paradise, Flex, frash, FreshCoffee, fullstop, fxotoole, GarIT, Gasherbraun, gerrybbadd, gimli2112, gman127, gmisk, golondrinas, GoneHome, grahambo, Greentopia, Greentree_uk, Grid., GTDolanator, happyoutscan, holyhead, housetypeb, how.gareth, ilkhanid, IrishGrimReaper, IrishZeus, Irish_rat, JayZeus, JCX BXC, jmayo, JMNolan, jmreire, josephsoap, JOSman, JP Liz V1, Juanito13, JupiterKid, KevRossi, kingchess, Kivaro, klaaaz, Koloman, kowloon, listermint, Lithium93_, lunamoon, maebee, marcusgunn, markfinn, Matt Barrett, Mickiemcfist, Millypenny, mirrorwall14, Monife, newcavanman, NIMAN, nuac, Odelay, Ohmeha, OldGoat, PaddyBomb, PaddyWilliams, PandaPoo, paulbok, pg633, pgj2015, PMC999, Quackster, R00ster, rawn, Reati, retro:electro, RichTea123, Rikand, rn, robinwing, saintsaltynuts, SaltSweatSugar, Sarn, scotchy, Season 2, SecretsOfEarth, selectamatic, seligehgit, SexBobomb, Shankly Gates, Sheep breeder, sideswipe, SirChenjin, SM01, Smudger80, smurgen, Snow Garden, Some Yoke, somefeen, Sorry about that, Springfields, Stark, Stoner, sullivlo, SuperS54, take everything, Tangatagamadda Chaddabinga Bonga Bungo, tespor, Teyla Emmagan, The Diddakoi, TheDavester, the_syco, Timistry, Ursus Horribilis, Venom, VG31, VicMackey1, Vic_08, Vowel Movement, WarpAsylum, whisky_galore, Wibbs, WoollyRedHat, yermandan, ygolometsipe, youandme13, _Kaiser_
21-05-2019, 09:21   #7
2011
Moderator
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Posts: 8,673
It’s great that our TDs lead by example. If you need money for a deposit for a house / holiday / whatever you’re having yourself just destroy some business with a claim. Is it any wonder we have such high insurance premiums??
2011 is offline  
(161) thanks from:
65535, Accumulator, acequion, ahnowbrowncow, amber69, Andrew76, artvanderlay, Augme, banquo, batman_oh, BattleCorp, biko, BK92, blinding, blingrhino, bottlebrush, BrenMar, buried, cal naughton, Catmaniac, cefh17, Chinese whospers, Church on Tuesday, clancywigam, Comhra, Conchir, Cookie_Monster, CrabRevolution, Cyclonius, D.J., dark crystal, davidfo, DavidLyons_, Deadlift kid, deadlineday, DebDynamite, Deja Boo, dermo888, Dtp1979, dublincelt, EmptyTree, enfant terrible, ExoPolitic, FAILSAFE 00, Fann Linn, Filmer Paradise, frash, FreshCoffee, fullstop, fyfe79, GarIT, GiantPencil, gizabeer, gman127, golondrinas, GoneHome, grahambo, Greentopia, holliehobbie, holyhead, homik, housetypeb, howamidifferent, IrishGrimReaper, Irish_rat, janfebmar, JCX BXC, JMNolan, jmreire, Joekers, josephsoap, josip, JP Liz V1, Juanito13, JupiterKid, KevRossi, kingchess, Kivaro, KKGirlatheart, klaaaz, LillySV, listermint, Littlehorny, maebee, marcusgunn, markfinn, massdebater, Matt Barrett, md23040, mirrorwall14, Monife, my3cents, newcavanman, nuac, Odelay, PaddyBomb, PaddyWilliams, Padkir, PandaPoo, paulbok, PCX, peekachoo, pgj2015, Posy, Potential-Monke, prunudo, Quackster, R00ster, rainbowtrout, rawn, RDM_83 again, Reati, retro:electro, RichTea123, RoryMac, saintsaltynuts, SaltSweatSugar, Samuel Vimes, Sandz_066, Sarn, scotchy, SeanW, Season 2, seligehgit, SexBobomb, Shankly Gates, Sharknose, Sheep breeder, SirChenjin, SM01, smurgen, Snow Garden, Springfields, spurshero, Squatter, Stark, steddyeddy, Stoner, Suckler, SuperS54, SusieBlue, Tacadh, take everything, Tangatagamadda Chaddabinga Bonga Bungo, tespor, Teyla Emmagan, The Diddakoi, TheDavester, Timistry, Touchee, Ursus Horribilis, VG31, VicMackey1, Vic_08, votecounts, Vowel Movement, wetlandsboy, Wibbs, WoollyRedHat, yermandan, ygolometsipe
21-05-2019, 09:22   #8
amcalester
Registered User
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 3,968
Quote:
Originally Posted by gmisk View Post
It's kind of not really the point...do you think they should have someone supervising adults on the swing?.
It will make her a laughing stock and rightly so, but doubt she will care as she is laughing all the way to the bank
I hit submit to quick and added and edit.

If she fell of the swing of her own accord then she deserves nothing but ridicule.
amcalester is offline  
21-05-2019, 09:22   #9
Faith+1
Registered User
 
Faith+1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 3,568
Shes a TD who doesn't understand the complexities of a swing.......makes sense.
Faith+1 is offline  
(111) thanks from:
ahnowbrowncow, Aisling(",), amber69, An Ri rua, Andrew76, artvanderlay, Atoms for Peace, Augme, banquo, BattleCorp, BK92, blackbox, blinding, blingrhino, Catmaniac, CB19Kevo, Comhra, Conchir, Cyclonius, dark crystal, davycc, DeBurca, Deise Vu, Deja Boo, Deub, dotsman, Dr Turk Turkelton, Dtp1979, Eathrin, EmptyTree, FAILSAFE 00, Flex, Fol20, FreshCoffee, fullstop, GarIT, gerrybbadd, Glico Man, golondrinas, GoneHome, Greentopia, GTDolanator, holyhead, howamidifferent, ilkhanid, IrishGrimReaper, IrishZeus, Irish_rat, jmayo, jmreire, josephsoap, JOSman, JP Liz V1, Juanito13, KevRossi, kingchess, Kivaro, KKV, klaaaz, kona, kowloon, listermint, Lu Tze, maebee, marcusgunn, massdebater, Matt Barrett, md23040, Meeoow, Mickiemcfist, Millypenny, mirrorwall14, my3cents, na1, nuac, Odelay, Ohmeha, PaddyWilliams, peekachoo, Posy, Potential-Monke, R00ster, saintsaltynuts, SexBobomb, Sharknose, Sheep breeder, SM01, smurgen, Springfields, Squatter, stampydmonkey, Strumms, Suckler, SuperS54, tacofries, take everything, Tangatagamadda Chaddabinga Bonga Bungo, Thargor, Tiercel Dave, Titzon Toast, Touchee, twowheelsonly, Ursus Horribilis, Venom, Vic_08, Vowel Movement, weldoninhio, Wibbs, WoollyRedHat, yermandan, ygolometsipe
Advertisement
21-05-2019, 09:23   #10
Johnny Dogs
Registered User
 
Johnny Dogs's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2017
Posts: 5,571
Actually just seen this bit.


Quote:
In circuit court proceedings, she accused the hotel of negligence, saying the swing was "unsupervised" and there were no signs to instruct patrons how to safely use it.
She needs signs to instruct her how to use a swing.

This is a person elected to legislate.

Johnny Dogs is offline  
(258) thanks from:
2smiggy, 65535, A Dub in Glasgo, A Tyrant Named Miltiades!, Accumulator, Aglomerado, ahnowbrowncow, alchemist33, amber69, An Ri rua, Andrew76, AngryHippie, Ardent, artvanderlay, Atoms for Peace, Augme, AuldDaysul, Ave Sodalis, banquo, BattleCorp, Beechwoodspark, beno619, BigAl81, biko, Billgirlylegs, Birneybau, BK92, blackbox, blinding, blingrhino, boardz, Bobby Baccala, bottlebrush, Bradt Pitt, Brendan Filone, cal naughton, Capt'n Midnight, Catmaniac, CB19Kevo, charlietheminxx, cherryghost, Chinese whospers, ciaran76, Claireabella, Comhra, Conall Cernach, Conchir, Cookie_Monster, Cornelius Crow, CrabRevolution, Crosby Brave Bartender, Cyclonius, D.J., DaDumTish, dark crystal, Darth Melkor, davehey79, Dave_The_Sheep, davycc, Deadlift kid, deadlineday, DebDynamite, DeBurca, Deebles McBeebles, dee_mc, Deja Boo, Deub, dmakc, Doc07, dotsman, Dr Turk Turkelton, Dub Ste, dublincelt, dublinman1990, dubstarr, earthwormjack, Eathrin, EmptyTree, endacl, enfant terrible, extra gravy, FAILSAFE 00, Faith+1, Fann Linn, FishOnABike, Flex, frash, FreshCoffee, fullstop, GarIT, Gasherbraun, gauralordon, GBX, gerrybbadd, gizabeer, Glico Man, gman127, gman2k, golondrinas, GoneHome, grahambo, Greentopia, Grid., Gyan84, Head_Hunter, holliehobbie, holyhead, homik, housetypeb, how.gareth, howamidifferent, Immortal Starlight, IrishGrimReaper, IrishZeus, Irish_rat, J Madone, Jack Five, jackofalltrades, Jamiekelly, JayZeus, JCX BXC, JDxtra, Jimmy Bottlehead, JMNolan, jmreire, joeysoap, jos28, josephsoap, josip, JP Liz V1, Juanito13, Keisha07, KevRossi, kingchess, Kivaro, KKV, klaaaz, Koloman, kona, kowloon, KSU, LasersGoPewPew, lawred2, Lia_lia, LisaLee, listermint, Lithium93_, M5, maebee, marcusgunn, markpb, massdebater, Matt Barrett, md23040, MICKEYG, Millypenny, mirrorwall14, Misguided1, Monife, mountai, Mr E, mrslancaster, my3cents, na1, newcavanman, ngunners, nuac, o1s1n, Odelay, Omackeral, Oops!, overkill602, PaddyBomb, PaddyWilliams, Padkir, PandaPoo, PCX, peekachoo, pgj2015, pm1977x, PMC999, Pops_20, Posy, Potential-Monke, PrettyBoy, Purgative, Pythagorean, quickbeam, R00ster, Ragnar Lothbrok, rainbowtrout, rawn, Reati, RhubarbCrumble, RichTea123, RoryMac, Rothko, runawaybishop, saintsaltynuts, SaltSweatSugar, Sandz_066, Sarn, scotchy, Season 2, SecretsOfEarth, selectamatic, seligehgit, SexBobomb, Shankly Gates, Sharknose, Sheep breeder, SirChenjin, SM01, SmallTeapot, smurgen, Some Yoke, somefeen, Stark, stratowide, Strumms, stunner dunner, Suckler, sullivlo, SuperS54, SusieBlue, swine, Tacadh, Tacitus Kilgore, take everything, tampopo, Tangatagamadda Chaddabinga Bonga Bungo, tespor, Thargor, The Diddakoi, The Tetrarch, TheDavester, Three More Big Sleeps, Tiercel Dave, TiGeR KiNgS, Timistry, Titzon Toast, tnegun, Tow, Uriel., Ursus Horribilis, Vegeta, VG31, Vowel Movement, wench, whiskeyman, Wibbs, Wiggles88, Willfarman, WoollyRedHat, Yeah_Right, yermandan, ygolometsipe, yourdeadwright
21-05-2019, 09:23   #11
Idbatterim
Registered User
 
Idbatterim's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 12,459
What a moron. I’ve seen people absolutely pissed use it with no issue!
Idbatterim is offline  
21-05-2019, 09:25   #14
TCM
Registered User
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 621
Adult was not "supervised" on a swing. Hard to believe it.
TCM is offline  
21-05-2019, 09:26   #15
Bambi
Registered User
 
Bambi's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Posts: 18,064
Can they install a noose for the next time she visits?
Bambi is offline  
Post Reply

Quick Reply
Message:
Remove Text Formatting
Bold
Italic
Underline

Insert Image
Wrap [QUOTE] tags around selected text
 
Decrease Size
Increase Size
Please sign up or log in to join the discussion

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search



Share Tweet