RTE Radio 1: Late Debate

Rubik. · 27-01-2011 2:38pm #1

The best thing that happened to Newstalk's Breakfast Show was Claire Byrne leaving it. Why would anyone in Montrose think that it would be a good idea to get her to present a current affairs programme? Its not a programme a lot of people listen to, but still, there are any number of more suitable presenters knocking around RTE.

http://blog.marketing.ie/?p=4652

ntlbell · 27-01-2011 2:40pm

I really enjoy the late debate, this is really terrible news

What are the people in RTE thinking.

Bits_n_Bobs · 27-01-2011 3:00pm

Can't believe that.

Her questioning style seemed to be ask something that if the interviewee answered in a truthful manner would cause all sorts of headlines.

Which is fine if the question itself could be considered subtle/innocuous enough to gain a straight answer from anyone but a complete idiot. Or even if the question was posed in a fairly gentle/friendly manner the way Finucane seems to be able to do.

When the interviewee did the obvious thing and not answer the damn question she would just repeat the question in an increasingly hectoring tone achieving nothing except to make the interviewee more and more defensive.

I assume she tries for something similar to Paxmans style of interviewing, but she has neither the gravitas, intelligence or usually knowledge about the topic she was asking about.

Stupid decision by RTE one way or the other.

Aidric · 27-01-2011 3:01pm

The post above sums up my feelings. A truly facepalm moment.

FlutterinBantam · 27-01-2011 4:23pm

What's happening Cormac O'Hara?

telekon · 27-01-2011 4:48pm

This is a shocking shocking decision. :mad:

She's got a face for television. Lets leave it that way. She's perfect for the fluff tv with that moron Daithi O'Shea.

Couldnt stand her on the breakfast show and now newstalk is my station of choice in the morning since she left. Little analysis, depth or grace to her interviewing technique. Shocking.

Will not be listening while she hosts it. What was wrong with Cormac??? Not "glam" enough for Montrose I suppose...:rolleyes:

mikom · 27-01-2011 4:55pm

You'll take what you're given from RTE.
What a bunch of chancers.

Sergeant · 27-01-2011 5:14pm

Your man Cormac did a good job anytime I listened to the show. Byrne on RTE, Coleman on Newstalk, not exactly a treasure trove of late evening current affairs.

JonathanAnon · 27-01-2011 5:17pm

telekon wrote: »

This is a shocking shocking decision. :mad: She's got a face for television. Lets leave it that way. She's perfect for the fluff tv with that moron Daithi O'Shea.

I agree with my oul pal Telekon.. Cant understand how they have given her this if they have listened to her on the radio show.. I hope Rachael's not ill again is she? She's an excellent presenter..

Our man in Havana · 27-01-2011 5:18pm

Will they be feeding her the questions via an earpiece?

JonathanAnon · 27-01-2011 5:19pm

Sergeant wrote: »

Your man Cormac did a good job anytime I listened to the show.

Yeah Cormac is a tough, solid presenter.. Much better than Coleman who coughs and splutters his way through the hour.

craoltoir · 27-01-2011 5:20pm

Cormac will probably continue with Glór Anoir on RTÉ RnaG

dib · 27-01-2011 5:27pm

Our man in Havana wrote: »

Will they be feeding her the questions via an earpiece?

The presenters tend to wear fairly obvious headphones (usually DT100s) so no need for an earpiece. Producers feed presenters possible questions and suggestions by talkback and text all the time.

Cormac O Hara is a very competent presenter and I think it's a shame that he's being replaced.

Itssoeasy · 27-01-2011 6:28pm

Ah no not Claire byrne. Did rte not listen to one bit of her newstalk "career" ? I agree with everything most people have said. I caught the show she does with your man from Kerry and good god almighty, you could have replastered the gable end of a house with the makeup she had on.

*unsubscribes to the late debate podcast*

Badabing · 27-01-2011 6:38pm

It's only during the election campaign that she's on, i presume Cormac will be doing work on RnaG.

Dirigent · 27-01-2011 6:49pm

dib wrote: »

Cormac O Hara is a very competent presenter and I think it's a shame that he's being replaced.

I agree. Maybe that and the fact that he doesn't allow guests (particularly ministers) to waffle on and on made him unpopular with those in charge.

Red Alert · 03-02-2011 11:14pm

She's a complete disaster, the show is noticeably of poorer quality since she took over. No gravitas, very poor presenting style, annoying voice.

constitutionus · 04-02-2011 11:02am

ah jaysus i was hoping this was just a rumour.

i dont listen to the late debate that often, mainly as i keep forgetting its on.

i tend to switch over to it when coleman on newstalk gets up himself on a subject and always found it a more stable show.

byrne is just a disaster on radio, the newstalk breakfast show is actually FUN now and while chris is still getting into his stride as a presenter its obvious he and ivan get on. something byrne has never been able to impart with whom ever she's partnered with.

i hope this really is just for the election period as she hasnt got the temperment or charisma to do this full time.

telekon · 04-02-2011 11:11am

constitutionus wrote: »

byrne is just a disaster on radio, the newstalk breakfast show is actually FUN now and while chris is still getting into his stride as a presenter its obvious he and ivan get on. something byrne has never been able to impart with whom ever she's partnered with.

I bet she has to carry a cold spoon around when working with her current tv partner. Sleazebag.

sgb · 04-02-2011 11:14am

She was hopeless on Newstalk,bet Ivan was glad to get shot of her. Seems she wants to be Kay Burley.

Lapin · 04-02-2011 12:35pm

Bring back Rachel English.

yosser hughes · 18-02-2011 2:02pm

Cormac O'Hara was very good at presenting this show. I can't believe this airhead has been given his slot. She's thick and if she's the best RTE have to present this then god help us.
I'm raging because I used to listen to the late debate but it's insulting to me as a listener when the presenter is a dim witted bluffer. She'll probably go along way in RTE now that she's got her foot in the door.

excellence · 18-02-2011 8:54pm

I think I'll stick with TV3 and Vincent Browne.

discodekkers · 18-03-2011 8:33pm

I don't think the opinions here from what I hear coincide with Ms. Byrne's. Sadly it appears RTE are impressed with style not substance. I wish her sights were lower as she will be found out. She's good on TV fluff though. Cormac O'Hara was pretty impressive but the standard of Rachel English is hard to achieve.

Rubik. · 18-03-2011 10:20pm

The election has come and gone, but it looks like Byrne is here to stay.

http://www.rte.ie/radio1/latedebate/

Maybe it's time that a certain agents influence at RTE was questioned. She's obviously not the best person for the job, so why did she get it?

telekon · 19-03-2011 12:26pm

Rubik. wrote: »

The election has come and gone, but it looks like Byrne is here to stay.

http://www.rte.ie/radio1/latedebate/

Maybe it's time that a certain agents influence at RTE was questioned. She's obviously not the best person for the job, so why did she get it?

Ah c'mon, you can't be serious! :mad:

Seriously, what does she have on the senior management in Montrose???

Itssoeasy · 19-03-2011 1:18pm

So it wasn't just for the election then ? Who's cornflakes did cormac o hara piss in to get shafted for Claire byrne ?

@ telekon the pics must be dynamite on someone.

dh0661 · 19-03-2011 9:23pm

Itssoeasy wrote: »

Who's cornflakes did cormac o hara piss in to get shafted for Claire byrne ?

OOORRR - who ate Claire Byrne's cornflakes for breakfast ?, to get her "the gig".

Lapin · 20-03-2011 12:05am

Doubt she'll be eating too many cornflakes over the coming days.

She just had her appendix removed.

Hope she makes a speedy recovery.

constitutionus · 21-03-2011 11:54am

had to laugh that i heard that on newstalks breakfast show of all places , apparetly she's still in contact with ivan.

so she's gonna be permanent on the slot then eh ?

looks like my boycott of it is then as well.

bureau2009 · 21-03-2011 12:09pm

constitutionus wrote: »

had to laugh that i heard that on newstalks breakfast show of all places , apparetly she's still in contact with ivan.

so she's gonna be permanent on the slot then eh ?

looks like my boycott of it is then as well.

+ 1000%

It is UTTERLY UNFATHOMABLE that Claire Byrne has been given this slot over Cormac O'Hara. The programme has gone down already under Ms Byrne's watch.

PS - I heard Donagh Diamond stand in last week and he was fine. What on earth does he do in RTE for the rest of the time - he only occasionally reports for Prime Time??????????????

Boulevardier · 11-05-2011 11:52am

RTE Radio 1's Late debate (normally Tues-Thurs 10-11pm) has been off air for weeks, even though political life is proceeding normally.

Does anyone know what is going on?

yosser hughes · 11-05-2011 11:56am

Not sure.I thought it should have been on last night as well.I have to say I was not impressed when they appointed Claire Byrne as a presenter. She is a complete lightweight. However she has hit the jackpot now having got in to RTE which seems to be the ambition of anyone in the media these days.
There are some talented people out there yet people with high profiles seem to get the jobs. Claire is more suited to day time TV,NOT the Late Debate.
In answer to the question maybe it's just RTE holidays,they do take a lot of time off.

bureau2009 · 11-05-2011 12:20pm

yosser hughes wrote: »

I thought it should have been on last night as well.

I have to say I was not impressed when they appointed Claire Byrne as a presenter.

She is a complete lightweight.

However she has hit the jackpot now having got in to RTE which seems to be the ambition of anyone in the media these days.
There are some talented people out there yet people with high profiles seem to get the jobs.

Claire is more suited to day time TV,NOT the Late Debate.

In answer to the question maybe it's just RTE holidays,they do take a lot of time off.

I couldn't agree more. Claire Byrne has greatly diminished the Late Debate slot.

snubbleste · 11-05-2011 1:40pm

They are taking a month off. If you were a regular listener, you'd be aware of this

Boulevardier · 11-05-2011 2:14pm

I am a regular listener. When did they tell us listeners this, and what reason did they give?

snubbleste · 11-05-2011 2:24pm

Boulevardier wrote: »

I am a regular listener. When did they tell us listeners this, and what reason did they give?

On the last show three odd weeks ago, there was an easter break.. it's due back next week

Boulevardier · 11-05-2011 2:32pm

They seem to have given themselves a stunningly generous Easter break. It looks pretty inexcusable to me.

snubbleste · 11-05-2011 2:35pm

Boulevardier wrote: »

They seem to have given themselves a stunningly generous Easter break. It looks pretty inexcusable to me.

Quiet!! Just keep paying your licence.

FlutterinBantam · 11-05-2011 8:22pm

I'm a regular listener and never heard it either.

Clare Byrne is not suited to the job.

Vinnie/Rachel/Cormac O'Hura:D way way better.

constitutionus · 11-05-2011 10:48pm

me three.

though since claires taken over i have missed the odd episode as she does my head in.

now im stuck with that twonk coleman to take up the slack.

Dirigent · 12-05-2011 8:58am

FlutterinBantam wrote: »

I'm a regular listener and never heard it either.

Clare Byrne is not suited to the job.

Vinnie/Rachel/Cormac O'Hura:D way way better.

Fully agree, he was like a dog with a bone, compared (if I can continue with the k9 theme) to the normal RTE poodles.

rebeve · 15-05-2011 11:22am

Cormac was the man .Got shafted for asking the right questions .

padd b1975 · 15-05-2011 3:43pm

this was great listening back in the day with vincent and more recently rachel and cormac. Sadly now on a downward spiral thanks to parachute clare . Stick to the afternoon fluff with the kerry man and cocaine gerrys young one!

ElfinGrot · 17-05-2011 11:14am

Its back!

Tonight on RTE Radio One from 10pm...with a new presenter. She's Audrey Carville, from Castleblayney in Co Monaghan....former presenter of "Europe Today" on BBC World Service.

She's very good.

Claire who?!

padd b1975 · 17-05-2011 11:40am

thanks for that! Should be worth a listen.

Badabing · 17-05-2011 12:02pm

ElfinGrot wrote: »

Its back!

Tonight on RTE Radio One from 10pm...with a new presenter. She's Audrey Carville, from Castleblayney in Co Monaghan....former presenter of "Europe Today" on BBC World Service.

She's very good.

Claire who?!

She was on with Sam Smyth on Today FM last Sunday.

FlutterinBantam · 17-05-2011 3:14pm

Heard her today on the promo.

Will be tuned in, she sounds like a yoke who won't take prisoners.

Boulevardier · 18-05-2011 10:20am

I heard some but not all of the programme last night. I heard no explanation of the long Easter gap.

That Carville woman was lightweight. Myles Dungan more or less co-hosted.

JonathanAnon · 18-05-2011 6:15pm

Wow, they didnt give Claire Byrne long did they... another baffling decision from RTE to give her the job in the first place.. I mean they knew that Claire Byrne wasnt great at the political stuff.. She's more of a pleasant, pretty face for lightweight television shows like The Daily Show...

telekon · 18-05-2011 6:59pm

JonathanAnon wrote: »

Wow, they didnt give Claire Byrne long did they... another baffling decision from RTE to give her the job in the first place.. I mean they knew that Claire Byrne wasnt great at the political stuff.. She's more of a pleasant, pretty face for lightweight television shows like The Daily Show...

I bet she spends half her time beating Daithi's hand away from her thighs underneath that desk. Whenever, i see her on it, she looks rather uncomfortable. She probably thinks she's too good for this type of fluff.

Sorry Claire, you've struck out at least twice now on the current affairs format (not counting her reading the news). You'll have to put up with Daithi's creepy, lecherous ways a while longer I'm afraid.

Was she not given the gig just for election season? Thought someone said that on here at the time...

RTE Radio 1: Late Debate

Comments