Operation Transformation

mloc123 · 28-01-2021 10:55pm

strandroad wrote: »

Healthy cooking requires some prep, it is what it is... Sure it's easier to eat oven meals or deli food but that path hasn't been working well for him.

But his own dinner which he likes... salmon, sliced potato and asparagus in the oven takes about 20 mins. I am not talking about oven chips and a frozen chicken kiev... there are plenty of simple to prep and cook meals which are nutritional and low in calories

Cazale · 29-01-2021 9:06am

Saw a former leader recently. They had put all the weight they lost on the show back on and probably another 4-5 stone on top of it. Was sad to see as I was really rooting for them at the time and followed their plan. You forget that these leaders are real people with real issues that a show like operation transformation might only help temporarily. I hope they can get back on track with it some day for their own sake.

happyday · 29-01-2021 10:29am

Cazale wrote: »

Saw a former leader recently. They had put all the weight they lost on the show back on and probably another 4-5 stone on top of it. Was sad to see as I was really rooting for them at the time and followed their plan. You forget that these leaders are real people with real issues that a show like operation transformation might only help temporarily. I hope they can get back on track with it some day for their own sake.

That's such a pity. It's very common with all weight loss plans. It's a change you need to make for life not just for a few weeks or months.

world class wreckin’ cru · 29-01-2021 10:34am

mloc123 wrote: »

This is not "simple"... 18 ingredients and easily an hour to make?

Looks very simple! Literally just chopping a few things and adding a few things together. The first time you do it it might take longer but when you've done it once, it would be fine.

That would take me 20 minutes.

However, if I was complaining and had the attitude of your man, it would take me a lot longer as I wouldn't be invested in the process.

wirelessdude01 · 29-01-2021 10:51am

Each year there is someone on the show who you'd consider to be the joker in the pack. Now joker isn't necessarily someone funny, it could also mean as in this case that person who pushes back against the advice or blatantly ignores it.

Naos · 29-01-2021 10:51am

strandroad wrote: »

He's made a dinner there on camera, chicken (or was it salmon), asparagus and potato. Three ingredients, was it roasted or grilled? Not much work either way.
It's just not the heavy fried food he likes (and takes one minute to buy in the deli or throw in the oven).

strandroad wrote: »

Healthy cooking requires some prep, it is what it is... Sure it's easier to eat oven meals or deli food but that path hasn't been working well for him.

That's poor form on your part.

The meal you seen him cook was his own. He said it's one of his favourite meals, he loves it and when he travels, where he goes/stays often does not have good cooking facilities but they. always have an oven.

He can prep that meal in 5 mins, cook it in 5 mins and eat it (in 5 mins apparently).

It's healthy, it's nutritious, it's simple to make and most importantly, he LOVES it. There is a far higher likelihood of him sticking to that type of eating than those meals they are putting out there.

They should be commending him and telling him to eat that every day if he wants (providing portions are weighed). Trying to make him eat vegan or eat a different meal for no reason whatsoever is absurd.

wirelessdude01 · 29-01-2021 10:56am

Naos wrote: »

That's poor form on your part.

The meal you seen him cook was his own. He said it's one of his favourite meals, he loves it and when he travels, where he goes/stays often does not have good cooking facilities but they. always have an oven.

He can prep that meal in 5 mins, cook it in 5 mins and eat it (in 5 mins apparently).

It's healthy, it's nutritious, it's simple to make and most importantly, he LOVES it. There is a far higher likelihood of him sticking to that type of eating than those meals they are putting out there.

They should be commending him and telling him to eat that every day if he wants (providing portions are weighed). Trying to make him eat vegan or eat a different meal for no reason whatsoever is absurd.

They also suggested batch cooking at the weekend. It's the norm in many busy houses to prepare meals in advance at the weekend. He is just full of excuses.

My guess there will be a slot this week or next with Aoife turning up to whatever accommodation he is in showing him how to rustle up something along the lines of the food plan in a few minutes that can be over cooked.

Naos · 29-01-2021 10:58am

mloc123 wrote: »

This is not "simple"... 18 ingredients and easily an hour to make?

world class wreckin’ cru wrote: »

Looks very simple! Literally just chopping a few things and adding a few things together. The first time you do it it might take longer but when you've done it once, it would be fine.

That would take me 20 minutes.

However, if I was complaining and had the attitude of your man, it would take me a lot longer as I wouldn't be invested in the process.

You're missing the point. He is working all day and so eats ****e. Chap comes in tired, think he's going to stand there and prep everything for the 20 mins you state or do you think it's easier for him to stick something healthy (Salmon, asparagus & a single sliced potato) in the oven that he can prep quickly and then sit down for a few minutes.

Princess Calla · 29-01-2021 11:03am

Naos wrote: »

You're missing the point. He is working all day and so eats ****e. Chap comes in tired, think he's going to stand there and prep everything for the 20 mins you state or do you think it's easier for him to stick something healthy (Salmon, asparagus & a single sliced potato) in the oven that he can prep quickly and then sit down for a few minutes.

You have to feel sorry for him.

The only person in the country that works all day and has to cook dinner when he gets home.

He can't live on his favourite dish 7 nights a week.

ednwireland · 29-01-2021 11:23am

Naos wrote: »

You're missing the point. He is working all day and so eats ****e. Chap comes in tired, think he's going to stand there and prep everything for the 20 mins you state or do you think it's easier for him to stick something healthy (Salmon, asparagus & a single sliced potato) in the oven that he can prep quickly and then sit down for a few minutes.

if it takes me more than 20 mins on a week night i aint doing it.
honestly its the nutritionists job to come up with a workable plan for this guy - i was really surprised at their attitude - i dont know but he may come in at 8 9 o clock at night and be out at 6am.
you cant blame him for wanting stuff that works for him otherwise the shows absolutely pointless.

he certainly isn't a great character but i thought they would take into account his lifestyle like that.

but maybe they will do the usual criticize then sort it out instead of doing it right in the first place. make it more of a story arc.

strandroad · 29-01-2021 11:44am

Naos wrote: »

That's poor form on your part.

The meal you seen him cook was his own. He said it's one of his favourite meals, he loves it and when he travels, where he goes/stays often does not have good cooking facilities but they. always have an oven.

He can prep that meal in 5 mins, cook it in 5 mins and eat it (in 5 mins apparently).

It's healthy, it's nutritious, it's simple to make and most importantly, he LOVES it. There is a far higher likelihood of him sticking to that type of eating than those meals they are putting out there.

They should be commending him and telling him to eat that every day if he wants (providing portions are weighed). Trying to make him eat vegan or eat a different meal for no reason whatsoever is absurd.

But if his meals are so great and easy why is he xxx stone overweight and pre-diabetic with sleep apnea? That's the point - he's used to fast (cooked or bought) food, and he gobbles it. They are trying to make him slow down with both, and reduce his intake at the same time because at the end of the day he is there to lose weight. Was his roast meal the same calorie value as the chopped meal, was it mentioned?

world class wreckin’ cru · 29-01-2021 11:49am

Naos wrote: »

That's poor form on your part.

The meal you seen him cook was his own. He said it's one of his favourite meals, he loves it and when he travels, where he goes/stays often does not have good cooking facilities but they. always have an oven.

He can prep that meal in 5 mins, cook it in 5 mins and eat it (in 5 mins apparently).

It's healthy, it's nutritious, it's simple to make and most importantly, he LOVES it. There is a far higher likelihood of him sticking to that type of eating than those meals they are putting out there.

They should be commending him and telling him to eat that every day if he wants (providing portions are weighed). Trying to make him eat vegan or eat a different meal for no reason whatsoever is absurd.

Yes, he loves it so much except he won't heat it in a microwave. :rolleyes:

Naos wrote: »

You're missing the point. He is working all day and so eats ****e. Chap comes in tired, think he's going to stand there and prep everything for the 20 mins you state or do you think it's easier for him to stick something healthy (Salmon, asparagus & a single sliced potato) in the oven that he can prep quickly and then sit down for a few minutes.

Yes I expect an adult who wants so much to change their lifestyle prep and cook some food for 20-30mins. He could even make double or triple the amount for the next 2 days, but he refuses to use a microwave.

His problem is he's pushing back too much and not trying to come up with any workable solutions himself. He's acting like a child.

wirelessdude01 · 29-01-2021 11:56am

world class wreckin’ cru wrote: »

His problem is he's pushing back too much and not trying to come up with any workable solutions himself. He's acting like a child.

This is it in a nutshell. He needs to ask himself again why he put himself forward and agreed to go on the show.

Deeec · 29-01-2021 1:16pm

I agree with him - recipes on OT could be made simpler. I think he does represent alot of Irish men who dont like modern meals. From what I can see he likes plain old fashioned food - and there is nothing wrong with that if it is cooked correctly. He seems to be a meat, potatoes and veg guy - this is healthy if cooked in a healthy way and portion size is controlled. For the plan to be sustainable for the long term Aoife should be giving easy to prepare family friendly meals. Most of the meals on OT my kids wouldnt eat however they absolutely devour a stew with lean meat and plenty of veg. The OT plan needs to be compatible with busy lives.

frozenfrozen · 29-01-2021 1:26pm

This is the same guy who was refusing to cut sugar out of his tea and sprinkled on the breakfast and now he's being revised to sound like he's standing up for people with busy lives...

Sunny Dayz · 29-01-2021 1:41pm

I wonder do the producers take into account the food likes and dislikes of the participants? I had a look at the food plan for a few days and there's stuff there I wouldn't eat - fish, tofu, mushrooms.

The food plan for Paul looks like a huge jump from what he's used to or likes eating. For example he's said he likes salmon - well put salmon on his meal plan once a week and have a different recipe each week.

wirelessdude01 · 29-01-2021 1:53pm

Sunny Dayz wrote: »

I wonder do the producers take into account the food likes and dislikes of the participants? I had a look at the food plan for a few days and there's stuff there I wouldn't eat - fish, tofu, mushrooms.

The food plan for Paul looks like a huge jump from what he's used to or likes eating. For example he's said he likes salmon - well put salmon on his meal plan once a week and have a different recipe each week.

The guy has serious issues coming down the line due to his food and lifestyle. HE needs to change for himself.

Deeec · 29-01-2021 1:56pm

wirelessdude01 wrote: »

The guy has serious issues coming down the line due to his food and lifestyle. HE needs to change for himself.

He knows he has to change and is changing. He doesnt need to be eating tofu and noodles to change though. Healthy food can be traditional food that he actually likes to eat. Thats the point he was trying to make. The plan needs to be sustainable for him.

witchgirl26 · 29-01-2021 2:06pm

strandroad wrote: »

Look up the recipes, they are simple. He seems to be used to oven ready meals, deli hot food and heavier food in general so the transition must be hard. Learning a new way of eating completely.

wirelessdude01 wrote: »

They already are pretty simple. The issue is that he is just a lazy sod. Not sure why he is on the programme as he has a smart answer every week over something. Al3ays knows brpetter than the people who are there to help and guide.

Ah they're not that simple. We've been making the meals for the past couple of weeks now & it does take quite a bit of time. They are nice, don't get me wrong, but they do take a bit of time to cook & get together. Now obviously making something the first time does take a bit longer but still.

joe40 wrote: »

Yeah I agree they should simplify the food especially since there are a lot of people following.
By all means have interesting meals but you could also have traditional lean meat, potatoes and veg meal which would be perfectly healthy. Note the portion sizes though.
Why not include some meals with frozen vegetables as well, if they want to encourage large swathes of the population to follow.

I really think they need to look at that. And also meals that could be batch cooked. We prefer to do that as with both of us working and a young child, it's not the easiest to get a lot of a time in the evening to cook from scratch every night. It would be nice for them to recognise that a bit and include batch cooking recipes so that people could reheat (unlike Paul, I have nothing against microwaves!).

world class wreckin’ cru wrote: »

Looks very simple! Literally just chopping a few things and adding a few things together. The first time you do it it might take longer but when you've done it once, it would be fine.

That would take me 20 minutes.

However, if I was complaining and had the attitude of your man, it would take me a lot longer as I wouldn't be invested in the process.

Having made at least 12 of the meals, the prep on most of them was in the region of 30-40mins. I think some of the problem lies with it being a different dinner every night with no repeats so yes you would get quicker at making something the more you make it (apart from cooking time) but if you're learning a new recipe every night, it's never going to get quicker.

Man Vs ManUre · 29-01-2021 2:17pm

When will we be able to have a meal pill?? I’m sick of having to go to the supermarket, cook and wash up after.

DenMan · 29-01-2021 2:47pm

I’ve just been following up on the recent posts here. One poster said he should be commended on his favourite dish and that he should have it every day of the week, albeit on a reduced portion size. I honestly don’t know what to make of this. The whole point of the show is that his current diet and lack of exercise isn’t working for him and that he needs a whole new approach for his body to get used to. It’s also a great way of introducing the nation to healthier and more sustainable fruit and vegetables that they’ll hopefully incorporate into their daily lives. Having his favourite dish 7 days a week is a win win for him as he’s not giving anything up, in fact he’s been rewarded for his mediocre effort. Paul gives us the impression that he wants us to hold his hand all the way through and if he goes a day without taking sugar he should get a big round of applause. It’s a terrible mindset to have. Ah sure it’s only a bit of craic for 8 weeks and then that’ll be the end of it, that’s the vibe I get off him. He has a wife and family there to help him, surely to god they can prepare his vegetables for him in advance. Oh no he just wants to make things difficult for everybody else. He gets his cup of tea handed to him in the mornings in his favourite mugs, surely he can make his own cup of tea. Who made him his soup I wonder.

In relation to the meals I would recommend (and have said it to OT) that all of the meals are prepared on video first before the show goes live, or at least a week in advance of the next broadcast. Get celebrity cooks from TV or members of the public to create a video of them being prepared and put them up on the website and their social media channels, Instagram being the most popular. That way every meal is up for people to watch first and they know just how long it takes to prepare and the more they do it the quicker their prep time. People could watch the videos on their lunch break a few days in advance, like Paul’s dashboard dining which apparently he’s the only person in the country who does this according to some posters here, when he’s far from not. Paul seemed to take pride in wolfing down his dinner in five minutes or so which is another problem for him as you are supposed to eat your food slowly to give it time to digest. He has to be different and I think he ate it quickly just to spite everyone else. All the other contestants are doing great and I’m looking forward to seeing when they team up and work together in the challenges. Hopefully they’ll talk to Paul’s co-workers next week and they’ll encourage and motivate him like the other leaders, who have a support network there, especially Susuana. However he has to want to do it for himself first.

wirelessdude01 · 29-01-2021 3:01pm

DenMan wrote: »

I’ve just been following up on the recent posts here. One poster said he should be commended on his favourite dish and that he should have it every day of the week, albeit on a reduced portion size. I honestly don’t know what to make of this. The whole point of the show is that his current diet and lack of exercise isn’t working for him and that he needs a whole new approach for his body to get used to. It’s also a great way of introducing the nation to healthier and more sustainable fruit and vegetables that they’ll hopefully incorporate into their daily lives. Having his favourite dish 7 days a week is a win win for him as he’s not giving anything up, in fact he’s been rewarded for his mediocre effort. Paul gives us the impression that he wants us to hold his hand all the way through and if he goes a day without taking sugar he should get a big round of applause. It’s a terrible mindset to have. Ah sure it’s only a bit of craic for 8 weeks and then that’ll be the end of it, that’s the vibe I get off him. He has a wife and family there to help him, surely to god they can prepare his vegetables for him in advance. Oh no he just wants to make things difficult for everybody else. He gets his cup of tea handed to him in the mornings in his favourite mugs, surely he can make his own cup of tea. Who made him his soup I wonder.

In relation to the meals I would recommend (and have said it to OT) that all of the meals are prepared on video first before the show goes live, or at least a week in advance of the next broadcast. Get celebrity cooks from TV or members of the public to create a video of them being prepared and put them up on the website and their social media channels, Instagram being the most popular. That way every meal is up for people to watch first and they know just how long it takes to prepare and the more they do it the quicker their prep time. People could watch the videos on their lunch break a few days in advance, like Paul’s dashboard dining which apparently he’s the only person in the country who does this according to some posters here, when he’s far from not. Paul seemed to take pride in wolfing down his dinner in five minutes or so which is another problem for him as you are supposed to eat your food slowly to give it time to digest. He has to be different and I think he ate it quickly just to spite everyone else. All the other contestants are doing great and I’m looking forward to seeing when they team up and work together in the challenges. Hopefully they’ll talk to Paul’s co-workers next week and they’ll encourage and motivate him like the other leaders, who have a support network there, especially Susuana. However he has to want to do it for himself first.

He is just dog lazy.

Also I think that perhaps he thinks he is giving two fingers to the 'establishment' with his attitude. He is just coming across as a little man child..

strandroad · 29-01-2021 3:36pm

Deeec wrote: »

Most of the meals on OT my kids wouldnt eat however they absolutely devour a stew with lean meat and plenty of veg. The OT plan needs to be compatible with busy lives.

If you wrote out how to make you meat and veg stew the way OT writes recipes for complete beginners it would also list many ingredients (they list every single spice and seasoning, and staples like olive oil) and would read like an essay (they literally explain how to chop onions vs how to chop carrots). And it takes its time to cook, would Paul be okay with that?
If you're used to cooking you don't notice the complexity but it's there. Paul would probably consider your stew too complicated to make.

Deeec · 29-01-2021 4:06pm

strandroad wrote: »

If you wrote out how to make you meat and veg stew the way OT writes recipes for complete beginners it would also list many ingredients (they list every single spice and seasoning, and staples like olive oil) and would read like an essay (they literally explain how to chop onions vs how to chop carrots). And it takes its time to cook, would Paul be okay with that?
If you're used to cooking you don't notice the complexity but it's there. Paul would probably consider your stew too complicated to make.

Its quite possible he would find it difficult. What I think he was trying to say (badly) was that he does not like the food. That the overall food plan doesnt suit him. I think he needs the support of his wife and family. While she is doing the exercise and is offering him some support it is not clear from the programme if his wife is also following the food plan. If she was preparing his meals prep wouldnt be an issue for him.

Cazale · 29-01-2021 4:19pm

The show has been going for years and it's no surprise how they approach the food on it. The whole idea is to teach the leaders and those following it how to cook especially new things they never cooked before. The recipes teach nutrition, technique etc. It's not about just liking a particular dish. It's supposed to be a springboard for the leaders to have the cooking skills to continue when the show finishes.

There is no point just getting through the 6 or 8 weeks of the show as easy as possible and ultimately learning nothing from it. To change an unhealthy lifestyle you need to make sacrifices. If leaders are unwilling to try they will never succeed.

frozenfrozen · 29-01-2021 4:44pm

Cazale wrote: »

The show has been going for years and it's no surprise how they approach the food on it. The whole idea is to teach the leaders and those following it how to cook especially new things they never cooked before. The recipes teach nutrition, technique etc. It's not about just liking a particular dish. It's supposed to be a springboard for the leaders to have the cooking skills to continue when the show finishes.

There is no point just getting through the 6 or 8 weeks of the show as easy as possible and ultimately learning nothing from it. To change an unhealthy lifestyle you need to make sacrifices. If leaders are unwilling to try they will never succeed.

spot on. Learn how to cook full meals from scratch and decide after 8 weeks of it if you want to go back to only knowing how to cook fish on tin foil.

happyday · 29-01-2021 8:20pm

witchgirl26 wrote: »

Ah they're not that simple. We've been making the meals for the past couple of weeks now & it does take quite a bit of time. They are nice, don't get me wrong, but they do take a bit of time to cook & get together. Now obviously making something the first time does take a bit longer but still.

I really think they need to look at that. And also meals that could be batch cooked. We prefer to do that as with both of us working and a young child, it's not the easiest to get a lot of a time in the evening to cook from scratch every night. It would be nice for them to recognise that a bit and include batch cooking recipes so that people could reheat (unlike Paul, I have nothing against microwaves!).

Having made at least 12 of the meals, the prep on most of them was in the region of 30-40mins. I think some of the problem lies with it being a different dinner every night with no repeats so yes you would get quicker at making something the more you make it (apart from cooking time) but if you're learning a new recipe every night, it's never going to get quicker.

Also if you follow the meal plan you end up buying lots of ingredients and only using a little of some of them so stuff ends up being unused and wasted. It can be expensive because of that.

wirelessdude01 · 29-01-2021 8:24pm

happyday wrote: »

Also if you follow the meal plan you end up buying lots of ingredients and only using a little of some of them so stuff ends up being unused and wasted. It can be expensive because of that.

Go on, list what would be unused and wasted?

mloc123 · 29-01-2021 8:31pm

I think the show has passed its sell by date? But, I do enjoy hate watching it... I think I am not alone in that.

Niall_76 · 29-01-2021 8:39pm

Paul’s a bit of a pain in the arse but people can get cranky when cutting back on food. Especially if he cut out the sugar. He’s still lost a good bit.

I must’ve missed the stick for another contestant who missed target 2 out of 3 weeks so far. Nothing but sympathy from the expert team.

strandroad · 29-01-2021 9:04pm

Niall_76 wrote: »

I must’ve missed the stick for another contestant who missed target 2 out of 3 weeks so far. Nothing but sympathy from the expert team.

Who, Susuana? Karl was tough on her making her finish her walks when she was huffing and puffing and barely able to. And they made her weigh her food when she resisted, even put the camera over her kitchen scales. The point is she is walking and weighing her food now...

deisemum · 30-01-2021 12:31am

wirelessdude01 wrote: »

My guess there will be a slot this week or next with Aoife turning up to whatever accommodation he is in showing him how to rustle up something along the lines of the food plan in a few minutes that can be over cooked.

This sort of thing happens every year and usually on week 4. It looks so scripted at this stage.

Naos · 30-01-2021 1:16am

wirelessdude01 wrote: »

They also suggested batch cooking at the weekend. It's the norm in many busy houses to prepare meals in advance at the weekend. He is just full of excuses.

My guess there will be a slot this week or next with Aoife turning up to whatever accommodation he is in showing him how to rustle up something along the lines of the food plan in a few minutes that can be over cooked.

So he batch cooks meals and it takes an hour to do. Or he just cooks fresh & simple meals like he is suggesting - chuck it in the oven and forgot about it.

Tell me - what is the difference between the two providing the nutrition & calories are the same?

Princess Calla wrote: »

You have to feel sorry for him.

The only person in the country that works all day and has to cook dinner when he gets home.

He can't live on his favourite dish 7 nights a week.

His favourite dish that is simple, easy to cook, nutrition & the ingredients can be picked up in any shop. What's the issue?

A lot of people on that show would turn their noses up at the thoughts of eating salmon & asparagus, he didn't. Encourage him to eat it.

strandroad wrote: »

But if his meals are so great and easy why is he xxx stone overweight and pre-diabetic with sleep apnea? That's the point - he's used to fast (cooked or bought) food, and he gobbles it. They are trying to make him slow down with both, and reduce his intake at the same time because at the end of the day he is there to lose weight. Was his roast meal the same calorie value as the chopped meal, was it mentioned?

He was pre-diabetic and overweight because he was eating ****e from a garage, drinking tea's with x amount of sugars in them and god knows what else.

He's trying to cut that crap out and in return asked for easy, simple meals he can cook like that salmon dinner, which is a perfecftly reasonable request.

world class wreckin’ cru wrote: »

Yes, he loves it so much except he won't heat it in a microwave. :rolleyes:

Yes I expect an adult who wants so much to change their lifestyle prep and cook some food for 20-30mins. He could even make double or triple the amount for the next 2 days, but he refuses to use a microwave.

His problem is he's pushing back too much and not trying to come up with any workable solutions himself. He's acting like a child.

Why do if he can cook something fresh just as quick? Why does he have to precook the meals? He's already doing that with his lunch on the go, allow the man a fresh dinner in the evening.

A lot of people here are being overly negative and you really need to take a step back and look at what is going on. Taking this guy as an example, he clearly had a bad diet and is making steps towards changing this but it needs to be sustainable steps (there's a reason why they are not parading all past participants each week).

If those steps are cutting from 2-3 sugars a tea down to half a sugar and salmon, asparagus & a potato meals instead of a take-away, then so be it. They run into these problems each and every single show, remember the lady who wanted a few drinks with her mates and was scolded for it when she worked out the calories, cut back a bit of food and four (I think) drink instead of her usual 10 and was subsequently scolded?

Consistency & more importantly sustainability, week after week, month after month, year after year is what is required to turn the ship here.

Cazale · 30-01-2021 8:41am

Naos wrote:

A lot of people here are being overly negative and you really need to take a step back and look at what is going on. Taking this guy as an example, he clearly had a bad diet and is making steps towards changing this but it needs to be sustainable steps (there's a reason why they are not parading all past participants each week).

Naos wrote:

If those steps are cutting from 2-3 sugars a tea down to half a sugar and salmon, asparagus & a potato meals instead of a take-away, then so be it. They run into these problems each and every single show, remember the lady who wanted a few drinks with her mates and was scolded for it when she worked out the calories, cut back a bit of food and four (I think) drink instead of her usual 10 and was subsequently scolded?

If someone wants to slowly change they should do it on their own. Operation Transformation by its nature is an intensive program over a short period. They aren't going to have a week where all the ask participants to do is reduce sugar in their tea.

As I posted previously OT has a well established format so nobody is under any illusion before they sign up. If someone participating doesn't want to do what is asked the show isn't for them. It's akin to going on I'm a Celebrity and being shocked when being handed a kangaroo testicle to chew on.

joe40 · 30-01-2021 9:41am

The Paul guy is coming across as a bit of a pain, especially if complaining about microwaving food (didn't see that episode)
But I do feel meal plans could be simplified. Maybe have a sliding scale of complexity, but keep the meals nutritious and calorie controlled.

People can start easy and move from there. Not just the contestants but viewers also.

Have they ever used frozen veg in the show? (I don't know)

Princess Calla · 30-01-2021 10:04am

Naos wrote: »

So he batch cooks meals and it takes an hour to do. Or he just cooks fresh & simple meals like he is suggesting - chuck it in the oven and forgot about it.

His favourite dish that is simple, easy to cook, nutrition & the ingredients can be picked up in any shop. What's the issue?

A lot of people on that show would turn their noses up at the thoughts of eating salmon & asparagus, he didn't. Encourage him to eat it.

Batch cooking is suggested as it's one afternoon of "pain" for maybe a few weeks of dinners, especially if you make a few different dishes at the same time.

The "issue" with his favourite dish is it's not sustainable. Eating salmon and asparagus 7 days a week would get monotonous extremely fast.

Niall_76 · 30-01-2021 12:02pm

strandroad wrote: »

Who, Susuana? Karl was tough on her making her finish her walks when she was huffing and puffing and barely able to. And they made her weigh her food when she resisted, even put the camera over her kitchen scales. The point is she is walking and weighing her food now...

I wouldn’t say they were tough on her at all. And yes she is doing the right things now but wasn’t the first two weeks. All felt sorry for her the second week. Just very different reactions towards her on the show and on here.

I hope it works out for both of them. Part of me thinks both situations are set ups to show how the plan works when followed.

The sustainability of it that people have mentioned is very interesting. Follow ups for all contestants should be part of it, not just the success stories.

HildaOgdenx · 30-01-2021 1:26pm

Niall_76 wrote: »

I wouldn’t say they were tough on her at all. And yes she is doing the right things now but wasn’t the first two weeks. All felt sorry for her the second week. Just very different reactions towards her on the show and on here.

I hope it works out for both of them. Part of me thinks both situations are set ups to show how the plan works when followed.

The sustainability of it that people have mentioned is very interesting. Follow ups for all contestants should be part of it, not just the success stories.

I have to catch up yet on this week.

I was just thinking that, following up with previous participants would be very interesting. And I suppose, a true measure of the success and sustainability of the programme.

There definitely are some positive stories, like Shane from last year. The garda who was on it, a few years ago, also has featured on ads or something for the programme. His was a success story too.

I would love to see how the couple from Cork, got on, or the paramedic guy from Donegal, (who Karl told a hundred times over 'you're the heaviest participant we ever had') I think he was the previous year.

They were lovely people, and I do hope they had continued success with weight loss, and healthy habits.

mloc123 · 30-01-2021 4:50pm

What always amazes me each year is...they get thousands of applicants. They make them all cry and beg to get on the show etc... And almost every year they end up with a couple of no hopers in the final 5.

It must be intentional?

DenMan · 30-01-2021 4:53pm

mloc123 wrote: »

What always amazes me each year is...they get thousands of applicants. They make them all cry and beg to get on the show etc... And almost every year they end up with a couple of no hopers in the final 5.

It must be intentional?

What do you mean by that? Do you mean it is difficult for them to lose the weight?

freshpopcorn · 30-01-2021 4:57pm

mloc123 wrote: »

What always amazes me each year is...they get thousands of applicants. They make them all cry and beg to get on the show etc... And almost every year they end up with a couple of no hopers in the final 5.

It must be intentional?

It's reality TV.
They don't want boring people who'll just loose wright. They want the drama of that Paul guy at the end of the day.

wirelessdude01 · 30-01-2021 5:15pm

Think we all tend to forget that the show isn't really about helping people, at the end of the day if people are helped in some way it really is a by product of the whole process. The show exists for ad revenue and sponsorship.

They draw us in with personalities and sob stories(which pretty much without fail each participant has every year). There is always the 'joker' the person who tried to either make a laugh out of it or pushes against the process. There is always the one who goes mad exercising, the one the loses the plot(pardon the pun) at some stage and the spoof that is our Eddie has to swoop in and pay a visit for a chat in the woods(like happened last week).#

Never forget it is a reality show.

barney shamrock · 03-02-2021 10:27pm

"This week... you weigh 14 stone 6 pounds... or TWO Kathryn Thomases... "

KrustyUCC · 03-02-2021 10:37pm

Paul moaning and whinging already

The Princess Bride · 03-02-2021 10:41pm

Paul should channel his anger into running or jogging or whatever it takes to lose the kgs.

Arduach · 03-02-2021 10:41pm

He has an awful attitude and comes across a bit low on the IQ.

Sorry if that's harsh but he's a pain.

KrustyUCC · 03-02-2021 10:42pm

Good weight loss but his attitude stinks overall

Arduach · 03-02-2021 10:44pm

Long-term I couldn't see him staying the course. Meeting a few weeks weight loss is the easy part. It's what he'll be like in 12 mts, 5 years time etc.

KrustyUCC · 03-02-2021 10:46pm

Yeah that's true

I think he'll fall back into bad habits as soon as the cameras stop rolling

Always tries to get the last word in too

Arduach · 03-02-2021 10:58pm

KrustyUCC wrote: »

Yeah that's true

I think he'll fall back into bad habits as soon as the cameras stop rolling

Always tries to get the last word in too

So true about the last word. He's like a young lad that never grew up.

Compared to Sharon on now. Does her work, no back chat, humble lady.

Operation Transformation

Comments