Ireland Team Talk/Gossip/Rumour Thread IV

Ceadog · 31-08-2015 08:07PM

connachta wrote: »

Payne can cover 12 too, seeing his physical qualities

Possibly but I'd rather have experienced cover there. He's playing out of position at 13 as it is.

PTH2009 · 31-08-2015 08:08PM

This time 2 months the headlines

Ireland are world champions

Tox56 · 31-08-2015 08:15PM

Hagz wrote: »

I'm on board with bringing 2 loose-heads and 2 scrum-halves. Frees up room elsewhere. The only problem is if one of them goes down on the day of kick-off, which is highly unlikely. Otherwise Ireland is just a stones throw away and you can get another prop/scrum-half over in a matter of hours. It's a risk sure, but I think it's a risk worth taking.

But if you bring in an injury replacement, you cant bring back the player theyre replacing for the rest of the tournament, no? If Murray gets an injury that puts him out of the France game but hed be back for the QF, we'd be in trouble. I suppose they could go in with Madigan as back up 9 and hope Reddan doesnt get an injury, but its still very thin ice

sydthebeat · 31-08-2015 08:19PM

Tox56 wrote: »

But if you bring in an injury replacement, you cant bring back the player theyre replacing for the rest of the tournament, no? If Murray gets an injury that puts him out of the France game but hed be back for the QF, we'd be in trouble. I suppose they could go in with Madigan as back up 9 and hope Reddan doesnt get an injury, but its still very thin ice

jesus, just imagine having reddan starting and madigan at 21 against france

just no!

talk about offering a lamb (reddan) to the slaughter

connachta · 31-08-2015 08:22PM

sydthebeat wrote: »

jesus, just imagine having reddan starting and madigan at 21 against france

just no!

Hell Yes. Reddan injured 11th, 70min of Mad Dog as 9:D

thomond2006 · 31-08-2015 08:30PM

Hagz wrote: »

I'm on board with bringing 2 loose-heads and 2 scrum-halves. Frees up room elsewhere. The only problem is if one of them goes down on the day of kick-off, which is highly unlikely. Otherwise Ireland is just a stones throw away and you can get another prop/scrum-half over in a matter of hours. It's a risk sure, but I think it's a risk worth taking.

You can't bring them over within hours though. There has to be 2 days notice to make them eligible to play. So if one of the 9s gets sick on the morning of the match say then we're bunched!

phog · 31-08-2015 08:32PM

Hagz wrote: »

I'm on board with bringing 2 loose-heads and 2 scrum-halves. Frees up room elsewhere. The only problem is if one of them goes down on the day of kick-off, which is highly unlikely. Otherwise Ireland is just a stones throw away and you can get another prop/scrum-half over in a matter of hours. It's a risk sure, but I think it's a risk worth taking.

They can't train nor play for 48hrs after replacing an injured player.

Hagz · 31-08-2015 08:33PM

thomond2006 wrote: »

You can't bring them over within hours though. There has to be 2 days notice to make them eligible to play. So if one of the 9s gets sick on the morning of the match say then we're bunched!

Did. Not. Know. That.

Gulp

Neil3030 · 31-08-2015 08:36PM

Tox56 wrote: »

But if you bring in an injury replacement, you cant bring back the player theyre replacing for the rest of the tournament, no? If Murray gets an injury that puts him out of the France game but hed be back for the QF, we'd be in trouble. I suppose they could go in with Madigan as back up 9 and hope Reddan doesnt get an injury, but its still very thin ice

Do you then sacrifice another player for a replacement scrummie for the France game? Say, bring Boss or Marmion over for Cave?

padser · 31-08-2015 08:40PM

I'm sorry but I just don't get at all how these selections make sense. It's very very un Joe like assuming it's true.

We will be in the situation where an injury to any one of 6 players (Sexton, Madigan, Redden, Murray, Healy, McGrath) leaves us with one of the following happening (at least for the last 10-15 minutes of a game, as in all those positions Schmidt rarely gets played to play the full 80)

1) Furlong at Loose Head
2) Madigan at scrumhalf
3) ??? At outhalf (Dave Kearney?)

That's just bonkers. Schmidt has amazed me before but this would be unbelievably strange.

The upside to this scenario is that we have

1) Furlong instead of Bend as third choice Tighthead
2) An extra outside back (so that we can have 2 not needed in each match day squad assuming that 4 make the match day squad)

The upsides just seem so small, and the risks so big.

I'll be amazed if true.....

smiley_face · 31-08-2015 08:41PM

Neil3030 wrote: »

Do you then sacrifice another player for a replacement scrummie for the France game? Say, bring Boss or Marmion over for Cave?

This has been said a lot, but I'll repeat, you can only replace a player that has a definite tournament ending injury that the team doctor and the tournament doctor both sign off on.
Can't choose to jettison a player otherwise.

Neil3030 · 31-08-2015 08:43PM

Scrumley in the IT now reporting the 'probable' squad as leaked:

http://www.irishtimes.com/sport/rugby/international/joe-schmidt-to-take-calculated-risks-with-ireland-world-cup-squad-1.2335336

penybont exile · 31-08-2015 08:44PM

So ... With all the hype about Henderson are you going to drop Toner?

smiley_face · 31-08-2015 08:46PM

padser wrote: »

I'm sorry but I just don't get at all how these selections make sense. It's very very un Joe like assuming it's true.

We will be in the situation where an injury to any one of 6 players (Sexton, Madigan, Redden, Murray, Healy, McGrath) leaves us with one of the following happening (at least for the last 10-15 minutes of a game, as in all those positions Schmidt rarely gets played to play the full 80)

1) Furlong at Loose Head
2) Madigan at scrumhalf
3) ??? At outhalf (Dave Kearney?)

That's just bonkers. Schmidt has amazed me before but this would be unbelievably strange.

The upside to this scenario is that we have

1) Furlong instead of Bend as third choice Tighthead
2) An extra outside back (so that we can have 2 not needed in each match day squad assuming that 4 make the match day squad)

The upsides just seem so small, and the risks so big.

I'll be amazed if true.....

We'd need 2 injuries at Loose Head and two injuries between 9 and 10 to have any problems. It's not as risky as you stated.

Neil3030 · 31-08-2015 08:47PM

Irish Times wrote:

Secondrow
Paul O’Connell (Toulon, capt)

kuang1 · 31-08-2015 08:47PM

penybont exile wrote: »

So ... With all the hype about Henderson are you going to drop Toner?

In the big games I think not.
Henderson will be the impact sub he was in the 6N.
He'll probably get 80 minutes vs Romania.

thomond2006 · 31-08-2015 08:52PM

If Madigan is going to be an emergency 9, I hope he plays there in one of the next three matches.

connachta · 31-08-2015 08:53PM

calculated risks it is! I love that squad, except for Moore...

connachta · 31-08-2015 08:53PM

thomond2006 wrote: »

If Madigan is going to be an emergency 9, I hope he plays there in one of the next three matches.

you're right

connachta · 31-08-2015 08:55PM

smiley_face wrote: »

We'd need 2 injuries at Loose Head and two injuries between 9 and 10 to have any problems. It's not as risky as you stated.

Not for the bench. One injury within 48h before K-o, and Madigan is straight send to n°21

Tox56 · 31-08-2015 08:57PM

penybont exile wrote: »

So ... With all the hype about Henderson are you going to drop Toner?

No. He is an excellent impact sub but for this tournament Id be stunned if Toner was dropped for any of the important games

Tompatrick · 31-08-2015 08:57PM

Possible case for Strings to be going tbh if Boss is judged not to be up to it.

connachta · 31-08-2015 08:58PM

Look, If Reddan AND Murray both get just a knock, it's either Madigan, either Marmion and Boss (or even Stringer) for the rest of the tournament, as the injured ones can't come back!! Such an exciting gamble, let's admit this!:eek::pac:

smiley_face · 31-08-2015 09:01PM

connachta wrote: »

Not for the bench. One injury within 48h before K-o, and Madigan is straight send to n°21

Yes, and stays on the bench unless injury number 2 occurs.

connachta · 31-08-2015 09:05PM

smiley_face wrote: »

Yes, and stays on the bench unless injury number 2 occurs.

Agree but it means 80min+80+80 etc, until the injured one comes back or be definitively replaced.

irishbucsfan · 31-08-2015 09:07PM

Trying to get through 80 minutes with the same scrum half is massively hamstringing yourself. Very few teams want to do without that influx of pace and fresh legs.

sydthebeat · 31-08-2015 09:08PM

irishbucsfan wrote: »

Trying to get through 80 minutes with the same scrum half is massively hamstringing yourself. Very few teams want to do without that influx of pace and fresh legs.

and reddan doesnt have the legs to sustain 80mins of his best tempo.

i dont want him starting any of our big games.

connachta · 31-08-2015 09:09PM

Indeed, 80 minutes in a row, several times potentially

+

connachta wrote: »

Look, If Reddan AND Murray both get just a knock, it's either Madigan, either Marmion and Boss (or even Stringer) for the rest of the tournament, as the injured ones can't come back!! Such an exciting gamble, let's admit this!:eek::pac:

It's craziness, I love it, but It's crazy!!!

vienne86 · 31-08-2015 09:10PM

So Furlong is the bolter - well fair play - delighted for the lad.

Buer · 31-08-2015 09:16PM

So, with Trimble now definitely out of the picture, who takes the 11 jersey as it's possibly the only jersey where there's a real debate? After the weekend, I'm leaning towards Dave Kearney slotting back in there and Zebo's ability to cover both wing and full back making him the likely candidate for the 23 jersey.

If Kearney doesn't make the team, I would think he's not in the 23 which I don't really see happening right now.

Neither Earls nor Fitzgerald made nearly a good enough case for the 11 jersey but there's a lot of rugby to be played between now and Italy.

Ireland Team Talk/Gossip/Rumour Thread IV

Comments