Garage Won't Return My Vehicle..;(

gctest50 · 25-11-2014 09:49PM

Drummer1967 wrote: »

..I asked a garage their opinion and they told me

If he takes that engine and gearbox back out that vehicle will never drive again...

what garage would give that opinion ?

Tail Docker · 25-11-2014 09:50PM

Chocolate Lions wrote: »

You're doing your best anyway and that's what matters.

Thank you madam. This thread has got convoluted. I don't even remember who owns/owes what anymore.

tomwaterford · 25-11-2014 09:53PM

gctest50 wrote: »

what garage would give that opinion ?

If he takes the engine and box out...why can theu not be put in again??
Even if certain drivechain have to be replaced...there is no reason why it'll not dive again

gctest50 · 25-11-2014 10:01PM

tomwaterford wrote: »

If he takes the engine and box out...why can theu not be put in again??
Even if certain drivechain have to be replaced...there is no reason why it'll not dive again

for sure

could eeven put in a Formula1 engine

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KnqdIsBJT0A

( since the thread is gone off the reality ski jump and off into the pointless forest anyway)

Gritz · 25-11-2014 10:01PM

stick to what you agreed and make him stick to the same deal, pay up and move on... before he starts adding storage charges to your bill

slimjimmc · 25-11-2014 10:07PM

Credit/Debit card is not legal tender so unless it was agreed you could pay using cards the only form of payment which the garage can insist on or must accept from you is legal tender Euro notes. It sounds to me you are throwing new conditions to the contract.

kingchess · 25-11-2014 10:12PM

Did I read the posts correctly??you spent 2000 euro for 2nd hand engine and gearbox (most people will not give a guarantee for that)for a van that you were willing to sell for 1500,Maybe you would have been better off spending 3500 on a good second hand van?/ Anyway you made the bargain and will have to pay .

K.Flyer · 25-11-2014 10:43PM

A few things come to mind.
Why did you use this "garage's" services when you were not going to trust them to do the work properly in the first place? Because if you did trust them, you would not be looking for second opinions.
How long has the van been ready and waiting for you to pay for it?
What can another independent garage tell you that a skilled mechanic with some tools and a portable analyser that you pay for and bring to look at the van can't tell you?
In the same way as your having doubts about their workmanship, why should he trust you to take the van away and come back promptly with the cash?
I know of many a mechanic that has trusted people to pay later, not to see them again.

corner of hells · 25-11-2014 10:46PM

Kidnap one.of his mechanics , hold him for about three weeks , then break the silence and offer to buy his garage.

Chocolate Lions · 25-11-2014 10:49PM

Tail Docker wrote: »

Thank you madam. This thread has got convoluted. I don't even remember who owns/owes what anymore.

I doubt you'd be confused of your corner in any matter.

Drummer1967 · 25-11-2014 10:56PM

mr_edge_to_you wrote: »

Joooooooeeeee Dufffffyyyyyy

joe duffy is a serious prospect at this stage...i'm a lone parent of two small kids and this garage is holding on to my livelihood since 7th of November...sorry kids Christmas is cancelled because the garageman wants to keep my van

Yawns · 25-11-2014 10:59PM

Drummer1967 wrote: »

sorry kids Christmas is cancelled because the garageman wants to keep my van get paid for agreed work carried out at agreed price

fyp

NewApproach · 25-11-2014 11:01PM

Drummer has to be trolling. Pay the man for the work.

Drummer1967 · 25-11-2014 11:01PM

tomwaterford wrote: »

If he takes the engine and box out...why can theu not be put in again??
Even if certain drivechain have to be replaced...there is no reason why it'll not dive again

The implication is that there will be willful damage done to the engine as a payback by the garage...I dunno!

Drummer1967 · 25-11-2014 11:06PM

NewApproach wrote: »

Drummer has to be trolling. Pay the man for the work.

read the previous posts...I offered to pay the full price, but he wont accept it

Drummer1967 · 25-11-2014 11:10PM

Thanks to all who made helpful comments.

Much Appreciated.:)

tomwaterford · 25-11-2014 11:14PM

Drummer1967 wrote: »

The implication is that there will be willful damage done to the engine as a payback by the garage...I dunno!

I severely doubt that....they would more likely sell on the good engine and box...in an effort to recoup some of the cost as they are now waiting six weeks for payment and after getting you the sale of van which is after falling through in the mean time

Dempsey · 25-11-2014 11:15PM

tomwaterford wrote: »

There no garage anywhere stand over quality of a secondhand engine and gearbox....also in all my time in and out of scrapyards...I've never seen anything approaching a receipt being handed out (not sayin it don't happen)
Pay the garage....unless it's completely obvious altogether how will the other garage know???
It's usually accepted when your buying second hand parts the risks being taken...usually if there is a rapid failure the garage or scrapyard covers the replacement out of good will....which I doubt the op will get much of after this!!

Then why wont he let another mechanic at least inspect the work? Why look to buy the van altogether? Cowboy at work

whupdedo · 25-11-2014 11:17PM

Serves you right for buying a commercial vw, he might have done you a favour and scrapped it :pac:

Drummer1967 · 25-11-2014 11:25PM

whupdedo wrote: »

Serves you right for buying a commercial vw, he might have done you a favour and scrapped it :pac:

Who said it was a commercial..?? It's a caravelle 8 seater and your comment is nonsense.

tomwaterford · 25-11-2014 11:29PM

Dempsey wrote: »

Then why wont he let another mechanic at least inspect the work? Why look to buy the van altogether? Cowboy at work

What is the other mechanic going to see beyond the blindingly obvious??

I know of no mechanic who has xray vision and can physically see inside an engine/ gearbox without ripping...if he has such little time for the mechanic why did he not go to the maindealer to start with...seems the most unusual taught process to go through...Il go cos you cheap...on second thoughts you must be carp...so il get someone else to check up on you.....does the op have any reasonable reasons to doubt the quality of first garages work???
And if so why get them to do in the firstplace???
There apapears to be the issue with the reg number for the donor car...which I've never heard anyone wanting to check out the service history of a scrapped car...let alone expecting anyone to stand over the use of second hand parts

K.Flyer · 25-11-2014 11:30PM

Drummer1967 wrote: »

...
and this garage is holding on to my livelihood since 7th of November..

Drummer1967 wrote: »

The owner threatened to remove the fitted engine and gearbox..That was on October 7th...I still have not got my vehicle back.

Drummer1967 wrote: »

At first I agreed to sell it for scrap for 1500

Drummer1967 wrote: »

,Now he wants to buy the vehicke and has offered me 2,000 but I just want it back...

Drummer1967 wrote: »

....
I asked them to bring it up to vw so they could verify that the engine is what he promised me but he refused...I have offered to pay the full amount once the work is verified,

Why should he bring it anywhere, if you are not sure about things, then you should bring someone to the garage to check out the repairs, do it promptly, pay them and get on with things.

Personally I think there is more to this story that we are hearing.

Drummer1967 · 25-11-2014 11:37PM

perhaps i'm an idiot but I take people at their word when they tell me they are going to do x or y for 2000 euro.
so when suddenly x or y goes missing I get nervous and rightly so.This chap told me the engine I was getting was bullet proof, his words...so why wont he let me have it verified..i know its secondhand..but i'm not paying 2,000 for essentially is a pig in a bag..

NewApproach · 25-11-2014 11:40PM

Drummer1967 wrote: »

I offered to pay the full price, but he wont accept it

Drummer1967 wrote: »

..but i'm not paying 2,000 for essentially is a pig in a bag..

Well which is it?

Was the original agreement expressly conditional on a 3rd party inspection? If not, the 'full price' is €2,000 and you drive it away. If you want to get it checked afterwards, that's your business.

K.Flyer · 25-11-2014 11:43PM

To many inconsistencies...

**unfollow**

Drummer1967 · 25-11-2014 11:47PM

No 3rd party was mentioned at the start I took his word that the engine was from this vehicle....but when he ignored my requests for proof of this so called engine I got suspicious...then I insisted on a 3rd party check.simple as that..as someone pointed out earlier, the trust is long gone here so it's more than likely going to end up in court.

whupdedo · 25-11-2014 11:49PM

Something strikes me as odd, you say you can't take 1500 for the van, but you have 2000 to pay the man with, why not take the 1500 and together with your 2grand you can go and buy something better, your story doesn't add up, pay the man his money and be done with it

Drummer1967 · 25-11-2014 11:49PM

K.Flyer wrote: »

To many inconsistencies...

**unfollow**

Perhaps I didn't explain myself well enough for your satisfaction but hey off you go!

Drummer1967 · 25-11-2014 11:52PM

whupdedo wrote: »

Something strikes me as odd, you say you can't take 1500 for the van, but you have 2000 to pay the man with, why not take the 1500 and together with your 2grand you can go and buy something better, your story doesn't add up, pay the man his money and be done with it

simple answer to that; I don't have 2,000 its going on my visa card!
secondly, it's a wheelchair accessible vehicle and cant be bought cheap....

gctest50 · 26-11-2014 12:21AM

Drummer1967 wrote: »

simple answer to that; I don't have 2,000

at last

Drummer1967 wrote: »

its going on my visa card!

A visa card isn't legal tender afaik - they don't have to accept it

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxQTDRXbe-4

Garage Won't Return My Vehicle..;(

Comments