Irish smokers should defend themselves more

Spanish Eyes · 03-10-2013 06:44PM

ThePieintheSky wrote: »

On the whole campus? You think that's a clever thing to do? What are smokers suppose to do - get a bus to the entrance, stand there, get a bus back - every hour or whatever?

I can see why that would anger people.

Ah.... god be with the days when students were radical. When they would protest at the least thing.

Now? They are part of the establishment.

Doesn't matter that it's smoking, that can be done in a little shelter well away from the dons and prikks of the higher moral ground variety.

They might need to check the bags for the lemonade bottle full of YKWIM though, far more detrimental to ones' demeanour, but probably fires up the academic juices.

Go students! Fight for a Nanny Free State please. You are all we have left.

darkpagandeath · 03-10-2013 06:45PM

Links234 wrote: »

It annoys me that people who smoke think that those of us who don't just "don't like" their habit, or the smell, etc. I've got asthma, second hand smoke can trigger an attack. you have to be severely ignorant to think that your smoking doesn't effect the people around you

so can pollen pet dander a whole host of things you want them band also ? being overweight can be a factor in asthma

dublinbhoy88 · 03-10-2013 06:46PM

ThePieintheSky wrote: »

On the whole campus? You think that's a clever thing to do? What are smokers suppose to do - get a bus to the entrance, stand there, get a bus back - every hour or whatever?

I can see why that would anger people.

they can celebrate this decision by goin into he bar in UCD and wreck their liver and start a fight,people worrying about their health from second hand smoke then go and pollute themselves with alcohol:pac:

SimonLynch · 03-10-2013 06:47PM

I'd imagine it'll be an idealistic thing that won't be enforced, go to Tallaght or Blanch hospitals and observe the 'smoke free' campuses.

Chips Lovell · 03-10-2013 06:47PM

ThePieintheSky wrote: »

I'm getting tired of the nannyism of the state sticking their nose in to what we should and shouldn't eat or drink or inhale etc.

Except it's not the state sticking their nose in. It's the UCD students voting themselves on what rule to implement in their own campus.

I don't mind people smoking outdoors myself, but it's their campus, so fair enough.

Links234 · 03-10-2013 06:50PM

darkpagandeath wrote: »

so can pollen pet dander a whole host of things you want them band also ? being overweight can be a factor in asthma

this isn't a thread about pollen, etc, is it? I get very bad reactions from cigarette smoke, the OP seems to suggest that non smokers 'just don't like' smoking, the context here is obvious.

Jonny Blaze · 03-10-2013 06:50PM

Seachmall wrote: »

At the same time, as a smoker, I think all this tiptoeing around the issue is moronic. Just ban the damn things if they're so much trouble.

They would only for the fact that it's a tidy little earner for them, in or around 6 euro per box!

ThePieintheSky · 03-10-2013 06:51PM

Cody Pomeray wrote: »

I have a right not to have my lung function disturbed or inflamed.

The operative word in my point being "outdoors". Who are you to say someone cannot smoke outdoors?

dark crystal · 03-10-2013 06:51PM

DeVore wrote: »

We pay for your lung transplants and provide the lungs to be transplanted. Meet us half way yeah?

You do?

I wasn't aware only non-smokers paid taxes towards the health care system.

Jonny Blaze · 03-10-2013 06:53PM

DeVore wrote: »

We pay for your lung transplants and provide the lungs to be transplanted. Meet us half way yeah?

Also liver disease, heart disease, stitching split open heads, not to mention cleaning takeout mess and pools of piss and vomit from the streets every saturday and sunday morning..

Oh wait that's booze!

DamagedTrax · 03-10-2013 06:53PM

where do we get these lungs that non-smokers buy us? i never got mine

Greenmachine · 03-10-2013 06:53PM

So glad I am not in UCD. Seriously OTT banning smoking on the entire campus. pfft how long does it take to walk through a doorway.

darkpagandeath · 03-10-2013 06:54PM

Links234 wrote: »

this isn't a thread about pollen, etc, is it? I get very bad reactions from cigarette smoke, the OP seems to suggest that non smokers 'just don't like' smoking, the context here is obvious.

well this is not a thread about asthma either i was just giving other factors that can cause just as bad reaction

Seachmall · 03-10-2013 06:54PM

DeVore wrote: »

We pay for your lung transplants

So do we.

and provide the lungs to be transplanted.

So do we.

ThePieintheSky · 03-10-2013 06:54PM

DeVore wrote: »

We pay for your lung transplants and provide the lungs to be transplanted. Meet us half way yeah?

Tiny minority end up in that situation. I am not a smoker but I can see that smokers are being demeaned and isolated.

It's a large group of the population. And most smokers to my knowledge don't smoke by choice. It's an addiction.

Grab All Association · 03-10-2013 06:56PM

DeVore wrote: »

We pay for your lung transplants and provide the lungs to be transplanted. Meet us half way yeah?

The state made €1.3 billion from tax on tobacco last year. I think we smokers pretty much paid for ourselves.

humanji · 03-10-2013 06:58PM

ThePieintheSky wrote: »

Tiny minority end up in that situation. I am not a smoker but I can see that smokers are being demeaned and isolated.

It's a large group of the population. And most smokers to my knowledge don't smoke by choice. It's an addiction.

And this is incentive to try and break the habit.

On a side not, anyone know if those e-cigarettes are a valid alternative?

darkpagandeath · 03-10-2013 06:59PM

Chris___ wrote: »

The state made €1.3 billion from tax on tobacco last year. I think we smokers pretty much paid for ourselves.

Your not allowed logic here as apparently the whole cost of healthcare is caused via smoking. So smokers don't pay for themselves they cost the state money they will tell you.

Cody Pomeray · 03-10-2013 07:00PM

ThePieintheSky wrote: »

The operative word in my point being "outdoors". Who are you to say someone cannot smoke outdoors?

Contrary to that newspaper report, students haven't made the decision.

The students "preferendum" was technically just asking for students' opinions, since it would likely be impossible to implement a ban without students' co-operation.

The ultimate decision is that of the UCD Governing Authority/ University Management, and they have every right, as per their intention, to implement the ban on the campus, just like any other business can regulate what happens on its grounds, within the law.

DamagedTrax · 03-10-2013 07:00PM

And this is incentive to try and break the habit.

is this an incentive decided upon by all the smokers who have a right to choose if they smoke or not?

On a side not, anyone know if those e-cigarettes are a valid alternative?

they're pretty good as they keep the hands occupied, which is a major obstacle to giving up.

Seachmall · 03-10-2013 07:00PM

humanji wrote: »

On a side not, anyone know if those e-cigarettes are a valid alternative?

I know a few people who've tried them, all went back to the fags.

In theory they're great, but in practice it's too easy to fall back into the old ways.

Although I'm sure they're successful for others.

lahalane · 03-10-2013 07:01PM

humanji wrote: »

On a side not, anyone know if those e-cigarettes are a valid alternative?

Most people I know that bought them are still using them instead of cigarettes. My sister buys different flavours online. There's some crazy ones there. Her one at the moment tastes like a chocolate milkshake. She says you can buy Refresher bar flavours too. :eek:

03-10-2013 07:04PM

dark crystal wrote: »

You do?

I wasn't aware only non-smokers paid taxes towards the health care system.

Both smokers and non-smokers alike pay taxes, and end up contributing towards costs like that. But you must see there's a cause for resentment there from non-smokers.

I have an uncle who got cancer in his throat and lungs, went to hospital, got it removed, got treatment, recovered, and continued to smoke like a chimney. I'd love to end up being an organ donor after death, as I'm aware there's a long waiting list for some people (including sick children) who desperately need a transplant to live. The thought that my organs could go to someone who smokes every day, who will recover, smoke, and end up taking up yet another spot on the waiting list, is really terribly sad to me.

dublinbhoy88 · 03-10-2013 07:04PM

Seachmall wrote: »

I know a few people who've tried them, all went back to the fags.

In theory they're great, but in practice it's too easy to fall back into the old ways.

Although I'm sure they're successful for others.

ive been using them for nearly a year, much prefer them than a real smoke, would love to be able to buy an e-cig with cannabis in it mind ye

MadYaker · 03-10-2013 07:05PM

Its banned on the grounds of the hospital in Galway, but not the university, yet. I rarely have smoke blown in my face when walking around campus so it doesn't really bother me. But I don't have asthma or any alergies or anything so maybe I don't notice it as much as others.

the government will never ban them, it brings in too much cash. I reckon smoking will die out on a its own eventually, its not cool like it used to be.

darkpagandeath · 03-10-2013 07:07PM

true-or-false wrote: »

Both smokers and non-smokers alike pay taxes, and end up contributing towards costs like that. But you must see there's a cause for resentment there from non-smokers.

I have an uncle who got cancer in his throat and lungs, went to hospital, got it removed, got treatment, recovered, and continued to smoke like a chimney. I'd love to end up being an organ donor after death, as I'm aware there's a long waiting list for some people (including sick children) who desperately need a transplant to live. The thought that my organs could go to someone who smokes every day, who will recover, smoke, and end up taking up yet another spot on the waiting list, is really terribly sad to me.

So one persons life is worth more than someone else's ? i thought we were all entitled to medical care when needed. I do agree that he prob should have stopped smoking tbh but it's not Illegal just bad form.

hardCopy · 03-10-2013 07:07PM

ThePieintheSky wrote: »

I must have missed something - how exactly does banning smoking outdoors enhance civil liberties? It's the opposite. Where is the civil liberties in demeaning those that smoke?

You're complaining about a supposed erosion of civil liberties in Ireland yet you compare us to the UAE where they have the liberty to smoke but just have to worry about slavery, child labour, prosecutions of rape victims and restrictive alcohol laws.

ThePieintheSky · 03-10-2013 07:07PM

I also find it hilarious getting the UAE thing thrown at me when I want to bring something like this up at home. The UAE is more liberal and safer than Ireland is in many different ways. I know some won't believe that but I live here and I can say that is 100% the case. It's a grand place. So many misconceptions. Some places you can't smoke but most you can. In pubs and nightclubs (yes they have pubs and nightclubs but not many) you can smoke.

But I don't see why it should matter where another poster is bringing up what is effectively a civil liberties issue at home. Throwing that out is very weak in my opinion anyway.

Seachmall · 03-10-2013 07:07PM

dublinbhoy88 wrote: »

ive been using them for nearly a year, much prefer them than a real smoke, would love to be able to buy an e-cig with cannabis in it mind ye

The refills are liquids, aren't they?

Could try hash oil.

lukesmom · 03-10-2013 07:09PM

As a smoker I'm pretty sick of them trying to ban it everywhere. Feel like I'm back at school again having to sneak a quick fag down the hockey pitch. We're slowly becoming a very anti-social country.

Irish smokers should defend themselves more

Comments