who's the most talented - Gervais or Coogan

fryup · 24-08-2013 08:16PM

OrphansRFunny wrote: »

To be honest, I've never even heard of the The Trip. Good?

very self-indulgent very patchy, i find it tedious most of the time

karma_ · 24-08-2013 08:18PM

fryup wrote: »

very self-indulgent very patchy, i find it tedious most of the time

It's Coogan and Brydons best work tbh.

I'd still rather have Gervais though.

thisonetaken · 24-08-2013 08:19PM

OrphansRFunny wrote: »

The BBC in their wisdom didn't order another series. Shocking decision.

the whole series past me by first time round, only recently discovered it on netflix, for some reason it seems the bbc did little to no promotion for it

BunShopVoyeur. · 24-08-2013 08:21PM

thisonetaken wrote: »

the whole series past me by first time round, only recently discovered it on netflix, for some reason it seems the bbc did little to no promotion for it

I was the same, I started to watch it on Netflix a while back by chance.

I think it's fantastic and they could have easily have gotten another series out of the characters.

Amirani · 24-08-2013 08:21PM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=euhGPrgVZj0

wil · 24-08-2013 08:24PM

Charlee Crashing Rabbit wrote: »

Coogan was doing voice overs and impersonations for Spitting Image years before Partridge. All Gervais has really ever played is himself or Brent.

I'd say Coogan by a nose
Never a huge fan of Gervais, find he is probably a little bitter still about the pop career and quite a sneering attitude to people. Worked fine as Brent but tiresome outside of that. He has some good ideas but I'd say Steven Merchant is as much responsible for the better ones. Idiot Abroad works not because of Gervais idiotic psycho laughter but Karls often brilliantly insightful solid gold view on life. Derek was quite heartless and soulless as comedy because of Gervais portrayal

Here was the first time I even noticed Gervais, playing exactly the same role as now.

And heres the ironically bitter Bowie wannabe

BunShopVoyeur. · 24-08-2013 08:27PM

Love this scene and was great to see him make an appearance in Saxondale.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X1N_jkgv3vw

Billy86 · 24-08-2013 08:28PM

Dylan Moran.

Sure he's basically been playing Bernard Black for 15 years.

Otherwise, Coogan.

philstar · 24-08-2013 08:44PM

RayM wrote: »

Coogan does a brilliant Irish accent. Better than any other British actor.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJNGfUYMJNY

(skip to 1:25)

the way he effortlessly switches between two accents is nothing short of astonishing ...and that was done ad lib

very talented

DainBramage · 24-08-2013 08:45PM

I prefer Coogan. The Alan Partridge stuff is some of the best comedy ever made. He is also a very talented mimic and seems like a down to earth character

While theres no denying the office and Extras were class, its Gervais' persona I don't find appealing.
He seems very disingenuous and sneery ( if that's a word). Some posts are citing Derek as an example of his acting diversity- but whenever I watch him in this role it just seems like he is taking the piss out of simple people like Derek, and not attempting to portray them fairly.

But also to Gervsis' credit he's promoted someone deserving i.e Karl Pilkington .

Roose · 24-08-2013 08:51PM

Coogan has some serious chops.

hmmm · 24-08-2013 08:54PM

I've been watching "The Trip" recently and the ad libbing from Coogan is just so clever. Gervais got lucky with the Office, I've never found his other stuff as good as it was hyped.

wil · 24-08-2013 08:54PM

DainBramage wrote: »

I prefer Coogan. The Alan Partridge stuff is some of the best comedy ever made. He is also a very talented mimic and seems like a down to earth character

While theres no denying the office and Extras were class, its Gervais' persona I don't find appealing.
He seems very disingenuous and sneery ( if that's a word). Some posts are citing Derek as an example of his acting diversity- but whenever I watch him in this role it just seems like he is taking the piss out of simple people like Derek, and not attempting to portray them fairly.

But also to Gervsis' credit he's promoted someone deserving i.e Karl Pilkington .

Agree with you about his Derek portrayal as I said. I feel his use of Karl was quite self serving and intentionally exploitative but the round headed buffoon had the last laugh, a point I am not sure Gervais gets.

BunShopVoyeur. · 24-08-2013 08:54PM

RayM wrote: »

Coogan does a brilliant Irish accent. Better than any other British actor.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJNGfUYMJNY

(skip to 1:25)

He spends his holidays in Ireland every year. He comes here to write.

DainBramage · 24-08-2013 09:01PM

wil wrote: »

Agree with you about his Derek portrayal as I said. I feel his use of Karl was quite self serving and intentionally exploitative but the round headed buffoon had the last laugh, a point I am not sure Gervais gets.

The only parts of idiot abroad I dont like are when merchant and gervais are behind the desk like two smug overlords and insulting him ,its not that funny.
'Idiot' is a misnomer though, Pilkington is definitely a smart guy to get where he's got even if has meant demeaning himself to a fairly large degree.

Mouzone · 24-08-2013 09:01PM

Coogan all the way, even his Curb Your Enthusiasm episode is much better.

caustic 1 · 24-08-2013 10:42PM

Can't stand either of them... not even a smidgen.

timthumbni · 24-08-2013 10:55PM

kraggy wrote: »

Gervais is about as funny as finding out your girlfriend is pregnant.

By your best friend.

On your birthday.

Which happens to be your last birthday because you're terminally ill.

For some reason my mind read this out to me in an Edmund Blackaddder voice. Brilliant.

Eeden · 24-08-2013 11:29PM

caustic 1 wrote: »

Can't stand either of them... not even a smidgen.

Neither can I, but then that's obviously not your (or my) type of humour. Comedy is so subjective. You might need to start a thread about different comedians. I'd go along with that -- as long as Brendan O'Carroll isn't one of them!! :P

Wacker The Attacker · 24-08-2013 11:39PM

I'd rather eat my own scrotum (I wish I could auto fellate) than watch anything involving Ricky Gervais.

Wacker The Attacker · 24-08-2013 11:40PM

timthumbni wrote: »

For some reason my mind read this out to me in an Edmund Blackaddder voice. Brilliant.

A cunning plan

Dolbert · 24-08-2013 11:45PM

OrphansRFunny wrote: »

He spends his holidays in Ireland every year. He comes here to write.

He spent many childhood summers in Ireland too, allegedly Alan Patridge was inspired in part by Pat Kenny

wil · 25-08-2013 12:02AM

Dolbert wrote: »

He spent many childhood summers in Ireland too, allegedly Alan Patridge was inspired in part by Pat Kenny

Pat ALan Kenny

Yes, can confirm it all fits, must be true

Skylinehead · 25-08-2013 12:14AM

timthumbni wrote: »

For some reason my mind read this out to me in an Edmund Blackaddder voice. Brilliant.

Which begs the question, what happens when you throw Rowan Atkinson in the mix? I'd have him edging ahead of Coogan and miles ahead of Gervais.

Pang · 25-08-2013 12:15AM

Can't stand Gervais. His annoying laugh on that Karl Pilkington programme wrecked my head. Never liked Extras either.

Coogan is far superior. Some of the Alan Partridge stuff is sheer brilliant.

B.A._Baracus · 25-08-2013 12:43AM

So far the polls are saying Steve Coogan is the more talented one. But that right there says alot about life as I am sure Gervais has the bigger bank balance.

I can't help much mention a pro wrestling reference here (Yeah I know, pro wrestling of all things) But to quote the words of a famous wrestler by the name of Al Snow, who was asked in an interview once about what was the best match of WrestleMania 3, he said who did the people pay to see? So what was the best match on the card? [In reference to the fact while the randy savage vs ricky steamboat was regarded as the best match on the card.... who sold the most tickets. Who put the asses in chairs. It was Hulk Hogan Vs Andre the Giant]

So I guess what is talent. It's all about money.

Sinfonia · 25-08-2013 01:16AM

RayM wrote: »

Coogan does a brilliant Irish accent. Better than any other British actor.

Spends a lot of time in West Cork.. Apparently not very approachable though.

fryup wrote: »

Ricky Gervais for me...just for the Golden Globes alone, his monologue was flawless

i ask you who else would have the backbone to rip the p!ss out of Hollywood esp when surrounded by so many movie legends, it made a refreshing change from the butt kissing event that it usually is

I really like Ricky Gervais, for The Office, Extras, the podcasts and his stand-up for the most part, but I only really like Coogan for the Partridge stuff.
That said, Coogan gets my vote because Partridge is that good.

daRobot · 25-08-2013 01:44AM

Sinfonia wrote: »

Spends a lot of time in West Cork.. Apparently not very approachable though.

I'd could well believe that, seems a serious sort, despite his obvious ability for humour.

pablomakaveli · 25-08-2013 02:19AM

Gervais has been living off the reputation of the office for ages and has been living off Karl pilkington for the last couple of years as well. Really overrated person in my opinion.

bradlente · 25-08-2013 02:29AM

Went for Coogan.

The trip is great,The two would make a fantastic radio show I imagine.

who's the most talented - Gervais or Coogan

Comments