Scratch Cups

IITYWYBMAD · 28-06-2010 04:01PM

Lol...look at the ego's here!!! As somebody who has played both Carlow and Dundalk, I would say that Carlow is the better stretch. I can understand why somebody would call Carlow a pitch and putt course, as 8 of the 27 holes, play less than 400 yards.

However I much prefer it to Dundalk, which seems very confused in its layout.

There is no doubt that Carlow is a fantastic course, if a little short, but still tricky!!

jimjo · 28-06-2010 04:48PM

Lads what's Dundalk like? I see the JSC is 36 holes and not expensive to play in.

I would be playing it blind if I do choose to play. Is it quite tight? Going from the score card it long enough and it'll be off the blue's too. As courses go is local knowledge very important or could I turn up and its all in front of me type of place??

Grizz · 28-06-2010 05:28PM

Dundalk is very wide, you can give your drives a good belt. All par 4s/5s need a driver off the tee (no playing up anywhere)
Theres only one green out of sight (the 8th) the rest is what you see is what you get. All par 3's are +150meters and you can reach 2 of the 4 par 5s in 2 depending on the direction of the wind.
Deffo recommend it

jimjo · 28-06-2010 06:13PM

Wide open? Had a quick look at Kevin's book 'Hooked' and he talks about it being fairly tree lined, a classic treelined parkland type of course is the impression I got.

Anyone else got any info on the course?

madds · 28-06-2010 07:47PM

My brother was a member there for a couple of years and I've played it half a dozen times. It is lined with mature trees with "wide-ish" fairways. There are some good long par 4's that can play longer into a stiff breeze. There are very few holes where you'll be hitting less than a 6-iron in. Also has a very spacious practice area. A good course but one which I always felt was never presented in tip-tip condition, e.g. greens were good without being great and the place always looked in need of a cutting.

Deffo Carlow for me if I had the choice.

Miley Byrne · 29-06-2010 02:46PM

Anyone here playing the Intermediate Scratch Cup in Fota this Sunday?

thegen · 29-06-2010 05:22PM

Senior Scr Cup on Southcounty 3rd July, 36 holes, Call Pro Shop to book in.

heavyballs · 29-06-2010 08:26PM

Junior Scr in Bray on Saturday,fyi the place is in sheite,greens are a joke,full of sand and stones

ShriekingSheet · 30-06-2010 10:10AM

I'm gonna head to Slade Valley and South County junior scratchs this weekend. I know Dundalk and Carlow are on, and I'm not a fan of SV, but I know both courses well and always regret heading to a course I don't know for 36 holes strokes off the back tees.

charlieIRL · 30-06-2010 10:59AM

thelongfellow wrote: »

Athlone and Mount Temple are having Junior and Inter on Sunday

Minor SC on as well for us sky high handicappers!!

f22 wrote: »

Laughable that you even mention Athlone and Mount temple in the same sentence!

Why's that?
I actually like both courses. Mount Temple is in better condition but Athlone is a lot harder (for me anyway!)

f22 · 30-06-2010 05:40PM

charlieIRL wrote: »

Why's that?
I actually like both courses. Mount Temple is in better condition but Athlone is a lot harder (for me anyway!)

Simply because Carlow is a far superior course to the other two no matter what way you look at it.

thelongfellow · 30-06-2010 06:41PM

f22 wrote: »

Simply because Carlow is a far superior course to the other two no matter what way you look at it.

There are plenty of ways to look at it.

Maybe you should come to terms with the fact that a lot of people don't like Carlow golf course. And there is nothing wrong with that is there...

f22 · 30-06-2010 06:53PM

thelongfellow wrote: »

There are plenty of ways to look at it.

Maybe you should come to terms with the fact that a lot of people don't like Carlow golf course. And there is nothing wrong with that is there...

I simply answered the chaps question, I couldn't care less about your opinion.

thelongfellow · 30-06-2010 07:33PM

f22 wrote: »

I simply answered the chaps question, I couldn't care less about your opinion.

@charlieIRL you go play Mount Temple and Athlone and you enjoy them.

At f22 grow up.

charlieIRL · 01-07-2010 09:36AM

thelongfellow wrote: »

@charlieIRL you go play Mount Temple and Athlone and you enjoy them.

At f22 grow up.

hahaha, cheers for replies guys.

Played athlone there yesterday evening, gonna leave it at that - started raining on the second hole and never stopped. Wind picked up then to rub it in, disaster!!!

I'll have to meet you for a game in carlow some weekend F22 and you can show me around!!

f22 · 01-07-2010 10:26AM

charlieIRL wrote: »

hahaha, cheers for replies guys.

Played athlone there yesterday evening, gonna leave it at that - started raining on the second hole and never stopped. Wind picked up then to rub it in, disaster!!!

I'll have to meet you for a game in carlow some weekend F22 and you can show me around!!

Perhaps the other fella might be better served Charlie, he only needs a wedge and putter around there, it's only a pitch and putt course after all!

AGC · 01-07-2010 03:46PM

Anyone know why St. Annes senior scratch is off on Sunday? Just got a text there about it being cancelled.

Mister Sifter · 01-07-2010 04:01PM

AGC wrote: »

Anyone know why St. Annes senior scratch is off on Sunday? Just got a text there about it being cancelled.

I'm guessing here, but i'd say poor uptake. I played it last weekend and the greens are in an awful state. Barton Shield was on there so i'd imagine most of their target audience was put off the place and word has spread.

I haven't played on worse greens in summer ever.

madds · 01-07-2010 04:53PM

Mister Sifter wrote: »

I'm guessing here, but i'd say poor uptake. I played it last weekend and the greens are in an awful state. Barton Shield was on there so i'd imagine most of their target audience was put off the place and word has spread.

I haven't played on worse greens in summer ever.

They only had ~10 names signed up I believe.

Huntelaar · 01-07-2010 06:07PM

Ten names...... that's shocking!

I got the text too. Would've been more disappointed if it was a good course but still. Might head to South County instead. No idea what its like though!

f22 · 01-07-2010 06:35PM

Despite being such a poor course as links go, the condition of the places is pretty shocking. Those sort of numbers speak volumes, good to see people voting with their feet for a change.

AGC · 02-07-2010 09:38AM

Played in it a couple of years ago and was a great turnout with a very strong field so was surprised to hear numbers was the issue but I also wouldn’t have put my name down knowing the greens were in bits!

Go play South County or the K Club one now. South County should be in good condition after the Leinster Boys this week.

Mister Sifter · 02-07-2010 10:33AM

AGC wrote: »

Go play South County or the K Club one now. South County should be in good condition after the Leinster Boys this week.

Yeh, should be.

G1032 · 03-07-2010 07:27PM

thelongfellow wrote: »

And it plays a lot shorter but has small "poxy" greens. Athlone, Galway, Mullingar all have well supported Senior Cups-doesn't mean they are good courses.

Are you actually for real? Galway isn't a good course??? Granted it's not the best course in the west of Ireland as they like to claim but it is a very good course.
I don't think in 20 odd years playing golf I've ever before heard someone say Galway wasn't a good course...................

Too short for ya is it?

thegen · 03-07-2010 10:22PM

Anyone know what won Snr and Jnr at Southcounty today?

Paulusmaximus · 04-07-2010 05:31PM

Re. St annes, i got numerous texts and calls about playing it and then got the text to say it was cancelled. Greens were terrible for the barton shield...would have been a huge turn off for what is their target market...

Just a reminder for Senior and Junior scratch players that Malahide have a top golfer event next Sunday. 36 holes for the senior scratch and will use all three nines. The red nine has been redeveloped and is really worth seeing.

Jimdagym · 04-07-2010 10:41PM

Paulusmaximus wrote: »

Just a reminder for Senior and Junior scratch players that Malahide have a top golfer event next Sunday. 36 holes for the senior scratch and will use all three nines. The red nine has been redeveloped and is really worth seeing.

Played it last week, the red 9 really is cracking. a couple of very long par 4's.

AGC · 05-07-2010 11:41AM

Just entered Malahide for Sunday. Anyone any idea of numbers playing?

f22 · 05-07-2010 11:50AM

AGC wrote: »

Just entered Malahide for Sunday. Anyone any idea of numbers playing?

BRS booking system on their website should tell you

Mister Sifter · 05-07-2010 12:01PM

Eek, only 14 names in for Malahide Senior by the looks of it. Poor.

There doesn't seem to be an appetite for Senior Scratches at all really - less than 10 for St Annes, 20 or so at South County, 14 for Malahide.

Not enough ego massaging at these places for them?

Scratch Cups

Comments