Best Comedians Ever???

Mweelrea · 16-12-2007 9:21pm #1

Who in your opinionis the best comedian ever????:)

starn · 16-12-2007 9:23pm

Bill Hicks

bubonicus · 16-12-2007 9:33pm

starn wrote: »

Bill Hicks

Agree 100%. But I think he was more a modern day prophet that people found funny because what he said was/is true.

R.I.P, Goatboy

Mweelrea · 17-12-2007 12:08am

starn wrote: »

Bill Hicks

Bill Hicks; i've never heard of him! Better check him out so!:D

I liked Ronnie Barker of the two Ronnies.

humbert · 17-12-2007 2:29am

Bill Hicks is one of a kind but I actually found myself laughing more at George Carlin.

brightkane · 17-12-2007 10:30am

richard pryor past,

rich hall present

DBIreland · 17-12-2007 12:43pm

Daniel Kitson by a long way

Galvasean · 17-12-2007 1:00pm

Ever? Bill Hicks

Living: probably Billy Connolly

grames_bond · 17-12-2007 5:51pm

imo id go for bill hicks or mitch hedberg, 2 comedians taken WAY to early!!

carpainter · 17-12-2007 6:00pm

A work colleague introduced me to the comedy of Bill Hicks over 12 years ago, he was great. I've only seen Bill Bailey live once and I found him great too.

18-12-2007 3:14pm

Billy Connelly by a long shot.

Gazza376 · 19-12-2007 10:25pm

LittleNipper wrote: »

Billy Connelly by a long shot.

Billy Connelly one of the best without a doubt

RobbieBonham · 20-12-2007 4:26am

Doug Stanhope is a top fave

And Stewart Lee.

grames_bond · 20-12-2007 1:19pm

RobbieBonham wrote: »

And Stewart Lee.

yeah stewart lee is a legend, such a dry wit its unfrotunate that he hasnt hit MAINstream yet, as was seen in him being included in the "best of NEW stand up" on paramounts edinburgh and beyond!

Mweelrea · 22-12-2007 2:40am

Galvasean wrote: »

Living: probably Billy Connolly

yeah billy connolly is a great comedian too

I did a bit of searching up on bill hicks he's very good!

Akrasia · 03-01-2008 12:18am

I would include John Cleese (RIP)
and the rest of the Monty Python crew as amongst the funniest comedians of our time. They have certainly produced the very finest comedy film ever ever made, but they're not quite stand up (and their attempts at stage shows didn't work very well at all)
http://youtube.com/watch?v=B1U6_H5-AAc )
They might have been instrumental in spawning the 'sketch show' genre, but we can't blame them for drudge like little britain and trigger happy tv.

brayblue24 · 03-01-2008 12:26am

I know he's sold out a bit now but Peter Kay's two live DVDs were teriffic, particularly the second one from Bolton but I saw a pre "D'Unbelieveables" Jon Kenny live about 20 years ago in what is now The Martello but what was then O'Shea's "International" hotel in Bray and he was fantastic from start to finish. See he had a live DVD before Christmas, was going to buy it but thought I had hinted enough to get it on the day.. didn't. Any reviews?

CHD · 03-01-2008 5:28am

D'unbeleiveables!!!!

grames_bond · 03-01-2008 2:01pm

Akrasia wrote: »

I would include John Cleese (RIP)
and the rest of the Monty Python crew as amongst the funniest comedians of our time. They have certainly produced the very finest comedy film ever ever made, but they're not quite stand up (and their attempts at stage shows didn't work very well at all)

im goin to half agree with you, john cleese is, and always will be one of the greatest comedic performers/writers of all time. from python to faulty towers, to everything else....just brilliant (i have not seen his early stand up so i cant comment)

but you cant say pythons stage shows didnt work, they were one of the greatest and fastest selling comedy stage shows of all time, they did countless tours (ok i think it was three or four) do to phenominal demand they had to keep adding new dates and new tours.

biko · 03-01-2008 2:02pm

Akrasia wrote: »

I would include John Cleese (RIP)

RIP?

Heisenberg. · 03-01-2008 2:06pm

This post has been deleted.

Nightwish · 03-01-2008 3:18pm

Bill Hicks by a long shot. Angry, political and so eloquent! Everything he said back in the early 90's is still relevant today, particularly wrt to American politics and society.

Akrasia · 03-01-2008 3:38pm

biko wrote: »

RIP?

It was just a joke reference to the youtube clip I posted. It's John Cleese delivering his own Eulogy (very funny stuff)

Akrasia · 03-01-2008 3:41pm

grames_bond wrote: »

im goin to half agree with you, john cleese is, and always will be one of the greatest comedic performers/writers of all time. from python to faulty towers, to everything else....just brilliant (i have not seen his early stand up so i cant comment)

but you cant say pythons stage shows didnt work, they were one of the greatest and fastest selling comedy stage shows of all time, they did countless tours (ok i think it was three or four) do to phenominal demand they had to keep adding new dates and new tours.

Ok, I'll take it back so. I watched one of them on the internet and i thought it was just a little bit too mad (trying to fit so much material into a stage performance) .... but on second thoughts, it worked a lot better than it should have done.

grames_bond · 03-01-2008 3:50pm

Akrasia wrote: »

It was just a joke reference to the youtube clip I posted. It's John Cleese delivering his own Eulogy (very funny stuff)

and dont worry man, i got the RIP joke, that stuff on just for laughs was great, the eulogy and cleese idol!

18AD · 03-01-2008 4:49pm

My favourites have to be (in no particular order):
Bill Bailey
Dylan Moran
George Carlin
Mitch Hedberg

I wouldn't mind checking out some older stand-up. I've heard good things about Rowan Atkinson's sets.
And the John Cleese as mentioned above, and the other monty python people...

All the best.
AD.

cavemeister · 03-01-2008 6:49pm

In my opinion, Eddie Izzard is the greatest comedian to have ever graced this planet.

biko · 03-01-2008 8:47pm

cavemeister wrote: »

In my opinion, Eddie Izzard is the greatest comedian to have ever graced this planet.

He would be very high on my list too.

Duzzie · 03-01-2008 9:14pm

Hmmmmmm Tough one. I guess my favourite would be one of:

Billy Connolly
Robin Williams or
Emo Philips

mister1777 · 05-01-2008 5:40pm

Steve Wright...for those who can handle quick fire dead pan one lines check this out......... http://ie.youtube.com/watch?v=XYffXv7jMYQ

Jack Sheehan · 05-01-2008 6:14pm

I actually don't think Bill Hicks was funny.

*Flees in Terror*

I'm surprised no one has mentioned Dermot Morgan.

grames_bond · 05-01-2008 6:17pm

steve wright us brilliant allright, he is billy connolly's favourite stand up (he used 2 of steves jokes in his new act- said they were steves tho, he didnt steal them) you cant get a much better review today!!

Galvasean · 06-01-2008 1:56am

Jack Sheehan wrote: »

I'm surprised no one has mentioned Dermot Morgan.

I think it might be a generation gap. I have his 'Live' DVD and while its very funny there are quite a few bits that go over my head, ie: some of the political humour is fairly outdated at this point and I just don't recognise some of the references.

Armin_Tamzarian · 06-01-2008 1:59am

Jerry Seinfeld, Chris Rock, Jimmy Carr, Jack Dee, Dermot Morgan

Peyton Manning · 06-01-2008 2:00am

I actually find Bill Hicks more educating than funny. Never found myself laughing out loud during his shows, but his opinions were very entertaining.

I agree Mitch Hedberg is/was one of the best. Id also give honourable mentions to Eddie Izzard and Dylan Moran (more of a personal favourite - have met him a couple of times).

Jack Sheehan · 06-01-2008 5:29pm

Archimedes wrote: »

I actually find Bill Hicks more educating than funny. Never found myself laughing out loud during his shows, but his opinions were very entertaining.

I agree Mitch Hedberg is/was one of the best. Id also give honourable mentions to Eddie Izzard and Dylan Moran (more of a personal favourite - have met him a couple of times).

This is a fair point. Hicks was a very intelligent and educated/educating man, I just never found myself laughing out loud at him.

grames_bond · 06-01-2008 5:34pm

yeah hicks stand up was more of a lecture, but he still imo has a good few brilliantly funny moments which did make me laugh out loud, but all of which still had a political and/or humanitarian view point which differed him from alot of comedians who would just say funny things without meaning or feeling!

Naos · 07-01-2008 11:58pm

Ross Noble -For engaging with audience
Jimmy Carr - For wit (8/10 Cats etc.), don't like his standup
Dara O Brien - For engaging with the audience
Mitch Hedberg - Brilliant one liners (I got a candle holder.. a cake)

Tzetze · 08-01-2008 12:09am

Lenny Bruce.
His humour does seem dated now, but he paved the way for political and sociological satire which very often broached tabboo subjects.

Many have mentioned Bill Hicks (he's my number 2), but would he have even gotten into comedy if it hadn't been for Lenny Bruce? Obviously nobody can answer that question, but I think it's doubtful that he would have.

ThE_IVIAcIVIAIV · 10-01-2008 8:53pm

katt williams, dave chappelle , chris rock , tommy tiernan , richard pyror, eddie murphy.

tech77 · 14-01-2008 6:25am

grames_bond wrote: »

steve wright us brilliant allright, he is billy connolly's favourite stand up

Would never have imagined that Steven Wright was Billy Connelly's favourite comedian because imo they have very different styles.
I like Steven Wright's stuff but tbh i never understood the Billy Connelly "best comic ever" tag.

Have to agree that from what i've seen of Bill Hicks i would've appreciated his refreshing/no bull$hit style and searingly honest opinions first and foremost more than anything else about him.

Others:
Steven Wright
Stewart Lee
Ricky Gervais

Lucy Lambourne · 14-01-2008 8:47pm

The answer of course...is Mitch Hedberg

grames_bond · 17-01-2008 5:01pm

Lucy Lambourne wrote: »

The answer of course...is Mitch Hedberg

+1 here here!!

vote for him in the stand up comedy showdown! he is up to 10th but is being beaten by some wasters who dont deserve to hold the same mic as him! http://www.comedycentral.com/events/susd/index.jhtml

eoin1981 · 22-01-2008 1:34pm

grames_bond wrote: »

+1 here here!!

vote for him in the stand up comedy showdown! he is up to 10th but is being beaten by some wasters who dont deserve to hold the same mic as him! http://www.comedycentral.com/events/susd/index.jhtml

agree with the 2 above. Mitch Hedberg is the funniest comedian ever! His delivery is second to none and his jokes are timeless. such a talented man. Very sad that he is no longer with us.

www.mitchhedberg.net
www.hedburgh.com

Jay P · 15-02-2008 1:52am

Bill Bailey. Hands down. And he and my friend are identical, beard and all

grames_bond · 15-02-2008 12:56pm

Jay P wrote: »

Bill Bailey. Hands down. And he and my friend are identical, beard and all

HUMAN SLAVES....IN AN INSECT NATION....OOOH AW WOAH WOAH!

mollybird · 21-02-2008 10:39am

Des bishop does it for me everytime. looking forward to his new show this weekend. hope it's a good one. not seen him in a few years

brayblue24 · 29-02-2008 12:33am

Got the Dara O'Briain DVD knocked down at Golden Discs. Decided to take a chance. Fantastic. Thought I'd wet myself when he started on about baguettes. Saw it coming a mile off but the delivery....

roadruner · 02-03-2008 2:02am

LittleNipper wrote: »

Billy Connelly by a long shot.

There can be only one king of stand up

The Big Yin

Billy Connolly - Reasons For Swearing

"swearing is bad use of good language, now F*** off"

grames_bond · 02-03-2008 1:50pm

roadruner wrote: »

There can be only one king of stand up

The Big Yin

Billy Connolly - Reasons For Swearing

"swearing is bad use of good language, now F*** off"

and he's coming to ireland!!

roadruner · 02-03-2008 2:18pm

grames_bond wrote: »

and he's coming to ireland!!

seriously, when dude ??

oh man now thats something i'll be looking forward to !!!!

Best Comedians Ever???

Comments