Should there be zero tolerance by Gardaí towards scumbags?

Red Kooga · 09-11-2005 01:41PM

I have to agree again with New York been safer. I once lost a friend in Times Square at 5am and felt ok. The cops take no shíte.

Deadwing · 09-11-2005 03:00PM

Spike wrote:

One final thing (links to the first paragraph), on the plane back this morning, I really didn't want to come back here! I actually despise this country. I mean, if you do or wear something out of the ordinary, you'll undoubtedly get a lot of hassle from scumbags. New York you could wander around nearly naked (ala the Naked Cowboy) and not get a second glance. Granted that's a bit exaggerated, but you get what I'm saying.

Screw this, I'm living in America.

One thing ive always noticed about this hellhole. If you dare to do/wear anything that might be considered a little 'different', youll get every cream cracker on the street shouting "LOOKIT DE BLEEDIN STATE AH YER MAN!!!"
The law is far too soft on the little knackers that litter this city. A few weeks ago some scumbags started throwing stones at my DAD ffs, the guy is built like a ****in tank from years of workin as an electrician..he couldve pulled thier heads off, but it just goes to show they have no respect, or fear, of elders anymore. I know that makes me sound like some misty eyed old timer, but its true.
I honestly think something that would serve this country well, is if everyone was made serve a mandatory year in the army at the age of 18, like in Sweden. it might serve to put some manners and respect on kids.
So to answer the quation, yes guards should have a zero tolerance policy, and issued proper WEAPONS. At least some form of a deterrant. Glad im in Berlin at the moment, i plan on moving here for a while next year for more study, hopefully i wont have to come back

09-11-2005 03:09PM

lock the little druggie ****s up!from where im from those lil ***** are snorting coke at 15!

Red Kooga · 09-11-2005 04:28PM

Deleted User wrote:

lock the little druggie ****s up!from where im from those lil ***** are snorting coke at 15!

:eek:

Please tell me you're joking

3greenrizla's · 09-11-2005 05:28PM

Red Kooga wrote:

Zero Tolerance: Turkish police crack heads of any drunk troublemakers starting fights. A nice big wallop of a baton, thats the only message the fúckers understand. Gardaí need to be more like their European counterparts.

i really cant believe the replies to this post, i cant understand the concept of giving the current gardai permission to crack heads. FFS what are you people on, i'm sure that the cops in donegal would love that.

i'm not trying to defend the scumbags, but this is not the answer, nor is bringing in the army.

my mother brought me up to respect the Guards, that day is gone, would that be part of the problem

Ag marbh · 09-11-2005 07:23PM

Deleted User wrote:

lock the little druggie ****s up!from where im from those lil ***** are snorting coke at 15!

You should be shot.

Ag marbh · 09-11-2005 07:25PM

Deadwing wrote:

One thing ive always noticed about this hellhole. If you dare to do/wear anything that might be considered a little 'different', youll get every cream cracker on the street shouting "LOOKIT DE BLEEDIN STATE AH YER MAN!!!"
The law is far too soft on the little knackers that litter this city. A few weeks ago some scumbags started throwing stones at my DAD ffs, the guy is built like a ****in tank from years of workin as an electrician..he couldve pulled thier heads off, but it just goes to show they have no respect, or fear, of elders anymore. I know that makes me sound like some misty eyed old timer, but its true.
I honestly think something that would serve this country well, is if everyone was made serve a mandatory year in the army at the age of 18, like in Sweden. it might serve to put some manners and respect on kids.
So to answer the quation, yes guards should have a zero tolerance policy, and issued proper WEAPONS. At least some form of a deterrant. Glad im in Berlin at the moment, i plan on moving here for a while next year for more study, hopefully i wont have to come back

Some day you won't care what other people think of you and serving a year in the army would be terrible. I certainly wouldn't want my kids serving for a poxy army.

Dave! · 09-11-2005 09:32PM

Deadwing wrote:

One thing ive always noticed about this hellhole. If you dare to do/wear anything that might be considered a little 'different', youll get every cream cracker on the street shouting "LOOKIT DE BLEEDIN STATE AH YER MAN!!!"
The law is far too soft on the little knackers that litter this city. A few weeks ago some scumbags started throwing stones at my DAD ffs, the guy is built like a ****in tank from years of workin as an electrician..he couldve pulled thier heads off, but it just goes to show they have no respect, or fear, of elders anymore. I know that makes me sound like some misty eyed old timer, but its true.
I honestly think something that would serve this country well, is if everyone was made serve a mandatory year in the army at the age of 18, like in Sweden. it might serve to put some manners and respect on kids.

Yer I agree with that.

Deadwing · 09-11-2005 10:41PM

Ag marbh wrote:

Some day you won't care what other people think of you and serving a year in the army would be terrible. I certainly wouldn't want my kids serving for a poxy army.

I dont care what people think of me, im saying anyone who DOES look different in any way is usually pointed out and laughed at by most knackers. And a year stint in the army doesnt seem to have done sweden any harm

Fabrizio · 10-11-2005 12:36AM

Totally agree that everyone should have to do a year in the army! This would put manners and respect on alot of people. The gardai today are a joke, ok some of them are decent,but the law dosent help them either. For Example, he sees a "scumbag" up to something minor, why wud he bother bringing him in when he knows that he will just get off with a warning and be back out the next night doing the same thing.

I was in USA for the summer, and the cops over there are built like tanks! I know i wudnt act the pri** if i saw them around. I came back to Dublin and i see cops that are 45 years old, a beer belly and slouched across a chair. Hardly intimidating!

When i read in the paper about the librarian being beaten up and the guys getting 12 weeks in prison, it made me sick (im from Sligo also, where the victim was from). So tomorrow night i can go out and kick someone within an inch of my life and because i dont have a previous record i will wake free from jail after a few weeks! Can everyone, including the judge and the politicans not see that this is apauling!!! Absolute Joke!

Ireland is a beautiful country, there is just a few things that i totally hate about it. And zero tolerance is one of the ways to improve it! But typically the Government wont do anything until SERIOUS lobbying is done! I think we need to look at who we are electing for Governement and the simple fact is that they aint good enough! (but thats a different story)

Zulu · 10-11-2005 12:40AM

Fabrizio wrote:

Totally agree that everyone should have to do a year in the army!

...off with you. You wouldn't last 5 days :rolleyes:

bounty · 10-11-2005 01:02AM

you hear stories of scumbags with over 20 convictions :eek:

after 3 chances your out, classed a worthless scumbag and got rid off

im trying to think of what they could do to them, but i just dont care, once they dont cost any more money and never come back...

Red Kooga · 10-11-2005 04:40AM

Was it Bush who had a "3 strikes = 20 years prison" rule?

Zulu · 10-11-2005 10:37AM

Red Kooga wrote:

Was it Bush who had a "3 strikes = 20 years prison" rule?

no

Dave! · 10-11-2005 10:42AM

bounty wrote:

you hear stories of scumbags with over 20 convictions :eek:

after 3 chances your out, classed a worthless scumbag and got rid off

im trying to think of what they could do to them, but i just dont care, once they dont cost any more money and never come back...

Australia?

Nah, don't think that'd be much of a punishment

Maybe send them to this island

Ag marbh · 10-11-2005 10:51AM

bounty wrote:

you hear stories of scumbags with over 20 convictions :eek:

after 3 chances your out, classed a worthless scumbag and got rid off

im trying to think of what they could do to them, but i just dont care, once they dont cost any more money and never come back...

It was the dumb mayor of New York.

dent · 10-11-2005 10:58AM

Fabrizio wrote:

So tomorrow night i can go out and kick someone within an inch of my life and because i dont have a previous record i will wake free from jail after a few weeks! Can everyone, including the judge and the politicans not see that this is apauling!!! Absolute Joke!

I'd go a step further and say you could kick someone to death and you will only end up serving a few years in prison.

I think we should take a zero tolerance approach. By zero tolerance I mean if the Guards see someone pissing against a wall they are fined on the spot or arrested.

If someone is drinking on the street then they should be fined on the spot or arrested.

If someone cannot get away with drinking on the street he will think twice about getting away with hitting someone.

The problem in implementing this is an understaffed and demoralised Garda force that also has its fair share of waster's.

This combined with a court system that doesn't punish offenders and jails that can't fit offenders means we will have to put up with the current system for a long time to come.

But as always we will still vote for the politicians that gave us this system in the first place.

Zulu · 10-11-2005 11:10AM

dent wrote:

I'd go a step further and say you could kick someone to death and you will only end up serving a few years in prison.

I think we should take a zero tolerance approach. By zero tolerance I mean if the Guards see someone pissing against a wall they are fined on the spot or arrested.

If someone is drinking on the street then they should be fined on the spot or arrested....

You all seem to be missing the point. Zero Tolerance would be a disaster. I hear you (the general you) complaining about Temple Bar, so imagine this:
3:45am, Temple Bar. Gardai foot patrol walking through Temple Bar. They approach the Hard Rock cafe were some young lad is releaving himself. Meanwhile a group of thugs are kicking another lad within an inch of his sences outside the banklink on the square.

Zero tolerance will mean the Guards arrest and cart off the young lad having a piss. What will happen the other lad? The Guards aren't going to arrive on the scene for over a half an hour, as they've to arrest someone for pissing. Is this the way you want it? :rolleyes:

dent · 10-11-2005 11:18AM

Zulu wrote:

Zero tolerance will mean the Guards arrest and cart off the young lad having a piss. What will happen the other lad? The Guards aren't going to arrive on the scene for over a half an hour, as they've to arrest someone for pissing. Is this the way you want it? :rolleyes:

I think having adequate numbers of Guards would solve the problem. Also the Guards can throw him into the back of a ( paddy wagon

) and not have to leave the scene. Plus your forgetting the on the spot fine aspect.

As it is the guards are not there at all. So this not arriving on the scene for half an hour is already a reality.

The main point is that if you know you’re not going to get away with pissing on the street you’re not going to do it. Let alone get involved in a brawl. Take a look at NYC it worked their.

But like I said I doubt the government would ever put the resources into it.

Less of the :rolleyes: please.

Red Kooga · 10-11-2005 02:31PM

Found this article

Traders act to clean up image of Temple Bar

With the Christmas party season under way Dublin's Temple Bar is moving to rid itself of its image of excessive, sometimes inappropriate, revelry.

Traders who have banded under the acronym TASCQ - Traders in the Area Supporting the Cultural Quarter - have launched a "Play Nice" campaign to encourage partygoers as well as hoteliers and pub owners to be mindful of the fact that some 3,000 people live in the inner city enclave.

The campaign wants to eliminate bad behaviour. This includes noise, particularly at night; excessive alcohol consumption; public urination and littering.

A publican's charter, to which many of the pubs in Temple Bar have signed up, provides for staff training and a co-ordinated approach to security with security personnel wearing name badges and operating on a fixed short-wave radio "open channel".

Traders will also attempt to shift the focus from drinking to cultural shows, including poetry readings. Signs indicating that toilets are for patrons use only are to be removed, with additional signs going on display telling patrons they are being monitored by video.

Dublin Bus, which at one time had plans to build a bus station in the area, said it was "delighted to be part of a new initiative".

The company said its Nitelink bus service was available for many of the people who frequent Temple Bar and it also offered a "city bus tour" in the area.

Play Nice aims to improve further the local environment "for all who live in, work or visit Temple Bar, by improving training standards in licensed premises, educating visitors on what is acceptable behaviour and by working more closely with the gardaí and the city council", said a spokeswoman.

dSTAR · 11-11-2005 01:04PM

Deadwing wrote:

...Glad im in Berlin at the moment, i plan on moving here for a while next year for more study, hopefully i wont have to come back

I feel the same. Having grown up on the 'mean streets of Dublin' I know only all too well what its like. Now I live in a beautiful suburb in Melbourne with very little crime.

I can walk around Melbourne CBD after dark with my wife and baby on the weekend and STILL feel safe.

I will NEVER return to Dublin to live. Life here is too good.

Whats going on over there?

Ireland needs a serious shift to the right to sort the country out.

IvaBigWun · 02-01-2006 03:52PM

dSTAR wrote:

I can walk around Melbourne CBD after dark with my wife and baby on the weekend and STILL feel safe.
/QUOTE]

I was under the imprression that alot of Oz was dangerous?

Vorsprung · 02-01-2006 04:01PM

Was reading today's Indo, crime down in New York for the 17th year in a row - incredible. Seems zero tolerance does work!

New York crime rate falls again
ADVERTISEMENT

THE crime rate in New York has dropped for the 17th consecutive year, with the fewest number of recorded murders in the city since 1963.

Over the past year, there have been 537 murders, down from 566 in 2004, and a peak of 2,245 in 1990.

Rape, assault, burglary and car theft have all tumbled, with subway crime down by 5pc, according to New York Police Department statistics.

New York is now the safest big city in America, while other major cities, including Boston, Houston and Philadelphia, are witnessing soaring crime rates.

The crime drop began under mayor Rudolph Giuliani in the mid-1990s, when he invented "zero tolerance" whereby police clamped down on all crimes. (© Daily Telegraph, London)

http://www.unison.ie/irish_independent/stories.php3?ca=30&si=1535877&issue_id=13495

IvaBigWun · 02-01-2006 04:06PM

New York is now the safest big city in America

:eek:

Surely a typo?!

:eek:

Supercell · 02-01-2006 04:21PM

bigjimthefirst wrote:

Was reading today's Indo, crime down in New York for the 17th year in a row - incredible. Seems zero tolerance does work!

http://www.unison.ie/irish_independent/stories.php3?ca=30&si=1535877&issue_id=13495

That is a remarkable success story indeed, shows with polititions with balls in charge sustained change can happen even in the "big city".

Will it happen here, doubt it, politions in Ireland are a bunch of brown bag, corrupt, spineless, apathetic wasters.

Maybe Dublin city needs a publically elected Mayor with real powers ?

IvaBigWun · 02-01-2006 06:14PM

Longfield wrote:

Maybe Dublin city needs a publically elected Mayor with real powers ?

The Dublin Mayor has no political power whatsoever then?

Vorsprung · 02-01-2006 06:21PM

IvaBigWun wrote:

The Dublin Mayor has no political power whatsoever then?

I could be wrong but I always thought the Lord Mayor position was a largely ceremonial position. You only hold the post for a year - if it was a position with power, it's a ridiculously short amount of time to be able to introduce any meaningful reforms.

Longfield wrote:

Maybe Dublin city needs a publically elected Mayor with real powers ?

Have a feeling I heard something about directly elected mayors last year, haven't time to look it up.

IvaBigWun · 02-01-2006 07:34PM

bigjimthefirst wrote:

I could be wrong but I always thought the Lord Mayor position was a largely ceremonial position.

Bertie is the first mayor I can remember as a kid and look at him now :rolleyes:

Vorsprung · 02-01-2006 09:26PM

IvaBigWun wrote:

Bertie is the first mayor I can remember as a kid and look at him now :rolleyes:

Didn't know that. Anyone remember Royston?

Hagar · 02-01-2006 10:02PM

Didn't young Haughey run the shop for a while?
Wasn't it nice of daddy and his buddies to get him a handy little number?

Should there be zero tolerance by Gardaí towards scumbags?

Comments